arXiv ScienceSearch

arXiv subjects

Greg L. Bryan

Publications and source records attributed to Greg L. Bryan.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

BIND (Baryonic INpainting with Deep learning): A Field-level Emulator for Galaxy Groups and Clusters

Baryonic feedback is a dominant source of systematic uncertainty for upcoming weak-lensing surveys, but current tools for modeling its effect rely on spherical approximations and density profiles calibrated almost entirely on two-point statistics. We introduce BIND (Baryonic INpainting with Deep learning), a conditional flow-matching model that learns a field-level mapping from dark-matter-only halos to their hydrodynamical counterparts. BIND is trained on halos from the 1024 paired hydrodynamical and dark-matter-only simulations of the CAMELS $50\,h^{-1}\,\mathrm{Mpc}$ SB35 suite and samples dark matter, gas, and stellar mass fields over redshift across the full 35-dimensional $\Lambda$CDM and IllustrisTNG galaxy formation parameter space. BIND recovers dark matter, gas, and stellar masses at the percent level, reproduces azimuthally averaged profiles to $\lesssim10\%$ at all radii, and matches halo shape distributions with high fidelity. The learned parameter dependence captures the rank correlations between the generated fields and the subgrid parameters, and the field-level response to individual parameter variations is recovered in both sign and morphology. Halo mass is never supplied as conditioning, yet the baryon fraction, stellar-to-halo mass relation, inter-component scaling relations, and the joint covariance of their residuals are all reproduced. We finally show that, applied halo-by-halo to a $(50\,h^{-1}\,\mathrm{Mpc})^3$ $N$-body volume with $512^3$ particles, BIND reproduces the projected matter power spectrum suppression to the accuracy ceiling set by pasting in the hydrodynamical halos themselves, in minutes on one GPU. We release the trained BIND models and all generated halos as open-source tools. A companion paper extends BIND to thermodynamic fields and non-Gaussian weak-lensing statistics.

astro-ph.GA

BINDing the lightcone: A suite of astrophysical ray-traced weak lensing and SZ maps

Recent multiwavelength observations of galaxy group and cluster gas suggest stronger baryonic feedback than our best-calibrated hydrodynamical simulations produce, while modeling this feedback remains a primary source of uncertainty in Stage-IV weak-lensing (WL) analyses. We present a suite of ray-traced maps generated with BIND (Baryonic INpainting with Deep learning), a conditional flow-matching model that paints baryonic mass and gas thermodynamics onto the halos of dark-matter-only simulations, and which was developed in a companion paper. Applied to IllustrisTNG300-Dark and ray-traced, we generate convergence, optical depth, and Compton-$y$ maps at five source redshifts, each with $1000$ pseudo-independent realizations. We build lightcones across a 256-node Sobol sequence spanning the thirty-dimensional IllustrisTNG galaxy formation prior, with individual parameter variations and at the fiducial model. In validation, the maps match those built from the IllustrisTNG300 halos to within LSST-Y10-like precision for a range of WL statistics. Across the prior, the response to feedback exceeds Stage-IV statistical precision by more than an order of magnitude on small scales, and different statistics respond to different model sectors: galactic winds control the WL power spectrum and gas auto- and cross-spectra, while the stellar initial mass function slope and AGN parameters shape the morphological statistics (PDF, peaks, minima, and Minkowski functionals). Finally, we find that the response of statistics can be compressed into seven halo properties which linearly predict a range of WL and SZ statistics. We publicly release the maps, statistics, and model tables.

astro-ph.CO

RIGEL: Ultra-faint dwarf galaxy diversity shaped by inhomogeneous cosmic reionization

