arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Paola Pinilla

Publications and source records attributed to Paola Pinilla.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Complex Interplay between Outer Disk Dynamics and Inner Water Reservoir

We present a homogeneous characterization of outer disk dust and gas properties for 51 protoplanetary disks from the JWST/MIRI Cycle 1 programs, combining new ALMA observations with archival data. Visibility fitting with frank recovers more and higher-contrast substructures in the mm continuum than image-plane analysis, placing the innermost features of several disks at 4-5 au and leaving only three disks featureless at the current resolution. CO gas disk sizes span $\sim$60-1000 au and correlate strongly with mm continuum sizes, with $R_{\rm CO}/R_{\rm mm}$ ranging from 1.4 to 9.7 (median 2.95). We then connect these outer disk properties to JWST/MIRI inner disk water diagnostics. We find no global correlation between the cold-to-hot water flux ratio ($F_{\rm cold}/F_{\rm hot}$), a proposed proxy of cold water enrichment by pebble transport, and any single outer disk parameter, including $R_{\rm mm}$, $R_{\rm CO}/R_{\rm mm}$, and innermost substructure location. Three compact ($R_{\rm mm}<30$ au), structureless disks with $R_{\rm CO}/R_{\rm mm}>4$ show both elevated $F_{\rm cold}/F_{\rm hot}$ and cold water emission near the snowline temperature, consistent with unimpeded inward drift of icy pebbles. For structured disks, the water properties instead vary widely at fixed gap location, reflecting the sensitivity of the inner disk water content to multiple factors, including gap leakiness, grain size, and thermal history. Linking outer disk dust evolution to inner disk water content thus requires carefully selected samples with detailed constraints on these additional parameters.

astro-ph.EP↗

Testing Models of Disk Formation and Gravito-Viscous Evolution Against Observations of Young Protoplanetary Disks

Young protoplanetary disks have received increasing attention in recent years, due to observations revealing the presence of substructures in disks younger than one million years, suggesting that planet formation may begin earlier than previously thought. Other recent observations have provided new insights into the evolution of gas and dust in these early stages, enabling comparisons with evolved Class II disks. Yet the physical processes governing the earliest stages of disk evolution remain poorly understood. In this paper, we present two-dimensional thin-disk hydrodynamical simulations of the formation and early evolution of protoplanetary disks, under the influence of self-gravity and turbulent viscosity alone. We explore various properties of disks forming from the collapse of clouds with a range of initial masses and we compare our results with surveys of protoplanetary disks across multiple evolutionary stages. Our simulations broadly reproduce key observational constraints, including the mm fluxes of Class 0 disks and the dust disk radii of later stages. However, our models do not explain the observed gas and dust disk masses of Class I and II disks: while they account for the most massive observed disks, they fail to reproduce the least massive ones. We discuss that simulations incorporating the influence of the star-forming environment might be needed to resolve this discrepancy.

astro-ph.EP↗

Missing Outer Rings in the exoALMA Sample: Physical Mechanisms Suppressing Dust Ring Formation Despite Strong Pressure Bumps

The exoALMA survey has revealed candidate gas pressure bumps at radii beyond the observed millimetre continuum discs in several protoplanetary systems, raising the question of whether these regions could host undetected dust structures. We investigate this for nine of the exoALMA discs by reconstructing gas surface density profiles from midplane pressure gradient measurements derived from $^{12}$CO and $^{13}$CO ALMA Band 7 observations. We evolve the dust using DustPy across a grid of turbulence and fragmentation parameters ($α\in \{10^{-4}, 10^{-3}\}$; $v_\mathrm{frag} \in \{1, 10\}\,\mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$), followed by radiative transfer calculations with RADMC-3D to give predictions for the continuum emission. We find that the dominant outcome across the explored parameter space is efficient outer dust trapping, leading to prominent outer continuum rings that should be detectable at ALMA Band 7, in tension with the observations. The $^{13}$CO-based reconstructions almost universally produce detectable outer rings, whereas the $^{12}$CO-based reconstructions show more variation. We further test delayed formation of the outer pressure bump and enhanced outer-disc turbulence as possible suppression mechanisms of ring formation. Enhanced turbulence weakens the predicted outer continuum emission most effectively, although the efficiency of the mechanism depends on the system explored and on where the turbulence transition is placed. Delayed bump formation generally does not prevent rapid outer dust accumulation.

