arXiv subjects

Jochen Kuhn

Publications and source records attributed to Jochen Kuhn.

30 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

arXiv2023

Harnessing Large Language Models to Enhance Self-Regulated Learning via Formative Feedback

Effectively supporting students in mastering all facets of self-regulated learning is a central aim of teachers and educational researchers. Prior research could demonstrate that formative feedback is an effective way to support students during self-regulated learning (SRL). However, for formative feedback to be effective, it needs to be tailored to the learners, requiring information about their learning progress. In this work, we introduce LEAP, a novel platform that utilizes advanced large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, to provide formative feedback to students. LEAP empowers teachers with the ability to effectively pre-prompt and assign tasks to the LLM, thereby stimulating students' cognitive and metacognitive processes and promoting self-regulated learning. We demonstrate that a systematic prompt design based on theoretical principles can provide a wide range of types of scaffolds to students, including sense-making, elaboration, self-explanation, partial task-solution scaffolds, as well as metacognitive and motivational scaffolds. In this way, we emphasize the critical importance of synchronizing educational technological advances with empirical research and theoretical frameworks.

physics.ed-ph↗

arXiv2023

Educational data augmentation in physics education research using ChatGPT

Generative AI technologies such as large language models show novel potentials to enhance educational research. For example, generative large language models were shown to be capable to solve quantitative reasoning tasks in physics and concept tests such as the Force Concept Inventory. Given the importance of such concept inventories for physics education research, and the challenges in developing them such as field testing with representative populations, this study seeks to examine to what extent a generative large language model could be utilized to generate a synthetic data set for the FCI that exhibits content-related variability in responses. We use the recently introduced ChatGPT based on the GPT 4 generative large language model and investigate to what extent ChatGPT could solve the FCI accurately (RQ1) and could be prompted to solve the FCI as-if it were a student belonging to a different cohort (RQ2). Furthermore, we study, to what extent ChatGPT could be prompted to solve the FCI as-if it were a student having a different force- and mechanics-related misconception (RQ3). In alignment with other research, we found the ChatGPT could accurately solve the FCI. We furthermore found that prompting ChatGPT to respond to the inventory as-if it belonged to a different cohort yielded no variance in responses, however, responding as-if it had a certain misconception introduced much variance in responses that approximate real human responses on the FCI in some regards.

physics.ed-ph↗

arXiv2023

Unreflected Acceptance -- Investigating the Negative Consequences of ChatGPT-Assisted Problem Solving in Physics Education

Large language models (LLMs) have recently gained popularity. However, the impact of their general availability through ChatGPT on sensitive areas of everyday life, such as education, remains unclear. Nevertheless, the societal impact on established educational methods is already being experienced by both students and educators. Our work focuses on higher physics education and examines problem solving strategies. In a study, students with a background in physics were assigned to solve physics exercises, with one group having access to an internet search engine (N=12) and the other group being allowed to use ChatGPT (N=27). We evaluated their performance, strategies, and interaction with the provided tools. Our results showed that nearly half of the solutions provided with the support of ChatGPT were mistakenly assumed to be correct by the students, indicating that they overly trusted ChatGPT even in their field of expertise. Likewise, in 42% of cases, students used copy & paste to query ChatGPT -- an approach only used in 4% of search engine queries -- highlighting the stark differences in interaction behavior between the groups and indicating limited reflection when using ChatGPT. In our work, we demonstrated a need to (1) guide students on how to interact with LLMs and (2) create awareness of potential shortcomings for users.

physics.ed-ph↗

arXiv2023

Newspaper Story Problems and Other Tasks for Context Based Physics Education: A Research Based report on classroom practice

Background: Context Based Science Education (CBSE) has a long-standing tradition and is discussed as a highly promising approach in science education. It is supposed that CBSE can foster pupils engagement and learning. However, classroom implementations of CBSE based on solid empirical evidence are surprisingly scarce. Purpose: The present research-based report of practice seeks to bridge this theory practice gap for some specific forms of CBSE. We examine the use of science problems based on newspaper articles and the real-life contexts they provide (newspaper story problems, NSP). Design and Methods: While the research background has been reported elsewhere, the main objective of the present contribution is to provide a detailed account of the practical aspects of the approach. Two concrete, curriculum-relevant classroom teaching experiments based on newspaper story problems are reported, combined with a quasi-experimental study comparing NSPs against conventional textbook problems. The implementation of the teaching learning sequence in classroom practice is described in detail. Additionally, tasks types similar to NSPs, but using other ways of contextualisation (e.g. advertisements) will be discussed as perspective. Results: A considerable improvement in motivation was found, which proved stable at least in the medium term. Learning turned out to also be fostered to a sizeable extent, including the educationally important issue of transfer. Conclusions: The use of NSPs as a form of CBSE can have large positive, robust, and sustainable effects of both motivation and learning. Being flexible and practical to implement, they appear thus highly suited to classroom application. In perspective, a series of similar forms of tasks implementing CBSE is presented, such as by experimental of aesthetic contexts.

