arXiv Science⌕ Search

subject

cs.NE

cs.NE: explore 93 source-linked works published from 2022 to 2026, with original documents and citations.

This collection is a preview while coverage and quality are evaluated.

Search within this collection

Coverage and selection

Includes records with this source-supplied label or an explicit phrase match in their metadata. Matches indicate a mention, not proof that a paper uses a method or tests a material. Source versions are consolidated by DOI.

Sources: arxiv. Collection updated 2026-09-16. Counts describe this index, not the complete source archives.

Reinforcement learning to choose optimizers

No single optimization method is uniformly best for all problems, and the most suitable optimizer choice can change during a run. Existing approaches that change optimizer during execution typically predetermine part of the strategy: the portfolio is restricted to one algorithm class, the switch occurs once at a fixed time, or the frequency of decisions is treated as a hyperparameter rather than a learned one. We introduce "Reinforcement Learning to Choose Optimizers", which formulates the optimization algorithm choice as a sequential decision-making problem. At each decision, a recurrent policy reads the current run state and decides both which optimizer should be used next and for how long. The portfolio includes both gradient-based and derivative-free optimizers, and each switch passes on the current best solution and a representative step size. A context proxy conditions a gating network over expert heads, and training employs a decoupled actor-critic whose return is expressed in the same empirical runtime distribution metric used at evaluation. Training tasks and portfolio are designed jointly so that no optimizer dominates. On unseen problems, the learned policy outperforms every portfolio optimizer at all but the smallest budgets, and it remains robust under distribution shift.

cs.NE↗

Diffusion models for eye-gaze trajectory generation using position and velocity representations

Eye-tracking data are expensive to collect, requiring specialized hardware and controlled laboratory conditions, and difficult to share because of privacy constraints. We address this using two complementary denoising diffusion probabilistic models (DDPMs) for unconditional generation of eye-gaze dynamics from visual-search data. Both use an identical FiLM-conditioned one-dimensional U-Net with self-attention (19.35,M parameters), trained on 8,s sliding-window sequences from 28 participants. One model generates raw two-dimensional gaze-position sequences, while the other generates two-component velocity sequences; each uses representation-specific preprocessing, training settings, data partitions, and evaluation protocols. Both are evaluated across three independent training seeds, with aggregated metrics reported as mean,$\pm$,SD. The position-space model achieves a mean Jensen-Shannon (JS) divergence of $0.016\pm0.004$ across nine kinematic features, with the highest feature-wise mean below $0.030$, fixation duration within 2% of real data, and a Fr'echet Gaze Distance more than an order of magnitude below statistical and Markovian baselines. Under a Train-on-Synthetic-Test-on-Real protocol, synthetic-only training achieves $R^2=0.66\pm0.02$, or 82.7% of the real-data $R^2$ point estimate. The velocity-space model achieves a mean JS divergence of $0.0065$ across velocity components, speed, log-speed, and turning angle, with a maximum of $0.015\pm0.005$. Reconstructed path length is less accurate ($0.21\pm0.02$ versus $0.03\pm0.01$ in position space), although the protocols differ. Overall, unconditional diffusion captures local gaze kinematics and short-range temporal and directional structure, while long-range properties such as saccade counts and cumulative path geometry remain targets for future conditioned models.

cs.CV↗

Perforated Backpropagation: A Neuroscience Inspired Extension to Artificial Neural Networks

The neurons of artificial neural networks were originally invented when much less was known about biological neurons than is known today. Our work explores a modification to the core neuron unit to make it more parallel to a biological neuron. The modification is made with the knowledge that biological dendrites are not simply passive activation funnels, but also compute complex non-linear functions as they transmit activation to the cell body. The paper explores a novel system of ``perforated'' backpropagation empowering the artificial neurons of deep neural networks to achieve better performance coding for the same features they coded for in the original architecture. After an initial network training phase, additional ``dendrite'' nodes are added to the network and separately trained with a different objective: to correlate their output with the remaining error of the original neurons. The trained dendrites are then frozen, and the original neurons are further trained, now taking into account the additional error signals provided by the dendrites. The cycle of training the original neurons and then adding and training dendrites can be repeated several times until satisfactory performance is achieved. Our algorithm was successfully added to modern state-of-the-art PyTorch networks across multiple domains, improving upon original accuracies and allowing for significant model compression without a loss in accuracy.