Ultra-faint dwarf galaxies (UFDs) are among the smallest and oldest galaxies in the Universe and are widely regarded as relics of cosmic reionization. To investigate how reionization quenches star formation and shapes the diversity of UFDs, we present a suite of eight cosmological zoom-in simulations of isolated UFDs with present-day halo masses of $\sim10^9\,{\rm M}_\odot$. The simulations are performed with the radiation-magnetohydrodynamic galaxy formation framework Realistic ISM modeling in Galaxy Evolution and Lifecycles (RIGEL), coupled to realistic large-scale radiation fields extracted from the THESAN reionization simulation. Despite residing in similar $z=0$ halos, the simulated galaxies span nearly two orders of magnitude in stellar mass and broadly reproduce the observed luminosities, sizes, metallicities, and stellar kinematics of Local Group UFDs. We find that reionization quenches star formation through a two-stage process. The arrival of the ionization front rapidly photoionizes the diffuse circumgalactic and intergalactic gas, suppressing further gas accretion onto the galaxy. Star formation nevertheless continues for several hundred Myr using the surviving self-shielded gas reservoir and ceases only after this gas is consumed or dispersed. Within 500 Myr after reionization, less than 40% of the initial gas mass remains in the halo, with photoevaporation constituting the dominant gas-loss channel. We further show that the halo mass at the time of reionization is a key parameter governing the subsequent evolution of UFDs. Galaxies residing in more massive halos at reionization retain gas for longer periods and undergo more extended chemical enrichment. Consequently, the halo mass at reionization strongly correlates with the final stellar mass, stellar age spread, and chemical evolution of the galaxy.

astro-ph.GA

High-spectral-resolution Observations of the [S II] Emission-line Doublet in the Filamentary Nebula Surrounding NGC 1275

We analyze new high-spectral resolution SITELLE observations (R = $\lambda/\Delta\lambda$ = 7000) of the filamentary nebula surrounding NGC 1275, central galaxy of the Perseus cluster. We present here analysis of the \sii$\lambda6716$ and \sii$\lambda6731$ emission line doublet, using its ratio to determine the electron density of the optically emitting filaments. We compare these measurements with electron densities derived from deep Chandra X-ray observations of the intra-cluster medium (ICM) to determine if any correlations in density can be found. We report the detection of a clear dichotomy between the outer filaments, displaying on average lower \sii\text{ }emission line ratio of $\sim 1.1$ and the inner filaments displaying higher ratios of $\sim 1.3$. These results indicate that most of the gaseous filaments lie close to the low-density threshold for the density measurement of $\sim 10^2\text{ cm}^{-3}$. Using radial profiles, we find that the inner filaments have a roughly constant density, whereas the ICM density decreases with radius. In the outer filaments, we observe hints of local connections between the densities of the ICM and optical filaments, but no clear correlation seems to be observed overall. We also combined these density measurements with cold molecular CO gas observations to derive a relationship between temperature, density and pressure for the multiphase environment surrounding NGC 1275. Finally, we investigated potential models to explain the observed density measurements and explored similar studies of filamentary nebula around other central galaxies of cool-core galaxy clusters.

astro-ph.GA

Abundant Heavy Black Hole Seeds from Moderate Lyman-Werner Radiation

The existence of high-redshift quasars may indicate that massive black hole seeds formed via supermassive Population III stars in atomic-cooling halos with large gas inflow rates; however, the dependence of this process on halo assembly rate and radiative background remains poorly constrained. We present a large suite of 65 high-resolution cosmological zoom-in simulations of 15 pristine halos spanning a wide range of Lyman-Werner radiation backgrounds and halo assembly histories. We introduce a novel method to estimate the final Population III stellar mass from radial gas infall profiles at the onset of runaway collapse and validate it against simulations from the literature that explicitly follow protostellar accretion with sink particles, reproducing protostellar masses to within a factor of $\sim2$. We find a clear transition in gas inflow rates between halos exposed to $J_{\rm 21} \lesssim 1$ and $J_{\rm 21} \gtrsim 10$, with the latter frequently sustaining inflow rates above the adopted threshold for supermassive star formation and producing estimated stellar masses up to $10^{5} \, M_{\odot}$. In contrast, the halo assembly timescale, $M_{\rm Halo}$/$\dot{M}_{\rm Halo}$, shows no statistically significant correlation with predicted stellar mass, despite halo assembly rates spanning $0.01$-$7 \, M_{\rm \odot} \, {\rm yr}^{-1}$. The Lyman-Werner radiation field therefore is a stronger predictor of sustained high accretion within our parameter space. Finally, a semi-analytic model applied to cosmological volumes shows that halos exposed to intermediate Lyman-Werner backgrounds ($1 \lesssim J_{\rm 21} < 10$) are orders of magnitude more common than those in the high-$J_{\rm 21}$ tail. If sustained high accretion extends into this intermediate regime, heavy black hole seeds may form in substantially more common environments than required by classical direct-collapse scenarios.

