arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Umang Mathur

Publications and source records attributed to Umang Mathur.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Partial Borrows in Rust

Rust ensures memory safety by requiring exclusive access to mutably borrowed data. However, a borrow can prevent access to more data than necessary. For example, a method with an &mut self parameter borrows the entire struct, even when the method uses only some of its fields. Calling the method can therefore conflict with an existing borrow of a field the method never uses, causing Rust to reject the program. Resolving such conflicts can require programmers to compromise useful abstractions, make non-local changes to their programs, or worse, resort to unsafe code. We introduce view types, a backward-compatible refinement of reference types that specifies which fields a reference may access. This allows methods to partially borrow a struct, accessing only the fields they need without blocking access to the rest. We establish the first fully mechanized foundation for Aeneas in Rocq. Along the way, we uncover and fix gaps in the original semantics and proofs. Building on this foundation, we formalize partial borrows and prove the extended borrow checking sound. We implement view types in rustc and extend the Aeneas interpreter to support partial borrows. Our evaluation shows how view types systematically resolve borrowing conflicts across method boundaries at no runtime cost.

cs.PL↗

Quantifying the Advantage of Coarser DPOR

Dynamic partial-order reduction (DPOR) has emerged as a promising approach to addressing interleaving explosion in bounded model checking of concurrent programs. Given an equivalence relation on interleavings, the model checker explores a program's executions while minimizing repeated visits to the same class; optimal model checkers avoid such repetition altogether. A coarser equivalence promises faster exploration by reducing the number of classes. This has motivated alternatives to Mazurkiewicz's trace equivalence such as reads-from and reads-value-from equivalence. This promise, however, does not always materialize in practice: while a coarser equivalence can yield exponentially fewer classes on some families of programs, it may offer little or no reduction for the program at hand. We show how to quantify the advantage of coarser equivalences for individual programs. We focus on the problem of counting the reads-from (RF) equivalence classes induced by a given program, as well as the problem of computing the ratio of RF to Mazurkiewicz class counts under sequential consistency. We show that both problems are $\#\mathrm{P}$-hard and that the reduction ratio remains hard to approximate accurately under standard complexity assumptions. Guided by these limits, we present CoEst, a sampling-based algorithm for estimating both the RF count and its ratio to the Mazurkiewicz count. For a fixed number of threads, each trial runs in polynomial time and yields unbiased count estimates. As the number of independent trials grows, the count and ratio estimates converge almost surely to their true values. Our algorithm can provide statistical evidence for deciding whether Mazurkiewicz or RF model checking is likely to be faster for a given program. In experiments across 34 benchmark configurations, our method selects the faster checker in 99.4% of runs using a one-minute estimation budget.

cs.PL↗

A Type System for Communication-Safe Hardware Design

Hardware components communicate through clock-cycle-sensitive protocols. Hardware Description Languages (HDLs), however, provide limited support for expressing these protocols or for checking that independently developed components agree on them. When components disagree, the composed design can perform unsynchronized exchanges or stop making progress. We call these failures communication-safety violations. Communication safety is thus a global property, determined by interactions between components. This makes it difficult to check modularly. This paper presents Pact, a typed extension of Anvil for modular verification of communication safety in synchronous hardware. Pact types describe message-passing, control-flow, and clock-cycle behaviour. Each component is checked against its type. Compatible types guarantee that the components compose into a communication-safe system. Pact also supports incremental design. It can check a subsystem before the rest of the system exists. The check produces a summary type that captures the communication behaviour left for future compositions. To reduce annotation burden, Pact infers types by abstracting payload values while preserving communication, timing, control, and fairness. These inferred types are optimal for the checker: whenever some checker-accepted types can prove compatibility, the inferred types can prove it as well. Type inference and type checking are decidable, and compatibility is decided by a sound and complete algorithm. We implement Pact by extending the Anvil compiler and evaluate it along five dimensions: detecting communication errors in incremental design, expressiveness on ten clock-cycle-accurate translations of open-source hardware IPs, compatibility-checking time, generated hardware overhead, and annotation burden. Pact expresses realistic protocols and verifies all ten benchmarks in reasonable time.

