arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Jonathan Pipping-Gamón

Publications and source records attributed to Jonathan Pipping-Gamón.

8 recordsLinked to original sources

Challenge or Pass? A Dynamic Policy for MLB's Automated Ball-Strike System

Under Major League Baseball's automated ball-strike (ABS) challenge system, players must weigh the value of overturning a call against the risk of losing a challenge they may need later. We develop a policy that values an overturn through its effect on expected runs, accounting for the count, outs, and runners on base. Using pitch tracking and game records, we reconstruct challenge opportunities, including calls that players let stand. A Bayesian model represents players' imperfect impressions of pitch location and uses them to estimate overturn probabilities, with uncertainty calibrated from historical challenge decisions. Dynamic programming compares the expected gain with the future cost of losing a challenge, accounting for the stage of the game, the number of challenges remaining, and opportunities on both offense and defense. We develop the policy using games before the 2026 All-Star break and evaluate it without refitting on 983 games played afterward. Along the recorded sequence of opportunities, the policy recovers 0.536 modeled correction runs per game across both teams, compared with 0.452 under observed decisions, an improvement of 18.5%. The gain is 0.084 runs per game, with a 95% bootstrap interval of [0.065, 0.103]. The policy makes more challenges and recovers more value per successful review despite a lower overturn rate. These results show why overturn rate alone can be a misleading measure of challenge strategy.

stat.AP↗

Opponent-Adjusted Evaluation of NFL Pass Protection and Pass Rush

Evaluating NFL pass protectors and rushers is difficult because observed win rates reflect both player performance and the difficulty of the blocking assignments each player faces. Using Hudl player coordinates and blocking annotations from the 2021 NFL regular season, we estimate blocker and rusher strength jointly from initial blocking matchups. A ridge-regularized Bradley--Terry model uses early pass rush wins and losses within 2.5 seconds of the snap, while a multinomial extension models full-play losses, wins, pressures, and sacks. To summarize full-play performance, we use the outcomes' conditional associations with offensive expected points added (EPA) to weight predicted probabilities, giving ratings of expected disruption produced by rushers or allowed by blockers. In held-out Weeks 16--18, the early and final models reduce log loss by 4.5% and 3.6%, respectively, relative to historical matchup baselines whose smoothing strengths are selected by cross-validation; 95% game-bootstrap intervals for both reductions are above zero. The resulting ratings place observed success in the context of opponents and protection help, with game-bootstrap intervals quantifying sampling uncertainty in early strength and full-play disruption.

stat.AP↗

A Markov Chain Approach to Modeling Rugby Union

Rugby Union's continuous play, variable-length possessions, and multiple scoring outcomes make it difficult to model with standard approaches. We present a Markov Chain framework that represents Rugby Union as a finite state space over score differential, remaining time, and pitch location, with transition probabilities estimated from historical match data. The resulting model supports simulation and analysis of in-game trajectories, including win probability and expected point estimates from any given state. We validate the model through calibration analysis and comparison to models that predict only final outcomes. Our state-space approach produces well-calibrated, competitive estimates while additionally enabling analysis of how games evolve between states.

stat.AP↗

The Blown Lead Paradox: A Pathwise Calibration Benchmark for Win Probability Forecasts

Live win probabilities have given sports collapses a common numerical language: the highest win probability attained by the team that eventually lost. Yet this familiar number is a selected pathwise extreme. The losing path is identified by the terminal outcome and then searched for its most favorable point. Under ideal sequential calibration, we derive an exact continuous-path benchmark for this statistic, a conservative bound for discretely reported paths, and a probability-integral-transform diagnostic for collections of games. Unlike fixed-time calibration summaries and proper scores, the diagnostic asks whether a published feed produces severe losing paths as often as a calibrated sequential model should. We apply the benchmark separately to public regular-season NFL and NBA feeds from 2018-2024, using a season-stratified dyadic bootstrap to account for recurring teams. We detect no global departure in the NFL and a systematic excess of extreme losing-team peaks in the NBA. In the upper 5% benchmark tail, the NBA excess is 1.3% (95% interval 0.4% to 2.3%); first crossings of a published win probability of 0.95 show the same positive gap between observed and implied loss rates.