astro-ph.EP↗

Planet-gap-induced ice lines form observable dust rings in protoplanetary disks

Whether volatile ice lines can produce dust rings in protoplanetary disks remains debated. Previous modelling and observational studies place ice lines using smooth, monotonic disk temperature profiles. However, in substructured disks, the midplane temperature need not be smooth: a deep, planetary gap can locally heat, shift and multiply the ice-line locations. We adopt the non-smooth temperature profile of a hot planetary gap and use dust-evolution simulations to study how CO$_2$ ice lines, which imprint radial jumps in the fragmentation velocity $V_{\rm frag}$, affect dust evolution over 10 Myr and the observational signatures. For comparison, we also run models with uniform low ($V_{\rm frag}=1$ m/s) and high ($V_{\rm frag}=10$ m/s) fragmentation velocities. In the varying-$V_{\rm frag}$ model, dust piles up with enhanced grain sizes at the two CO$_2$ ice lines along the gap edges, appearing as clear double rings in dust observations at 13 $μ$m that persist over 10 Myr; at 1.3 mm, it shows only a modest ring-to-gap contrast of a factor of a few, consistent with the shallow, low-contrast rings in ALMA surveys. The uniform $V_{\rm frag}=10$ m/s model instead forms a single high-contrast ring at the pressure bump and suppresses the inward pebble flux to the inner disk by up to two orders of magnitude, whereas the uniform $V_{\rm frag}=1$ m/s model produces only weak substructure and strong outer-disk depletion. We propose a multi-wavelength test to distinguish these scenarios: ice-line rings stay at fixed radii from scattered light to the millimetre observation, whereas a pressure-bump trap produces a single dominant ring whose peak shifts inward at shorter wavelengths.

astro-ph.EP↗

The ALMA Survey of Gas Evolution of PROtoplanetary disks (AGE-PRO): Evolution of dust properties from multi-wavelength observations

Understanding the evolution of solids in protoplanetary discs is important to comprehend the formation of giant planets cores and terrestrial planets. The ALMA Large Program AGE-PRO studied key disc properties in a survey of 30 protoplanetary discs across three evolutionary stages: the embedded phase (0.5-1 Myr), the middle-age phase (1-3 Myr), and the end of the disc lifetime (2-6 Myr). Preliminary dust properties were estimated using 1.3 mm observations, but a multi-wavelength analysis provides a better constraint of important properties such as the dust disc mass, the dust temperature, and the maximum grain size. We present new ALMA 3.1 mm and 1.5 mm (Bands 3 and 5) continuum observations of the complete survey of 30 AGE-PRO discs. We fitted the observed visibilities and derived radial brightness profiles, spatially resolving 20 discs from the AGE-PRO sample at the two studied wavelengths. A multi-wavelength modelling was performed including also the radial profiles from the 1.3 mm observations. Our results replicate trends obtained from the single wavelength analysis: the dust disc size seems to be constant over age and the dust disc mass decreases with time, with a factor $\sim$10-40 uncertainty from opacity assumptions. This result implies much lower gas-to-dust mass ratios for the discs in our sample than previously reported. In addition, the derived spectral indices are consistent with optically thick emission in a large fraction of the AGE-PRO discs, in particular for the Ophiuchus and Lupus discs.