cs.NE↗

Persistent Memory Through Triple-Loop Consolidation Under Stochastic Unit Turnover

Dissipative cognitive architectures maintain computation through continuous energy expenditure, where units that exhaust their energy are stochastically replaced with fresh random state. This creates a fundamental challenge: how can persistent, context-specific memory survive when all learnable state is periodically destroyed? Existing memory mechanisms -- including elastic weight consolidation, synaptic intelligence, and surprise-driven gating -- rely on gradient computation and are inapplicable to systems that do not perform it. We introduce Deep Memory (DM), a backpropagation-free persistent memory mechanism operating through a triple-loop consolidation cycle: (1) recording of expert-specific content centroids, (2) seeding of replaced units with stored representations, and (3) stabilization through continuous re-entry. Discrete expert routing via Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) gating is required, in the regimes tested, to prevent the centroid convergence that would render stored memories identical. We derive a Foster-Lyapunov drift bound for the full triple loop, showing that seeding rescales the turnover noise floor. Across $1{,}007$ simulation runs over thirteen blocks: (i) removing stable context-expert binding removes specialization ($\mathrm{MI}=1.10$ vs. $0.001$; $n=91$); (ii) DM achieves $R=0.984$ vs. $0.385$ without memory ($n=16$); (iii) continuous seeding reconstructs representations after interference ($R_\mathrm{recon}=0.978$; one-shot fails; $n=30$); (iv) the mechanism operates within a characterized $(K,p)$ envelope ($n=350$); (v) recording $\times$ seeding is the minimal critical dyad ($n=40$); (vi) associative and reservoir baselines (Hopfield, ESN) are compared under matched turnover ($n=370$). DM is thus a falsifiable, bounded mechanism for persistent memory in backpropagation-free cognitive systems, with functional parallels to hippocampal consolidation.

cs.NE↗

Why Fine-Tuning Encourages Hallucinations and How to Fix It

Large language models are prone to hallucinating factually incorrect statements. A key source of these errors is exposure to new factual information through supervised fine-tuning (SFT), which can increase hallucinations w.r.t.~knowledge acquired during pre-training. Since these errors arise as a by-product of knowledge degradation, we explore whether established continual learning tools can mitigate them. We propose a self-distillation-based SFT method that facilitates effective factual learning while minimizing hallucinations w.r.t.~pre-existing knowledge by regularizing output-distribution drift. We also show that when new knowledge acquisition is unnecessary, suppressing factual plasticity by freezing parameter groups preserves task performance while reducing hallucinations. Lastly, we investigate the mechanism, contrasting capacity limitations, behavior cloning, and localized interference. Our experiments show that a main driver is interference among overlapping semantic representations, which self-distillation mitigates and an associative-memory model explains: forgetting grows with the overlap between new and stored facts.

cs.CL↗

CP$^2$N$^2$: A Control Plane for Heterogeneous Physical Neural Networks

Physical neural networks (PNNs) exploit diverse physical substrates---spanning molecular, wetware, and solid-state devices---to perform embodied neural computation close to physical processes. However, their operational heterogeneity in signal modalities, timing regimes, reset requirements, calibration lifecycles, and observability prevents their integration as interchangeable execution endpoints in edge, fog, and cloud workflows. We present CP$^2$N$^2$, a substrate-aware control-plane architecture that bridges software-level orchestration and physical neural computing. CP$^2$N$^2$ introduces a three-plane model that decouples high-level orchestration, twin-state synchronisation, and substrate-specific execution under versioned Physical Neural Resource Contracts. It extends Model Context Protocol (MCP)-style discovery and invocation with explicit lifecycle management, atomic leases, telemetry freshness verification, and fail-closed safety boundaries. We evaluate a reference prototype across contrasting behavioural twins, a same-host multi-process deployment under fault injection, and the Cortical Labs SDK Simulator. In a 945-request concurrency campaign, CP$^2$N$^2$ enforces typed contention and fail-closed recovery with sub-millisecond local orchestration overhead. Furthermore, in a 160-decision Agent-to-PNN campaign with a hosted LLM planner, independent enforcement ensured that 100% of executed actions remained strictly safe, verified, and reconciled despite planner-level inconsistencies. CP$^2$N$^2$ thus provides an enforceable systems abstraction for integrating scarce, stateful physical AI substrates into agentic computing environments.

