arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Subir Hait

Publications and source records attributed to Subir Hait.

10 recordsLinked to original sources

Maximum Scores and Treatment Feedback in Regression Discontinuity Designs

Hospitals use repeated risk scores to decide when to send an alert. Some evaluations summarize these scores by their maximum and use the maximum as the running variable in a regression discontinuity (RD) design. The maximum shows correctly whether a patient was ever alerted. However, it can include scores recorded after an earlier alert has already changed care. In this paper, we study what the maximum-score RD estimates when an earlier intervention changes a later score. We use a two-assessment model and derive a formula that splits the RD contrast into the causal effect and a composition term. When feedback moves scores in one direction, the composition term equals the relative jump in the density of the maximum at the cutoff times a prognostic contrast. Therefore, an exactly continuous density means no bias, and the population density jump bounds the bias. Valid inference on the jump turns this into a confidence bound under a stated sensitivity assumption. Within this model, bias behind a continuous density requires feedback in both directions. For this case, we bound bias by total boundary movement and construct conservative confidence sets for binary outcomes under explicit sensitivity and smoothness assumptions. We give closed forms for independent uniform scores and for correlated Gaussian scores. In one example, a true risk reduction of four percentage points appears as a one-point increase. Simulations confirm the formulas. Narrower bandwidths, robust bias correction, and machine-learning covariate adjustment do not remove the bias. A fuzzy RD on the first score recovers the causal effect when early and late treatment have the same effect. Our results concern how the running variable is built. We do not assess any published clinical study.

stat.ME↗

confoundvis for Visualizing and Reporting Sensitivity to Unmeasured Confounding in R

Sensitivity analysis asks how strong unmeasured confounding would have to be before an observational conclusion changes. Several R packages already calculate established sensitivity quantities, but their outputs use different parameters, objects, and plotting conventions. In this article, we describe confoundvis 0.3.0, an R package designed as a common interface for these analyses. The package stores results from the impact threshold of a confounding variable, the robustness of inference to replacement, partial-R^2 omitted-variable bias analysis, E-values, and Rosenbaum bounds for matched pairs in one confoundsens object. Each result keeps its own parameter and its own published formula. The same functions then draw robustness curves, locate the points at which a conclusion changes, write plain-language reports, and collect several analyses in one table. When a framework describes a confounder by two associations, the package also draws the two-parameter surface on which the familiar single number lies and, where such benchmarks are defined, places measured covariates on the surface. We demonstrate the package with the right heart catheterization data and with a matched-pair study of welders. The native calculations agree with sensemakr, konfound, DOS2, sensitivity2x2xk, and sensitivitymv to numerical or grid precision, and imported EValue results reproduce the reported E-values. The purpose of confoundvis is not to replace the underlying methods or to place their sensitivity parameters on a common scale. Its purpose is to provide a consistent workflow for drawing, comparing, and reporting the results that those methods produce.

stat.CO↗

Target-Aware Sequential Inference: Pooled versus Stratified Anytime-Valid Designs

Sequential studies with heterogeneous strata may define the estimand under a target mixture that differs from the sampling distribution. We organize the design problem by guarantee class: one pooled confidence sequence for a single prespecified target, shared pooled inference for a prespecified target set, and stratum-resolved inference when local guarantees must remain available. For target-set pooled inference we derive minimax, gap-aware, and range-capped shared proposals and an adaptive tracking rule. A specialized augmented off-policy score removes between-stratum mean heterogeneity asymptotically, recovering Neyman allocation for efficient single-target pooled inference. Robust directional certification over a convex target set is a classical intersection-union problem and does not require an M-fold vertex split. We derive a Gaussian information lower bound and an exact finite-support characteristic information that coincides with the bounded nonparametric KL-inf limit, and state sufficient conditions for first-order attainment of the Gaussian constant. Within the local-CS architecture, regularly varying boundaries imply a general allocation law with the 2/3 exponent for root-n variance-adaptive widths. Simulations and a PromptEval replay illustrate the resulting guarantee-efficiency frontier.

stat.ME↗

Beyond Actor-Partner Associations: A Target-Trial Framework for Causal Spillover Effects in Longitudinal Dyadic Data

Actor-partner interdependence models (APIMs) describe how one member's exposure is associated with that member's and the partner's outcomes, but actor and partner coefficients are causal only under additional design and identification assumptions. We formulate APIM-style questions as dyadic target trials under within-dyad interference and make three links between the associational and causal formulations explicit. First, under joint exchangeability, positivity, and a homogeneous correctly specified treatment-related conditional mean, APIM actor, partner, interaction, and joint coefficients equal the corresponding causal contrasts. Second, for binary dyadic treatment, multiplying the true member-specific propensities induces an exact one-parameter discrepancy delta(H) = Cov(A_1, A_2 | H): the four joint-cell errors are (+delta, -delta, -delta, +delta), total variation is 2|delta|, and IPW contrast bias has a closed-form representation. Third, the same discrepancy affects AIPW through its product with outcome-regression error. A 36-scenario simulation and a true-marginal factorization diagnostic show that large separate-propensity bias under residual dependence is primarily factorization bias, while flexible AIPW reduces nonlinear-model bias but not weak-support instability. In the strongest dependence condition, factorizing even the true marginals reversed the spillover contrast and inflated the interaction to nearly five times its true value. We apply the framework to 2,400 Health and Retirement Study couples studying retirement transitions and later depressive symptoms. Joint retirement was rare, residual treatment dependence was substantial, and estimates were sensitive to support and propensity flooring. The contribution is a design-and-diagnostic bridge from APIM questions to causal dyadic analyses, not a new general interference or AIPW theory.

