arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Simon Mackenzie

Publications and source records attributed to Simon Mackenzie.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Nearly Settling the Complexity of Connected $\varepsilon$-Envy-Free Cake Cutting

Envy-free cake cutting has been one of the central problems in fair division. In cake cutting, agents' preferences over the cake are accessed through Robertson--Webb (RW) queries. For three or more agents, no algorithm that makes finitely many RW queries can always find a contiguous, exactly envy-free allocation. For contiguous $\varepsilon$-envy-free allocations, however, Hollender and Rubinstein~(JACM, 2025) showed that $\poly(\log(1/\varepsilon))$ RW queries suffice for four agents, leaving open whether such a bound is possible for five or more agents. In this paper, we establish a striking change in query complexity: $\poly(\log(1/\varepsilon))$ RW queries suffice for up to five agents, whereas $(1/\varepsilon)^{Ω(1)}$ queries are necessary for seven or more agents, even when valuations are additive. Thus, we resolve the five-agent case and, more broadly, determine whether polylogarithmic query complexity is possible for every number of agents except six. We also explore the computational complexity of finding contiguous $\varepsilon$-envy-free allocations. When monotone Lipschitz valuations are given by polynomial-time evaluation procedures (e.g., arithmetic circuits and efficiently computable Turing machines), we show that an $\varepsilon$-envy-free division can be computed in polynomial time for five agents. In contrast, even for additive valuations, finding an $\varepsilon$-envy-free division is UEOPL-hard for every fixed number of agents $n\ge7$ and PPAD-complete for every fixed $n\ge13$.

cs.GT↗

EFX Need Not Exist

The existence of envy-free up to any good (EFX) allocations has long been a central open problem in discrete fair division. We resolve it in the negative by constructing a counterexample with three agents and eight goods. The instance is invariant under every simultaneous permutation of the agents and their associated good types, and this symmetry yields a short, self-contained proof of nonexistence. The counterexample can be realized with weighted-coverage, and hence submodular, valuations, and it extends to $n$ agents and $m$ goods for all $n\ge3$ and $m\ge n+5$. For three agents, eight goods is the minimum: every instance with three agents and at most seven goods admits an EFX allocation under arbitrary monotone valuations. The proof relies on a new analysis, valid for any number of goods, of when the invariant-based technique of [AACGMM25] produces an EFX allocation. This analysis strictly extends the class of MMS-feasible valuations. We also give explicit bounds for approximate EFX. For subadditive valuations, $α$-EFX allocations need not exist for any $α>2^{-1/6}\approx0.891$, and for submodular valuations for any $α>0.958$. On the positive side, if two of three agents have arbitrary monotone valuations and the third has a subadditive valuation, there is always an allocation that is EFX for the first two and $2^{-1/3}$-EFX ($\approx0.794$) for the third. A first version of the counterexample and of the seven-goods result was obtained using SAT/SMT solving, and the insights it provided guided our classical, pen-and-paper proofs. We also describe the encoding, which we believe is a valuable tool in its own right: to our knowledge, this is the first use of SAT/SMT solving for EFX.

cs.GT↗

NP-Hardness and Additive Inapproximability of Deterministic Communication Complexity

Given the full truth table of a Boolean function whose input is split between two players, we study the complexity of determining the minimum worst-case number of bits they must communicate to compute it. This is a basic meta-complexity question, posed by Yao in 1979. We prove NP-hardness of approximation within every fixed additive error for deterministic communication complexity, under deterministic polynomial-time reductions. The result holds both in the standard model and in Yao's original model, where the players alternate after every bit and only the receiver of the last bit must determine the answer. In particular, it resolves the exact computation question under Yao's original conventions. Earlier versions of this same paper established exact NP-hardness for the standard model, independently and concurrently with Hirahara, Ilango, and Loff. In both models, a polynomial-time estimator with any fixed additive error would yield a polynomial-time $3$-SAT algorithm, deterministic or bounded-error randomized according to the estimator. For the standard model, we also give quantitative implications for errors that grow with the number $T$ of table entries. A bounded-error randomized polynomial-time estimator with additive error $c\log T/\log\log T$, for any fixed $0\le c<1/8$, yields a bounded-error randomized $3$-SAT algorithm on $N$ variables and $O(N)$ clauses running in time $2^{O(N^α)}$ for every fixed $8c<α<1$. A deterministic polynomial-time estimator with additive error $c_*\log\log T$, for an effective absolute constant $c_*>0$, yields a deterministic algorithm running in time $2^{O((\log N)^2)}$ on such formulas.