cs.PL↗

Instrumentation Optimization for Practical Dynamic Race Detection

Dynamic data race detectors are successful at flagging concurrency bugs, but their high runtime overhead limits adoption. This overhead stems primarily from pervasive instrumentation of memory accesses -- a significant fraction of which is for safe accesses. We address this inefficiency through a compiler-integrated approach that identifies safe accesses using static analysis and eliminates instrumentation for these. We strike a careful balance between analysis precision and cost, to ensure applicability to real-world applications. We show that our optimizations never cause ThreadSanitizer to miss races it would otherwise detect. We further observe that many checks are redundant: They only flag a race if a preceding check has already flagged an equivalent race for the same memory location. We show that, when reporting one representative per class is sufficient, even more instrumentation can be eliminated. Lastly, we introduce a dynamic technique that skips instrumentation when there is only one thread at runtime, even when this could not be determined statically. We integrate these static analyses and program transformations into the ThreadSanitizer race detector based on LLVM. Our experiments on a diverse suite of real-world applications, including Memcached, Redis, SQLite, MySQL, and Chromium, demonstrate that our optimizations reduce the number of instrumentation calls at runtime by up to 91% and yield application-level speedups of up to 1.91x, a geometric-mean Chromium speedup of 1.25x on Blink and 1.14x on Speedometer 3.0, and peak speedups reaching 2.28x on Memcached with two server threads. Our optimizations are in the process of being upstreamed into ThreadSanitizer.

cs.PL↗

Scenario Proofs for Verification of Distributed Protocols

Formal verification of distributed protocols is still dominated by inductive-invariant proofs, whose central challenge is discovering strengthening assertions that rule out unreachable states. This burden is often misaligned with how protocol designers reason: they explain correctness by following representative executions, causal histories, and phase-structured interactions among nodes. This paper introduces scenario proofs, a verification methodology that makes such execution-oriented reasoning formal. A scenario is a structured expression describing representative protocol executions, enriched with ghost variables. Rather than enumerate all possible interleavings, a scenario describes canonical executions and uses a sound semi-commutation relation to account for reorderings that preserve feasibility and final states. Verification then factors into two main obligations. Coverage shows that every feasible protocol execution is equivalent, up to semi-commutation, to one described by the scenario; this obligation is independent of the safety property and serves as a reusable behavioral characterization of the protocol. Correctness proves the desired safety property only over the representative executions, using Hoare-style weakest-precondition reasoning along the scenario structure. We formalize the scenario language, its layered semantics, and proof rules for coverage and correctness. Through case studies of ring leader election, two-phase commit, a decentralized lock, two variants of multi-signature payment, and single-decree Paxos, we show how scenario proofs capture the causal and phase-based arguments used informally by protocol designers. These examples illustrate that scenario proofs can replace monolithic invariant discovery with structured reasoning over representative executions, while retaining a rigorous connection to all feasible protocol behaviors.

cs.PL↗

SafePar: Monitoring Asynchrony in Microservices

Modern cloud applications are built from loosely-coupled microservices that coordinate through well-defined APIs to service user requests. A single API request often triggers multiple downstream API calls, some executed sequentially and others spawned asynchronously in parallel. To certify safe and secure inter-service interactions in such applications, security and compliance teams must enforce policies not only over nested call/return structure, but also over the parallel structure of an execution: which calls may run concurrently, how many parallel branches can be spawned, and what combination of branch outcomes are allowed. However, existing runtime enforcement mechanisms typically model executions as sequential or purely nested traces, and cannot capture the parallel structure introduced by asynchronous API calls. Furthermore, since application implementations may not be accessible to security and compliance teams, the policy enforcement mechanism should be decoupled from the service implementation. We introduce SafePar, a specification and monitoring framework for policies over concurrent microservice executions. A SafePar policy constrains both the order of API calls and their series-parallel structure. To support seamless deployments, each policy is compiled into a series-parallel visibly pushdown automaton, a new model of computation we propose in this work, that drives a distributed runtime monitor implemented on top of the servicemesh layer. Our technique is blackbox and non-invasive: it requires no access or changes to the service implementation. Our experiments show that SafePar enforces rich concurrency-aware policies while incurring only millisecond-scale latency overhead.

