arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Nicodemo Mazzaferro

Publications and source records attributed to Nicodemo Mazzaferro.

3 recordsLinked to original sources

Efficient strategies for obtaining accurate kinetics from biased simulations

It has been demonstrated that one can recover the unbiased rate constants for slow conformational transitions by observing transitions driven by a bias potential added along one or several collective variables (CVs). However, the choice of CV, biasing scheme, biasing parameters and the rate estimator can all affect the results and it is not obvious which to choose for a given problem. In this study, we compare accuracy versus computational cost for a previously established benchmark system, a coarse-grained protein with computationally accessible unfolding kinetics. We apply bias to four CVs of decreasing quality in both a time-dependent and quasi-static manner, and compare different estimators for the unfolding rate constant in terms of absolute accuracy to the estimated reference unbiased rate. We show that in the case of gentle biasing, the exponential average time-dependent rate (EATR) framework, which simultaneously fits the unbiased rate constant and a coordinate quality metric $γ$, recovers accurate kinetics in nearly all cases. For poor CVs, estimators equivalent to assuming a good coordinate ($γ=1$) systematically fail regardless of biasing method or parameters. We introduce heuristics to show when we expect the rates to be inaccurate, and identify which combinations of biasing scheme, estimator and number of runs reach a given accuracy at the lowest cost.

physics.chem-ph↗

Stepping up enhanced rate calculations with EATR-flooding

Several recent methods have shown that it is possible to compute rate constants of very slow biomolecular processes using simulations where a time-dependent bias is added along one or several collective variables (CVs). We previously reported the exponential average time-dependent rate (EATR) method, which can improve upon these approaches by accounting for how efficiently the external biasing potential modifies the observed rate using a learned CV-quality factor $γ$. This results in more accurate rate estimates using the same data when biasing a suboptimal coordinate. However, as formulated EATR depended on the biasing potential varying over time to properly determine the biasing efficiency, which limits the method's applicability to quasi-static biasing schemes such as ``flooding'' or on-the-fly probability enhanced sampling (OPES). Here, we present the EATR-flooding approach, which generalizes our method by replacing the need for a time dependent bias by instead varying (stepping up) the strength of the biasing potential across multiple sets of simulations. We implement this approach as an open-source Python library, and demonstrate that this approach is accurate without substantial loss of efficiency compared to standard EATR for a coarse-grained protein system, and also show good performance on a fully atomistic cavity-ligand model. Two additional appealing features of EATR-flooding are an internal check for over-biasing and the fact that only a single $γ$ parameter is predicted for a given choice of CVs, as compared to our earlier results where $γ$ empirically depended on biasing rate. Finally, we believe EATR-flooding applies not only to OPES simulations but more generally to CV biasing enhanced sampling approaches, making it broadly useful.

physics.chem-ph↗

Good rates from bad coordinates: the exponential average time-dependent rate approach

Our ability to calculate rates of biochemical processes using molecular dynamics simulations is severely limited by the fact that the time scales for reactions, or changes in conformational state, scale exponentially with the relevant free-energy barriers. In this work, we improve upon a recently proposed rate estimator that allows us to predict transition times with molecular dynamics simulations biased to rapidly explore one or several collective variables. This approach relies on the idea that not all bias goes into promoting transitions, and along with the rate, it estimates a concomitant scale factor for the bias termed the collective variable biasing efficiency $γ$. First, we demonstrate mathematically that our new formulation allows us to derive the commonly used Infrequent Metadynamics (iMetaD) estimator when using a perfect collective variable, $γ=1$. After testing it on a model potential, we then study the unfolding behavior of a previously well characterized coarse-grained protein, which is sufficiently complex that we can choose many different collective variables to bias, but which is sufficiently simple that we are able to compute the unbiased rate dire ctly. For this system, we demonstrate that our new Exponential Average Time-Dependent Rate (EATR) estimator converges to the true rate more rapidly as a function of bias deposition time than does the previous iMetaD approach, even for bias deposition times that are short. We also show that the $γ$ parameter can serve as a good metric for assessing the quality of the biasing coordinate. Finally, we demonstrate that the approach works when combining multiple less-than-optimal bias coordinates.

physics.chem-ph↗