Aggregation Distortion in Multilevel Mediation: Estimand Geometry, Design Dependence, and Diagnostics

Subir Hait

Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2609.29685

Aggregation Distortion in Multilevel Mediation: Estimand Geometry, Design Dependence, and Diagnostics

Subir Hait

View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Researchers often summarize mediation in clustered data with a single-level product-of-coefficients estimator. We show what this pooled analysis estimates and why the target depends on the design. The pooled a-path is weighted by the within-between variance composition of the treatment. The pooled b-path uses a different weight, based on the mediator variance that remains after residualizing on treatment and covariates. Because these weights generally differ, the pooled indirect effect can differ from a level-respecting combination of the within- and between-level indirect effects. We derive the pooled probability limit and split this difference into a nonlinearity term and a weight-mismatch term. Equal b-paths remove the distortion, but equal a-paths do not. Allowing the two weights to vary gives a bilinear surface with saddle geometry, sharp corner bounds, and a zero-distortion frontier. We also define a design-standardized indirect effect and practical diagnostics. Simulations verify the identities and show that a common decompose-first, cluster-weighted construction can overstate apparent distortion. In an ECLS-K:2011 illustration with 8,363 children in 753 baseline schools, the within-level weights were 0.723 and 0.896, a difference of -0.173 (95% bootstrap CI [-0.193, -0.151]). The conventional construction produced 1.76 times the absolute distortion of the identity-consistent construction. The identity-consistent AD interval included zero. Thus, the application shows unequal weighting and sensitivity to construction, not evidence of nonzero population distortion.

Explore related subjects

stat.ME

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Subir Hait. 2026-08-30. Aggregation Distortion in Multilevel Mediation: Estimand Geometry, Design Dependence, and Diagnostics. https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.29685

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Bridging Impulse Control of Piecewise Deterministic Markov Processes and Markov Decision Processes: Frameworks, Extensions, and Open Challenges

Control theory plays a pivotal role in understanding and optimizing the behavior of complex dynamical systems across various scientific and engineering disciplines. Two key frameworks that have emerged for modeling and solving control problems in stochastic systems are piecewise deterministic Markov processes (PDMPs) and Markov decision processes (MDPs). Each framework has its unique strengths, and their intersection offers promising opportunities for tackling a broad class of problems, particularly in the context of impulse controls and decision-making in complex systems. The relationship between PDMPs and MDPs is a natural subject of exploration, as embedding impulse control problems for PDMPs into the MDP framework could open new avenues for their analysis and resolution. Specifically, this integration would allow leveraging the computational and theoretical tools developed for MDPs to address the challenges inherent in PDMPs. On the other hand, PDMPs can offer a versatile and simple paradigm to model continuous time problems that are often described as discrete-time MDPs parametrized by complex transition kernels. This transformation has the potential to bridge the gap between the two frameworks, enabling solutions to previously intractable problems and expanding the scope of both fields. This paper presents a comprehensive review of two research domains, illustrated through a recurring medical example. The example is revisited and progressively formalized within the framework of thevarious concepts and objects introduced

stat.ME↗

arXiv2026

Decision Theoretic Subgroup Detection With Bayesian Machine Learning

We consider the problem of identifying promising subpopulations in terms of treatment effectiveness or treatment effect heterogeneity, from a Bayesian decision theoretic perspective. We first show that a straight-forward application of Bayesian decision theory to subgroup detection leads to a counter-intuitive risk-seeking (RS) behavior. Motivated by this observation, we introduce the Bayesian Risk-Aware Inference and Detection of Subgroups (BRAIDS) utility and use it to perform subgroup selection and post selection inference. The BRAIDS utility interpolates between risk-seeking (RS) and risk-averse (RA) identifications of subgroups, with a variant of the virtual twins algorithm as its risk-neutral midpoint. We also argue that effective subgroup estimation and inference requires the use of regularization priors to safeguard inferences from the winner's curse. We provide empirical evidence that posterior credible intervals for subgroup effects can still obtain nominal coverage levels, provided that an appropriate prior distribution is chosen. The proposed framework is illustrated on data from clinical trial assessing the efficacy of canagliflozin as a treatment for type 2 diabetes.

stat.ME↗

arXiv2026

Modeling cyclostationarity in time series using ASCA

Modern data analysis across diverse disciplines increasingly relies on time series. Many of these datasets exhibit cyclostationarity, where patterns approximately repeat in a regular manner, often across multiple time scales, such as daily, weekly or yearly cycles. In this context, statistical inference is essential to distinguish genuine underlying effects from random variability. While tools like Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) provide such inference, they often lack interpretability and struggle with the complexities of multivariate data. To address these limitations, we propose a unified pipeline for the exploratory analysis of cyclostationary times series using ANOVA Simultaneous Component Analysis (ASCA). ASCA is an extension of ANOVA that is able to work in both univariate and multivariate cases. Combining inference with the visualization capabilities of Principal Component Analysis (PCA), ASCA provides powerful options for interpretability. ASCA's capabilities have been well-established in the analysis of experimental data, but they remain largely unexplored for observational data like time series. Our workflow introduces an algorithmic approach to modeling time-dependent data using ASCA, enabling control over multiple cyclostationary time scales while also accounting for the specific challenges of this type of data, such as autocorrelation. Furthermore, we observed that ASCA provides a better separation of variability across factors than ANOVA in unbalanced designs due to its multivariate nature. We demonstrate the efficacy of this methodology through two real-world case studies: water temperature trends in mountain lakes in Sierra Nevada, Spain, and airborne pollen trends over 30 years recorded in the city of Granada, Spain.

stat.ME↗