arXiv ScienceSearch

arXiv subjects

Suvodip Mukherjee

Publications and source records attributed to Suvodip Mukherjee.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Bridging Between Statistical Mechanics and Black Hole Evolution: Theoretical Formalism

Black holes in the Universe span nearly ten orders of magnitude in mass over a large cosmic timescale, dating back to at least the Universe's early history, when it was only a few hundred million years old. The formation and evolution of these objects remain a mystery because no direct probe can trace each black hole across the full mass range and cosmic time. This work shows, for the first time, a statistical mechanical description of black hole evolution. I show that though each black hole and its evolution are governed by stochastic processes, one can make a macroscopic description of the distribution function of black holes in the Universe, and its evolution over the entire mass range and cosmic time can be expressed in terms of the Kramers-Moyal expansion. This bridging between statistical mechanics and black hole evolution in terms of the Kramers-Moyal expansion enables the discovery of the underlying physical processes that play a role in the evolution of black holes. In the future, the application of this technique to data accessible from different messengers, such as gravitational waves and electromagnetic waves, which probe black holes in the Universe, can lead to a data-driven understanding of the underlying physical processes by this statistical mechanics technique despite the ignorance of the underlying microscopic stochastic processes.

gr-qc

Detecting Axion-like particles using Cosmic Variance Cancellation with CMB and Radio surveys

Axions and axion-like particles (ALPs) arise naturally in many extensions of the Standard Model and are among the well-motivated candidates for dark matter. In the presence of magnetic fields of galaxy clusters, the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) photons can convert to ALPs, with the efficiency of the process governed by the cluster electron density and magnetic field profiles, the photon-ALP coupling strength (${g_{aγ}}$), as well as the frequency ($ν$) of the photon at the redshift of the cluster. The CMB blackbody spectrum suggests this resonant conversion takes place at radio wavelengths as well, following the spectral behaviour of the ALP distortion signal. This opens up a new window to search for ALPs using cosmic variance cancellation (CVC), with multi-frequency tracers of the same phenomenon in CMB photon-ALP resonant conversion. The constraints on the ALP signal ratios from different combinations of microwave and radio bands of Simons Observatory (SO) and Square Kilometer Array (SKA), can be significantly improved using CVC as compared to the case of using auto-only spectra from the two experiments. With the large number of galaxy clusters that will be observed by SO and SKA, we will be able to obtain much more information using CVC, especially for the case of low-mass ALPs with stronger signals. Using the auto-only spectra from galaxy clusters up to redshift $z = 1$ for inference of normalized ratio parameter, we obtain a standard deviation of $5.9 \times 10^{-2}$ for ALP mass $m_a = 10^{-14} \, \rm{eV}$, which improves to $1.3 \times 10^{-2}$ using CVC. Not only is this method a universal probe of the ALP distortion signal using its spectral dependence, but will be able to provide a more robust consistency check, helping to identify and mitigate potential spurious signals that might arise in CMB-only analyses, based on its frequency behavior in different bands.

astro-ph.CO

Are all Binary Black Holes Detected by LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Following the Universal Time-Delay Distributions? Probably Not

The delay time distribution (DTD) of binary black hole (BBH) mergers encodes the evolutionary link between stellar formation history and gravitational-wave (GW) emission. We present a non-parametric reconstruction of the DTD using BBHs from the GWTC-4 catalog, employing a grid-based framework that avoids restrictive power-law assumptions. We divide the BBH population into two mass bins, $20$--$40\,M_\odot$ and $40$--$100\,M_\odot$, and reconstruct the DTD independently for each bin using grid-based trajectories, under three different star formation rate density (SFRD) models. We find that both mass bins favor an extended plateau of intermediate-to-long delay times rather than a single characteristic timescale, and that in both bins the reconstructed merger rate $\mathcal{R}(z)$ rises from its local value to a peak at intermediate redshift before declining. The two bins differ in degree rather than kind: the $20$--$40\,M_\odot$ bin is broadly constrained, with a local rate of $R_0 \approx 18$--$23\,\mathrm{Gpc^{-3}\,yr^{-1}}$ and a merger rate peaking at $z \sim 0.8$--$1.05$, while the $40$--$100\,M_\odot$ bin prefers a more sharply defined intermediate delay range of $\sim$2--4 Gyr with a steeper suppression of long delay times, within a noticeably tighter set of high-evidence trajectories, a lower local rate of $R_0 \approx 9$--$13\,\mathrm{Gpc^{-3}\,yr^{-1}}$, and a peak shifted to slightly higher redshift, $z \sim 1.0$--$1.05$. The results indicate that a single power-law DTD may not be sufficient to simultaneously describe both mass bins, pointing toward possible mass-dependent binary evolution pathways that merit further investigation with larger GW catalogs.