stat.ME↗

When Is a Relevance Threshold Statistically Resolvable? Minimax Limits for Effect Classification

Statistical precision and scientific relevance operate on different scales. In regular problems, sampling uncertainty contracts at rate $n^{-1/2}$, whereas the magnitude below which an effect is scientifically negligible may be fixed or may vary with information. Let $Δ_n$ denote a relevance threshold and $I_0$ Fisher information, and define $λ_n=\sqrt{nI_0}Δ_n$. For separated negligible and meaningful parameter classes, we establish the minimax lower bound $\liminf R_n^*\ge 2\{1-Φ(\varepsilonκ)\}$ when $λ_n\toκ$. If $λ_n\to0$, the experiments merge and consistent classification is impossible. If $λ_n\toκ\in(0,\infty)$, the problem converges to a Gaussian-shift decision problem. We characterize the exact minimax rule and risk in that limiting composite problem. As $κ\downarrow0$, the optimal cutoff converges to one statistical-error unit and the optimal improvement over trivial risk is $O(κ^2)$, while a simple relevance-boundary rule improves only at $O(κ^3)$; as $κ$ grows, that rule becomes asymptotically minimax. If $λ_n\to\infty$, consistent classification is attainable under a uniform estimation-resolution condition, verified for Gaussian and Bernoulli models. For $Δ_n=dn^{-γ}$, the critical rate is $γ=1/2$. We also show that moving asymmetric relevance regions depend on standardized distances to their two boundaries rather than total width alone. For heterogeneous true effects, we derive a significance-saturation limit and show that point-null significance can be most selective for scientifically relevant effects at intermediate information. The framework characterizes when scientific relevance is statistically resolvable through a common information scale.

math.ST↗

Is the Linear Threshold Good Enough? A Scale-Free Parameter and Adequacy Test for Curvature-Induced Threshold Displacement

Applied work often locates a threshold by linearizing a smooth function about a reference point and solving for the crossing. When the function is curved, the linear crossing can be substantively displaced even when standard errors are valid. We introduce the curvature-overstatement parameter $Θ_{COT}=\log(|h_2^*|/|h_1^*|)$, the log ratio of second- to first-order threshold displacement. On the quadratic branch continuous with the linear solution, $|h_2^*/h_1^*|=2/(1+\sqrt{1-u})$, where $u=2qa/b^2$ is a dimensionless index formed from the local gap, slope, and curvature. Thus $Θ_{COT}$ is scale-free, depends on the local parameters through one scalar, and has regular-domain range $(-\infty,\log 2)$, with boundary limit $\log 2$ at tangency. We derive regular asymptotic inference, characterize local-to-tangency and weak-slope failures, and give a remainder bound linking the second-order crossing to the true threshold. The main practical contribution is an adequacy test that can affirm that the linear threshold is accurate within a prespecified proportional tolerance, rather than treating failure to detect curvature as evidence of adequacy. Monte Carlo results confirm regular-case calibration, the predicted nonstandard behavior near tangency, and failure under weak slope, while bootstrap diagnostics identify regimes in which regular inference should not be used. COT therefore provides an effect-size scale, adequacy test, and diagnostics for deciding whether a first-order threshold is accurate enough to report.

stat.ME↗

Aggregation Distortion in Multilevel Mediation: Estimand Geometry, Design Dependence, and Diagnostics

Researchers often summarize mediation in clustered data with a single-level product-of-coefficients estimator. We show what this pooled analysis estimates and why the target depends on the design. The pooled a-path is weighted by the within-between variance composition of the treatment. The pooled b-path uses a different weight, based on the mediator variance that remains after residualizing on treatment and covariates. Because these weights generally differ, the pooled indirect effect can differ from a level-respecting combination of the within- and between-level indirect effects. We derive the pooled probability limit and split this difference into a nonlinearity term and a weight-mismatch term. Equal b-paths remove the distortion, but equal a-paths do not. Allowing the two weights to vary gives a bilinear surface with saddle geometry, sharp corner bounds, and a zero-distortion frontier. We also define a design-standardized indirect effect and practical diagnostics. Simulations verify the identities and show that a common decompose-first, cluster-weighted construction can overstate apparent distortion. In an ECLS-K:2011 illustration with 8,363 children in 753 baseline schools, the within-level weights were 0.723 and 0.896, a difference of -0.173 (95% bootstrap CI [-0.193, -0.151]). The conventional construction produced 1.76 times the absolute distortion of the identity-consistent construction. The identity-consistent AD interval included zero. Thus, the application shows unequal weighting and sensitivity to construction, not evidence of nonzero population distortion.

