arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Luca Castaldo

Publications and source records attributed to Luca Castaldo.

4 recordsLinked to original sources

Determinateness in a classical theory of nonclassical truth

Recent theories that take determinateness as primitive are either nonclassical theories of nonclassical truth, like Field's INT, or classical theories of classical truth, like Fujimoto and Halbach's CD and CD^+. This paper develops a third option: a classical theory of nonclassical truth. The theory, KFDcs, extends the Kripke-Feferman theory KFcs with a primitive determinateness predicate. Unlike CD^+, KFDcs keeps the iteration of truth unrestricted and gives up its completeness. With or without a consistency axiom, KFD is proof-theoretically equivalent to the theory \widehat{ID}_2 of twice iterated fixed points, with ordinal φ(φ({\varepsilon}_0, 0)0), thus stronger than CD^+. It is also shown that replacing full induction with internal induction yields ordinal φ(φ(ω, 0)0), and restricting internal induction to total formulae yields φ({\varepsilon_0},0), the ordinal of KF.

math.LO↗

An axiomatization of truth and paradoxicality

This short note introduces a formal system of truth and paradoxicality, outlining the main motivation, and proving its $ω$-consistency. The system is called TP, for 'Truth and Paradoxicality'.

math.LO↗

On Classical Determinate Truth

The paper proposes and studies new classical, type-free theories of truth and determinateness with unprecedented features. The theories are fully compositional, strongly classical (namely, their internal and external logics are both classical), and feature a \emph{defined} determinateness predicate satisfying desirable and widely agreed principles. The theories capture a conception of truth and determinateness according to which the generalizing power associated with the classicality and full compositionality of truth is combined with the identification of a natural class of sentences -- the determinate ones -- for which clear-cut semantic rules are available. Our theories can also be seen as the \emph{classical closures} of Kripke-Feferman truth: their $ω$-models, which we precisely pinned down, result from including in the extension of the truth predicate the sentences that are satisfied by a Kripkean closed-off fixed point model. The theories compare to recent theories proposed by Fujimoto and Halbach, featuring a primitive determinateness predicate. In the paper we show that our theories entail all principles of Fujimoto and Halbach's theories, and are proof-theoretically equivalent to Fujimoto and Halbach's $\cdplus$. {We also show establish some negative results on Fujimoto and Halbach's theories: such results show that, unlike what happens in our theories, the primitive determinateness predicate prevents one from establishing clear and unrestricted semantic rules for the language with type-free truth.

math.LO↗

KF, PKF, and Reinhardt's Program

In 'Some Remarks on Extending an Interpreting Theories with a Partial Truth Predicate' Reinhardt famously proposed an instrumentalist interpretation of the truth theory Kripke-Feferman (KF) in analogy to Hilbert's program. Reinhardt suggested to view KF as a tool for generating 'the significant part of KF', that is, as a tool for deriving sentences of the form $T\ulcornerφ\urcorner$. The constitutive question of Reinhardt's program was whether it was possible "to justify the use of nonsignificant sentences entirely within the framework of significant sentences"? This question was answered negatively by Halbach and Horsten (2006) but we argue that under a more careful interpretation the question may receive a positive answer. To this end, we propose to shift attention from KF-provably true sentences to KF-provably true inferences, that is, we shall identify the significant part of KF with the set of pairs $\langleΓ, Δ\rangle$, such that KF proves that if all members of $Γ$ are true, at least one member of $Δ$ is true. In way of addressing Reinhardt's question we show that the provably true inferences of KF coincide with the provable sequents of the theory Partial Kripke-Feferman (PKF).

math.LO↗