cs.DC↗

The Value of Spike Timing: A Leakage-Resistant Benchmark of SNN Design Choices for Network Intrusion Detection

Spiking neural networks (SNNs) are increasingly studied for network intrusion detection, but comparative evidence on how neuron models and spike encodings affect performance remains limited. Evaluation choices can further influence the observed results when preprocessing, capture structure, or scenario information crosses the train-test boundary. We evaluate nine snnTorch neuron families with three spike encodings, yielding 27 SNN configurations across four intrusion-detection benchmarks. We first screen the complete design space and then repeat the evaluation using train-only transforms, seed-independent partitions, and capture- or scenario-aware separation. At the shared operating point, LeakyParallel/latency achieved the lowest mean rank in both sweeps but was not statistically separated from Leaky/latency; their screening order reversed when CTU-13 was excluded. Overall, screening and confirmation retained substantial rank agreement despite changes in measured performance. We then examine what latency coding contributes by holding the active spike set fixed and changing only its temporal organization. At the main T=25 operating point, mapping feature magnitude to spike time improved macro-F1 on all five confirmation protocols, while spreading the same spikes through time without that mapping could either improve or reduce performance. Latency coding thus combines informative spike timing with temporal network dynamics. Sparse input encoding does not directly imply sparse internal activity, although latency coding requires fewer fanout-weighted operations than rate coding in the evaluated models. These findings motivate separate assessment of SNN design, evaluation protocol, spike timing, and computational activity for static network-flow data.

cs.CR↗

ITP-STDP: A Hardware-Efficient Intrinsic-Timing Power-of-Two Synaptic Learning Engine for On-Chip SNNs

Spiking neural networks (SNNs) have the potential to emerge as the third generation of neural networks and have attracted increasing attention across a wide range of applications. However, the large number of synaptic connections in SNNs leads to intensive weight-update computation by on-chip learning algorithms during training, resulting in substantial hardware resource utilization and energy consumption. Among existing SNN learning algorithms, spike-timing-dependent plasticity (STDP) is one of the most extensively studied and widely adopted, serving as a fundamental learning component in SNNs. To address the hardware and energy overheads associated with SNN training, this paper presents intrinsic-timing power-of-two STDP (ITP-STDP) and its corresponding prototype learning engine hardware architecture. The proposed design is evaluated through a dedicated mean-field synaptic drift model for dynamical analysis and further validated across SNN networks of different scales and datasets. It is further implemented on both ASIC and FPGA platforms and compared with state-of-the-art approaches, including the original STDP and more complex STDP variants. The results demonstrate superior energy efficiency, higher operating speed, and substantially lower hardware resource utilization, as the proposed design eliminates most of the computational overhead of STDP through both algorithmic and hardware-level optimizations. On the FPGA platform, the proposed design improves energy efficiency by 4.5$\times$ to 219.8$\times$ over the compared designs. On the ASIC platform, the proposed design achieves a 4.8$\times$ to 22.01$\times$ speedup while consuming only 1.2% to 3.3% of the area required by prior works.

cs.AR↗

Asymptotical Analysis of the $(1+(λ,λ))$ GA Escape Time from Local Optima on Jump Functions

The paper develops the approach to the runtime analysis of evolutionary algorithms on the basis of limit theorems from probability theory. We consider the family of Jump$_k$ benchmark functions, defined on the search space of binary strings of length $n$, parametrized by the integer $k$, which have a plateau of multiple local optima at the Hamming distance $k$ from a unique global optimum. In this work, we consider the genetic algorithm $(1+(λ,λ)) GA$ from (Doerr, Doerr and Ebel, 2015) with tunable parameters of the mutation rate $p$, crossover bias $c$, and two intermediate population sizes $λ_M$ and $λ_C$. We study the time it escapes from the plateau of local optima and reaches the global optimum in the case of Jump$_k$ fitness function and tighten the upper bounds on the expected escape time, known from the work of Antipov, Doerr and Karavaev (2022). The obtained bounds also apply to a wider range of algorithmic parameters. The main result of this work applies to the case when $k\to \infty$ as $n \to \infty.$ The case of finite $k$ is investigated quite simply and considered tangentially.

