arXiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2610.09190

Numerical error analysis of EMC3-EIRENE simulations in the HSX stellarator

F. A. Chavarria·D. Boeyaert·H. Frerichs·K. A. Garcia·B. Geiger
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Plasma edge simulations with codes like EMC3-EIRENE are widely used to study fusion magnetic confinement devices. However, numerical errors can significantly impact the simulation solution and are often insufficiently characterized. These errors consist of the statistical error, bias, and time integration error, resulting from the finite sampling and tracking of Monte Carlo particles, and the discretization error, resulting from a finite grid resolution. This work presents the first comprehensive numerical error analysis of EMC3-EIRENE simulations in stellarator geometries, focusing on edge plasmas in the Helically Symmetric eXperiment (HSX). Fundamental plasma and neutral quantities are analyzed, and error reduction rates are compared against theoretical expectations. The statistical error, bias, and time integration error are fully characterized; however, quantification of the discretization error remains challenging because of the complex grid geometries used in EMC3-EIRENE. The commonly used volume averaged relative change metric is shown to systematically underestimate the statistical error, highlighting a critical flaw in EMC3-EIRENE analysis, where convergence is claimed despite significant noise remaining in the simulation solution. Dominant contributions of the time integration error are shown to differ in stellarator simulations compared to tokamak simulations, related to the relative importance of cross-field transport between the two devices. Based on these results and existing literature, we establish best practices towards improved accuracy and efficiency in general stellarator modeling with EMC3-EIRENE.

Explore related subjects

physics.plasm-ph

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

F. A. Chavarria, D. Boeyaert, H. Frerichs, K. A. Garcia, B. Geiger. 2026-10-06. Numerical error analysis of EMC3-EIRENE simulations in the HSX stellarator. https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.09190

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Solution to an unsolved problem in diodes: Limiting current for small emission area and low emission energy

The maximum current that can be extracted from a diode is a central question in electronic devices, especially for the generation of radiation from microwaves to x-rays. The challenge in its prediction increases significantly when the electron emission is restricted to a small area for which the classical one-dimensional Child-Langmuir law is no longer applicable. We address this unsolved problem using a model that simultaneously includes a small emission area and a small electron emission velocity. New scaling laws are presented for this difficult regime. These results are obtained from three vastly different approaches: a differential equation formulation which provides extremely high resolution, an integral equation formulation which leads to the scaling laws, and a particle-in-cell simulation which shows the temporal-spatial evolution. Comparisons of the predicted maximum current among these three approaches are performed over a large range of parameters, paying special attention to the resolution of the potential minimum in the immediate vicinity of the cathode surface. Corroborations of the scaling laws with experiments on thermionic cathodes and on photoinjectors are indicated. The model consists of a periodic array of electron sheets of finite width in a planar diode, all emitted from a cathode with the same energy. Electron motion is restricted to the direction normal to the cathode. This problem is of interest to the electron device, accelerator, pulsed power, aerospace, and applied mathematics communities.

physics.plasm-ph↗
arXiv2026

Real-time Tokamak Equilibrium Reconstruction Under Limited Experimental Data via Physics-Grounded Synthetic Pre-training

Real-time equilibrium reconstruction is essential for tokamak plasma control. Data-driven surrogates are usually trained on high-quality labeled experimental data, but producing a large amount of labeled data sufficient for surrogate learning requires many expensive discharge shots, and few exist at the start of a new campaign or the operation of a new device. To reduce this cost, we propose to pre-train on simulated equilibria, generated at low cost by physics-based simulation, then fine-tune on limited real data. We evaluate under three settings with increasing difficulties, i.e., in-distribution, out-of-distribution (shape), and cross-campaign (temporal) splits, which mirror how reconstruction is actually deployed. Experimental results validate that synthetic pre-training is highly effective when few real labels are available: fine-tuning on only 1% of the full available real dataset cuts the per-sample normalized root-mean-square error (nRMSE) of the reconstructed poloidal flux by roughly 58% under out-of-distribution shapes and 64% under cross-campaign extrapolation, compared to a model trained from scratch on the same amount of real data. These realistic evaluations show that synthetic pre-training improves equilibrium reconstruction accuracy in the data-scarce regime that real tokamak campaigns face.

physics.plasm-ph↗
arXiv2026

On the particle and electromagnetic boundary conditions in a mesothermal plasma flow

The fully kinetic modeling of mesothermal plasma flows presents significant challenges in the description of boundary conditions for the electrons and the electromagnetic field. Due to their higher mobility compared to ions, electrons extend downstream of the ions, which hinders the implementation of the outflow boundary conditions during transient states. Although the electron drift velocity, $u_e$, is usually neglected as $u_e \simeq u_i < v_{th,e}$, where $u_i$ is the bulk velocity of the ions and $v_{th,e}$ is the thermal velocity of the electrons, we will show how accounting for it, both at the injection of particles and at the outflow boundary condition, is of great importance to achieve quasi-neutrality of charge and current densities. A new partial reflection model for electrons is presented to represent quasi-steady and transitory states. Additionally, we will show how we can employ Ampere-Maxwell's law to better represent the transitory electric field at the outflow boundary compared to the classical `zero-field' Neumann boundary without requiring any numerical parameters. With these new boundary conditions, we improve the quasi-steady and transitory descriptions of expanding mesothermal plasmas.

physics.plasm-ph↗