cs.CC↗

Fair Division with Indivisible Goods, Chores, and Cake

We study the problem of fairly allocating indivisible items and a desirable heterogeneous divisible good (i.e., cake) to agents with additive utilities. In our paper, each indivisible item can be a good that yields non-negative utilities to some agents and a chore that yields negative utilities to the other agents. Given a fixed set of divisible and indivisible resources, we investigate almost envy-free allocations, captured by the natural fairness concept of envy-freeness for mixed resources (EFM). It requires that an agent $i$ not envy another agent $j$ if agent $j$'s bundle contains any piece of cake yielding positive utility to agent $i$ (i.e., envy-freeness), and that agent $i$ be envy-free up to one item (EF1) towards agent $j$ otherwise. We prove that with indivisible items and a cake, an EFM allocation always exists for any number of agents with additive utilities. We reduce the problem of showing the existence of EFM to the problem of proving the compatibility of EF1 and envy-freeability. An allocation of indivisible items is said to be envy-freeable if the allocation can be made envy-free by allocating a sufficient amount of money to each of the agents. We show that for indivisible items, an EF1 and envy-freeable allocation always exists. Moreover, such an allocation can be found in polynomial time. This result, in and of itself, is of independent interest.

cs.GT↗

Exact Envy-Free Cake Cutting with Polynomial Expected Queries

Envy-free cake cutting asks how to divide a resource so that no agent prefers another agent's share. Finding such a division with few queries about preferences has been a longstanding challenge. Aziz and Mackenzie gave the first query bound depending only on the number $n$ of agents: a tower of six $n$'s. Subsequent improvements culminated in Ye and Bai's single-exponential bound of $n^{O(1)}2^n$. A large gap remains between this deterministic upper bound and Procaccia's general lower bound of $Ω(n^2)$. Whether polynomially many queries suffice is a central open question in fair division. We show that a polynomial expected query bound is possible. Our randomised protocol uses only independent, uniformly sampled points from the cake as its source of randomness. For every profile of $n$ agents with nonnegative, additive, nonatomic valuations, the protocol has the following guarantees: (1) It terminates with probability one. (2) Every allocation it returns is complete and exactly envy-free. (3) Its expected number of Robertson-Webb queries is $\widetilde{O}(n^{30})$. The expectation is taken solely over the protocol's random choices, with no distributional assumptions on preferences.

cs.GT↗

Lossless Hardness Condensation in Deterministic Communication Complexity

A communication problem can have far more possible inputs than its communication cost would suggest. Must its difficulty already be present on a much smaller set of inputs? We prove that every finite total Boolean matrix of deterministic communication complexity $c\ge4$ has a submatrix on $2^k$ of its original rows and $2^k$ of its original columns, with $k=Θ_\varepsilon(c)$ and complexity at least $(1-\varepsilon)(k+1)$, for every fixed $0<\varepsilon<1$. Since $k+1$ is the maximum possible cost on such a square, the retained problem can be arbitrarily close to maximally hard. This answers affirmatively the lossless condensation question of Hamed Hatami; Göös, Newman, Riazanov, and Sokolov (STOC 2024), who recorded it as Open Problem 2, conjectured a negative answer. Hrubeš previously guaranteed input length $Ω(\sqrt c)$. The same argument gives an original $2^{c-2}$-by-$2^{c-2}$ square retaining at least $c/3-O(\log c)$ bits of communication complexity. The proof builds on Hrubeš's counting and covering argument. We count submatrices equipped with short communication protocols: a player names a covering submatrix, then the players run its protocol. This avoids the loss from converting rectangle partitions into protocols. A recursion on rectangles makes the argument constructive. For fixed rational $\varepsilon$ and any target depth $d\ge4$, a deterministic algorithm returns either a protocol of depth below $d$, or a square of original inputs at input length $Θ_\varepsilon(d)$ with the same near-maximal guarantee. Its running time is $2^{O(2^d)}$ times a polynomial in the table size. If the original complexity is at least $d$, the algorithm necessarily returns the square. An extension gives constant-factor condensation for any fixed number of number-in-hand players, with bounds independent of the finite output alphabet.

