arXiv ScienceSearch

arXiv subjects

Felipe Avila

Publications and source records attributed to Felipe Avila.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

First tomographic measurements of the angular clustering and bias of photometric quasars from S-PLUS

We investigate the quasar clustering in the QuCatS photometric catalog, constructed from the fourth data release of the Southern Photometric Local Universe Survey (S-PLUS). The quasar sample for this study consists of $23,402$ quasars, spanning the redshift interval $1.1 \leq z_{\rm phot} \leq 2.6$, which we divided into four bins for our tomographic analyses. In each bin, we measured the two-point angular correlation function and compared it with theoretical predictions for the clustering of dark matter in the flat-$\Lambda$CDM cosmological model. We then estimate the effective linear bias in each bin that best fits the data, obtaining $b_{Q}(z_{\rm eff}=1.26)=2.17^{+0.30}_{-0.35}$, $b_{Q}(z_{\rm eff}=1.63)=2.67^{+0.36}_{-0.42}$, $b_{Q}(z_{\rm eff}=2.04)=3.29^{+0.52}_{-0.62}$, and $b_{Q}(z_{\rm eff}=2.38)=4.05^{+0.71}_{-0.86}$. These measurements are consistent with previous analyses in the literature. Moreover, the evolution of the bias agrees well with the $b(z)$ parameterization proposed by \cite{laurent2017}. Our measurements constitute the first cosmological study of the tomographic clustering of photometric quasars provided by the S-PLUS dataset, contributing to the mapping of the evolution of linear bias and paving the way for future analyses of data releases with larger datasets. In addition, our study also serves as a consistency test for the calibration procedure of the photometric redshift probability distributions of the quasars in the QuCatS catalog.

astro-ph.CO

Testing Scale-Dependent Suppression of Structure Growth in the Linear Regime

We investigate recent reports of a suppression in the growth rate of cosmic structures inferred from analyses of the $[f\sigma_8](z)$ dataset. To address this issue, we explore the hypothesis that the evolution of matter clustering is more accurately described within the framework of scale-dependent modified gravity. We perform a joint analysis of $[f\sigma_8](z)$, cosmic chronometer $H(z)$ measurements, luminosity distance data, and CMB observations using Markov Chain Monte Carlo techniques to constrain the parameters of a scale-dependent cosmological model and investigate its impact on the evolution of $[f\sigma_8](z)$. Our results indicate that the suppression of the growth rate of large-scale structures is more pronounced during the matter-dominated era than in the dark-energy-dominated epoch. We find evidence for scale-dependent growth at a statistical significance of $2.2\, \sigma$. In addition, we constrain the $S_8$ parameter and find it to be consistent with the value inferred from the CMB observations of the Planck Collaboration. Overall, our analysis shows that $k$-dependent growth models provide a viable explanation for the observed clustering of matter without exacerbating the current cosmological tensions.

astro-ph.CO

Accessing the homogeneity scale with 21 cm intensity mapping surveys

The homogeneity scale, $R_{\rm H}$, offers a fundamental test of the Cosmological Principle, yet it has not yet been measured with 21cm intensity mapping surveys. A key limitation for such a measurement is the telescope beam, which artificially smooths the observed signal. We quantify this effect using the two-point correlation function and the correlation dimension, $\mathcal{D}_2(r)$, to model how beam convolution suppresses intrinsic clustering. For any given redshift $z$, we identify a maximum beam width, $\sigma_{\rm max}(z)$, beyond which the homogeneity scale cannot be recovered. This limit defines an inaccessible region in the $\sigma \times z$ parameter space, where $R_{\rm H}$ is erased by beam smoothing. Applying this framework to several current and upcoming radio telescopes, we assess their ability to probe $R_{\rm H}$. Our results provide the first quantitative forecast of the instrumental requirements for measuring the cosmic homogeneity scale with 21cm IM, and establish a theoretical basis for future observational applications.

astro-ph.CO

The homogeneity scale in the Local Universe: model-independent estimate from S-PLUS DR4 blue galaxies

We present a model-independent estimate of the angular homogeneity scale in the Local Universe by analysing data from the Southern Photometric Local Universe Survey (S-PLUS). Two complementary estimators are employed: (i) a parametric approach fitting the power-law of the two-point angular correlation function, which yields the homogeneity scale $\theta_H = 9.01_{-3.61}^{+8.43}\;{\rm deg}$; and (ii) a non-parametric fractal correlation dimension method, computing $\mathcal{D}_2(\theta)$ directly from the correlation function, which results in $\theta_H = 6.28_{-4.43}^{+8.72}\;{\rm deg}$. From the mock catalogues generated with the GLASS algorithm, we find that the estimates from both methods are within $1 \sigma$ of the median values obtained by applying both methodologies to the mocks. The transition scale to homogeneity, according to the $\Lambda$CDM model, is defined for matter, i.e. $b = 1$. Measurements of this scale with observational data clearly depends on the cosmic tracer analysed, and a calibration is necessary. Our study with blue galaxies, with bias $b \simeq 1$, provides a suitable estimate for comparison. Indeed, the results obtained in both approaches are compared with the value expected in the $\Lambda$CDM model, obtaining a good concordance.