cs.PL↗

State Space Estimation for DPOR-based Model Checkers(Extended Version)

We study the estimation problem for concurrent programs: given a bounded program $P$, estimate the number of Mazurkiewicz trace-equivalence classes induced by its interleavings. This quantity informs two practical questions for enumeration-based model checking: how long a model checking run is likely to take, and what fraction of the search space has been covered so far. We first show the counting problem is #P-hard even for restricted programs and, unless $P=NP$, inapproximable within any subexponential factor, ruling out efficient exact or randomized approximation algorithms. We give a Monte Carlo approach to obtain a poly-time unbiased estimator: we convert a stateless optimal DPOR algorithm into an unbiased estimator by viewing its exploration as a bounded-depth, bounded-width tree whose leaves are the maximal Mazurkiewicz traces. A classical estimator by Knuth, when run on this tree, yields an unbiased estimate. To control the variance, we apply stochastic enumeration by maintaining a small population of partial paths per depth whose evolution is coupled. We have implemented our estimator in the JMC model checker and evaluated it on shared-memory benchmarks. With modest budgets, our estimator yields stable estimates, typically within a 20% band, within a few hundred trials, even when the state space has $10^5$--$10^6$ classes. We also show how the same machinery estimates model-checking cost by weighting all explored graphs, not only complete traces. Our algorithms provide the first provable poly-time unbiased estimators for counting traces, a problem of considerable importance when allocating model checking resources.

cs.PL↗

Mostly Automatic Translation of Language Interpreters from C to Safe Rust

Translating C programs to safe Rust is challenging owing to significant differences in typing constraints, ownership, and borrowing rules. Interpreter programs are particularly important targets for such translation, as they often handle untrusted inputs and suffer from memory-related vulnerabilities. We present Reboot, a mostly-automatic technique that translates real-world interpreter programs from C to safe Rust. Using Reboot, we have translated six interpreters ranging from 6k to 23k lines of C code to safe Rust, with each translation requiring only 1 to 11 brief user interventions. All translations pass 100% of the provided test suites, and achieve 62%--92% pass rates on separately created validation tests that were never exposed to the system. A security case study on mujs shows that memory vulnerabilities such as heap buffer overflows and use-after-free present in C are eliminated in the safe Rust translation. Two ideas underpin Reboot. First, feature reduction decomposes the translation by program features, creating a sequence of milestones where each is a complete, testable program; the translation starts from the simplest version and incrementally restores features, with each milestone validated before proceeding. Second, a multi-agent architecture orchestrates inherently unreliable coding agents through automated validation and feedback, keeping long-running translation workflows on track with minimal human involvement. An ablation study confirms that feature reduction improves translation correctness compared to using multi-agent translation alone, with 6%--20% improvements in pass rates on validation test suites.

cs.PL↗

Fixed Parameter Tractable Linearizability Monitoring

We study the linearizability monitoring problem, which asks whether a given concurrent history of a data structure is equivalent to some sequential execution of the same data structure. In general, this problem is $\textsf{NP}$-hard, even for simple objects such as registers. Recent work has identified tractable cases for restricted classes of histories, notably unambiguous and differentiated histories. We revisit the tractability boundary from a fine-grained, parameterized perspective. We show that for a broad class of data structures -- including stacks, queues, priority queues, and maps -- linearizability monitoring is fixed-parameter tractable when parameterized by the number of processes. Concretely, we give an algorithm running in time $O(c^{k} \cdot \textsf{poly}(n))$, where $n$ is the history size, $k$ is the number of processes, and $c$ is a constant, yielding efficient performance when $k$ is small. Our approach reduces linearizability monitoring to a language reachability problem on graphs, which asks whether a labeled graph admits a path whose label sequence belongs to a fixed language $L$. We identify classes of languages that capture the sequential specifications of the above data structures and show that language reachability is efficiently solvable on the graph structures induced by concurrent histories. Our results complement prior hardness results and existing tractable subclasses, and provide a unified algorithmic framework. We implement our approach and demonstrate significant runtime improvements over existing algorithms, which exhibit exponential worst-case behavior.

