Norbert Ankri | arXiv Science

arXiv2026

Marx's two aggregate invariants and the solution of the transformation problem in a Morishima-type formalism

The unit value of a commodity, as correctly determined by Michio Morishima's method and its variations, is the sum of the labour-values of its inputs and the direct labour required for its production. However, commodities are sold at their prices of production only when they meet effective social demand and are thereby validated as realised social value. Price determination involves the entire economy and the interconnections among its different branches. This condition gives full meaning to Marx's fundamental equalities, which derive from the law of value and function as invariants governing the economy as a whole. These equalities are necessary, and, once combined with the relevant reproduction constraints and a specified wage basket, sufficient to determine the admissible transformation in the simple reproduction cases examined here. We demonstrate this by starting from Morishima's formalism and returning to a formalism closer to that used by Marx.

econ.TH↗

arXiv2024

From Marx's fundamental equalities to the solving of the transformation problem -- Coherence of the model

Recently, V. Laure van Bambeke used an original approach to solve the famous problem of transformation of values into production prices by considering that capital reallocation to each department (branch) was part of the problem. Here, we confirm the validity of this consideration in relation with the satisfaction of demand (social need which is able to pay for the given product). In contrast to V. Laure van Bambeke's method of solving an overdetermined system of equations (implying that compliance with Marx's fundamental equalities could only be approached), we show that the transformation problem is solvable from a determined (two-branch models) or an underdetermined system of equations enabling to obtain exact solutions through an algorithm we provide, with no approximation needed. For systems with three branches or more, the solution of the transformation problem belongs to an infinite ensemble, accounting for the observed high competition-driven market fluidity. Furthermore, we show that the transformation problem is solvable in the absence of fixed capital, supporting that dealing with the latter is not essential and cannot be seen as a potential flaw of the approach. Our algorithm enables simulations illustrating how the transient rise in the rate of profit predicted by the Okishio theorem is consistent with the tendency of the rate of profit to fall (TRPF) subsequent to capital reallocation, and how the TRPF is governed by the increase of organic composition, in value. We establish that the long-standing transformation problem is not such a problem since it is easily solved through our algorithm, whatever the number of branches considered. This emphasizes the high coherence of Marx's conception, and its impressive relevance regarding issues such as the TRPF, which have remained intensely debated.

econ.GN↗