arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Isaac Goldbring

Publications and source records attributed to Isaac Goldbring.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Matrix ultraproducts have trivial fundamental group

We prove that every tracial ultraproduct $\prod_{\mathcal{U}} M_n(\mathbb{C})$ of matrix algebras has trivial fundamental group. In particular, this establishes that there are uncountably many nonisomorphic matrix ultraproducts, answering a question of Sorin Popa. We actually prove the stronger result that every matrix ultraproduct has trivial first-order fundamental group and thus our techniques are model-theoretic in nature.

math.OA↗

Effectively nuclear C*-algebras

We study the computable content of nuclearity for $C^*$-algebras. We show that nuclearity effectivizes automatically: a presentation of a $C^*$-algebra is effectively nuclear, in the sense that the completely positive approximations witnessing nuclearity can be computed uniformly from the data they approximate, if and only if it is a computable presentation of a nuclear $C^*$-algebra, and likewise for the effectivization of the Choi--Effros form of nuclearity. The main tool is an effective version of the Arveson extension theorem: we prove that the $n$-th matrix numerical range of a tuple from a computable presentation is computably compact, uniformly in all of its data, and deduce an algorithm which converts an approximately attainable tuple of matrices into a computable unital completely positive map attaining it. A byproduct is that the computable states of any computable presentation of a unital $C^*$-algebra are weak$^*$-dense in its state space. We also prove that the Cuntz algebras $\mathcal{O}_n$ are computably categorical and obtain an effective form of Kirchberg--Phillips absorption. By contrast with the conditions above, we do not know whether every computable presentation of a nuclear $C^*$-algebra admits a computable embedding into $\mathcal{O}_2$ with a computable conditional expectation; we answer this affirmatively for commutative $C^*$-algebras, for AF algebras, and, by a dynamical argument using invariant states, for the group $C^*$-algebras of a class of amenable groups including all finitely presented residually finite ones. Finally, we show that the set of indices of computable presentations of nuclear $C^*$-algebras is $Π^0_2$, and that the corresponding set for c.e. presentations is $Π^0_2$-hard; the latter rests on a result of independent interest, namely that amenability of computable groups is $Π^0_2$-complete within the class of computable groups.

math.OA↗

Computable presentations of reduced group C*-algebras of hyperbolic groups

Answering a question of Thomas Sinclair, we show that the standard presentation of the reduced group C*-algebra $C^*_r(G)$ of an infinite hyperbolic group $G$ is computable. The main ingredient in proving this result is showing that the Gromov boundary $\partial G$ of $G$ admits a computably compact metric presentation for which the natural action of $G$ on $\partial G$ is computable.

math.LO↗

Totally Bounded Elements in W*-probability Spaces

We introduce the notion of a totally ($K$-) bounded element of a $W^*$-probability space $(M, φ)$ and, borrowing ideas of Kadison, give an intrinsic characterization of the $^*$-subalgebra $M_{\operatorname{tb}}$ of totally bounded elements. Namely, we show that $M_{\operatorname{tb}}$ is the unique strongly dense $^*$-subalgebra $M_0$ of totally bounded elements of $M$ for which the collection of totally $1$-bounded elements of $M_0$ is complete with respect to the $\|\cdot\|_φ^\#$-norm and for which $M_0$ is closed under all operators $h_a(\log(Δ))$ for $a \in \mathbb{N}$, where $Δ$ is the modular operator and $h_a(t):=1/\cosh(t-a)$ (see Theorem 4.3). We also prove that totally $K$-bounded elements of an Ocneanu ultraproduct admit representatives with the same total bound using a careful effective estimate of the distance of a given totally bounded element to the totally 1-bounded elements. An alternative proof in the appendix uses an isometric $H^\infty$-lifting theorem for the Ocneanu multiplier quotient, derived from a metric $H^\infty$-lifting theorem for $C^*$-quotients and a $C^*$-algebraic Schur parametrization. We combine these results with Rieffel and Van Daele's bounded operator approach to modular theory to arrive at a new language and axiomatization of $W^*$-probability spaces as metric structures. Previous work of Dabrowski had axiomatized $W^*$-probability spaces using a smeared version of multiplication, but the subalgebra $M_{\operatorname{tb}}$ allows us to give an axiomatization in terms of the original algebra operations. Finally, we prove the (non-)axiomatizability of several classes of $W^*$-probability spaces.