astro-ph.EP↗

Bridging the gap between stars and planets

The formation mechanisms of brown dwarfs (BDs) and free-floating planets (FFPs) are poorly constrained. The two main competing scenarios include the star-like scenario, where these objects correspond to the least massive gravitationally unstable fragments of molecular clouds, and the planet-like scenario, where these objects form in a circumstellar disk and are subsequently ejected after a dynamical interaction. A new generation millimeter interferometer, such as ALMA2040, is required to disentangle the relevance of these scenarios. For this, ALMA2040 must provide the appropriate performance to explore BD/FFP formation from the cloud scale (~10 pc) down to the disk scale (~10 au). At cloud scales, ALMA2040 must detect a ~1 Mjup embedded FFP in the outer Galaxy (~10 kpc) in 1 h, or the same object in nearby clouds (<~ 400 pc) in about tens of seconds so that large-scale surveys of entire clouds can be performed. This would provide key censuses to compare the results with the predictions from each scenario. At disk scales, ALMA2040 must detect CO outflows from first hydrostatic cores in the substellar regime and potential molecular outflows from ~1 Mjup FFPs in nearby clouds, both with specific predictions in the star-like scenario. In addition, the planet-like scenario predicts a disk mass-to-star mass ratio for BDs larger than the star-like case, and testing this requires detecting disks of ~2 Earth masses around young BDs. Furthermore, the predicted emission for the star-like case of complex organic molecules in proto-BDs at 400 pc must be detected with ALMA2040, requiring a factor of 10 increase in line sensitivity at a spatial resolution of 5-10 au. Finally, ALMA2040 must detect Earth-like protoplanets around young BDs at 400 pc, in order to provide key observational constraints on the radial drift behaviour and planet formation mechanisms in the substellar regime.

astro-ph.IM↗

Secular evolution of viscous and self-gravitating protoplanetary discs with magnetic winds

Traditionally, the disc is believed to evolve under the influence of turbulent viscosity, although the importance of this mechanism has recently been questioned. Alternatively, magnetic disc wind or gravitational instability could be considered, but which of these three mechanisms contributes the most at a given evolutionary stage remains an open question. We present global numerical hydrodynamic simulations of protoplanetary disc evolution in the thin-disc limit on disc lifetime timescales, including all three mechanisms of mass and angular momentum transport. We calculate the gravitational, viscous, and magnetic torques to assess the contribution of each mechanism. We found that these transport mechanisms occupy distinct zones of influence in the disc depending on the stage of evolution: the dominance of disc self-gravity during the early phase is replaced by the prevalence of magnetic disc wind and viscosity, with the latter being especially relevant at the disc periphery. We show that a noticeable decrease in disc mass occurs only after the termination of the embedded phase. The suppression of disc viscous spreading is achieved only for the most intense wind; otherwise, the disc continues to grow in size till the end of simulations. The spiral structure contributes to the temporary retention of dust in the disc. However, this is insufficient to prevent the depletion of dust on long timescales. The results emphasize the importance of a comprehensive approach to long-term simulations of protoplanetary discs with no single mechanism of mass and angular momentum transport regarded as exclusive.

astro-ph.EP↗

Dust Substructures and Line Perturbations driven by a Forming Planet in J16120

Hints of planet formation have been independently reported within the gap of the disc around 2MASS J16120668-301027 from millimetre continuum, infrared, and H-alpha observations. In this work, we present new evidence for ongoing planet formation based on Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) Band 7 observations, detecting 0.87 mm dust continuum emission together with 12CO (J=3-2) and 13CO (J=3-2) line emission. Visibility modelling of the continuum data reveals an inner disc and two dust rings peaking at 23 and 75 au. The continuum morphology is better reproduced by an eccentric disc model (e approximately 0.1) than by an axisymmetric disc. We further investigate the gas kinematics through modelling of the 12CO channel maps. The residual line-width map shows a localised increase in velocity dispersion at the position of a previously reported circumplanetary disc candidate (deprojected radius approximately 32 au, position angle approximately 170 degrees) and along its orbit. This signal is spatially coincident with kink-like features and a transition from sub-Keplerian to super-Keplerian velocities. In addition, the velocity residual map exhibits an arc-like structure extending outward from the planet candidate, while the gas kinematics, despite substantial uncertainties, is consistent with inflow towards the candidate's orbital radius. The observed increase in velocity dispersion agrees with predictions from planet-disc interaction simulations, which produce enhanced turbulence both at the planet location and along its orbital path. Taken together, the continuum morphology and gas kinematic signatures provide compelling new evidence for ongoing planet formation within the disc gap.