physics.ed-ph↗

arXiv2023

Physics task development of prospective physics teachers using ChatGPT

The recent advancement of large language models presents numerous opportunities for teaching and learning. Despite widespread public debate regarding the use of large language models, empirical research on their opportunities and risks in education remains limited. In this work, we demonstrate the qualities and shortcomings of using ChatGPT 3.5 for physics task development by prospective teachers. In a randomized controlled trial, 26 prospective physics teacher students were divided into two groups: the first group used ChatGPT 3.5 to develop text-based physics tasks for four different concepts in the field of kinematics for 10th grade high school students, while the second group used a classical textbook to create tasks for the same concepts and target group. The results indicate no difference in task correctness, but students using the textbook achieved a higher clarity and more frequently embedded their questions in a meaningful context. Both groups adapted the level of task difficulty easily to the target group but struggled strongly with sufficient task specificity, i.e., relevant information to solve the tasks were missing. Students using ChatGPT for problem posing rated high system usability but experienced difficulties with output quality. These results provide insights into the opportunities and pitfalls of using large language models in education.

physics.ed-ph↗

arXiv2023

The impact of an interactive visualization and simulation tool on learning quantum physics: Results of an eye-tracking study

Employing scientific practices to obtain and use information is one of the central facets of next generation science standards. Especially in quantum technology education, the ability to employ such practices is an essential skill to foster both academic success and technological development. In order to help educators design effective instructions, the comparison between novices' and experts' eye movements allows the identification of efficient information extraction and integration strategies. In this work, we compare the gaze behavior of experts and novices while solving problems in quantum physics using an interactive simulation tool, Quantum Composer, which displays information via multiple external representations (numerical values, equations, graphs). During two reasoning tasks, we found that metarepresentational competences were crucial for successful engagement with the simulation tool. The analysis of the gaze behavior revealed that visual attention on a graph plays a major role and redundant numerical information is ignored. Furthermore, the total dwell time on relevant and irrelevant areas is predictive for the score in the second task. Therefore, the results demonstrate which difficulties novices encounter when using simulation tools and provides insights for how to design effective instructions in quantum technology education guided by experts' gaze behavior.

physics.ed-ph↗

arXiv2022

Development and validation of the Converging Lenses Concept Inventory for middle school physics education

Optics is a core field in the curricula of secondary physics education. In this study, we present the development and validation of a test instrument in the field of optics, the Converging Lenses Concept Inventory (CLCI). It can be used as a formative or a summative assessment of middle school students' conceptual understanding of image formation by converging lenses. The CLCI assesses: (1) the overall understanding of fundamental concepts related to converging lenses, (2) the understanding of specific concepts, and (3) students' propensity for difficulties within this topic. The initial CLCI consists of 16 multiple-choice items; however, one item was removed based on various quality checks. We validated the CLCI thoroughly with distractor analyses, classical test theory, item response theory, structural analyses, and analyses of students' total scores at different measurement points as quantitative approaches, as well as student interviews and an expert survey as qualitative approaches. The quantitative analyses are mostly based on a dataset of N = 318 middle school students who took the CLCI as a posttest. The student interviews were conducted with seven middle school students after they were taught the concepts of converging lenses. The expert survey included five experts who evaluated both individual items and the test as a whole. The analyses showed good to excellent results for the test instrument, corroborating the 15-item CLCI's validity and its compliance with the three foci outlined above.

physics.ed-ph↗

arXiv2020

Coordinating vector field equations and diagrams with a serious game in introductory physics

Mathematical reasoning with algebraic and graphical representations is essential for success in physics courses. Many problems require students to fluently move between algebraic and graphical representations. We developed a freely available serious game to challenge the representational fluency of introductory students regarding vector fields. Within the game, interactive puzzles are solved using different types of vector fields that must be configured with the correct mathematical parameters. A reward system implemented in the game prevents from using trial-and-error approaches and instead encourages the player to establish a mental connection between the graphical representation of the vector field and the (algebraic) equation before taking any action. For correct solutions, the player receives points and can unlock further levels. We report about the aim of the game from an educational perspective, describe potential learning scenarios and reflect about a first attempt to use the game in the classroom.

