arXiv subjects
Publications and source records attributed to Michael Nauenberg.
The dissemination of natural philosophy in the 18th-century, which was based primarily on Newton's pioneering work in mechanics, optics and astrophysics, is presented as seen through a remarkable textbook written by a little known Irish mathematics teacher, Robert Gibson. Later, he became the deputy surveyor general of Ireland (1752-1760).
Based on Propostion 6 of his Principia, Newton's geometrical derivation in Propositions 10 and 11 for the radial dependence of the two central forces that lead to elliptical orbits is notoriously difficult. An alternate and more transparent derivation is obtained by applying the affine transformation of a circle into an ellipse.
The manuscripts that presumably contained Newton's early development of the fundamental concepts that led to his Principia have been lost. A plausible reconstruction of this development is presened based on Newton's exchange of letters with Robert Hooke in 1679, with Edmund Halley in 1686, and on some clues in the diagram associated with Proposition1 in Book1 of the Principia that have been ignored in the past. The graphical method associated with this proposition leads to a rapidly convergent method to obtain orbital curves for central forces, and elucidates how Newton may have have been led to formulate some of his other propositions in the Principia.
Calculations of atmospheric refraction are generally based on a simplified model of atmospheric density in the troposphere which assumes that the temperature decreases at a constant lapse rate from sea level up to a height equal to eleven km, and that afterwards it remains constant. In this model, the temperature divided by the lapse rate determines the length scale in the calculations for altitudes less than this height. But daily balloon measurements across the U.S.A. reveal that in some cases the air temperature actually increases from sea level up to a height of about one km, and only after reaching a plateau, it decreases at an approximately constant lapse rate. Moreover, in three examples considered here, the temperature does not remain constant at eleven km , but continues to decreases to a minimum at about sixteen kilometers , and then increases at higher altitudes at a lower rate. Calculations of atmospheric refraction based on this atmospheric data is compared with the results of simplified models.
Newton's Principia, when it appeared in 1687, was received with the greatest admiration, not only by the foremost mathematicians and astronomers in Europe, but also by philosophers like Voltaire and Locke and by members of the educated public. In this account I describe some of the controversies that it provoked, and the impact it had during the next century on the development of celestial mechanics, and the theory of gravitation.
A critique to the article by C.A. Fuchs, N.D. Mermin, and R.Schack, "An introduction to QBism with and application to the locality of quantum mechanics" that appeared in Am. J. Phys. 82 (8), 749-754 (2014)
An approximate theory is presented describing the propagation of the ice-water front that develops in droplets of water that are deposited on a planar surface at a temperature below the melting point of ice. A calculation based on this theory is compared with our experimental observations of the time evolution of this front. The results of calculations of this front by Schultz et al7, obtained by integrating numerically the exact differential equations for this problem, were published graphically, but only for the time-dependent velocity of this front. Unfortunately, these theoretical results cannot be compared directly with our experimental observations. Our experiments were performed by freezing water droplets directly on a block of dry ice, and in order to examine the effects of the heat conductivity of a substrate during the freezing process, such droplets were also deposited on a glass plate and on a copper plate placed on dry ice. The temperature at the base of these droplets, and the dependence of the freezing time on their size was also investigated ex perimentally, and compared with our analytic approximation of the theory. Such experiment have not been published previously, and reveal that the usual assumption that the temperature at the base of the droplets is a constant, made in all previous theoretical papers on this subject, cannot be implemented in practice.
The supposed equivalence of the conventional interpretation of quantum mechanics with Bohm's interpretation is generally demonstrated only in the coordinate representation. It is shown, however, that in the momentum representation this equivalence is not valid.
A theory is presented for the formation of a conical tip in water drops that are frozen on a flat surface below freezing temperature. For the known ice to water density ratio r = .917, the angle of aperture of this cone is found to be θ = 33.550, consistent with observations.
In 1693, Gottfried Whilhelm Leibniz published in the Acta Eruditorum a geometrical proof of the fundamental theorem of the calculus. During his notorious dispute with Isaac Newton on the development of the calculus, Leibniz denied any indebtedness to the work of Isaac Barrow. But it is shown here, that his geometrical proof of this theorem closely resembles Barrow's proof in Proposition 11, Lecture 10, of his Lectiones Geometricae, published in 1670.
The central claim that understanding quantum mechanics requires a conscious observer, which is made made by B. Rosenblum and F. Kuttner in their book "Quantum Enigma: Physics encounters consciousnes", is shown to be based on various misunderstandings and distortions of the foundations of quantum mechanics.
