Ideal Observer for Segmentation of Dead Leaves Images
The visible parts of a scene are determined by occlusion among overlapping surfaces. Here we consider "dead leaves" models, which replicate this by independently sampling objects ("leaves") with position, shape, color, and texture and layering them until the image is covered. Building on prior theory, we present a self-contained framework that rigorously defines the dead leaves model and derives an analytical Bayesian ideal observer for partitioning finite pixel sets. The longest part of the paper spans the derivation of the prior probability, which elevates the observer beyond pixel-similarity methods by incorporating geometric information. These computations are practical only for small pixel sets (up to 9-10 pixels). We emphasize accessibility through step-by-step derivations, extensive visualizations, and examples. We empirically evaluate three tractable observers (prior-only, likelihood-only, and the full ideal observer), plus a random baseline on 108 dead leaves image datasets varying in texture intensity, leaf size, and image size. Likelihood-only performance falls with increasing texture intensity and image size. Prior-only performance falls with decreasing leaf size and increasing maximal image dimension. All model-based observers strongly outperform the random baseline, and the ideal observer consistently outperforms the others by combining both information sources. The model provides a principled upper bound on segmentation performance for limited pixel sets, enabling comparisons with human observers and algorithms.