astro-ph.EP↗

Drift-dominated dust evolution. A multiwavelength analysis of dust rings in CY Tau and DoAr25

Context. Protoplanetary disks are the birthplaces of planets, and understanding the distribution and evolution of dust within them is essential for tracing the early stages of planet formation. Aims. Following the DSHARP survey, we aim to constrain the radial distribution of the dust surface density and the maximum emitting grain size in the disks of CY Tau and DoAr 25 and assess the relative importance of dust trapping and radial drift in shaping the dust population in disks. Methods. We present multiwavelength continuum observations of CY Tau and DoAr 25 from ALMA at 2.4 and 1.25 mm and archival VLA data at 8.8 mm. Combining the observations with dust continuum forward modeling, we sought to infer a radial profile of the two systems of the dust surface density and maximum emitting grain size. Results. For DoAr 25, the results reveal a prominent dust ring at 111 AU and evidence for large (centimeter-sized) grains extending to the outer disk. In contrast, CY Tau exhibits a more compact and smoother structure, with both the dust surface density and grain size decreasing monotonically with radius. A tentative shoulder feature in the radial profiles, located between 20-40 AU, may point to a marginal substructure, possibly a weak dust trap. Conclusions. DoAr 25 shows evidence for a dust trap capable of halting inward drift, while CY Tau exhibits behavior consistent with evolution dominated by radial drift. Together, these results highlight how dust evolution processes shape the disk morphology and grain-size distributions, even in the low-mass stellar regime.

astro-ph.EP↗

The JDISC Survey: Inner Disk Chemistry of Class I/FS Disks and Tentative Evidence for Early Pebble Drift

We present the first chemical survey of Class I and Flat-Spectrum (I/FS) disks using JWST MIRI/MRS, targeting sixteen sources in the Ophiuchus star-forming region. Through empirical line luminosity measurements and multi-component slab modeling, we characterize the molecular reservoir of these young systems and compare them to twelve Class II disks of similar stellar mass. Water, HCN, C$_2$H$_2$, and CO$_2$ are frequently detected in I/FS sources with inclinations $i < 70^{\circ}$, whereas edge-on systems show significantly suppressed emission. Compared to Class II disks, I/FS sources show suggestive---though not yet statistically significant---evidence for elevated cold water ($\sim$200\,K) mass and lower CO$_2$ excitation temperatures. Statistical analyses identify accretion luminosity as the primary correlate of molecular mass across both evolutionary stages. Once this dependence is removed, cold water and CO$_2$ masses anti-correlate with mm-dust disk radius, while hot water remains insensitive to disk size. These patterns are qualitatively consistent with pebble drift models that predict early water enrichment followed by delayed CO$_2$ delivery, suggesting an evolutionary progression from molecular-poor Class 0 sources, through water-rich Class I/FS disks, to Class II disks with reduced cold water excess. This work provides an initial evolutionary framework for disk chemistry that requires larger, multi-region samples to confirm.

astro-ph.EP↗

Substructures in Planet-Forming Disks with the SKAO

Disks of gas and dust orbiting young stars are the arenas and material reservoirs for planet formation. Over the past decade, multiwavelength observations, from infrared to radio, have resolved the spatial distribution of hundreds of protoplanetary disks in nearby star-forming regions, revealing a diverse zoo of substructures. These substructures are morphological features such as rings, gaps, spirals, vortices, asymmetries, warps, or clumps that trace variations in density, temperature, or composition relative to an otherwise smooth distribution of gas and dust. Many unknowns persist as to the origin of these substructures, their role in planet assembly, and their true properties. SKA-Mid Band 5b continuum observations, offering angular resolutions of $\sim 0.05''$ ($\sim 0.15''$) with AA4 (AA*) at $12.5$ GHz / $2.4$ cm, will enable new progress at this frontier. In this chapter, we outline the open questions in the field of disk substructure that SKA-Mid is uniquely poised to address, with a lens on dust thermal emission.