cs.CC↗

Sampford Apportionment Satisfies Threshold Monotonicity

Apportionment distributes a fixed number of legislative seats among political parties in proportion to their vote shares. Randomization can satisfy quota in every realization and exact proportionality in expectation, but these requirements determine only the parties' marginal seat distributions. We study threshold monotonicity, which requires that when every standard quota inside a coalition weakly increases and every standard quota outside it weakly decreases, the coalition's new seat total stochastically dominates its old one. We prove that Sampford apportionment satisfies threshold monotonicity, resolving the threshold-monotonicity conjecture of Correa et al. (2024). Complementing this result, we prove that no quota-respecting, ex-ante proportional method satisfies pairwise threshold monotonicity even for disjoint coalitions when there are at least seven parties. This impossibility applies whether or not the method has full support.

cs.GT↗

Anchoring for Truthfulness: The Random-Anchor Volume Mechanism for Multi-Facility Location

We study the strategyproof placement of \(k\) facilities on the real line for \(n\) agents who privately report their locations, without monetary transfers. For two facilities, the Proportional Mechanism of Lu, Sun, Wang, and Zhu (2010) is strategyproof in expectation and achieves a constant-factor approximation to the optimal social cost. Whether such a guarantee is possible for three facilities in the standard model, where each agent is served by her nearest open facility, has remained open. We resolve this question affirmatively by introducing the \emph{Random-Anchor Volume} mechanism. The mechanism first opens a facility at the report of a uniformly random agent, called the \emph{anchor}, and then jointly selects two additional reports, assigning each pair probability proportional to the product of the two consecutive gaps formed by the pair and the anchor. We prove that the mechanism is strategyproof in expectation and has expected social cost at most \(8 OPT_3\), where \(OPT_k\) denotes the minimum social cost achievable using at most \(k\) facilities. The mechanism naturally extends to every \(k\geq 2\) by selecting \(k-1\) additional reports with probability proportional to the product of the consecutive gaps among them and the anchor. Under truthful reporting, this generalization has expected social cost at most \(4(k-1)OPT_k\). Its incentive guarantee, however, has a sharp boundary: the mechanism is strategyproof in expectation for \(k\in\{1,2,3\}\), but is manipulable for every \(k\geq 4\).

cs.GT↗

When One Good Is Not Enough: EF1 and Pareto Optimality Are Not Compatible for Submodular Valuations

One of the central questions in discrete fair division is whether fairness and efficiency can be achieved simultaneously. For indivisible goods, a canonical relaxation of envy-freeness is envy-freeness up to one good (EF1), while the standard efficiency benchmark is Pareto optimality (PO). In their seminal work, Caragiannis et al. showed that, for additive valuations, EF1 and PO are always compatible, and asked whether this compatibility extends to submodular valuations. This question has since become an important open problem in the study of fair division. In this paper, we settle the question in the negative. We construct an instance with two agents and eight goods, where both agents have submodular valuations, such that no EF1 allocation is even weakly Pareto optimal. Thus, the celebrated compatibility between EF1 and PO for additive valuations breaks down already for two agents under submodular valuations. We then map the boundary of this impossibility. On the negative side, we show that even for weighted matroid rank valuations, EF1 and fractional Pareto optimality (fPO) are incompatible. This rules out, in general, broad classes of weighted-welfare and Fisher-market-based approaches. On the positive side, we identify a common-envelope condition that restores compatibility. Under this condition, EF1+PO allocations exist for any number of agents. This yields new positive results showing that common-weight matroid-rank valuations always admit EF1+PO allocations. Finally, we quantify the efficiency loss that is unavoidable when insisting on EF1. Our submodular counterexample implies that there is a constant $α<1$ such that no EF1 allocation is $α$-\PO. For the broader class of subadditive valuations, we prove a tight two-agent bound: for any $\varepsilon>0$, there exists an instance in which no EF1 allocation is $\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}+\varepsilon\right)$-PO.

