arXiv ScienceSearch

subject

cs.NI

cs.NI: explore 170 source-linked works published from 2022 to 2026, with original documents and citations.

This collection is a preview while coverage and quality are evaluated.

Search within this collection

Coverage and selection

Includes records with this source-supplied label or an explicit phrase match in their metadata. Matches indicate a mention, not proof that a paper uses a method or tests a material. Source versions are consolidated by DOI.

Sources: arxiv. Collection updated 2026-09-15. Counts describe this index, not the complete source archives.

Prototyping QoE-Aware Rate Adaptation in Cellular Networks with Commercial Applications

Prior work has shown that QoE-aware resource sharing for real-time interactive video can support up to three times more simultaneous sessions at acceptable quality compared to rate-fair allocation. However, the required capabilities (QoE-targeted encoding, runtime spatial complexity estimation, and rich application-network APIs) are not yet available in commercial deployments. In this paper, we take an evolutionary approach: we design a system that delivers QoE-aware resource allocation using only capabilities that can be assembled in a lab today. We extend the utility-based allocation framework to the radio resource domain by introducing composite spatial complexity, which combines a session's video spatial complexity with its time-variant spectral efficiency into a single resource demand function. To operate with commercial real-time video streaming applications that use rate-based congestion control and lack capability to measure QoE, we use external tooling for QoE measurements. We develop an incremental reallocation algorithm with per-interval limits that encode both the congestion control algorithm's speed constraint and that spatial complexity estimates are reliable only near the current rate. The resulting prototype combines external QoE measurements with congestion-signal-based rate steering and does not require modification to commercial applications. We chart an evolution path from this prototype toward full QoE-aware resource sharing, mapping emerging standards (IETF SCONE, CAMARA, Media over QUIC) to the progressive capabilities they enable.

cs.NI

Towards Near-Real-Time Telemetry-Aware Routing with Neural Routing Algorithms

Routing algorithms are crucial for efficient computer network operations, and in many settings they must be able to react to traffic bursts within milliseconds. Live telemetry data can provide informative signals to routing algorithms, and recent work has trained neural networks to exploit such signals for traffic-aware routing. Yet, aggregating network-wide information is subject to communication delays, and existing neural approaches either assume unrealistic delay-free global states, or restrict routers to purely local telemetry. This leaves their deployability in real-world environments unclear. We cast telemetry-aware routing as a delay-aware closed-loop control problem and introduce a framework that trains and evaluates neural routing algorithms, while explicitly modeling communication and inference delays. On top of this framework, we propose LOGGIA, a scalable graph neural routing algorithm that predicts log-space link weights from attributed topology-and-telemetry graphs. It utilizes a data-driven pre-training stage, followed by on-policy Reinforcement Learning. Across synthetic and real network topologies, and unseen mixed TCP/UDP traffic sequences, LOGGIA consistently outperforms shortest-path baselines, whereas neural baselines fail once realistic delays are enforced. Our experiments further suggest that neural routing algorithms like LOGGIA perform best when deployed fully locally, i.e., observing network states and inferring actions at every router individually, as opposed to centralized decision making.

cs.LG

Interconnecting Regional QKD Networks: Hybrid Key Delivery Across Quantum Domains

QKD technology is being increasingly adopted inside the network core for protecting information transport against any form of computational attacks. However, the use of QKD for wide-area internetworking is still challenging and costly, due to its strong trust assumptions and the low achievable key rates in long QKD links. This paper presents a standards-driven design and implementation of a unified hybrid key delivery service for a network of isolated QKD domains (subnetworks using QKD as provider technology for secret key generation) connected via classical WAN links. The framework follows a distributed architecture and uses a hybrid approach where keys generated in a domain are securely relayed to other domains with PQC (Kyber), dynamically routed, and managed at the system level. The solution has been implemented in an operational testbed comprising three regional subnetworks. We present the design principles, the deployment, and the experimental performance results for this scalable key delivery service.