cs.PL↗

Adversarial Agent Collaboration for Correctness Improvements of C to Safe Rust Translation

Translating C to memory-safe languages, like Rust, prevents critical memory safety vulnerabilities that are prevalent in legacy C software. Even with recent LLM-based and tool-augmented translators, the resulting Rust code frequently diverges from the C source on inputs absent from the test suite used during translation; this correctness gap on unseen inputs remains a dominant obstacle to reliable, automatic C-to-Rust translation. In this work, we present ACToR (Adversarial C To Rust), a simple LLM-agent loop that closes this gap by adversarially searching for inputs on which the translation diverges from the C source, and using them to drive subsequent refinements. Inspired by GANs, ACToR pits a translator agent against a discriminator agent that collaborate to iteratively refine the Rust translation. On each iteration, the translator agent synthesizes and refines a Rust translation to pass an existing suite of tests, and then the discriminator agent finds new failing tests by constructing and refining a differential fuzzer over the C and Rust binaries. Across 63 real-world command-line C utilities, with an average size of 473 lines of code and the longest reaching thousands of lines in size, ACToR achieves over 90% test pass rate with zero human intervention. The improvement holds across seven agent-LLM configurations on our micro-benchmark, indicating that the loop is largely independent of the choice of underlying translator and LLM. Compared to a non-adversarial, coverage-driven test-generation baseline, ACToR improves correctness by up to 36.7%. When applied on top of one recent translator, C2SaferRust, ACToR further improves the validation pass rate by 16.6%.

cs.SE↗

Parametrizing Reads-From Equivalence for Predictive Monitoring

Predictive runtime monitoring asks whether an execution $σ$ of a concurrent program can be used to \emph{soundly predict} the existence of a reordering $ρ$ of $σ$ that satisfies a property $φ$. Its effectiveness and efficiency depend on two factors: (a) the complexity of $φ$, and (b) the expressive power of the reorderings considered. At one extreme, allowing all reorderings induced by \emph{reads-from equivalence} makes predictive monitoring intractable, even for simple properties such as data races. At the other extreme, restricting to commutativity-based reorderings (Mazurkiewicz trace equivalence) yields efficient algorithms for simple properties, but remains intractable for general regular specifications and offers limited predictive power. We address this tradeoff via \emph{parametrization}. We introduce \emph{sliced reorderings} and their generalization, \emph{$k$-sliced reorderings}. Informally, $ρ$ is a $k$-sliced reordering of $σ$ if $σ$ can be partitioned into $k+1$ ordered subsequences whose concatenation yields $ρ$, while preserving program order and reads-from constraints. Our results are twofold. First, $k$-sliced reorderings form a strictly increasing hierarchy that converges to reads-from equivalence as $k$ grows. Second, for any fixed $k$, predictive monitoring modulo $k$-sliced reorderings against any regular specification admits a constant-space streaming algorithm. Together, these results establish $k$-sliced reorderings as a principled alternative to existing equivalences, enabling a uniform parametrized framework where expressive power can be systematically traded off against computational cost.

cs.PL↗

Predictive Monitoring against Pattern Regular Languages

In this paper, we focus on the problem of dynamically analysing concurrent software against high-level temporal specifications. Existing techniques for runtime monitoring against such specifications are primarily designed for sequential software and remain inadequate in the presence of concurrency -- violations may be observed only in intricate thread interleavings, requiring many re-runs of the underlying software. Towards this, we study the problem of predictive runtime monitoring, inspired by the analogous problem of predictive data race detection studied extensively recently. The predictive runtime monitoring question asks, given an execution $σ$, if it can be soundly reordered to expose violations of a specification. In this paper, we focus on specifications that are given in regular languages. Our notion of reorderings is trace equivalence, where an execution is considered a reordering of another if it can be obtained from the latter by successively commuting adjacent independent actions. We first show that the problem of predictive admits a super-linear lower bound of $O(n^α)$, where $n$ is the number of events in the execution, and $α$ is a parameter describing the degree of commutativity. As a result, predictive runtime monitoring even in this setting is unlikely to be efficiently solvable. Towards this, we identify a sub-class of regular languages, called pattern languages (and their extension generalized pattern languages). Pattern languages can naturally express specific ordering of some number of (labelled) events, and have been inspired by popular empirical hypotheses, the `small bug depth' hypothesis. More importantly, we show that for pattern (and generalized pattern) languages, the predictive monitoring problem can be solved using a constant-space streaming linear-time algorithm.