astro-ph.GA

Evaluating the flexibility of the MillenniumTNG galaxy formation model with multi-zoom re-simulations

In this study we introduce a new simulation campaign designed to understand how parameters that control star-formation and AGN feedback processes in cosmological hydrodynamical simulations impact observables such as the galaxy stellar-mass function (GSMF) and the gas fractions in large dark matter halos. These simulations are zoom-ins to halos selected from the MillenniumTNG (MTNG) simulation, and are run employing a novel multi-zoom approach which simultaneously re-simulates several sub-regions of a given large volume at a higher resolution than the background, thus reducing computational cost and imbalances in parallelization. We measure the GSMF and gas-fractions in halos for each of the re-simulations, and train Gaussian-process emulators on these quantities. The resulting emulators predict the GSMF and gas-fractions in halos with $\sim0.1\,\mathrm{dex}$ and $\sim 10\%$ precision respectively. Using the emulators we can simultaneously fit recent measurements of both quantities, in particular the lower gas fractions now observed even for comparatively massive clusters. Interestingly, we find a combination of parameters of the MTNG galaxy formation model that provides a qualitatively good fit to both the measured GSMF and gas fractions. This combination of parameters differs from the fiducial one mainly by requiring that stellar-feedback is significantly less energetic, and that kinetic AGN feedback events are significantly more energetic and rare. This finding implies that the MTNG model can be consistent with scenarios of strong feedback that remove large amounts of gas from groups and clusters, albeit we caution that we have not extensively examined the effect of these new parameters on many quantities for which MTNG made successful predictions.

astro-ph.GA

Illuminating M82: Simulating X-ray Emission from Galactic Winds in a Starburst Galaxy

We generate mock X-ray observations from a suite of idealized high-resolution ($\sim 4$ pc), tall-box ($\sim 2 \times 2 \times 8$ kpc$^3$) simulations of star formation driven galactic winds in an M82-like system, varying the spatial resolution as well as the strength and distribution of supernova (SN) energy injection. We compare our mock X-ray observations with deep Chandra observations of the hot plasma around M82. While the simulated total X-ray luminosity, $L_X$, increases with resolution and when SNe feedback is spatially distributed, even in the best case scenario, our simulated $L_X$ is a factor of $\sim 50-100$ lower than observed and the surface brightness profiles of X-ray emission, $S_X(z)$, fall off too quickly with distance from the galaxy. Past results were able to reproduce these observables and we discuss potential simulation differences that could explain this discrepancy. We make the first comparison of the X-ray spectrum of our simulations to observations and find that our simulated spectrum is too soft, with a deficit of hard X-ray photons at $\gtrsim 1$ keV. We discuss how physical processes missing from our simulations and prior work (e.g., thermal conduction and cosmic rays) could help resolve this discrepancy.

astro-ph.GA

Learning the Universe with PRFM-vol: Introducing a new subgrid model for star formation in cosmological simulations

We introduce PRFM-vol, a new subgrid model for star formation in cosmological simulations that aims to increase the physical realism of cosmological simulations by leveraging results obtained with focused ISM simulations. We deploy a modified effective equation of state and calculate the star formation rate for each gas cell as a function of the ambient densities of gas, dark matter, and stars, based on the pressure-regulated feedback-modulated (PRFM) theory of star formation. Test simulations of our model in isolated galaxies show that we match PRFM predictions and TIGRESS scaling relations remarkably well, provided sufficiently high resolution is available. In particular, we are able to clearly demonstrate the impact of the stellar potential on the star formation rate, thereby retaining an important prediction of PRFM. We then apply our new model to cosmological multizoom simulations and find, compared to our previous TIGRESS/Schmidt model, a significant increase in the stellar scale heights and a slight increase in stellar mass. We demonstrate that modifying the effective equation of state significantly affects the morphology of simulated galaxies. Pronounced stellar clumps appear if the effective pressure at low hydrogen number densities is low, and disappear for higher pressure. We show that the formation of clumps is a result of Toomre instabilities, and conclude that simulated galaxy morphologies can be used to constrain effective equation of state models. Overall, our results establish PRFM-vol as a new self-consistent, physics-motivated subgrid model for star formation in high-resolution cosmological simulations.