astro-ph.HE

A New Framework to Detect Multi-Messenger Signals from Bright Sporadic Stochastic Gravitational Wave Background

The temporal dependence of the astrophysical stochastic gravitational-wave (GW) background (SGWB) in the hecto-hertz band brings a unique avenue to identify multi-messenger signals to these sources by using coincident detection in both GW and multi-band EM signals. We developed a new analysis pipeline, \textit{Multi-messenger Cross-Correlation} (MC$^2$) that can search for EM counterparts to the SGWB signal originating from both modeled and unmodeled sources by harnessing the nearly full-sky gamma-ray sky map. We provide an observation strategy that can be followed by current and future missions to discover EM counterparts to the weak GW signal hidden in the SGWB. We demonstrate the ability of this technique to drastically reduce the false alarm rates when involving EM multi-band analysis. This formalism aims towards advancing the multi-messenger observation frontier and improving our understanding of the population of bright SGWB sources present in the high-redshift universe and can also be applied to other messengers such as neutrinos in the future.

astro-ph.HE

Modeling Gravitational Wave Bias from 3D Power Spectra of Spectroscopic Surveys

We present a framework for relating gravitational wave (GW) sources to the astrophysical properties of spectroscopic galaxy samples. We show how this can enable using clustering measurements of GW sources to infer the relationship between the GW sources and the astrophysical properties of their host galaxies. We accomplish this by creating mock GW catalogs from the spectroscopic Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) DR7 galaxy survey. We populate the GWs using a joint host-galaxy probability function defined over stellar mass, star formation rate (SFR), and metallicity. This probability is modeled as the product of three broken power-law distributions, each with a turnover point motivated by astrophysical processes governing the relation between current-day galaxy properties and binary black hole (BBH) mergers, such as galaxy quenching and BBH delay time. Given that our analysis is anchored in the specific properties and selection characteristics of the adopted galaxy sample, as well as assumptions regarding the host-galaxy probability functions and BBH merger rate prescriptions, the resulting trends should be regarded as model-dependent. Within this framework, our results show that GW bias is most sensitive to host-galaxy probability dependence on stellar mass, with increases of up to $\sim O (10)\%$ relative to galaxy bias as the stellar mass pivot scale rises. We also find a notable relationship between GW bias and SFR: when the host-galaxy probability favors low-SFR galaxies, the GW bias significantly increases. In contrast, we observe no strong correlation between GW bias and metallicity. These findings suggest that the spatial clustering of GW sources is primarily driven by the stellar mass and SFR of their host galaxies and shows how GW bias measurements can inform models of the host-galaxy probability function.

astro-ph.GA

Model-Independent Search Discards Faint Lensed-Pairs of Gravitational Wave Events in the Sub-Threshold Candidates of GWTC-4

Gravitational lensing of gravitational waves (GWs) can produce multiple images in the geometric optics limit. These lensed GW images arrive at different times, are amplified by different magnification factors, and are shifted by constant phases. With current understanding, the occurrence of lensed events stands at a few per thousand events, and the number of GW detections is a few hundred with the ground-based detector network. However, with the inclusion of the sub-threshold events, the total number of detections crosses a few thousand. Therefore, a search that includes both types of events yields a higher chance of lensing detection. In this work, we carry out the first model-independent lensing search using a cross-correlation-based technique GLANCE over the entire volume of the GWTC-4 strain data, containing $\sim 90$ super-events $\sim 800$ sub-events forming a total of $\sim 11,000$ event pairs with a higher False Alarm Rate (FAR) event rate allowing to search deep in the noise dominated regime. We further conduct their spectrogram checks to inspect data quality, sky-map overlap of the interesting pairs, and a Bayesian parameter exploration of the sub-event to make a robust lensing detection. Although the search indicated four pairs of potential events with cross-correlation significance $\geq 2σ$, none were above $3σ$ at both the LIGO-Hanford and LIGO-Livingston detectors. This makes it possible to strongly rule out the presence of any statistically significant sub-threshold lensed GW event in GWTC-4. The null detection translates to an upper bound on the lensing detection rate to be $\leq$ 1.5/yr with inclusion of the sub-threshold event candidates. In the future, with more observation time, the detection of lensed GW can be possible from the current generation of GW detectors.