math.OA↗

Ultrapowers of spectral subspaces

We prove, for any W$^*$-probability space $(M,φ)$ where $M$ is a type $\mathrm{III}_1$ factor, any nontrivial, proper closed $F\subseteq \mathbb{R}$, and any nonprincipal ultrafilter $\mathcal{U}$ on $\mathbb{N}$, that the ultrapower $M(σ^φ,F)^{\mathcal{U}}$ of the spectral subspace $M(σ^φ,F)$ is a proper subset of the spectral subspace $M^{\mathcal{U}}(σ^{φ^{\mathcal{U}}},F)$. We discuss the model-theoretic implications of this result.

math.OA↗

Model theory and Connes' bicentralizer problem

We make a series of model-theoretic contributions to Connes' bicentralizer problem, one of the most prominent open problems in the theory of von Neumann algebras. Our work builds on the recent result of Houdayer and Marrakchi who show that, for separable diffuse W$^*$-probability spaces, having trivial bicentralizer is equivalent to being selfless, that is, having the first factor inclusion into the free product be an existential embedding. We first show that the class of selfless $W^*$-probability spaces is $\forall\exists$-axiomatizable. We then extend the Houdayer-Marrakchi equivalence to all diffuse W$^*$-probability spaces, removing the separability hypothesis. Combining these results, we show that for any axiomatizable class of diffuse $W^*$-probability spaces, those with trivial bicentralizer form an $\forall\exists$-axiomatizable class; in particular, the class of type $\mathrm{III}_1$ factors with trivial bicentralizer is $\forall\exists$-axiomatizable. We give concrete axioms for this class using totally bounded variants of Haagerup's characterization of the bicentralizer, which we develop here and believe to be of independent interest. We also introduce the notion of pseudoperiodic $\mathrm{III}_1$ factors and show that any such factor has trivial bicentralizer. In the final section, we prove that the bicentralizer problem has a positive solution if and only if the bicentralizer functor is a zeroset relative to the theory of $\mathrm{III}_1$ factors. We use this result to give an equivalent formulation of the bicentralizer problem in terms of a uniformity condition on Haagerup's Dixmier-type characterization of the bicentralizer.

math.OA↗

Computable $K$-theory for C*-algebras II: AF algebras

We continue the study of the effective content of $K$-theory for C*-algebras, with a focus on AF algebras. We show that from a c.e. presentation of an AF algebra it is possible to compute a representation of the algebra as an inductive limit of finite-dimensional algebras. Using this, and an analogous result for dimension groups, we show that the computable $K_0$ functor provides a computable equivalence of categories between c.e. presentations of AF algebras and c.e. presentations of unital (scaled) dimension groups, giving an effective version of Elliott's classification theorem. We use our results to determine the complexity of the index set and isomorphism problems for various classes of AF algebras.

math.OA↗

A nonstandard approach to the direct integral version of the Spectral Theorem

We use nonstandard methods to prove the direct integral version of the Spectral Theorem for Unbounded Self-adjoint Operators. Our proof avoids the standard reduction to the case of bounded normal operators via the Cayley transform and, as such, works uniformly for both real and complex Hilbert spaces. Our method also yields a new nonstandard proof of the spectral measure version of the Spectral Theorem.

math.SP↗

General real-valued theories with the Schröder-Bernstein property are stable

We show that every general theory à la Keisler with the Schröder-Bernstein property is stable. This generalizes the corresponding result from classical logic due to John Goodrick. Our proof uses the classical result (generalized to the case that the instability is witnessed by an infinitary formula) together with a discretization technique introduced by Keisler and the third-named author. We speculate on how our techniques could be adapted to show that every continuous theory with the Schröder-Bernstein property is stable.

math.LO↗

On definability of C*-tensor norms

We initiate the study of definability (in the model-theoretic sense) of C*-tensor norms. We show that neither the minimal nor maximal tensor norms are definable uniformly over all C*-algebras. The proof in the case of the minimal tensor product norm uses a deep theorem of Kirchberg characterizing exactness in terms of tensor products with matrix ultraproducts while the case of maximal tensor products uses Pisier's recent characterization of the lifting property in terms of maximal tensor products and ultraproducts. We also study the question of when one of these tensor products can be definable in a particular C*-algebra. We establish some negative results along these lines for particular C*-algebras and when the definability condition is strengthened to be computable and of a restricted quantifier-complexity; these results use the quantum complexity results MIP$^*$=RE and MIP$^{co}=$coRE. As a byproduct of our arguments, we answer a question of Fritz, Netzer, and Thom by showing that the norm on $C^*(\mathbb{F}_n\times \mathbb{F}_n)$ is not computable for any $n\in \{2,3,\ldots,\infty\}$.

math.OA↗

The Schröder-Bernstein property for operators on Hilbert spaces

We establish that the complete theory of a Hilbert space equipped with a normal operator has the Schröder-Bernstein property. This answers a question of Argoty, Berenstein, and the first-named author. We also prove an analogous statement for unbounded self-adjoint operators.