cs.NE↗

Basins of Attraction to Multiple Fixed Points in Discrete-time Hysteresis Neural Networks

This paper studies multiple fixed points in a discrete-time hysteresis neural network. The network consists of binary hysteresis neurons characterized by the threshold parameter. Depending on the parameter, the network can have a variety of multiple binary fixed points. Stability of each fixed point is characterized by basin of attraction (BOA): the set of initial points falling into the fixed point. In order to evaluate the distribution of BOA sizes, we present entropy. In order to escape from the curse of dimensionality, we introduce a simple problem: classification of binary data set. In the classification, BOAs correspond to classes. In the problem, we clarify that the threshold parameter can control the entropy, especially, can maximize the entropy: the distribution approaches to uniform. As a concrete example, we consider an item response data set in education. Using two fundamental metrics in the item response theory, the classification results are evaluated.

cs.NE↗

Mycelial Search: A Graph-Structured Metaheuristic for Continuous Optimisation

Continuous optimisation methods need to balance sharing information and maintaining alternative search directions. In this paper, we introduce Mycelial Search (Myco), a graph-structured metaheuristic designed around active tips, community-weighted flow, adaptive cord plasticity, and anchor-based injection. Candidate solutions form an evolving spatial graph in which a Louvain partition distinguishes within-community from cross-community information exchange. Adaptive cord plasticity subsequently modifies active tip-to-tip edges according to their alignment with the local flow. An anchor-based injection mechanism supplements the graph-driven tip dynamics. We evaluated Myco on the CEC 2022 single-objective bound-constrained benchmark suite at dimensions $D=10$ and $D=20$, using 30 independent runs per algorithm-function pair. The comparison includes eleven established optimisers from several search families. Myco reaches competitive results on selected functions across both dimensions. The ablation analysis further shows that community structure regulates the range of graph-based information exchange, whereas cord plasticity controls the persistence of local directional influence. These findings indicate that graph-structured local interaction can support continuous optimisation, while its effectiveness depends on landscape structure and information transfer across local search regions.

cs.NE↗

TPR-Attention for Combinatorial Generalization

Systematic generalization remains a significant challenge in deep learning. In particular, combinatorial generalization - generalizing to new configurations of known factors of variation - is effortless for humans but difficult for standard neural architectures that rely on statistical correlations rather than explicit structural representations. We introduce a new architectural component that embeds structured inductive bias into deep learning: an attention mechanism operating over tensor-product representations (TPRs). Through controlled experiments on compositional tasks, we show that this TPR-attention mechanism outperforms existing architectural components in combinatorial generalization. These results highlight the value of integrating explicit compositional structure into neural attention and point toward a promising path for models capable of systematic generalization.

cs.LG↗

"More Is Different'' in Neural Circuits: Algebraic Emergence of Effective Theories in Canonical Recurrent Motifs of Biological Neuronal Networks

Canonical neural circuit motifs are usually described functionally: divisive normalization rescales population activity by a pooled signal, and winner-take-all competition selects one pattern through recurrent excitation and shared inhibition. We represent them, and their compositions, algebraically as finite transformation systems and analyze the transition monoids generated by their input-conditioned updates, distinguishing structure already present in a generator from structure that appears only through composition, and, on a joint state space, structure inherited from one factor from structure that lives on a joint configuration. Individually aperiodic updates can generate non-aperiodic monoids. In the WTA, every frozen-drive generator collapses to fixed points, yet short input sequences create local cycles of winner-dependent inhibitory gating: globally dissipative dynamics with a reversible action. The strongest result arises in WTA-to-DN composition. The composed monoid then contains a genuinely composite local cycle in which normalization state and the winner's gating state change together, although every primitive generator is aperiodic. Holonomy analysis certifies this as a group component of the Krohn-Rhodes cascade rather than an incidental cycle, and finds most group-carrying image sets on joint configurations, whereas the uncoupled product has none. An exhaustive interface sweep shows that the composite cycle is a property of the coupling rather than of a chosen map. If motifs are building blocks of neural computation, composing them is a form of programming: one chooses primitives and interfaces so that the generated algebra has the intended repertoire. The transition monoid is that repertoire - what a primitive presents to any later construction. Recurrent circuits are compositional transformation systems; their algebra constrains what they can be programmed to compute.

q-bio.NC↗

Event-Driven Language Models with Sparse Neural Activity for Neuromorphic Hardware