astro-ph.EP↗

Demographics of planet-forming disks with the SKAO

Understanding how solid material in planet-forming disks evolves from micron-sized dust to planetary cores is a central challenge in modern astrophysics. This study has advanced dramatically in the past decade, largely driven by ALMA and high-contrast imaging facilities. However, major uncertainties remain regarding the presence, evolution, and role of centimeter-sized grains (the pebbles) in planet formation. The SKAO will fill this gap by enabling the first large-scale, high-resolution survey of disk emission at centimeter wavelengths. This chapter presents the scientific rationale and observational strategies to detect and characterize pebbles in the planet-forming disks of nearby star-forming regions. By resolving their spatial distribution, spectral properties, and evolutionary trends, SKA will offer essential constraints on dust growth and disk dynamics. This work provides observational strategies, target selection, and predictions on the detectability of hundreds of nearby disks. The chapter also explores SKA's potential to uncover the actual dust mass in disks, protoplanets and their circumplanetary disks, and other aspects of the planet formation. Together, these capabilities will establish SKAO as a cornerstone facility for planet formation science in the coming decade.

astro-ph.EP↗

Chemical Divergence and Water Depletion: Gas Properties of Evolved Upper Scorpius Disks Revealed by JWST/MIRI

Tracing the chemical evolution of protoplanetary disks over time requires observations of disks at different ages. However, most JWST/MIRI surveys published to date have targeted younger ($\sim$1-3 Myr) rather than older systems. We present the results of a JWST/MIRI MRS survey of the inner regions of 10 protoplanetary disks (ages $\sim$2-6 Myr, spectral types M0-M4.5) in the Upper Scorpius region previously characterized by the ALMA AGE-PRO large program. Using MCMC slab modeling, we fit to a wide variety of detected molecules, including H$_2$O, CO, C$_2$H$_2$, $^{13}$CCH$_2$, HCN, HC$_3$N, CO$_2$, $^{13}$CO$_2$, C$_2$H$_6$, C$_4$H$_2$, and OH, as well as C$_6$H$_6$, CH$_3$, and H$_2$ visually. We classify each disk along two independent axes-a Water Classification based on H$_2$O line luminosity (Water-Rich, Water-Poor, or Water-Absent) and a Chemotype based on the dominant non-water chemistry (Organic-Rich, CO$_2$-Dominated, or Molecule-Absent)-and find an unexpectedly high diversity of distinct chemical compositions within our population. We leverage the heterogeneity of detected molecules in our sample to present new characteristic "diagnostic" wavelength regions for most species. We find that carbon-based molecules consistently exhibit markedly lower excitation temperatures ($\lesssim$300 K) compared to younger ($\sim$1-3 Myr) star-forming regions ($\sim$600-1000 K), hinting at relatively colder molecular reservoirs. We also determine that Upper Scorpius disks show systematically lower water luminosities by factors of 10-1000. In particular, disks with strong carbon-based molecular features but no observed H$_2$O defy expectations of an inner-disk dust cavity or a low ($\lesssim3$) $R_{\rm gas}/R_{\rm dust}$ ratio, instead suggesting that the presence of a strong outer-disk dust trap largely controls the chemical outcome of the terrestrial planet-forming region.

astro-ph.EP↗

From Young to Older Disks: JWST/MIRI Evidence for Fading Molecular Emission and Hints for Elevated C/O in Upper Scorpius