stat.AP↗

Dummy RAPM: Representing Low-Minute Players in Regularized Adjusted Plus-Minus

Regularized Adjusted Plus-Minus (RAPM) uses stint-level lineup indicators to estimate player contributions to scoring margin. When low-minute player columns are removed, their stints remain in the data, but the design matrix no longer represents the complete lineup. Dummy RAPM restores this information using five indicators for the number of excluded players on each lineup side. Across 16 NBA seasons, chronological validation selects a 10-minute-per-appearance threshold and a dummy-to-player penalty ratio of 2.2. On held-out March-April games, Dummy RAPM reduces mean season game-margin RMSE from 12.897 to 12.856 and achieves lower RMSE in 13 of 16 seasons. The average reduction is 0.042 points, or 0.30%. Although the improvement in game-level predictive accuracy is small, it is consistent: RAPM performs better when it records how many excluded players are on each side.

stat.AP↗

A Unified Server Quality Metric for Tennis

Traditional tennis rating systems (e.g., Elo) summarize overall player strength but do not isolate the independent value of serving. Using point-by-point data from Wimbledon and the U.S.\ Open, we develop serve-specific player metrics that separate serving quality from return ability and other latent factors. For each tournament and gender, we fit logistic mixed-effects models of point outcomes using serve speed, speed variability, and placement features, with crossed server and returner random intercepts to capture unobserved player strengths. From these models we derive Server Quality Scores (SQS): partially pooled, opponent-adjusted estimates of players' serving impact. In out-of-sample evaluation, SQS aligns more strongly with serve efficiency$\unicode{x2014}$the probability of winning points within three shots$\unicode{x2014}$than weighted Elo. We further benchmark SQS against task-aligned serve-stat baselines and model ablations, quantifying the incremental value of serve features and partial pooling. Associations with overall serve win percentage are smaller and dataset-dependent, and neither SQS nor weighted Elo consistently dominates that outcome. Overall, SQS is best interpreted as a measure of serve-induced short-point advantage (serve quality plus early-point conversion), complementing holistic ratings with actionable insight for coaching, forecasting, and player evaluation.

stat.AP↗

Beyond Expected Goals: A Probabilistic Framework for Shot Occurrences in Soccer

Expected goals (xG) models estimate the probability that a shot results in a goal from its context (e.g., location, pressure), but they operate only on observed shots. We propose xG+, a possession-level framework that first estimates the probability that a shot occurs within the next second and its corresponding xG if it were to occur. We also introduce ways to aggregate this joint probability estimate over the course of a possession. By jointly modeling shot-taking behavior and shot quality, xG+ remedies the conditioning-on-shots limitation of standard xG. We show that this improves predictive accuracy at the team level and produces a more persistent player skill signal than standard xG models.

stat.AP↗

Kicking for Goal or Touch? An Expected Points Framework for Penalty Decisions in Rugby Union

Following a penalty in rugby union, teams typically choose between attempting a shot at goal or kicking to touch to pursue a try. We develop an Expected Points (EP) framework that quantifies the value of each option as a function of both field location and game context. Using phase-level data from the 2018/19 Premiership Rugby season (35,199 phases across 132 matches) and an angle-distance model of penalty kick success estimated from international records, we construct two surfaces: (i) the expected points of a possession beginning with a lineout, and (ii) the expected points of a kick at goal, taking into account the in-game consequences of made and missed kicks. We then compare these surfaces to produce decision maps that indicate where kicking for goal or kicking to touch maximizes expected return, and we analyze how the boundary shifts with game context and the expected meters gained to touch. Our results provide a unified, data-driven method for evaluating penalty decisions and can be tailored to team-specific kickers and lineout units. This study offers, to our knowledge, the first comprehensive EP-based assessment of penalty strategy in rugby union and outlines extensions to win-probability analysis and richer tracking data.

stat.AP↗