gr-qc

The First Detection of Sub-Populations in the Delay-Time Distribution of Binary Black Holes in GWTC-4 of LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA

The imprint of different formation channels of binary black holes (BBHs) is encoded in the distribution of time delays between BBH mergers and the formation of their progenitor stars, along with their source properties such as component mass, mass-ratio, spin, and more. This makes it possible for the presence of a potential correlation between the delay-time distribution and compact-object source properties. We report the first measurement of this inevitable signature from the fourth gravitational wave (GW) catalog (GWTC-4) of LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA and identified three sub-populations that show distinct merger rate behavior as a consequence of this. We find that the delay-time distribution of the sources above a mass of $45$ M$_\odot$ is significantly different from the ones below and exhibits strong dependence on the mass-ratio and spin, indicating that GW sources close to equal masses and close to zero effective spin are more delayed in comparison to the values otherwise. Our analysis identifies the presence of at least three source property dependent sub-population of merger rates with the merger rate at redshift $z=0$ varying from $\sim 0.6- 12$ Gpc$^{-3}$ yr$^{-1}$ for the three different sub-populations and hence rule out a Universal merger rate for all the BBHs detected using GW.

astro-ph.HE

BBH-Genesis: Disentangling Binary Black Hole Formation Channels with GWTC-4

The detected population of binary black holes (BBHs) from the gravitational wave (GW) data has made it possible to decipher their formation and evolution history over cosmic time. The complexity of astrophysical modeling of binary mergers makes it challenging to predict key signatures for different formation channels. As a result, one of the major avenues to discover the presence of different channels from detected GW events is through a data-driven way which can isolate different scenarios. In this spirit, we developed a new inference pipeline BBH-Genesis and applied it on the fourth GW catalog (GWTC-4) to identify the presence of multiple underlying distinct populations. We find that the current population of all the binary events in GWTC-4 can be explained with the strongest evidence for only a two-channel scenario, hinting at the presence of a non-isolated binary formation channel. This sub-population can be further divided into a third channel with mild support towards formation in AGN exhibiting a slightly different effective spin and mass ratio correlation. In the future, with the detection of more events, it will be clearer whether it is necessary to consider at least three channels to explain the BBH events detected using GW observations.

astro-ph.HE

Inferring the role of binary neutron star mergers in r-process nucleosynthesis with multi-messenger observations using Cosmic Explorer and Einstein Telescope

Identifying the cosmic origin of rapid neutron-capture (r-process) elements remains an open problem. Binary neutron-star (BNS) mergers and rare classes of core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe) represent the main contenders as major r-process production sites. Although BNS mergers could exclusively account for r-process nucleosynthesis, results from chemical evolution studies taking into account their delays with respect to star formation, observed BNS rates by gravitational-wave (GW) detectors, as well as issues with retention in low-mass halos suggest otherwise. Here, we propose a method to measure the contribution of BNS mergers to cosmic r-process nucleosynthesis with the third-generation GW detectors Cosmic Explorer and Einstein Telescope. It exploits the redshift-dependent correlation between the total number of BNS GW events and the average r-process abundances at redshifts $z \lesssim 1$. We apply this correlation technique to mock GW and abundance data, accounting for expected observational uncertainties in two limiting scenarios: GW events with electromagnetic counterpart (multi-messenger 'bright-sirens') and without ('dark-sirens'). Using Fisher forecasts, we demonstrate that the fractional cumulative contribution of BNS mergers to the total cosmic r-process $F_{\rm{BNS,z0}}$ can be estimated to the $\lesssim 5-6\%$ precision level for both scenarios at $1σ$ for fiducial astrophysical scenarios with $F_{\rm{BNS,z0}} \gtrsim 0.1-1$. Furthermore, the method also yields estimates of the BNS delay-time distribution parameters comparable to other approaches. Although cosmic r-process abundances may be reconstructed from local observations at low metallicity, this method also provides a science case to identify signatures of neutron-capture elements beyond the local Universe.

