Exact Finite-Horizon Memory, Conditioning, and Dissipative Decay in Coarse Upwind Finite-Volume Prediction
Coarse finite-volume averages do not generally form a predictive state: realized interface fluxes close a conservative update, but distinct fine-grid states with identical parent averages can generate different future coarse histories. We analyze this failure for periodic scalar advection discretized by a first-order upwind finite-volume method with forward Euler time integration. We derive a finite-horizon observation-rank law: each additional observation exposes one new child-cell layer and contributes one fewer independent direction than the number of parent cells, until the unresolved layers are exhausted. Centralized prediction therefore requires one fewer additional coordinate than the number of parent cells per exposed layer, whereas product-local prediction requires one coordinate per layer in each parent. An anchored flux-divergence queue attains the centralized bound, identifies the periodic flux gauge, and, at saturation, forms a minimal autonomous predictive state with the parent averages. We then distinguish exact observability from stable recoverability. The collar-to-queue map becomes rapidly ill-conditioned as the Courant number decreases, so algebraically visible delayed information may fall below a prescribed numerical tolerance. For Courant numbers strictly between zero and one, we prove contraction of the nonconstant component under bounded arithmetic perturbations, with separate control of mean drift, an explicit perturbation neighborhood, and a grid-dependent decay time. Numerical experiments illustrate the rank ladder, effective-rank loss, queue conditioning, step-function flattening, and delayed coarse separation followed by dissipative decay. The results provide a solvable benchmark for assessing state sufficiency in coarse, reduced, multiscale, and learned scientific models.