physics.ed-ph↗

arXiv2019

Visual attention while solving the test of understanding graphs in kinematics: An eye-tracking analysis

This study used eye-tracking to capture the students' visual attention while taking the test of understanding graphs in kinematics (TUG-K). A total of N = 115 upper-secondary-level students from Germany and Switzerland took the 26-item multiple-choice instrument after learning about kinematics graphs in the regular classroom. Besides choosing the correct alternative among research-based distractors, the students were required to judge their response confidence for each question. The items were presented sequentially on a computer screen equipped with a remote eye tracker, resulting in a set of approx. 3000 paired responses (accuracy and confidence) and about 40 hours of eye movementdata (approx. 500.000 fixations). The analysis of students' visual attention related to the item stems (questions) and the item options reveal that high response confidence is correlated with shorter visit duration on both elements of the items. While the students' response accuracy and their response confidence are highly correlated on the score level, r(115) = 0.63, p < 0.001, the eye-tracking measures do not sufficiently discriminate between correct and incorrect responses. However, a more fine-grained analysis of visual attention based on different answer options reveals a significant discrimination between correct and incorrect answers in terms of an interaction effect: Incorrect responses are associated with longer visit durations on strong distractors and less time spent on correct options while correct responses show the opposite trend. Outcomes of this study provide new insights into the validation of concept inventories based on students' behavioural level.

physics.ed-ph↗

arXiv2019

Using Mobile Devices to Augment Inquiry-Based Learning Processes with Multiple Representations

Technological advances offer the possibility of using mobile devices to enrich learning environments with multimedia content. Although physical experiments play a key role in science learning, little is known about integrating multimedia learning in physical experimental processes, especially in real classroom settings. In our approach, students use tablet PCs to investigate motions with an application providing multiple representations of the measurement data. We present the results of a cluster-randomized controlled trial (N=262 matched samples) that covered the topic uniform motion. The results show that the treatment not only leads to a significant reduction of extraneous cognitive load (F(1,240)=27.01, p<10-3, $η$2=0.101, $1-β$=1.000), but also to greater conceptual knowledge (F(1,259)=10.82, p=0.001, $η$2=0.048, $1-β$=0.953). Structure equation modeling statistically supports the assumption of a causal relationship between the reduction of extraneous cognitive load and the increase in conceptual understanding.

physics.ed-ph↗

arXiv2019

Collaborative Interactive Learning -- A clarification of terms and a differentiation from other research fields

The field of collaborative interactive learning (CIL) aims at developing and investigating the technological foundations for a new generation of smart systems that support humans in their everyday life. While the concept of CIL has already been carved out in detail (including the fields of dedicated CIL and opportunistic CIL) and many research objectives have been stated, there is still the need to clarify some terms such as information, knowledge, and experience in the context of CIL and to differentiate CIL from recent and ongoing research in related fields such as active learning, collaborative learning, and others. Both aspects are addressed in this paper.

cs.LG↗

arXiv2019

Improving students' understanding of rotating frames of reference using videos from different perspectives

The concepts of the Coriolis and the centrifugal force are essential in various scientific fields and they are standard components of introductory physics lectures. In this paper we explore how students understand and apply concepts of rotating frames of reference in the context of an exemplary lecture demonstration experiment. We found in a $Predict-Observe-Explain$-setting, that after predicting the outcome prior to the demonstration, only one out of five physics students correctly reported the observation of the trajectory of a sphere rolling over a rotating disc. Despite this low score, a detailed analysis of distractors revealed significant conceptual learning during the observation of the experiment. In this context, we identified three main misconceptions and learning difficulties. First, the centrifugal force is only required to describe the trajectory if the object is coupled to the rotating system. Second, inertial forces cause a reaction of an object on which they act. And third, students systematically mix-up the trajectories in the stationary and the rotating frame of reference. Furthermore, we captured students' eye movements during the $Predict$ task and found that physics students with low confidence ratings focused longer on relevant task areas than confident students despite having a comparable score. Consequently, this metric is a helpful tool for the identification of misconceptions using eye tracking. Overall, the results help to understand the complexity of concept learning from demonstration experiments and provide important implications for instructional design of introductions to rotating frames of reference.

physics.ed-ph↗