cs.NI

Automated Synthesis of Deterministic Cross-Domain Interfaces

Deterministic networking spans heterogeneous domains. At each boundary, two domains must agree on an assume--guarantee contract: what traffic the client may inject, and the QoS the carrier will hold for it. Composing such contracts into an end-to-end guarantee is standardized, but deriving each domain's contract is not. Today they are hand-crafted, static, and over-provisioned. The difficulty rises when traffic changes and the contract must become dynamic. We present a framework that automatically synthesizes the per-domain contract for both static and dynamic classes, along with the registration the dynamic one rests on. Two reasoning modules implemented with large language models (LLMs) drive it: an agent takes the client's traffic declaration and searches the carrier's configuration mechanisms, and a handler builds the network model from a typed disclosure of the substrate. The handler calls a network-calculus kernel for the model's hard terms, and an independent oracle---a faithful simulator, testbed, or live network---which verifies each candidate and discovers what lacks an a-priori algebraic form: when a reconfiguration is safe, and the instant to apply it. We synthesized a dynamic contract for uplink 5G fronthaul over a TDM-PON, grounded against a packet-level simulator. Across six draws from two LLM families, every synthesis produced a feasible, verified contract tight to ${\sim}1.2\,\mu$s, holding a $100$-$\mu$s deadline that reactive scheduling cannot meet, at up to $3.5$ times the bandwidth efficiency of static over-provisioning. Tasked instead with computing the worst-case delay directly, the LLMs were unsound in five of six attempts---evidence for the division of labor: LLMs construct the model, formal tools hold numeric authority. The same framework, unchanged, synthesized a static 5G--TSN bridge contract on a second substrate.

cs.NI

Ollama in the Wild: A Longitudinal Measurement of Exposed Ollama LLM Endpoints at Internet Scale

Self-hosted large language model (LLM) serving is emerging as a distinct category of Internet service, but we still know little about how these deployments appear and change on the public Internet. We present a 365-day longitudinal measurement of exposed Ollama endpoints (port 11434) from February 2025 to February 2026, combining daily active probing with GeoIP/ASN enrichment, PTR and port-443 host observations, and survival analysis. Across 362 observation days and approximately 4.8 million IP$\times$day observations, 26.4% of the 152,137 cumulative IPs appear for a single day; across five selected CVEs, only 0.43-2.90% of below-fix IPs upgraded in place; the top five countries/regions account for over 70% of weighted observations; and cloud and hosting providers dominate the top ASNs. These results characterize exposed Ollama as a structural exposure surface: persistent, growing, and heavily concentrated. At the same time, old versions, common model choices, cloud and hosting ASNs, PTR categories, and TLS certificate patterns remain visible across the year, indicating recurring insecure deployment practices in cloud infrastructure and the potential reach of provider-level mitigation.

cs.NI

Det-5G: Closing the Determinism Gap in 5G-Advanced for Industrial Closed-Loop Control

The ultra-reliable low-latency communication (uRLLC) capability of 5G has created significant opportunities for industrial wireless connectivity, yet widespread use of cellular networks for closed-loop control remains challenging. Closed-loop control requires more than low packet latency and high reliability: cyclic command/feedback exchanges must complete within predictable time bounds despite changing channel conditions, recovery transmissions, mobility, and multi-device contention. This paper introduces Deterministic-5G (Det-5G), a unified radio resource allocation framework for industrial closed-loop control. Det-5G treats the complete bidirectional control cycle as the scheduling object and combines coordinated downlink/uplink allocation, adaptive bundled transmissions, group-oriented downlink communication, and optimized multi-user uplink scheduling over 5G air-interface. Its performance is evaluated through a combination of closed-form analysis and Monte Carlo scheduling experiments, with comparisons against conventional dynamic grant-based scheduling, semi-persistent scheduling/configured grant operation, and fixed proactive repetition. The evaluation shows that Det-5G improves predictability of cycle completion, maintains the target reliability under changing link conditions, and scales more effectively to multi-device control than conventional reactive scheduling, while adapting radio resource use instead of continuously provisioning for the worst case as in fixed repetition. These characteristics make cycle-oriented scheduling a pragmatic solution for reducing the determinism gap that limits the use of 5G for closed-loop control in different verticals, especially as it evolves through 5G-Advanced toward 6G.

