Journalist Ideology and the Production of News: Evidence from Movers

Abstract

What role do journalists play in determining the political slant of the news they produce? We develop and estimate a model where journalists and newspaper outlets contract over both slant and wages. The model implies a set of conditions under which we can consistently estimate the role of journalist preferences in driving the observed variation in slant across outlets by leveraging journalist transitions between outlets. To measure slant, we train a transformer-based, machine learning model using articles tweeted by politicians and apply it to a full-text database of 9+ million newspaper articles published in the US between 2013 and 2018. Under our model and identifying assumptions, our estimates (a) reject the hypothesis that journalists have zero ideological preferences over the content they produce and (b) imply that 10% of the variation in slant can be explained by journalists. When journalists move across outlets, their average slant shifts by 77% of the gap between their destination and origin outlet averages. In counterfactuals that reweight journalist party composition, moving from the observed left-leaning distribution to an even distribution of Democrats, Republicans, and non-partisans shifts average article slant in a more conservative direction, but only by 0.04 standard deviations in slant.