Inference with transformer-based large language models (LLMs) is often limited by the memory-bound KV cache and quadratic attention cost. State-space models (SSMs) mitigate this through linear attention and fixed-size recurrent states, but their large dense linear projections remain computationally expensive even after quantization. We introduce a method that induces sparse neural activity in heavily quantized linear-attention models with minimal performance loss. Activations below a per-projection trainable threshold ($\pm Δ$) are nullified while preserving crucial outliers, achieving comparable performance to dense models with up to 4$\times$ fewer effective arithmetic operations. Targeting a multi-core, multi-chip neuromorphic platform, where event-driven execution converts unstructured sparsity into throughput at both the compute and communication levels, a capability GPU architectures fundamentally lack, we project up to 37$\times$ higher throughput and 16$\times$ lower power versus edge GPU inference of a comparable transformer-based model, and up to 5.4$\times$ improvements over the non-sparsified baseline. These results position sparse, quantized linear-attention models as a natural fit for deploying LLMs on event-driven multi-core platforms.

cs.NE↗

Conjoint Audio-to-Spikes Encoding and Processing for Efficient Neuromorphic Speech Recognition

Obtaining data from neuromorphic sensors and processing it with Spiking Neural Networks is a promising solution to lower the energy cost of artificial intelligence. The current rarity of natively neuromorphic datasets promotes the development of software tools to translate input sensory data into spikes. However, highly bio-mimetic simulators can be challenging to implement on digital hardware. In this work, we evaluate the neuromorphic encoding and subsequent classification of audio into spikes using a non-learnable, high-level, programmable encoder targeting hardware implementation on FPGA. We quantify the pipeline's efficiency with hardware-agnostic metrics based on the quantitative spiking activity. Our study focuses on the simultaneous optimisation of encoder and classifier: the first provides efficient and informative data so that the latter achieves a better performance with an overall lower energy cost at learning and inference. This work introduces the first end-to-end neuromorphic spike-encoding and evaluation of the TIMIT dataset. Our simple feedforward network reaches a classification accuracy of 99.77% on a spike-encoded Heidelberg Digits, overcoming the neuromorphic state of the art on this benchmark dataset.

cs.NE↗

Flawed in Nature, Perfect through Evolution

The performance of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) models degrades when the problem they were trained on drifts. This is a near-universal feature of real-world problems, which often change unpredictably. Biological evolution has achieved intelligence by overcoming this obstacle through natural selection acting on heritable variation. AI/ML techniques have long incorporated forms of natural selection, but it has been challenging to maintain model diversity as optimization naturally drives convergence. Here we show that a swarm of AI/ML models subjected to deliberate mutations of their model coefficients away from optimality can reliably and sustainably improve performance in changing environments by acting as a statistical hedge against non-stationarity. We call this mechanism 'Flawed in Nature, Perfect through Evolution', reflecting that the collective performance gain goes at the expense of individual performance. We prove via four theorems that the resulting regret reduction is guaranteed under general conditions, establishing the Flawed-in-Nature mechanism as a generalizable design principle for AI/ML systems. We validate these results on synthetic linear regression tasks, demonstrating that the mutated swarm delivers the best model in $\sim80\%$ of environment changes and that inference synthesis successfully translates this individual advantage into a collective one. The mechanism proves to be most effective when the mutation drift rate matches the drift rate of the environment. We outline a simple, adaptive controller that enables practical applications by tuning the mutation drift rate to match the unknown drift rate of the environment. The close analogy of the Flawed-in-Nature mechanism to biological evolution suggests it may have been a critical missing ingredient for the organic discovery of AI forms that more closely mimic biological intelligence.

cs.LG↗

Where Should Experience Live? Hierarchical Hebbian Memory for Continual Vision Transformers