cs.NI

Blockchain-based Proportional Fair Scheduling for Multi-Operator O-RAN

The openness and disaggregation of Open radio access network (O-RAN) facilitate resource sharing and coordination across networks, creating new demands for efficient and trustworthy cross-operator scheduling. However, such scheduling is beyond the scope and capability of conventional proportional fair scheduling (PFS), which lacks mechanisms for establishing trust among independent operators. To fulfill this gap, we propose the blockchain-based proportional fair scheduling (BC-PFS) that enables trustworthy inter-network coordination and resource pooling across operators in O-RAN. Specifically, we design four core smart contracts including registration, status reporting, scheduling, and settlement contracts with corresponding Solidity implementations to ensure trustworthy on-chain execution. Theoretically, to evaluate the BC-PFS performance, we develop an analytical framework to derive the user average throughput via both probabilistic and ordinary differential equation (ODE) approaches, and provide a simplified closed-form solution. Based on the above performance assessment, we quantify the pooling effect in O-RAN achieved through trustworthy cross-operator collaboration via BC-PFS, and point out that this effect grows monotonically in both the numbers of operator networks and users. Simulations validate the theoretical analysis and show the performance of the BC-PFS in O-RAN.

cs.NI

Perception-Aware Joint Power and Sub-Band Allocation for 6G In-Body Subnetworks

In-body subnetworks (IBSs) are expected to become a key enabler of immersive eXtended Reality (XR) services in sixth-generation (6G) networks by providing ultra-short-range, low-latency wireless connectivity around the human body. However, the dense coexistence of multiple IBSs leads to severe co-channel interference, requiring increased transmit power to satisfy the stringent latency requirements of XR applications. Existing interference management approaches allocate radio resources solely according to application-level Quality-of-Service (QoS) requirements, overlooking the perceptual limitations of human users. This paper proposes perception-aware joint power control and sub-band allocation framework that integrates users' delay perception into radio resource allocation for XR-oriented IBSs. A learning-based perception model is first developed by combining Gaussian mixture modeling (GMM) with supervised learning to develop a statistical model of the delay perception threshold. The learned perception model is then incorporated into a stochastic radio resource allocation problem, which is reformulated using a Lyapunov drift-plus-penalty and solved through a low-complexity per-slot resource allocation procedure. System-level simulations under realistic intra- and inter-IBS propagation conditions demonstrate that the proposed approach substantially improves radio resource efficiency, achieving up to 26% transmit power reduction under stringent latency requirements and approximately 60% power savings in dense IBS deployments, while maintaining the required Quality of Experience (QoE).

cs.NI

No-Regret Mixing of LRU and LFU with Optimal Switching Cost

Caching systems often rely on simple eviction policies such as Least Recently Used (LRU) and Least Frequently Used (LFU), which perform well in complementary request regimes. Recent policies such as LeCar and Cacheus combine LRU and LFU using ideas from the experts problem in online learning. Specifically, upon a miss, they randomize between the two eviction rules using probabilities derived from scores updated by tracking the history of past evictions. While these policies exhibit strong empirical performance, it remains unclear whether they are guaranteed, on every request sequence, to perform asymptotically as well as the better of LRU and LFU, i.e., whether they achieve sublinear regret with respect to this benchmark. We first show that LeCar suffers linear regret against an oblivious adversary, even with unbounded history. We then propose H-MC, a Hedge-based mixture of virtual LRU and LFU caches that preserves Hedge's selection probabilities, and hence its regret guarantees, while minimizing the switching cost among all joint selection rules with these marginals.

cs.LG

How Bitcoin Forms Its Network: Peer-Table Sampling and Structural Properties

The global structure of P2P networks underlying modern cryptocurrencies is hidden by design: each node only knows its neighbors and maintains a local \textit{peer table} of IP addresses. The peer table of a node can be seen as the node's ``local view'' of the set of nodes currently in the network: it is constantly updated with information collected from the neighbors and it is used by the node to establish new connections when needed. The maintenance rules of the nodes' peer tables determine the global structure of the network and its evolution. Even though the global structure is unknown to any node of the network as well as to any external observer, the rules for the exchange of information between neighbors are compatible with the design and use of network \textit{crawlers} that can query the nodes and extract some information about their peer tables. In this paper we first analyze the data we crawled from nodes of the Bitcoin and Dogecoin P2P networks, to collect information about the distribution of IP addresses in the peer tables and to estimate the evolution of network size and churn rate; we then use the estimates to set up the parameters for a simulation of the Bitcoin network and we analyze the evolution of the network structure that we get from the simulation. Overall, our results show that Bitcoin's peer-table maintenance rules induce non-uniform, heavy-tailed visibility patterns while nevertheless generating a well-connected and structurally robust network.