We present JWST/MIRI spectroscopy of 14 disks in the older (~5-10 Myr) Upper Scorpius (USco) association and use slab of gas in local thermal equilibrium to infer basic gas properties. We find that half of these disks are molecular rich, with detections of H$_2$O, CO$_2$, HCN, C$_2$H$_2$, and H$_2$, while the other half are molecular poor, showing no molecular emission other than H$_2$. We further combine this sample with 10 other USco disks from the AGE-PRO program and compare the combined older sample to young (~1-3 Myr) JDISCS Cycle~1 systems, which are analyzed in a similar manner. We find that USco disks have lower detection rates of major molecular species but a significantly higher detection rate of rarer C-bearing molecules such as C$_4$H$_2$. At a given accretion luminosity, molecular line luminosities are systematically lower in USco than in young disks, and the scaling relations with accretion luminosity differ between the two populations. Moreover, we find that about half of the older disks, preferentially the millimeter faint, and likely more compact disks, have observable mass ratios of C- to O-bearing molecules that are higher than the maximum values in the young sample. These results point to reduced inner-disk molecular gas masses, cooler emitting layers, and higher inner gas C/O ratios in older disks, the latter being consistent with pebble drift. Taken together, our findings provide evidence for chemical evolution of inner disk gas from young to older systems, with important implications for the accretion of primordial planetary atmospheres.

astro-ph.EP↗

Molecular Similarity and Water Diversity in Coeval Binary Disks: JWST/MIRI Observations of Sz 65 and Sz 66

We present JWST/MIRI Medium Resolution Spectrometer spectra of the wide-separation (projected separation $= 980$ au) binary protoplanetary disks Sz 65 (K7; $0.68~M_{\odot}$) and Sz 66 (M3; $0.30~M_{\odot}$), reduced using the uniform pipeline of the JWST Disk Infrared Spectral Chemistry Survey. Both disks show rich molecular emission, including H$_2$O, CO$_2$, HCN, C$_2$H$_2$, and OH. The scaled spectra of the two disks exhibit remarkably similar H$_2$O, CO$_2$, and HCN line emission in the 13--18 $μ$m region, with the only notable difference being stronger C$_2$H$_2$ emission in the primary (Sz 65). Beyond 18 $μ$m, the difference in H$_2$O line emission between the two disks increases. Both the flux ratios and the slab-model-derived mass ratios of cold to hot H$_2$O ($\sim$200 K to $\sim$750 K) and warm to hot H$_2$O ($\sim$450 K to $\sim$750 K) are significantly higher in the secondary (Sz 66). Because binary stars share nearly the same age and metallicity, and as both disks appear compact in millimeter emission ($<30$ au), we suggest that the excess cold H$_2$O in the secondary is best explained by its unstructured dust disk, in contrast to the primary, which shows gaps at 6 and 20 au. The enhanced cold water in the secondary is consistent with efficient pebble drift across the water snow line and increased H$_2$O vapor from the sublimation of icy mantles. Our results demonstrate that wide-separation binaries can serve as powerful control samples for isolating the impact of individual disk properties on inner-disk chemistry and evolution.

astro-ph.EP↗

The ALMA Survey of Gas Evolution of PROtoplanetary Disks (AGE-PRO): Formaldehyde (H$_2$CO) emission and its links to disk properties

Protoplanetary disks are rotating structures of gas and dust surrounding young stars, serving as the birth places of planets. Understanding the chemical evolution of organic materials in these disks is key for tracing the origins of organics in planetary systems. Formaldehyde (H$_2$CO) is the most commonly detected organic molecule in protoplanetary disks. In this study, we investigate the emission of H$_2$CO and its link to disk properties, using a sample of 20 Class II disks in the Lupus and Upper Sco star-forming regions spanning over 1-6 Myr. We analyze the H$_2$CO lines at 218.222 and 290.623 GHz observed as part of the AGE-PRO ALMA Large Program. Within this sample we achieve a detection rate of H$_2$CO of 45% (9/20), and set robust upper limits for the non-detections. We measure the excitation temperature and column density of the H$_2$CO gas in the sources with H$_2$CO detections. We combine our sample with 13 additional disks with archival H$_2$CO detections and search for correlations between H$_2$CO properties and disk parameters. Notably, we find strong correlations between H$_2$CO line luminosity and dust radius, gas radius, dust mass, gas mass, stellar mass, and stellar luminosity. This suggests that H$_2$CO emission is brighter for extended massive dust disks where H$_2$CO can form via CO ice hydrogenation on grain surfaces. We find that the H$_2$CO excitation temperature is also correlated with stellar mass and stellar luminosity, so more massive and luminous stars could increase H$_2$CO excitation.