astro-ph.GA

Learning the Universe: Constrained simulations of the Coma galaxy cluster -- I. Radial X-ray and Compton-y signatures

We present a suite of 50 high-fidelity simulations of Coma cluster analogues constructed from BORG/MANTICORE constrained initial conditions and evolved with the IllustrisTNG galaxy formation model. Regions predicted to form massive clusters comparable to Coma in mass and environment are selected and followed through cosmic time, producing realistic galaxy populations and intracluster medium properties. The ensemble captures both cosmic variance and uncertainties in the local initial conditions, providing a statistically robust framework for interpreting Coma in a cosmological context. We focus on direct comparisons with observed thermodynamical profiles of the intracluster medium. Specifically, we extract X-ray surface brightness profiles from the simulated clusters and confront them with measurements from eROSITA, as well as compute the thermal Sunyaev--Zel'dovich effect via integrated Compton-$y$ profiles for comparison with Planck satellite data. The simulations reproduce the broad shape and normalisation of both observables, while also highlighting the range of scatter expected from environmental and assembly history differences. This enables us to assess how feedback processes, merger activity, and large-scale environment shape observable cluster properties. Our results demonstrate that combining constrained cosmological initial conditions with state-of-the-art galaxy formation physics provides an effective strategy for generating targeted, observation-driven analogues of specific clusters. The resulting dataset offers a valuable resource for testing models of intracluster medium physics, calibrating scaling relations, and interpreting upcoming joint X-ray and Sunyaev--Zel'dovich observations of nearby massive clusters.

astro-ph.CO

Learning the Universe at High Redshifts: Impact of Accretion Modeling on Early Black Hole Growth

JWST discoveries of the earliest ($z \gtrsim 9$) supermassive black holes (BHs, $M_\bullet \gtrsim 10^6\,\rm{M}_\odot$) challenge the BH seeding and accretion models of most cosmological simulations. In this work, we compare early BH growth arising from three different accretion prescriptions characterized by distinct scalings between the accretion rate ($\dot{M}_{\rm \bullet}$) and the BH mass ($M_{\rm \bullet}$): the commonly used Bondi-Hoyle model ($\dot{M}_{\rm \bullet}\propto M_{\rm \bullet}^2$), and two free-fall models with shallower scalings ($\dot{M}_{\rm \bullet}\propto M_{\rm \bullet}^{1/2}$ and $M_{\rm \bullet}$). Bondi accretion tends to produce stronger runaway growth than the free-fall models when using heavy ($\sim10^5\,\rm{M}_\odot$) seeds in extreme environments owing to the steeper $M_\bullet$ scaling, but its sensitivity to the local gas sound speed makes it more susceptible to suppression from temperature increases due to AGN and stellar feedback. The free-fall models tend to produce stronger growth for lower-mass seeds ($\sim10^{3-4}\,\rm{M}_\odot$) in moderate environments as they are less dependent on the BH's mass to accrete effectively, however in this regime BH growth remains negligible for all accretion models in the presence of fiducial stellar feedback. Enhancing early BH growth via many BH-BH mergers disproportionately enhances subsequent accretion-driven growth for Bondi due to the steeper $M_{\rm \bullet}$ dependence. Our simulations can thus assemble BHs with masses of $\sim10^6-10^7~M_{\odot}$ at $z\gtrsim9$, as inferred by JWST, under two circumstances: 1) abundant heavy-seed formation that drives BH-BH mergers, or 2) Bondi accretion with weak feedback.