astro-ph.HE

The First Upper Bound on the Non-Stationary Gravitational Wave Background and its Implication on the High Redshift Binary Black Hole Merger Rate

The high redshift merger rate and mass distribution of black hole binaries provide a direct probe to distinguish astrophysical black holes (ABHs) and primordial black holes (PBHs), which can be studied using the Stochastic Gravitational-Wave Background (SGWB). The conventional analyses solely based on the power spectrum are limited in constraining the properties of the underlying source population under the assumption of a non-sporadic Gaussian distribution. However, recent studies have shown that SGWB is expected to be sporadic and non-Gaussian in nature, which gives rise to non-zero \textit{spectral correlation} that depends on the high redshift merger rate and mass distribution of the compact objects. In this work, we present the first spectral covariance analysis of the SGWB using data from the LIGO--Virgo--KAGRA collaboration during the third and the first part of the fourth observing runs. Our analysis indicates that the current spectral correlation is consistent with non-stationary noise, yielding no detection and providing only upper bounds over the frequency range of 20 Hz to 100 Hz. This upper bound on the spectral correlation translates into a mass-distribution-dependent upper bound on the merger rate of PBHs. This provides a stringent upper bound on the PBH merger rate at high redshift and hence puts constraints on the PBH formation scenarios. In the future, detection of this signal will provide a new avenue to probe the high-redshift black hole population using gravitational waves.

astro-ph.HE

Is the Binary Black Hole Population Inference from Gravitational-Wave Data Robust?

Gravitational-wave observations are playing an instrumental role in understanding the population of binary compact objects in the Universe. These observations have begun to hint at the mass distribution of binary black holes (BBHs), with tentative evidence for features in the mass distribution beyond a simple power-law. Such features, hence, can be connected with different formation scenarios of BBHs and lead to important astrophysical conclusions. However, it is crucial to understand whether these features are truly astrophysical or connected with any unknown systematics. We show in this work that waveform modelling uncertainties can significantly distort inferred features in the BBH mass distribution, which can be more pronounced than the statistical uncertainty, even with the current generation detectors, which can peak close to the lower edge of the pair instability supernovae (PISN) mass gap, and also can impact the slope of the power-law distribution. So, in order to have a confirmed detection of astrophysical features in the BBH mass distribution and connecting them with BBH formation channels, it is important to consider waveform systematics in the astrophysical population analysis. We show the typical scaling of the systematic error and discuss a few avenues to mitigate this effect for robust measurements in the future.

astro-ph.HE

Blinded Mock Data Challenge: Is the Spectral Siren Technique Robust for Measuring the Hubble Constant?

The measurement of the Hubble constant from gravitational wave (GW) sources is one of the independent avenues to shed light on the Hubble tension, which is associated with about an $8\%$ mismatch in the value of the Hubble constant inferred from low-redshift and high-redshift cosmological probes. Such a key measurement is expected from GW sources as it is a direct measurement of the Hubble constant using the luminosity distance without the need for any luminosity distance calibration. However, such a measurement relies strongly on the reliability of the independent inference of the source redshift of the GW source. As a result, it becomes pertinent to gauge the accuracy and precision of techniques in understanding their reliability in inferring redshifts of GW sources. In this work, we show the requirement of the spectral siren technique in knowing the mass distribution of BBHs across cosmic redshifts in order to make a reliable inference of the Hubble constant. We show by a blinded mock data challenge analysis the criticality in capturing the underlying metallicity dependence of the BBH mass distribution and its interplay with time-delay distribution for a robust inference of the Hubble constant using the spectral siren technique. In order to have a reliable measurement of the Hubble constant at the level required to resolve the Hubble tension in the future, the mass distribution of the BBHs needs to be independently inferred at all relevant redshifts with an accuracy less than the statistical uncertainty. Otherwise, a mismatch of the true model and the underlying assumption made in the analysis can lead to a best-fit model for the wrong value of both BBH population parameters as well as the Hubble constant.