cs.NI

Real-Time dApps for AI-RAN: Measured Interface Requirements for Inline PHY and Slot-Level Control

Distributed applications (dApps) bring AI to the microsecond-to-millisecond band beside the 5G distributed unit (DU), but every public dApp framework realizes them the same way: an external process that receives an indication and returns a control message. That boundary is right for sensing and advisory workloads. It cannot express a neural receiver that must finish inside a slot, and it cannot hold a scheduling decision the MAC is waiting on. This paper asks what a dApp interface must deliver, in latency and bandwidth, for the AI-RAN use cases now filed under that name to be realized as dApps at all. It treats the coupling between a dApp and the DU as a design axis with two legitimate ends, a C ABI inside the DU process and a protocol-standard E3AP association over SCTP, and places the three OCUDU dApp classes on it. An audited corpus of 39 runtime AI-RAN use cases, sized by 5G NR timing, shows that more than half cannot cross the observer boundary: inline PHY work because an indication has no return path into the same slot, and bounded control because of the tail under load. Measuring the mechanisms each framework actually uses, on a quiet host and with a live cell on the air, shows that every carrier meets a 100 us control deadline on an idle host and that only the in-process paths still do once the DU is running. The asynchronous use cases remain feasible at every position, so the protocol-standard end is kept as a first-class option; what in-process placement adds for them is accountable staleness and an observation-to-decision path with no message on it. These measurements derive the released ABI, a stream for inline work, a validated call for bounded control, and a choice of lease, supervised ring, or portable E3 client for observation, and four dApps of all three classes are validated together on one over-the-air cell.

cs.NI

The OCUDU dApp Platform: An Open Runtime and E3 Interface for Real-Time AI-RAN

Machine learning has shown its largest gains in the band below 10 ms inside a 3GPP new radio (NR) 5G distributed unit (DU): link adaptation, per-slot scheduling, channel estimation, and the receiver itself. No open platform has let independently built software run there. Prior dApp frameworks reached the band only as external observers of an export stream. This paper is a guided introduction to the OCUDU dApp platform, an open runtime and E3 interface under which signed AI-RAN applications execute inside a production DU under three timing contracts: resident on the GPU receive chain (Class A), inside the scheduler's 100 us admitted deadline (Class B), or as never-blocking observers whose results the scheduler consumes (Class C). The conventional path is never displaced, and every authority is typed, validated, and operator-bounded. The paper explains how the runtime, the embedded E3 agent, and the three public repositories fit together; shows a dApp's source, its signed package, and its lifecycle state machine; defines the contracts a module is written against; and shows how one management surface serves a Python script, an operator's console, and an LLM agent. On a GB10 gNB with attached handsets, dApps of all three classes, including an out-of-tree neural equalizer, ran together on a live cell without a single fallback, and equalizer variants were compared over the air by lifecycle operations alone. Every measured checkpoint is reported with its conditions and its gaps. Platform, SDK, and a zero-hardware quickstart are public under BSD-3-Clause-Clear as a preview release of the OCUDU AI-RAN Working Group 2, inviting feedback, new use cases, and independent vetting ahead of upstreaming into the OCUDU mainline.

cs.NI

Movable Antennas Enabled Wireless Powered Networks: Principles and Technologies

As an emerging framework, movable antenna (MA)-enabled wireless powered networks (WPNs) have attracted growing attention. WPNs integrate wireless communication and energy transfer. MA can dynamically adjust the position of antenna units by introducing additional spatial degrees of freedom, so as to make full use of channel gain, optimize the effect of energy beamforming, and further improve the performance of WPNs. In this article, we first classify the implementations of MA, and review the fundamental principles of WPNs. We then highlight the key advantages of MA-enabled WPNs in enhancing wireless power transfer efficiency, realizing flexible and adaptive beamforming, and improving system robustness and interference resilience. Furthermore, four representative application scenarios and three key enabling technologies are discussed. A case study is also presented to show the improvement of energy harvesting performance brought by MA for WPNs. Finally, we discuss the challenges and future directions of MA-enabled WPNs, aiming to provide reference for future research and practice.