astro-ph.GA

AGN Line-Intensity Mapping: A Probe of Faint Black Holes at Cosmic Noon

We propose line-intensity mapping (LIM) as a new probe of active galactic nuclei (AGN). By cross-correlating [Ne V] intensity maps with galaxy redshift surveys, we show that the cumulative AGN line emission can be detected even when individual sources are below the detection threshold. The 97.1 eV ionization potential of [Ne V] makes it an essentially uncontaminated tracer of AGN activity, arising from the narrow line region which is accessible even in heavily obscured AGN. We forecast signal-to-noise ratios using a Fisher matrix formalism for two hypothetical future instruments: a CDIM-like instrument targeting [Ne V] $\lambda 3426$ and a PRIMA-like instrument optimized for LIM targeting [Ne V] $14.3 \mu$m. For the CDIM-like case we find strong constraints on the product of the mean AGN intensity and bias, $S_{\rm NeV} b_{\rm NeV}$, across $z=2-3$, with redshift-space distortions enabling individual constraints on $S_{\rm NeV}$ and $b_{\rm NeV}$. The LIM signal retains sensitivity to AGN below the $5\sigma$ direct detection threshold, which at $z=3$ corresponds to $L_{\rm bol} \sim 5\times10^{43}$ erg s$^{-1}$ and coincides with the faint end of existing luminosity function measurements. Roughly 10% of the total signal originates from below this threshold, with the sub-threshold population detectable at $S/N=9-4$ across $z=2-3$ (for $S_{\rm NeV} b_{\rm NeV}$). The PRIMA-like instrument achieves slightly lower signal-to-noise but provides a complementary probe of the AGN population due to the insensitivity of the $14.3 \mu$m line to dust attenuation. AGN LIM can potentially be applied to several scientific problems including tracing the total AGN emissivity history, constraining the black hole-halo connection at faint luminosities, and discriminating between supermassive black hole seeding mechanisms.

astro-ph.CO

Ceci n'est pas une Couche de M\'elange: The Meaning of Resolved Turbulent Radiative Mixing

Turbulent Radiative Mixing Layers (TRMLs) are of fundamental importance to the transport of energy and momentum in multi-phase, astrophysical fluids. We use measurements of the "micro" and "macro" properties of these layers in high-resolution \texttt{AthenaK} simulations to investigate when their properties can be considered \textit{well}-resolved. In particular, we demonstrate that the previously noticed resolution independence of total cooling, $\dot{E}_{\rm cool}$, in these simulations is due to a remarkable, and perhaps fortuitous, cancellation of the countervailing effects of numerical dissipation and numerical viscosity. This calls into question the degree to which we can trust the results of these experiments, as there is no physical picture that explains this cancellation. We also demonstrate that in order to correctly resolve the phase structure in these layers, important for accurate predictions of their observable properties, one must resolve the scale on which turbulent diffusion acts on time-scales comparable to the cooling time. This "turbulent Field length", $\lambda_{\rm F,turb}$, is where the eddy turnover time is equal to the cooling time ($t_{\rm eddy}(\lambda_{\rm F,turb}) = t_{\rm cool}$). We demonstrate that resolving this scale results in converged phase-structure and spatially resolved transitions in the gas phases.

astro-ph.GA

The Origin of Da Scaling: Suppressed Cooling in Fast-Cooling Mixing Layers

In numerical experiments simulating Turbulent Radiative Mixing Layers (TRMLs) it is observed that as the cooling time in the mixed gas, $t_{\rm cool}$, becomes very short compared to the dynamical time of the turbulence, $t_{\rm eddy}/t_{\rm cool} \gg 1$, there is a change in the scaling behavior of the total energy radiated in the TRML as a function of this ratio, also known as the Damk\"{o}hler number, ${\rm Da} \equiv t_{\rm eddy}/t_{\rm cool}$, from $\dot{E}_{\rm cool} \propto {\rm Da}^{1/2}$ to $\dot{E}_{\rm cool} \propto {\rm Da}^{1/4}$. The latter, so-called "fast-cooling," regime is of particular interest as many astrophysical mixing layers lie in this regime. We demonstrate that the origin of this change is the suppression of turbulent folding of the surface by the ram-pressure of the inflowing gas, which becomes much greater than the turbulent pressure in this regime. We present an argument that reproduces the $\dot{E}_{\rm cool} \propto {\rm Da}^{1/4}$ behavior by appealing to the suppression of the fractal structure of the interface by the ram-pressure of the inflowing gas.