astro-ph.CO

Agnostically decoding gravitational wave model deficiencies in GWTC-3

Gravitational Wave (GW) data bring an exceptional avenue to test the underlying models of coalescing compact objects. In the regime of strong gravity and high curvature, they allow the exploration of minute deviations from the best-fit models, which are difficult to uncover with other observational modalities. These deviations can stem from departures from General Relativity (GR) or unaccounted astrophysical effects. They may not be explainable within the current description of GW strain data, or may simply be difficult to model. However, they are expected to be correlated between detectors and across the population of observed events. The recently developed SCoRe analysis pipeline leverages these properties by focusing on the correlated power between detectors and combining results from multiple events. In this paper, we apply the framework on the Third Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog to search for source-dependent deviations. In particular, we explore whether there is evidence for a mass-scale in the observed events, which can act like a line of demarcation in their physical properties by exhibiting a deviation that is different above and below this mass-scale. This mass scale dependency naturally arises in gravitational theories described through effective field theories, due to environmental effects or in scenarios involving exotic compact objects, where the GW signature can differ from the standard binary black holes in GR. Using the 30 highest Signal-to-Noise Ratio events in the catalog, we find Bayes factors ranging from 0.16--0.5 (depending on where the threshold mass is set), thus disfavoring the hypothesis of existence of any mass-scale between $\sim 2.5$ M$_\odot$ and $60$ M$_\odot$. We also compute the distribution of excess cross-correlated power across events and find a Bayes factor of $0.07$, which agrees with expected noise statistics.

gr-qc

How lonely are the Binary Compact Objects Detected by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Collaboration?

Gravitational-wave (GW) observations of compact binary coalescences (CBCs) are traditionally interpreted under the assumption that the binary evolves in isolation. However, in realistic astrophysical environments, brief three-body encounters may perturb the binary's orbital evolution and imprint deviations on the emitted GWs. We develop a physically motivated model for such interactions, retaining Newtonian three-body dynamics supplemented by leading-order ($2.5$PN) radiation-reaction within the binary. We show that such encounters produce a distinctive morphology of dephasing and amplitude modulation in GWs. We search for this kind of distortion from the LIGO--Virgo--KAGRA (LVK) GW catalog GWTC-4 on three events: GW170817, GW190814, and GW230627\_015337, chosen based on high SNR and in-band duration $\gtrsim 10~\mathrm{s}$. We find no statistically significant deviation in the data, which translates into constraints on the absence of any intermediate-mass black hole in the mass range above $\sim 10^2$ M$_\odot$ in the vicinity of these binaries of radius approximately $10^{-1}~\mathrm{AU}$. This arises from robust exclusions arising from fly-by interactions that would dynamically disrupt the binary and are directly ruled out independent of waveform modelling, placing the first upper bound on intermediate-mass black holes near these GW events. In future, with the availability of long-duration GW signals, this new avenue can probe encounters of the binary GW sources with compact objects of lighter masses at distances farther away than 1 AU and hence opens a new window to probe the population of individual compact objects of both astrophysical and primordial origin in astrophysical systems of dense environments ranging from galactic centers to dense globular clusters.

astro-ph.HE

The First Model-Independent Upper Bound on Micro-lensing Signature of the Highest Mass Binary Black Hole Event GW231123

The recently discovered gravitational wave event, GW231123, is the most massive binary black hole merger detected to date. The inferred source masses of the event fall within the pair-instability supernova mass gap, where black holes formed directly from stellar progenitors are expected to be rare, making alternative formation scenarios for such massive black holes especially relevant. One proposed explanation is gravitational lensing, which can make the source masses to be inferred as higher than their true values. In this work, we search for lensing signatures in GW231123, together with other O4a events, using a model-independent approach with mu-GLANCE. The method tests residual strain for correlated features across the detector network via cross-correlation and infers lensing-induced modulations within a Bayesian framework. Our analysis finds no strong evidence for lensing in GW231123, but reveals a potential residual feature that could be consistent with microlensing, with a modulation amplitude of up to 0.8 at 95% confidence. However, we find that waveform systematics for such heavy binary systems are sufficiently large to shadow the lensing signatures in short-duration signals like GW231123, preventing any definitive claim of lensing at this stage. We conclude that, if this event is lensed, similar lensed events will be detectable in the near future with current detector sensitivity, opening a new discovery space for lensed gravitational waves with the aid of more accurate waveform models.