cs.GT↗

Optimal Subsidy Bounds for Goods and Chores: One Dollar Each Suffices

We study the fair allocation of $m$ indivisible items to $n$ agents with additive utilities. In our setting, each indivisible item may be a good, yielding non-negative utility to some agents, or a chore, yielding negative utility to others. Whilst envy-free allocations may not exist in the indivisible-items setting, envy-freeness can be achieved if some amount of divisible good (i.e., \emph{money}) is introduced. When each item's utility or disutility is bounded by one, we show that a subsidy of at most one dollar per agent suffices to guarantee the existence of an envy-free allocation, and that this bound is tight. Moreover, such an allocation can be computed in polynomial time. Since at least one agent need not receive any subsidy, our results imply that a total subsidy of at most $n-1$ dollars suffices to ensure envy-freeness.

cs.GT↗

Best-of-Both-Worlds Fairness for Mixed Goods and Chores

We study the fundamental problem of fairly dividing indivisible items among agents with additive utilities. In our model, an item can be a good yielding non-negative utilities to some agents and simultaneously a chore yielding negative utilities to others. We take the best-of-both-worlds perspective and our goal is to construct a randomized allocation that is exactly fair ex ante while also being supported on ex post approximately fair allocations. The fairness notions examined in this paper are envy-freeness (EF) and its well-known relaxation envy-freeness up to one item (EF1). Our main result is that ex-ante EF and ex-post EF1 can be achieved simultaneously. To achieve this, we introduce a novel probabilistic Hall-type matrix decomposition that intricately correlates the fractional assignments of goods and chores. We resolve this decomposition problem by combining continuous minimax duality -- via Sion's minimax theorem -- with carefully designed biased flow networks.

cs.GT↗

Faster Exponential-Time Approximate Counting via Bounded Self-Reductions

We give faster exponential-time randomised approximation algorithms for counting problems where polynomial-time approximation is unavailable and exact exponential-time counting remains expensive. For general \(n\)-vertex graphs, our independent-set counter runs in \(O^{\ast}(1.1869^{n})\) time, improving the previous \(O^{\ast}(1.2041^{n})\) general-graph bound. For \(n\)-variable \#\textsc{2-SAT}, we obtain an \(O^{\ast}(1.2373^{n})\)-time approximation algorithm, narrowly below Wahlstr{ö}m's currently cited \(O^{\ast}(1.2377^{n})\) variable-parameter exact bound. The new algorithmic point is to take the square root after decomposition. For a single bounded unweighted self-reduction with \(f(x)\) positive leaves and recursion-compatible upper bound \(b(x)\), an enumerate-or-sample estimator gives an \((\varepsilon,δ)\)-approximation in \[ O^{\ast}\!\left(\sqrt{b(x)}\,\varepsilon^{-2}\log \tfrac1δ\right) \] time. After preprocessing decomposes an input into many bounded cores, the combined estimator pays \[ O^{\ast}\!\left(\sqrt{\sum_i b_i(x_i)}\,\varepsilon^{-2}\log \tfrac1δ\right), \] rather than estimating the cores separately at cost \(\sum_i \sqrt{b_i(x_i)}\). The same conversion improves the bases for counting maximal cliques, minimal separators, and perfect matchings in subcubic graphs. Bounded unweighted self-reductions provide the formal language; at the level of counting classes, the resulting unweighted formulation has the same Karp closure as TotP. With explicit recursion-tree access, the framework yields black-box quantum speed-ups.

cs.DS↗

Counterexamples to EFX for Submodular and Subadditive Valuations

The existence of EFX allocations is a fundamental question in fair division. In this paper, we construct a three-agent, eight-good instance with monotone subadditive valuations such that no allocation satisfies $α$-EFX for any $α> \frac{1}{\sqrt[6]{2}} \approx 0.89$. We also provide a closely related three-agent, eight-good instance with submodular (in fact weighted coverage) valuations for which no EFX allocation exists. A key feature of our construction is its symmetry: the agents' valuations are identical up to a relabeling of the goods. Thus, EFX can fail even when agents differ only in how the goods are labeled. This symmetry makes the counterexamples compact and human-verifiable, yielding simple combinatorial obstructions to the existence of EFX.