astro-ph.GA

How High-Specific-Energy Winds Regulate the Circumgalactic Medium of Dwarf Galaxies

We investigate the role of ejective and preventive feedback in $\mathrm{\sim10^{10}-10^{11}\,M_\odot}$ dwarf halos using cosmological zoom-in simulations. These simulations use adaptive mesh refinement to capture high-specific-energy outflows, together with an implementation of discrete supernovae (SNe). We show that episodic, SNe-driven shock heating sustains the circumgalactic medium (CGM) at $\mathrm{\sim T_{vir}}$. This process also increases the ratio $\mathrm{t_{cool}/t_{ff} > 10}$ in the outer CGM and intergalactic medium (IGM), placing the gas in a radiatively stable regime. Hot outflows ($\mathrm{\gtrsim10^5\, K}$) dominate the energy budget, and their high specific energy allows them to traverse the CGM, escape the halo, and heat the IGM. In contrast, warm outflows ($\mathrm{\lesssim10^5\, K}$) dominate the mass budget and are largely recycled back into the interstellar medium (ISM), where they fuel future star formation. We identify a gradual transition at $\mathrm{\sim 5\, Gyr}$ that marks a shift in the balance between ejective and preventive feedback. At early times ($\mathrm{< 5\, Gyr}$), although the CGM cooling rate dominates for a larger fraction of time, the infrequent yet powerful SNe energy injection into the CGM is able to quickly dominate the cumulative energy balance. These outflows and their high specific energy are able to 'sweep' up mass in the CGM and IGM. At late times ($\mathrm{> 5\, Gyr}$), the CGM baryon fraction is only $\mathrm{\sim0.1}$, leading to a transition toward a preventive feedback mode in which SNe maintain $\mathrm{t_{cool}/t_{ff} > 10}$ and prevent $\mathrm{\sim75\%}$ of the expected baryon accretion rate.

astro-ph.GA

ArkenstoneBH. A model for high-specific energy black hole feedback in cosmological simulations

AGN feedback is a key piece of galaxy evolution but is difficult to model due to its high specific energies, multiphase nature, and limited simulation resolutions. Arkenstone is a subgrid framework for representing multiphase flows in coarse resolution simulations that has been used to model stellar feedback driven galactic winds. It ensures the correct treatment of high specific energy feedback that would otherwise be challenging to model accurately in Lagrangian simulations. We introduce the new Arkenstone BH model, which extends the Arkenstone framework to model black hole feedback. We focus on describing the first piece of this framework, which follows the hot, high specific energy phase of these outflows. The second piece, which treats their multiphase structure with a scheme for modeling unresolved cold clouds, will be implemented and described in a later paper. We present Arkenstone BH in simulations of an isolated galaxy to demonstrate the framework and its ability to capture high specific energy feedback that interacts only weakly with cold, dense gas. We show how these energetic outflows suppress star formation in our isolated galaxy by counteracting the inflow of gas from the circumgalactic medium into the interstellar medium. This work is part of the "Learning the Universe" collaboration, which aims to understand the Universe's underlying physics and initial conditions.

astro-ph.GA

Resolving the Unresolved Galactic Winds in Multi-phase Models. I. Methodology and Application