cs.PL↗

The Complexity of Testing Message-Passing Concurrency

A key computational question underpinning the automated testing and verification of concurrent programs is the consistency question - given a partial execution history, can it be completed in a consistent manner? Due to its importance, consistency testing has been studied extensively for memory models, as well as for database isolation levels. A common theme in all these settings is the use of shared-memory as the primal mode of interthread communication. On the other hand, modern programming languages, such as Go, Rust and Kotlin, advocate a paradigm shift towards channel-based (i.e., message-passing) communication. However, the consistency question for channel-based concurrency is currently poorly understood. In this paper we lift the study of fundamental consistency problems to channels, taking into account various input parameters, such as the number of threads executing, the number of channels, and the channel capacities. We draw a rich complexity landscape, including upper bounds that become polynomial when certain input parameters are fixed, as well as hardness lower bounds. Our upper bounds are based on algorithms that can drive the verification of channel consistency in automated verification tools. Our lower bounds characterize minimal input parameters that are sufficient for hardness to arise, and thus shed light on the intricacies of testing channel-based concurrency. In combination, our upper and lower bounds characterize the boundary of tractability/intractability of verifying channel consistency, and imply that our algorithms are often (nearly) optimal.

cs.PL↗

Counting and Sampling Traces in Regular Languages

In this work, we study the problems of counting and sampling Mazurkiewicz traces that a regular language touches. Fix an alphabet $Σ$ and an independence relation $\mathbb{I} \subseteq Σ\times Σ$. The input consists of a regular language $L \subseteq Σ^*$, given by a finite automaton with $m$ states, and a natural number $n$ (in unary). For the counting problem, the goal is to compute the number of Mazurkiewicz traces (induced by $\mathbb{I}$) that intersect the $n^\text{th}$ slice $L_n = L \cap Σ^n$, i.e., traces that admit at least one linearization in $L_n$. For the sampling problem, the goal is to output a trace drawn from a distribution that is approximately uniform over all such traces. These tasks are motivated by bounded model checking with partial-order reduction, where an \emph{a priori} estimate of the reduced state space is valuable, and by testing methods for concurrent programs that use partial-order-aware random exploration. We first show that the counting problem is #P-hard even when $L$ is accepted by a deterministic automaton, in sharp contrast to counting words of a DFA, which is polynomial-time solvable. We then prove that the problem lies in #P for both NFAs and DFAs, irrespective of whether $L$ is trace-closed. Our main algorithmic contributions are a \emph{fully polynomial-time randomized approximation scheme} (FPRAS) that, with high probability, approximates the desired count within a prescribed accuracy, and a \emph{fully polynomial-time almost uniform sampler} (FPAUS) that generates traces whose distribution is provably close to uniform.

cs.FL↗

Anvil: A General-Purpose Timing-Safe Hardware Description Language

Expressing hardware designs using hardware description languages (HDLs) routinely involves using stateless signals whose values change according to their underlying registers. Unintended behaviours can arise when the stored values in these underlying registers are mutated while their dependent signals are expected to remain constant across multiple cycles. Such timing hazards are common because, with a few exceptions, existing HDLs lack abstractions for values that remain unchanged over multiple clock cycles, delegating this responsibility to hardware designers. Designers must then carefully decide whether a value should remain unchanged, sometimes even across hardware modules. This paper proposes Anvil, an HDL which statically prevents timing hazards with a novel type system. Anvil is the only HDL we know of that guarantees timing safety, i.e., absence of timing hazards, without sacrificing expressiveness for cycle-level timing control or dynamic timing behaviours. Unlike many HLS languages that abstract away the differences between registers and signals, Anvil's type system exposes them fully while capturing the timing relationships between register value mutations and signal usages to enforce timing safety. This, in turn, enables safe composition of communicating hardware modules by static enforcement of timing contracts that encode timing constraints on shared signals. Such timing contracts can be specified parametric on abstract time points that can vary during run-time, allowing the type system to statically express dynamic timing behaviour. We have implemented Anvil and successfully used it to implement key timing-sensitive modules, comparing them against open-source SystemVerilog counterparts to demonstrate the practicality and expressiveness of the generated hardware.