cs.GT↗

Refuting the Direct Sum Conjecture for Total Functions in Deterministic Communication Complexity

In communication complexity the input of a function $f:X\times Y\rightarrow Z$ is distributed between two players Alice and Bob. If Alice knows only $x\in X$ and Bob only $y\in Y$, how much information must Alice and Bob share to be able to elicit the value of $f(x,y)$? Do we need $\ell$ more resources to solve $\ell$ instances of a problem? This question is the direct sum question and has been studied in many computational models. In this paper we focus on the case of 2-party deterministic communication complexity and give a counterexample to the direct sum conjecture in its strongest form. To do so we exhibit a family of functions for which the complexity of solving $\ell$ instances is less than $(1 -ε)\ell$ times the complexity of solving one instance for some small enough $ε>0$. We use a customised method in the analysis of our family of total functions, showing that one can force the alternation of rounds between players. This idea allows us to exploit the integrality of the complexity measure to create an increasing gap between the complexity of solving the instances independently with that of solving them together.

cs.CC↗

A Faster Randomized Algorithm for Vertex Cover: An Automated Approach

This work introduces two techniques for the design and analysis of branching algorithms, illustrated through the case study of the Vertex Cover problem. First, we present a method for automatically generating branching rules through a systematic case analysis of local structures. Second, we develop a new technique for analyzing randomized branching algorithms using the Measure & Conquer method, offering greater flexibility in formulating branching rules. By combining these innovations with additional techniques, we obtain the fastest known randomized algorithms in different parameters for the Vertex Cover problem on graphs with bounded degree (up to 6) and on general graphs. For example, our algorithm solves Vertex Cover on subcubic graphs in $O^*(1.07625^n)$ time and $O^*(1.13132^k)$ time, respectively. For graphs with maximum degree 4, we achieve running times of $O^*(1.13735^n)$ and $O^*(1.21103^k)$, while for general graphs we achieve $O^*(1.25281^k)$.

cs.DS↗

The Fluid Mechanics of Liquid Democracy

Liquid democracy is the principle of making collective decisions by letting agents transitively delegate their votes. Despite its significant appeal, it has become apparent that a weakness of liquid democracy is that a small subset of agents may gain massive influence. To address this, we propose to change the current practice by allowing agents to specify multiple delegation options instead of just one. Much like in nature, where --- fluid mechanics teaches us --- liquid maintains an equal level in connected vessels, so do we seek to control the flow of votes in a way that balances influence as much as possible. Specifically, we analyze the problem of choosing delegations to approximately minimize the maximum number of votes entrusted to any agent, by drawing connections to the literature on confluent flow. We also introduce a random graph model for liquid democracy, and use it to demonstrate the benefits of our approach both theoretically and empirically.

cs.GT↗

The Provable Virtue of Laziness in Motion Planning

The Lazy Shortest Path (LazySP) class consists of motion-planning algorithms that only evaluate edges along shortest paths between the source and target. These algorithms were designed to minimize the number of edge evaluations in settings where edge evaluation dominates the running time of the algorithm; but how close to optimal are LazySP algorithms in terms of this objective? Our main result is an analytical upper bound, in a probabilistic model, on the number of edge evaluations required by LazySP algorithms; a matching lower bound shows that these algorithms are asymptotically optimal in the worst case.

cs.RO↗

A Discrete and Bounded Envy-Free Cake Cutting Protocol for Any Number of Agents

We consider the well-studied cake cutting problem in which the goal is to find an envy-free allocation based on queries from $n$ agents. The problem has received attention in computer science, mathematics, and economics. It has been a major open problem whether there exists a discrete and bounded envy-free protocol. We resolve the problem by proposing a discrete and bounded envy-free protocol for any number of agents. The maximum number of queries required by the protocol is $n^{n^{n^{n^{n^n}}}}$. We additionally show that even if we do not run our protocol to completion, it can find in at most $n^3{(n^2)}^n$ queries a partial allocation of the cake that achieves proportionality (each agent gets at least $1/n$ of the value of the whole cake) and envy-freeness. Finally we show that an envy-free partial allocation can be computed in at most $n^3{(n^2)}^n$ queries such that each agent gets a connected piece that gives the agent at least $1/(3n)$ of the value of the whole cake.

cs.DS↗