gr-qc

False Alarm Rates in Detecting Gravitational Wave Lensing from Astrophysical Coincidences: Insights with Model-Independent Technique GLANCE

Lensing of gravitational waves (GWs) due to intervening massive astrophysical systems between the source and the observer is an inevitable consequence of the general theory of relativity, which can produce multiple GW events with overlapping sky localization error. However, the confirmed detection of such a unique astrophysical phenomenon is challenging due to several sources of contamination, ranging from detector noise to astrophysical uncertainties. Robust model-independent search techniques that can mitigate noise contamination have been developed in the past. In this study, we explore the astrophysical uncertainty associated with incorrectly classifying a pair of unlensed GW events as a lensed pair and the associated false alarm rate (FAR) depending on the GW source properties. To understand the effect of unlensed astrophysical GW sources in producing false lensing detections, we perform a model-independent test using the pipeline GLANCE on a simulated population of merging binary black holes (BBHs). We find that $\sim$ 0.01% of the pair of events can be falsely classified as lensed with a lensing threshold signal-to-noise ratio of 1.5, appearing at a time delay between the pair of events of $\sim$ 1000 days or more. We show the FAR distribution for the parameter space of the GW source masses, delay time, and lensing magnification parameter over which the model-independent technique GLANCE can confidently detect lensed GW pair with the current LIGO detector sensitivity. In the future, this technique will be useful in understanding the lensing FAR for next-generation GW detectors, which can observe more GW sources.

gr-qc

Hint towards inconsistency between BAO and Supernovae Dataset: The Evidence of Redshift Evolving Dark Energy from DESI DR2 is Absent

The combination of independent cosmological datasets is a route towards precise and accurate inference of cosmological parameters if these observations are free from systematic effects. However, unknown systematics in different datasets can lead to biased inference of cosmological parameters. In this work, we test the consistency of two independent tracers of low-redshift cosmic expansion, namely the supernova dataset from Pantheon$+$ and the BAO dataset from DESI DR2, using the distance duality relation, a cornerstone of cosmology within General Relativity. We find that these datasets violate the distance duality relation and show a redshift-dependent signature, hinting at unaccounted physical effects or observational artifacts. This effect mimics a redshift-evolving dark energy scenario when Pantheon$+$ and DESI datasets are combined without accounting for this inconsistency. Accounting for this effect in the likelihood refutes the previous claim of evidence for non-cosmological constant dark energy from DESI DR2, yielding results consistent with a cosmological constant with $w_0= -0.92\pm 0.08$ and $w_a= -0.49^{+0.33}_{-0.36}$. This is further supported by an increased Bayes factor at ($w_0 = -1$, $w_a = 0$) when the inconsistency is accounted for. This indicates that current conclusions from DESI DR2 combined with Pantheon$+$ likely arise from combining inconsistent datasets, leading to precise but inaccurate inference of cosmological parameters. Future tests of consistency between cosmological datasets will be essential for robust inference and for identifying unaccounted physical effects or observational artifacts.[Abridged]

astro-ph.CO

The Non Parametric Reconstruction of Binary Black Hole Mass Evolution from GWTC-4.0 Gravitational Wave Catalog

The distribution of binary black hole (BBH) masses and its evolution with redshift provide key insights into the different formation channels of compact objects and their dependence on cosmic time and stellar properties such as metallicity and star formation history. We present a non-parametric framework of the redshift evolution of the BBH mass distribution using the gravitational-wave (GW) catalogs GWTC-3 and GWTC-4 of LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (LVK). This method simultaneously searches for the signature of any linear and quadratic redshift evolution with respect to the low-redshift population in a Bayesian framework, taking into account the detector selection effects. We find tentative evidence for a linear redshift-dependent evolution of the mass distribution, consistent over a mass range ($m \gtrsim 50\,M_\odot$), while lower-mass systems show no significant evolution. The quadratic term remains consistent with zero, indicating that a simple linear dependence adequately describes the population up to redshift $z \sim 1$. With more GW sources in the future, this technique can reveal subtle evolutionary features in BBH populations and provide new insights into the cosmic history of black hole formation.

astro-ph.HE