cs.AR↗

Efficient Decrease-and-Conquer Linearizability Monitoring

Linearizability has become the de facto correctness specification for implementations of concurrent data structures. While formally verifying such implementations remains challenging, linearizability monitoring has emerged as a promising first step to rule out early problems in the development of custom implementations, and serves as a key component in approaches that stress test such implementations. In this work, we investigate linearizability monitoring -- check if an execution history of an implementation is linearizable. While this problem is intractable in general, a systematic understanding of when it becomes tractable has remained elusive. We revisit this problem and first present a unified `decrease-and-conquer' algorithmic framework for linearizability monitoring. At its heart, this framework asks to identify special linearizability-preserving values in a given history -- values whose presence yields an equilinearizable sub-history when removed, and whose absence indicates non-linearizability. We prove that a polynomial time algorithm for the problem of identifying linearizability-preserving values, yields a polynomial time algorithm for linearizability monitoring, while conversely, intractability of this problem implies intractability of the monitoring problem. We demonstrate our framework's effectiveness by instantiating it for several popular data types -- sets, stacks, queues and priority queues -- deriving polynomial time algorithms for each, with the unambiguity restriction, where each insertion to the underlying data structure adds a distinct value. We optimize these algorithms to achieve the optimal log-linear time complexity by amortizing the cost of solving sub-problems through efficient data structures. Our implementation and evaluation on publicly available implementations show that our approach scales to large histories and outperforms existing tools.

cs.PL↗

Dynamic Race Detection With O(1) Samples

Happens before-based dynamic analysis is the go-to technique for detecting data races in large scale software projects due to the absence of false positive reports. However, such analyses are expensive since they employ expensive vector clock updates at each event, rendering them usable only for in-house testing. In this paper, we present a sampling-based, randomized race detector that processes only constantly many events of the input trace even in the worst case. This is the first sub-linear time (i.e., running in o(n) time where n is the length of the trace) dynamic race detection algorithm; previous sampling based approaches like Pacer run in linear time (i.e., O(n)). Our algorithm is a property tester for HB-race detection -- it is sound in that it never reports any false positive, and on traces that are far, with respect to hamming distance, from any race-free trace, the algorithm detects an HB-race with high probability. Our experimental evaluation of the algorithm and its comparison with state-of-the-art deterministic and sampling based race detectors shows that the algorithm does indeed have significantly low running time, and detects races quite often.

cs.PL↗

Program Skeletons for Automated Program Translation

Translating software between programming languages is a challenging task, for which automated techniques have been elusive and hard to scale up to larger programs. A key difficulty in cross-language translation is that one has to re-express the intended behavior of the source program into idiomatic constructs of a different target language. This task needs abstracting away from the source language-specific details, while keeping the overall functionality the same. In this work, we propose a novel and systematic approach for making such translation amenable to automation based on a framework we call program skeletons. A program skeleton retains the high-level structure of the source program by abstracting away and effectively summarizing lower-level concrete code fragments, which can be mechanically translated to the target programming language. A skeleton, by design, permits many different ways of filling in the concrete implementation for fragments, which can work in conjunction with existing data-driven code synthesizers. Most importantly, skeletons can conceptually enable sound decomposition, i.e., if each individual fragment is correctly translated, taken together with the mechanically translated skeleton, the final translated program is deemed to be correct as a whole. We present a prototype system called Skel embodying the idea of skeleton-based translation from Python to JavaScript. Our results show promising scalability compared to prior works. For 9 real-world Python programs, some with more than about 1k lines of code, 95% of their code fragments can be automatically translated, while about 5% require manual effort. All the final translations are correct with respect to whole-program test suites.

cs.PL↗