cs.NI

Modeling Edge-to-Cloud Offloading Workloads for Autonomous Vehicles

Autonomous vehicles often need to upload high volumes of diverse data within the edge-to-cloud continuum: telemetry, sensor data for offline training, and observations used to maintain high definition (HD) maps. We introduce a workload generator that represents each process for individual vehicles and aggregates the resulting traffic for a fleet and its wireless access points. Using Munich city as a real-world case study, we combine SUMO vehicle activity, sensor parameters, and hourly weights derived from recorded road accidents. The studies varying the timing and number of training data selections, model parameters, and transfer deadlines show that, with a two-hour deadline, earliest deadline first scheduling reduces the peak workload by 8.3% without discarding data. At the same total capacity, demand-based allocation reduces the median unserved load from 28.4% under equal allocation to 0% across five rolling evaluations. The generator provides profound reproducible inputs for capacity, scheduling, and placement experiments.

cs.NI

Contextual Chain: A Controlled Simulation Study of Context-Informed Gossip Scheduling for Post-Partition Recovery

We introduce Contextual Chain as a design principle in which evolving operational context can guide subsequent system decisions, and evaluate a first systems realization for post-partition recovery. The central timing experiment uses explicitly separated common-random-number (CRN) streams so that matched timing policies experience identical proposal, broadcast-channel, and gossip-opportunity traces at exactly the same assigned synchronization budget. Relative to approximately uniform FixedMatched timing, the oracle-assisted Adaptive schedule raises final agreement from 0.794 to 0.832 in Case A and from 0.787 to 0.834 in Case B, shortens mean recovery by 14.4 and 12.1 s, and increases the post-rejoin agreement fraction by about 0.044 in both cases. An offline non-contextual DisruptionWindowMatched control preserves each Adaptive run's exact total budget and low/high-rate tick counts while placing high-rate effort around the known disruption boundary without using the quarantine fraction. This control recovers 2.3 and 1.2 s faster than Adaptive and has essentially the same post-rejoin agreement fraction, while Adaptive retains a smaller final-agreement advantage of 2.3 and 1.8 percentage points. Thus most of the recovery-time benefit is explained by concentrating synchronization around disruption/rejoin rather than by the oracle context signal itself; within this simulator, the contextual trigger contributes a modest additional end-of-horizon agreement benefit. A broader factorial screening study shows that synchronization provisioning is the dominant recovery factor, whereas the Full head-selection rule has no consistent advantage over height-only selection. The evidence is limited to an abstract oracle-assisted simulator and assigned pair opportunities; decentralized estimation, bounded state, packet-level cost, adversarial robustness, and deployment validation remain open.

cs.DC

ncsim: A Lightweight Simulator for Networked Edge Computing with Wireless Interference Modeling

Evaluating directed acyclic graph (DAG) task schedulers for wireless edge computing requires jointly modeling compute placement and wireless interference, yet many evaluation setups simplify the wireless coupling. This can lead to rank inversions: a scheduler selected under an interference-free model need not remain best when concurrent wireless traffic is included. We present ncsim, a lightweight discrete-event simulator that combines DAG workflow scheduling with an analytical IEEE 802.11 contention and hidden-interference model in a single Python package. A 108-run factorial experiment on grid networks and DAG workflows finds rank inversions in 6 of 18 scenarios (33.3%). Solo retains single-link MAC overhead, while Full adds concurrent-link wireless effects. Selecting a policy under Solo and executing it under Full incurs a maximum scheduling regret (makespan penalty relative to the best evaluated policy under Full) of 52.3%. Validation includes Bianchi's published numerical and graphical results and fixed-rate ns-3 experiments. The default model closely tracks homogeneous contention. The scheduler results show how wireless coupling can change policy selection within the stated flow model.

cs.DC

Adaptive Bridge: A Proxy-Based Decoupling Layer for Mitigating DDS Backpressure in ROS 2

In systems built on Robot Operating System 2 (ROS 2) and using Data Distribution Service (DDS), a single network-impaired or throttled subscriber on a RELIABLE topic can cause backpressure that degrades throughput and latency for all other subscribers, including safety-critical ones sharing the publisher, because the publisher's DDS writer can no longer accept new samples. We present Adaptive Bridge, a proxy-based layer that decouples critical subscribers from degraded or noncritical ones, thereby isolating the critical path through topic splitting and dynamic rate control. The proxy acts as a middleman and subscribes to the original topic and republishes the messages to two independent DDS writers: one RELIABLE writer for critical nodes and one BEST EFFORT writer for noncritical or degraded nodes, thus isolating the degraded nodes and safeguarding the publisher and critical nodes from backpressure. A probe-based classifier actively monitors subscriber health through sampling with hysteresis and adjusts subscriber rate limits in real time. We evaluate the system under a Gilbert-Elliott bursty wireless loss model using a reproducible Docker-based harness. The results show that using the Adaptive Bridge in our evaluation harness reduces the critical subscriber tail p95 latency from up to 15 s to 1.55 ms across all impairment severities while preserving the publisher's configured throughput.

