Jiamu Zhang | arXiv Science

arXiv2026

Rethinking the Evaluation of Efficiency Methods for Multi-Agent Systems

Efficiency is increasingly important for Large Language Model (LLM)-based multi-agent systems (MAS), as larger models and more agents introduce substantial execution costs. Recent methods aim to make MAS cheaper by pruning agents, removing communication edges, or searching for compact structures. However, we argue that existing evaluations may overestimate their true ability to improve MAS efficiency. Reported gains are often measured under method-specific prompts and starting topologies, making them difficult to attribute to the proposed structural changes. Moreover, many reported successes appear in non-MAS-demanding settings, where a single agent or a randomly pruned system can already preserve strong performance. To study these issues, we introduce a controlled and MAS-demanding diagnostic benchmark for representative MAS efficiency methods. We evaluate methods under a shared backbone model, agent registry, and runtime, across controlled variations in topology, scale, depth, and tool use. Our analysis shows that many reported gains are setup-dependent and may arise from structural collapse, disabled tool pathways, or starting systems where random pruning already preserves accuracy, rather than robust improvements in MAS efficiency.

cs.LG↗

arXiv2026

WiSP: A Working-Set View of Mixture-of-Experts Serving on Extremely Low-Resource Hardware

Modern local and agentic workloads often need large-model capacity at low concurrency, but run on GPUs that cannot keep a frontier-scale model resident. Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models are a natural fit because they activate only a small subset of experts per token, but their sparsity saves computation, not residency: the full expert pool still has to be stored, and any expert used by a layer must be in GPU memory when that layer runs. Static layer-level CPU offload makes such models fit, but transfers the expert layer in bulk on every forward pass, losing much of the sparsity advantage. We view low-resource MoE serving as a working-set problem on the GPU. Routed expert weights and the KV cache are two memory-demand streams competing for the same limited VRAM. We implement this view in WiSP (Working-Set Paging), a routing-aware expert pager that plugs into an unmodified serving engine and preserves byte-identical outputs. On a real 24 GiB RTX 3090, WiSP achieves up to 2.0x the decode throughput of static offload at the same memory budget when the model does not fit. A natural next step is to predict future experts and prefetch them. We find that this does not help in single-stream decode: the bottleneck is PCIe bandwidth, not prediction quality, so speculative transfers compete with demand transfers instead of hiding them. This shifts the design question from prefetching to allocation: how should one VRAM budget be divided between resident experts and the KV cache? We answer with MV-WSA (Marginal-Value Working-Set Allocation), which splits memory by marginal latency benefit per byte while enforcing a KV-admission floor. As a startup configurator, MV-WSA is the only policy we test that stays near-best on both prefill and decode; as a live controller, it resizes both pools while serving and reduces end-to-end time by up to 1.19x over a fixed offline split, without changing model outputs.

cs.LG↗