arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Shantanu Chadha

Publications and source records attributed to Shantanu Chadha.

2 recordsLinked to original sources

When the Norm is Wrong: Social Norm Misspecification and Targeting with an Application to Microfinance Adoption

Structural models of peer effects typically capture peer influence through the average, aggregate, or in some cases through extreme peer actions. Such specifications, however, are imposed ex ante and are typically ad hoc. We study the consequences of social norm misspecification by extending the constant elasticity of substitution (CES) norm from continuous to discrete choices. Considering a binary-choice game with incomplete information, we derive results on existence and uniqueness of a rational expectations equilibrium and establish conditions for identification of the structural parameters. We estimate the model by the Nested Pseudo-Likelihood estimator, implemented using the spectral algorithm. Monte Carlo simulations show that the CES estimates of the peer effects approach their true values as the sample grows, whereas imposing a linear norm biases them even in large samples. We apply the framework to microfinance adoption in India and find a strongly max-leaning norm, with significant heterogeneity in curvature and peer effects across villages grouped by caste composition and wealth. In a counterfactual exercise that allocates a fixed subsidy budget to maximise adoption, the estimated and linear norms target very different households, with the former favouring village "leaders", who are more likely to adopt and were the first to be informed about microfinance.

econ.EM↗

Empirical Challenges with Peers-of-Peers Instruments in the Linear-In-Means Model

In the linear-in-means model, endogeneity arises naturally due to the reflection problem. A common solution is to use Instrumental Variables (IVs) based on higher-order network links, such as using friends-of-friends' characteristics. In this paper, we show that such instruments are unlikely to work well in many applied settings due to a specific sparse/dense-network mechanism: in extremely sparse networks, friends-of-friends instruments may become degenerate, while in denser networks they may still provide too little first-stage information. This implies that the IVs may be weak or that the first-stage estimand is undefined. We use random graph theory to characterize the rates at which these issues arise for a benchmark class of random graphs. This allows us to link network topology to first-stage information accumulation and to identify when such instruments are likely to perform well. We show how existing weak-IV robust inference can be adapted to this environment, and how scaling the network provides an alternative specification that can mitigate some of these challenges. We provide extensive Monte Carlo simulations and revisit empirical applications, showing the prevalence of such issues in empirical practice, and how our results apply.

econ.EM↗