Vision Transformers provide strong visual representations but typically rely on slowly updated parameters, limiting their ability to organize newly acquired information across different memory timescales. This work proposes \textit{Hierarchical Hebbian Memory}, a three-level memory architecture composed of rapid Working Memory, persistent Routed Episodic Memory, and slower Semantic Memory. A learned controller regulates memory contribution, read and write routing, plasticity, retention, and consolidation. A causal read-before-write lifecycle ensures that the current outcome cannot influence the prediction it supervises. The architecture is evaluated on Omniglot 5-way 1-shot recognition and CORe50 continual object recognition. With Swin-Tiny, the hierarchical model reaches 97.39\% accuracy on Omniglot and 95.37\% final accuracy on CORe50 when combined with experience replay. Learned multi-bank retrieval reaches 47.50\% delayed-association accuracy, compared with 24.17\% for a single persistent bank and 25.00\% without memory. After intervening distractors, Episodic Memory retains approximately 0.96 cosine similarity with stored associations, while Working Memory falls to approximately 0.05. These results show that Hebbian association and learned memory routing can jointly organize online visual experience across rapid, persistent, and consolidated memory timescales within Vision Transformers.

cs.CV↗

Efficient Memristive Spiking Neural Networks Architecture with Supervised In-Situ STDP Method

Memristor-based Spiking Neural Networks (SNNs) with temporal spike encoding enable ultra-low-energy computation, making them ideal for battery-powered intelligent devices. This paper presents a circuit-level memristive spiking neural network (SNN) architecture trained using a proposed novel supervised in-situ learning algorithm inspired by spike-timing-dependent plasticity (STDP). The proposed architecture efficiently implements lateral inhibition and the refractory period, eliminating the need for external microcontrollers or ancillary control hardware. All synapses of the winning neurons are updated in parallel, enhancing training efficiency. The modular design ensures scalability with respect to input data dimensions and output class count. The SNN is evaluated in LTspice for pattern recognition (using 5x3 binary images) and classification tasks using the Iris and Breast Cancer Wisconsin (BCW) datasets. During testing, the system achieved perfect pattern recognition and high classification accuracies of 99.11\% (Iris) and 97.9\% (BCW). Additionally, it has demonstrated robustness, maintaining an average recognition rate of 93.4\% under 20\% input noise. The impact of stuck-at-conductance faults and memristor device variations was also analyzed.

cs.ET↗
Compare source metadata on this page
WorkPublishedSource identifierSource
Reinforcement learning to choose optimizers2026-09-012609.01811arxiv
Diffusion models for eye-gaze trajectory generation using position and velocity representations2026-09-012609.05522arxiv
Perforated Backpropagation: A Neuroscience Inspired Extension to Artificial Neural Networks2026-08-312501.18018arxiv
Persistent Memory Through Triple-Loop Consolidation Under Stochastic Unit Turnover2026-09-242603.27188arxiv
Why Fine-Tuning Encourages Hallucinations and How to Fix It2026-09-252604.15574arxiv
CP$^2$N$^2$: A Control Plane for Heterogeneous Physical Neural Networks2026-08-312605.04256arxiv
The Value of Spike Timing: A Leakage-Resistant Benchmark of SNN Design Choices for Network Intrusion Detection2026-10-092606.01442arxiv
ITP-STDP: A Hardware-Efficient Intrinsic-Timing Power-of-Two Synaptic Learning Engine for On-Chip SNNs2026-08-312606.06159arxiv
Asymptotical Analysis of the $(1+(λ,λ))$ GA Escape Time from Local Optima on Jump Functions2026-08-312607.14278arxiv
Basins of Attraction to Multiple Fixed Points in Discrete-time Hysteresis Neural Networks2026-08-312608.23225arxiv
Mycelial Search: A Graph-Structured Metaheuristic for Continuous Optimisation2026-08-312608.23323arxiv
TPR-Attention for Combinatorial Generalization2026-08-312608.30124arxiv
"More Is Different'' in Neural Circuits: Algebraic Emergence of Effective Theories in Canonical Recurrent Motifs of Biological Neuronal Networks2026-08-312608.30231arxiv
Event-Driven Language Models with Sparse Neural Activity for Neuromorphic Hardware2026-08-312608.30439arxiv
Conjoint Audio-to-Spikes Encoding and Processing for Efficient Neuromorphic Speech Recognition2026-08-312608.30792arxiv
Flawed in Nature, Perfect through Evolution2026-08-312609.00129arxiv
Where Should Experience Live? Hierarchical Hebbian Memory for Continual Vision Transformers2026-08-312609.00358arxiv
Efficient Memristive Spiking Neural Networks Architecture with Supervised In-Situ STDP Method2026-08-302507.20998arxiv

These are bibliographic comparisons, not experimental rankings. Follow the original document for methods and conditions.