math.LO↗

Model theory of Hilbert spaces expanded by normal operators

We study expansions of Hilbert spaces with a bounded normal operator $T$. We axiomatize this theory in a natural language and identify all of its completions. We prove the definability of the adjoint $T^*$ and prove quantifier elimination for every completion after adding $T^*$ to the language. We identify types with measures on the spectrum of the operator and show that the logic topology on the type space corresponds to the weak*-topology on the space of measures. We also give a precise formula for the metric on the space of $1$-types. We prove all completions are stable and characterize the stability spectrum of the theory in terms of the spectrum of the operator. We also show all completions, regardless of their spectrum, are $ω$-stable up to perturbations.

math.LO↗

Existentially closed measure-preserving actions of approximately treeable groups

Given a countable group $Γ$, letting $\mathcal{K}_Γ$ denote the class of {\pmp} actions of $Γ$, we study the question of when the model companion of $\mathcal{K}_Γ$ exists. Berenstein, Henson, and Ibarlucía showed that the model companion of $\mathcal{K}_Γ$ exists when $Γ$ is a nonabelian free group on a countable number of generators. We significantly generalize their result by showing that the model companion of $\cal K_Γ$ exists whenever $Γ$ is an approximately treeable group. The class of approximately treeable groups contain the class of treeable groups as well as the class of universally free groups, that is, the class of groups with the same universal theory as nonabelian free groups. We prove this result using an open mapping characterization of when the model companion exists; moreover, this open mapping characterization provides concrete, ergodic-theoretic axioms for the model companion when it exists. We show how to simplify these axioms in the case of treeable groups, providing an alternate axiomatization for the model companion in the case of the free group, which was first axiomatized by Berenstein, Henson, and Ibarlucía using techniques from model-theoretic stability theory. Along the way, we prove a purely ergodic-theoretic result of independent interest, namely that finitely generated universally free groups (also known as limit groups) have Kechris' property MD. We also show that for groups with Kechris' EMD property, the profinite completion action is existentially closed, and for groups without property (T), the generic existentially closed action is weakly mixing, generalizing results of Berenstein, Henson, and Ibarlucía for the case of nonabelian free groups.

math.LO↗

Computable presentations of randomizations

We initiate the effective metric structure theory of Keisler randomizations. We show that a classical countable structure $\mathcal{M}$ has a decidable presentation if and only if its Borel randomization $\mathcal{M}^{[0,1)}$ has a computable presentation for which the constant functions are uniformly computable points. We determine a sufficient condition for which the uniform computability of the constant functions can be dropped. We show that when $\mathcal{M}$ is effectively $ω$-categorical, then $\mathcal{M}^{[0,1)}$ is computably categorical, that is, has a unique computable presentation up to computable isomorphism. A special case of this result is that the unique separable atomless probability algebra is computably categorical. Finally, we show that all randomizations admit effective quantifier elimination.

math.LO↗

Computable $K$-theory for $\mathrm{C}^*$-algebras: UHF algebras

We initiate the study of the effective content of $K$-theory for $\mathrm{C}^*$-algebras. We prove that there are computable functors which associate, to a computably enumerable presentation of a $\mathrm{C}^*$-algebra $\boldA$, computably enumerable presentations of the abelian groups $K_0(\boldA)$ and $K_1(\boldA)$. When $\boldA$ is stably finite, we show that the positive cone of $K_0(\boldA)$ is computably enumerable. We strengthen the results in the case that $\boldA$ is a UHF algebra by showing that the aforementioned presentation of $K_0(\boldA)$ is actually computable. In the UHF case, we also show that $\boldA$ has a computable presentation precisely when $K_0(\boldA)$ has a computable presentation, which in turn is equivalent to the supernatural number of $\boldA$ being lower semicomputable; we give an example that shows that this latter equivalence cannot be improved to requiring that the supernatural number of $\boldA$ is computable. Finally, we prove that every UHF algebra is computably categorical.

math.LO↗

On the First-Order Free Group Factor Alternative

We investigate the problem of elementary equivalence of the free group factors, that is, do all free group factors $L(\mathbb{F}_n)$ share a common first-order theory? We establish a trichotomy of possibilities for their common first-order fundamental group, as well as several possible avenues for establishing a dichotomy in direct analog to the free group factor alternative of Dykema and Radulescu. We also show that the $\forall \exists$-theories of the interpolated free group factors are increasing, and use this to establish that the dichotomy holds on the level of $\forall \exists$-theories. We conclude with some observations on related problems.

math.LO↗