cs.NI

A Theory of Information Architecture for Networked Decisions: Freshness, Locality, and Coordination

Networked systems face a tradeoff between the scope of the information behind a decision and its freshness: a broader view of the system supports better coordination, but assembling and communicating it takes time, so it arrives older. We study this tradeoff for a team of agents that repeatedly choose actions to minimize a shared quadratic cost driven by an environment that evolves on its own, unaffected by the agents' actions. An information architecture specifies what each agent observes, from where, and with what delay; we measure an architecture by the cost it loses relative to a decision made with complete, current information. We first compare fresh local observations with a complete but delayed global view. When every component of the environment decorrelates at a common exponential rate, this comparison reduces to a closed-form threshold on the ratio of delay to coherence time. We then study intermediate architectures in which each agent acts on a time-aligned, and therefore older, snapshot of a wider neighborhood. The optimal neighborhood radius occurs where the marginal value of added scope equals the marginal cost of lost freshness. In a canonical spatial model, this radius is set by the spatial-correlation, decision-relevance, and temporal-propagation lengths. Throughout, architecture performance is governed by the predictability of the optimal decision rather than of the raw state.

eess.SY
Compare source metadata on this page
WorkPublishedSource identifierSource
Prototyping QoE-Aware Rate Adaptation in Cellular Networks with Commercial Applications2026-09-08Proc. 2026 18th International Conference on Quality of Multimedia Experience (QoMEX), IEEE, 2026, pp. 1-7arxiv
Towards Near-Real-Time Telemetry-Aware Routing with Neural Routing Algorithms2026-04-032604.02927arxiv
Interconnecting Regional QKD Networks: Hybrid Key Delivery Across Quantum Domains2026-04-222604.20376arxiv
Automated Synthesis of Deterministic Cross-Domain Interfaces2026-08-102608.09312arxiv
Ollama in the Wild: A Longitudinal Measurement of Exposed Ollama LLM Endpoints at Internet Scale2026-09-072609.07115arxiv
Det-5G: Closing the Determinism Gap in 5G-Advanced for Industrial Closed-Loop Control2026-09-072609.07386arxiv
Blockchain-based Proportional Fair Scheduling for Multi-Operator O-RAN2026-09-072609.07473arxiv
Perception-Aware Joint Power and Sub-Band Allocation for 6G In-Body Subnetworks2026-09-072609.07519arxiv
No-Regret Mixing of LRU and LFU with Optimal Switching Cost2026-09-072609.07566arxiv
How Bitcoin Forms Its Network: Peer-Table Sampling and Structural Properties2026-09-072609.07609arxiv
Real-Time dApps for AI-RAN: Measured Interface Requirements for Inline PHY and Slot-Level Control2026-09-072609.07805arxiv
The OCUDU dApp Platform: An Open Runtime and E3 Interface for Real-Time AI-RAN2026-09-072609.07843arxiv
Movable Antennas Enabled Wireless Powered Networks: Principles and Technologies2026-09-072609.08042arxiv
Modeling Edge-to-Cloud Offloading Workloads for Autonomous Vehicles2026-03-242603.23310arxiv
Contextual Chain: A Controlled Simulation Study of Context-Informed Gossip Scheduling for Post-Partition Recovery2026-04-082604.06529arxiv
ncsim: A Lightweight Simulator for Networked Edge Computing with Wireless Interference Modeling2026-05-012605.01094arxiv
Adaptive Bridge: A Proxy-Based Decoupling Layer for Mitigating DDS Backpressure in ROS 22026-08-152608.15380arxiv
A Theory of Information Architecture for Networked Decisions: Freshness, Locality, and Coordination2026-09-062609.06351arxiv

These are bibliographic comparisons, not experimental rankings. Follow the original document for methods and conditions.