Galactic winds shape galaxy evolution; however, the outflowing gas is complex: it consists of multiple ionization phases, and its properties vary spatially. Therefore, methods that combine high-fidelity observations with state-of-the-art galactic-wind models are limited. Here we investigate methods for fitting the column density profiles derived from high-quality outflow observations with the multiphase, multiscale wind model from Fielding & Bryan 2022. We identify three key outflow parameters: the initial hot-phase mass-loading factor ($\eta_\text{ M,hot,0}$), the initial cool-phase mass-loading factor ($\eta_\text{ M,cool,0}$), and the initial cool-cloud mass. We obtain good fits for most galaxies, with tight constraints on $\eta_\text{ M,cool,0}$ and moderate constraints on the other two parameters. We find the inferred $\eta_\text{ M,cool,0}$ and $\eta_\text{ M,hot,0}$ are mostly of order unity, with significant scatter. The constraints on $\eta_\text{ M,hot,0}$ suggest that the interaction between the cool and hot phases allows us to indirectly constrain the properties of the hot wind from cool-outflow observations. The model also predicts various radial trends. First, for all galaxies, the cool-phase outflow velocity increases between $1-2$ times of the half-light radius, then reaches a plateau. Second, most galaxies exhibit increasing $\eta_\text{ M,cool}$ and decreasing $\eta_\text{ M,hot}$ with radius, with a few showing the reverse trends. These results are effective, model-conditional constraints, and are consistent with other recent multiphase simulations and observations. This highlights that the velocity-radius mapping encoded in UV absorption profiles enables recovery of outflow spatial structures from spatially integrated spectra. Our method paves the way for future broad parameter studies and guides updates of outflow simulations in future work.

astro-ph.GA

Probing the Hot Gaseous Halos of Milky Way-like Galaxies in the TNG50 simulation

The origin and structure of the hot ($T\gtrsim10^6$K) gaseous halo around Milky Way (MW)-mass galaxies provide a critical test for galaxy formation models. We perform a comprehensive comparison for a sample of MW analogues from the TNG50 cosmological simulation by generating synthetic soft X-ray emission and O VII/O VIII absorption lines, viewed from both internal (Solar) and external perspectives. The simulated halos successfully reproduce the observed global soft X-ray luminosity, inner-halo X-ray surface brightness, emission measure, and O VII absorption strength. However, two interconnected discrepancies are identified. First, the azimuthally averaged X-ray surface brightness profile from external viewpoints declines too steeply with radius compared to the extended emission detected in eROSITA stacking of SDSS galaxies, falling below the observations by up to $\sim 1$ dex at $R \gtrsim 100$ kpc. Second, the halos systematically underproduce O VIII absorption, with a median equivalent width $\sim 65\%$ lower than that observed in the Galactic halo, pointing to a deficit of hotter-phase gas at $T\sim(1.6-3.2)\times10^6$ K. These findings indicate that the simulated hot halos are too spatially compact and lack a hotter gas phase, suggesting that the TNG50 feedback model, while generating hot gas, deposits energy too centrally and too vigorously to sustain a gently extended, multi-phase corona.

astro-ph.GA

The Thermodynamic and Kinematic Evolution of Circumgalactic Gas around $z=1$ in the IllustrisTNG model

The circumgalactic medium (CGM) is known to contain multiphase gas in various stages of evolution and interaction with the galaxy. In order to characterize its detailed behavior on short timescales, we use a subregion of the TNG100 cosmological simulation to study the evolution of the $z=1$ CGM around six galaxies in $10^{11.5}-10^{12}$ $M_{\odot}$ halos at a high time cadence of $\approx2$ Myr. We use Monte Carlo tracer particles to follow this CGM gas forward in time in a Lagrangian way and determine how its thermodynamic and kinematic properties change. We find that CGM gas mixes between different temperature and density phases quickly and within $\approx500$ Myr evolves into distinct cold ($T\approx10^4$ $\rm{K}$) and warm-hot ($T\approx10^{5.5}$ $\rm{K}$) phases at small and large distances from the galaxy, respectively, regardless of its initial ($z=1$) halo-centric radius. This is largely driven by feedback from the galaxy, which heats and ejects cold gas that had previously cooled and accreted toward and occasionally into the galaxy from the outer CGM. We see signatures of this process in autocorrelations of kinematic quantities, which take $\approx400$ Myr to fully decorrelate from their initial values, suggesting a timescale over which feedback disrupts and reprocesses CGM gas. We also examine gas in narrow temperature and density ranges associated with commonly observed ions and find that gas that is O VI-like stays in its phase for hundreds of Myr longer than gas that is Mg II-like or C IV-like, suggesting that CGM observations of different species could probe gas in different evolutionary states, even if the gas is cospatial.

astro-ph.GA