Since the discovery of the figure-8 orbit for the three-body problem [Moore 1993] a large number of periodic orbits of the n-body problem with equal masses and beautiful symmetries have been discovered. However, most of those that have appeared in the literature are either planar or are obtained from perturbations of planar orbits. Here we exhibit a number of new three-dimensional periodic n-body orbits with equal masses and cubic symmetry. We found these orbits numerically by minimizing the action as a function of the trajectories' Fourier coefficients. We also give numerical evidence that a planar 3-body orbit first found in [H\'enon, 1976], rediscovered by [Moore 1993], and found to exist for different masses by [Nauenberg 2001], is dynamically stable. It is a pleasure to dedicate this paper to Philip Holmes.
The recent radial velocity Keck data for GJ876 in Laughlin et al. (2005) is shown to be in good agreement, apart from a 6 m/s scatter, with a theoretical calculation (Nauenberg, 2002) based on orbital parameters from a fit to the earlier Keck data. The time variation of the periods of the inner and outer planets, which are locked in a near 2:1 resonance, are evaluated, and their mean values, Pi and Po, are shown to satisfy closely the relation Po/Pi=2+Po/P, where P is the period for the retrograde precesion of the common mean periastron of these planets.
Numerical solutions are presented for a family of finite angular momentum orbits with three equal masses which connects the classical circular Lagrange orbit with the recently discovered planar figure eight orbit. Each member of this family is a periodic orbit in a frame rotating around the horizontal symmetry axis of the figure eight orbit. Numerical evidence is given that this family is a continuous function of the angular rotation frequency. Similar numerical solutions are also found for n>3 equal masses, where n is an odd integer. Finite angular momentum orbits also have been obtained for rotations along the two other symmetry axis of the figure eight orbit. The stability of these orbits is examined numerically without the restriction to a linear approximation.
I discuss a memorandum entitled " A True state of the Case and Controversy between Sir Isaak Newton and Dr. Robert Hooke as the Priority of that Noble Hypothesis of motion of ye Planets about ye Sun as their Centers", where Hooke summarizes his life long contributions to the development of the physics of orbital motion and the universal theory of gravitation
In 1916 Einstein introduced the first rules for a quantum theory of electromagnetic radiation, and he applied them to a model of matter in thermal equilibrium with radiation to derive Planck's black-body formula. Einstein's treatment is extended here to time-dependent stochastic variables, which leads to a master equation for the probability distribution that describes the irreversible approach of Einstein's model towards thermal equilibrium, and elucidates aspects of the foundation of statistical mechanics. An analytic solution of this equation is obtained in the Fokker-Planck approximation which is in excellent agreement with numerical results. At equilibrium, it is shown that the probability distribution is proportional to the total number of microstates for a given configuration, in accordance with Boltzmann's fundamental postulate of equal a priori probabilities for these states. While the counting of these configurations depends on particle statistics- Boltzmann, Bose-Einstein, or Fermi-Dirac - the corresponding probability is determined here by the dynamics which are embodied in the form of Einstein's quantum transition probabilities for the emission and absorption of radiation. In a special limit, it is shown that the photons in Einstein's model can act as a thermal bath for the evolution of the atoms towards the canonical equilibrium distribution of Gibbs. In this limit, the present model is mathematically equivalent to an extended version of the Ehrenfests' ``dog-flea'' model, which has been discussed recently by Ambegaokar and Clerk.
During the past dozen years there have been numerous articles on a relation between entropy and probability which is non-additive and has a parameter $q$ that depends on the nature of the thermodynamic system under consideration. For $q=1$ this relation corresponds to the Boltzmann-Gibbs entropy, but for other values of $q$ it is claimed that it leads to a formalism which is consistent with the laws of thermodynamics. However, it is shown here that the joint entropy for systems having {\it different} values of $q$ is not defined in this formalism, and consequently fundamental thermodynamic concepts such as temperature and heat exchange cannot be considered for such systems. Moreover, for $q\ne 1$ the probability distribution for weakly interacting systems does not factor into the product of the probability distribution for the separate systems, leading to spurious correlations and other unphysical consequences, e.g. non-extensive energy, that have been ignored in various applications given in the literature.
The nonlinear stability domain of Lagrange's celebrated 1772 solution of a three-body problem is obtained numerically as a function of the masses of the bodies and the common eccentricity of their Keplerian orbits. This domain shows that this solution may be realized in extra-solar planetary systems similar to those that have been discovered recently with two Jupiter-size planets orbiting a solar-size star. For an exact 1:1 resonance, the Doppler shift variation in the emitted light would be the same as for stars which have only a single planetary companion. But it is more likely that in actual extra-solar planetary systems there are deviations from such a resonance, raising the interesting prospect that Lagrange's solution can be identified by an analysis of the observations. The existence of another stable 1:1 resonance solution which would have a more unambiguous Doppler shift signature is also discussed.