astro-ph.EP↗

Diverse dust vertical height and settling strength conditions in protoplanetary discs

The settling of dust particles plays a critical role in the growth and dynamics of dust grains. We performed a detailed modeling of the ALMA continuum substructures for six highly inclined protoplanetary discs using radiative transfer simulations, to constrain the vertical height of millimetre dust grains and the settling strength. Our modeling results are a very thin millimetre dust disc in T Cha ($\text{h}_{\text{dust}}<$ 0.1 au throughout the disc), a vertically extended dust disc in DoAr 25 ($\text{h}_{\text{dust}}$ of $\sim$ 4.7 au at 140 au) and tentatively a thin disc in MY Lup ($\text{h}_{\text{dust}}<$ 0.5 au at 70 au). From lower resolution observations we found a very thin disc for PDS 111 ($\text{h}_{\text{dust}}<$ 0.1 au throughout the disc) and a more vertically extended millimetre dust disc in V409 Tau ($\text{h}_{\text{dust}}$ of $\sim$ 1.3 au at 35 au). We could not measure the vertical height in the asymmetric disc of RY Lup. We also found that the input dust opacities are a source of degeneracy in our models. Our tentative results, assuming the Ricci dust opacities, point to a diverse settling strength in our sample and possible radial variations. We also compared the models that best fit the ALMA data with the SPHERE data to test if they can reproduce the vertical distribution of small dust grains. This comparison suggests that models that reproduce the dust density distribution in the midplane cannot reproduce the distribution of small dust grains in the upper layers, reinforcing the need for more complex models.

astro-ph.EP↗

The ALMA Survey of Gas Evolution of PROtoplanetary Disks (AGE-PRO): Constraints on disk turbulence, fragmentation velocity, and inner pebble fluxes

How substructures and disk properties affect dust evolution and the delivery of solids and volatiles into planet-forming regions remains an open question. We present results from tailored dust evolution modeling of the AGE-PRO ALMA large program, a sample of 30 protoplanetary disks spanning different evolutionary stages. Visibility fitting of the AGE-PRO ALMA data (at 1.3\,mm) reveals that approximately half of the disks exhibit radial substructures. Combined with stellar properties, disk inclinations, and gas mass estimates from CO isotopologues and N$_2$H$^+$, this well-characterized set of disks provides an ideal testbed to constrain dust evolution models across different ages and disk morphologies. Using the dust evolution code \texttt{DustPy}, we simulate dust evolution in each disk under four model configurations, varying two key free parameters: the turbulent viscosity ($α= 10^{-4}, 10^{-3}$) and fragmentation velocity ($v_{\rm{frag}} = 1 \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}, 10 \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$). Pressure traps are incorporated by perturbing the gas surface density based on the continuum intensity profiles, and synthetic observations generated with \texttt{RADMC-3D} are compared to these profiles. While no single model fits all disks, nearly half are best reproduced by the configuration with low turbulence and low fragmentation velocity ($α= 10^{-4}, v_{\rm{frag}} = 1\,\mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$). Models of smooth disks underpredict dust mass, possibly indicating unresolved substructures. Pebble fluxes into inner disk regions correlate more strongly with disk age than with the presence of substructures, highlighting time-dependent dust transport as a key factor in shaping inner disk composition. Our results also provide a comparative baseline for interpreting multiwavelength and JWST water vapor observations.

astro-ph.EP↗