stat.ME↗

Orthogonal Validation-Augmented Cox Regression with Internally Validated Failure Indicators Cross-Fitted Estimation, Risk-Set Linearization, and Validation Design

Incomplete adjudication and endpoint misclassification arise when gold-standard event classification is available only for an internal validation sample. With accurate follow-up times and covariates but error-prone event indicators, naive Cox regression can be biased and inverseprobability weighting inefficient. We develop orthogonal validation-augmented Cox (OVAC) regression, a cross-fitted augmented Cox estimator for incomplete failure indicators. OVAC replaces the missing event indicator with a cross-fitted augmented pseudo-event and explicitly retains the first-order contribution from estimating the Cox risk-set mean. The same term emerges from projection of the full-data influence function through the validation mechanism, linking the score expansion to the observed-data efficient influence function. The score exhibits exact product-form nuisance drift, yielding double-robust identification, Neyman orthogonality, and root-n inference under product-rate conditions. In 1,000 R replications, full-variance SE/SD ratios were 0.997 and 0.992, with 95% coverage of 0.955 and 0.948. A 200-replication diagnostic showed that the risk-set term alone was 77.8% and 81.1% of the full-SE magnitude, although covariance cancellation made its net SE effect smaller than 0.3%. In a 250-replication method comparison, OVAC reduced empirical variance by 38.8% and 37.7% relative to IPW. OVAC provides machine-learning-compatible Cox estimation with explicit risk-set linearization, calibrated inference, and validation-design guidance.

stat.ME↗

Design-Indexed Heterogeneity in Meta-Analysis: A Constrained Location-Scale Specification

An analyst should not assume that a design score improves a meta-analysis simply because it is labeled as robustness. This paper treats declining heterogeneity along a prespecified, outcome-separated design score as a falsifiable directional hypothesis. In an 18-study illustration, the constrained model lands at $γ= 0$ and becomes numerically identical to conventional random effects, while the unrestricted scale fit points in the opposite direction. Simulations that deliberately violate the restriction show the same graceful fallback under wrong-direction and U-shaped heterogeneity; a stepwise decreasing variance function retains an efficiency gain despite functional-form misspecification. DR-Meta formalizes the hypothesis as $τ^2(\mathrm{DR}) = τ_0^2 \exp(-γ\mathrm{DR})$, $γ\geq 0$, within an established location-scale framework. Exact nesting, conditional weight monotonicity, a fixed-effect upper bound, pseudo-true targets under mean misspecification, and score-rescaling behavior are derived with full proofs. Efficiency gains are negligible around an empirically anchored $γ$ near 1 and become material only under stronger gradients; the largest RMSE reduction, about 9.6 percent, occurs in a deliberately extreme condition. Plug-in intervals under-cover relative to random effects, and modified Knapp-Hartung adjustment improves coverage only modestly. Widening the $γ$ optimization bound changes $γ$ estimates much more than pooled-estimate RMSE. The practical contribution is therefore diagnostic rather than automatic efficiency: a nested directional restriction can be supported, contradicted, or collapse transparently to random effects, provided constrained, unrestricted, location, and sensitivity analyses are reported together.

stat.ME↗

Evidence, Calibration, and Stability: A Triadic Framework for Hypothesis Testing Under Model Uncertainty

Statistical tests are often asked to do too much. A single reported result is expected to describe what the observed data say, reassure readers about repeated-sampling behavior, and remain convincing when the working model is perturbed. Those tasks are connected, but they are not equivalent. Fisherian inductive inference and Neyman-Pearson decision theory clarify the first two; robust testing, sensitivity analysis, fragility measures, multiverse analysis, and distributional-stability methods speak to the third. I propose Evidence-Calibration-Stability (ECS) as a framework for keeping these roles separate while reporting them together. Evidence is post-data. Calibration belongs to the design or procedure. Stability is the post-data distance from the benchmark analysis to a conclusion-reversing perturbation within a declared model neighborhood. Full ECS support is conjunctive: a strong coordinate cannot rescue a failed one. For finite-dimensional affine perturbations, I derive an exact ellipsoidal stability radius. For smooth nonlinear margins, a uniform quadratic-remainder condition yields a certified lower bound over a declared neighborhood, showing when the affine formula is only a surrogate. I also establish coordinate invariance and a matrix extension for multiple claims, and distinguish confirmatory calibration from descriptive calibration profiles when prespecification is unavailable. Simulations for the one-sample t test and Student's historical sleep data show that the three coordinates can lead to different interpretations. ECS is a formal synthesis, not a claim that evidence, power, or robustness is itself new.

stat.ME↗