astro-ph.CO

High-redshift transverse BAO measurements with the SDSS quasar catalog

Transverse Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) measurements offer a robust geometric probe of the Universe expansion, presenting minimal dependence on fiducial cosmological models. In this work, we analyze the SDSS-DR16 quasar catalog to search for the 2D BAO signal in the unexplored redshift interval $1.5 \leq z \leq 2.0$. Performing a fine tomographic analysis in 50 thin disjoint redshift shells ($\Delta z = 0.01$), to suppress line-of-sight projection smearing, and incorporating a full analytical covariance matrix, we detect the acoustic peak in two uncorrelated redshift shells: $\theta_{\rm BAO} = 1.911^{\circ} \pm 0.062^{\circ}$ and $\theta_{\rm BAO} = 1.727^{\circ} \pm 0.081^{\circ}$ centered at $z_{\rm eff} = 1.725$ and $z_{\rm eff} = 1.775$, with statistical significances of $3.4\,\sigma$ and $3.0\,\sigma$, respectively. By introducing a dimensionless shift parameter $\alpha$ in our empirical parameterization procedure, we then obtain two scaled angular diameter distances: $D_A/r_d = 11.00 \pm 0.36$ at $z_{\rm eff}=1.725$ and $D_A/r_d = 11.96 \pm 0.56$ at $z_{\rm eff}=1.775$. Incorporating these two novel data points into a literature compilation of 16 transverse BAO measurements, we perform a flat-$\Lambda$CDM parameter estimation, obtaining $\Omega_{m,0} = 0.41 \pm 0.06$ and $h r_d = 99.3 \pm 2.0$ Mpc. Our measurements successfully bridge a significant observational gap at high redshift, which remain highly consistent with the constraints reported by the Planck and DESI collaborations, demonstrating the potential of quasar tomographic surveys for dynamical dark energy studies.

astro-ph.CO

Updated Cosmological Constraints from 2D BAO Measurements: A New Compilation and Comparison with DESI DR2

We investigate and update observational constraints on cosmological parameters within the $\Lambda$CDM and dynamical dark energy frameworks, using a new compilation of the transverse (or 2D) BAO data, measurements that provide a relatively model-independent estimate of the BAO angular scale at a given redshift. Firstly, we assess the consistency of this compilation with CMB-Planck data and recent BAO results from the DESI collaboration. After confirming minimal tension with CMB data, we perform a series of joint analyses combining CMB data with the 2D~BAO compilation, as well as with several recent Type Ia supernova (SNIa) samples. In all cases, we compare the constraining power of the 2D~BAO data with that of DESI~DR2 data (3D~BAO). Our results indicate that combining 2D~BAO with CMB and SNIa data provides observational constraints that are in agreement with those obtained using DESI~DR2 data. Although the precision of DESI~DR2 results remains higher, as expected due to the more accurate 3D measurements, the 2D~BAO compilation combined with other probes yields strong constraints. For example, in the $\Lambda$CDM context, we find (CMB + 2D~BAO): $H_0 = 68.16^{+0.41}_{-0.37} \,\,\, \text{km s}^{-1}\,\text{Mpc}^{-1}$ and $\Sigma m_{\nu} < 0.081~\mathrm{eV}$ (95\%~CL). These results are consistent with analogous analyses using DESI~DR2. Several other cases are investigated and discussed in the main text. Our results show that this new 2D~BAO compilation is robust and delivers meaningful cosmological constraints. Parameters from 2D~BAO alone agree with CMB-only results, with no significant tension. Overall, 2D and 3D BAO provide consistent and complementary information when combined with other probes.

astro-ph.CO

Probing the Cosmic Distance Duality Relation via Non-Parametric Reconstruction for High Redshifts

We test the validity of the cosmic distance duality relation (CDDR) by combining angular diameter distance and luminosity distance measurements from recent cosmological observations. For the angular diameter distance, we use data from transverse baryon acoustic oscillations and galaxy clusters. On the other hand, the luminosity distance is obtained from Type Ia supernovae in the Pantheon+ sample and from quasar catalogs. To reduce the large dispersion in quasar luminosity distances, we apply a selection criterion based on their deviation from the $\Lambda$CDM model and implement a binning procedure to suppress statistical noise. We reconstruct the CDDR using Gaussian Processes, a non-parametric supervised machine learning method. Our results show no significant deviation from the CDDR within the $2\sigma$ confidence level across the redshift range explored, supporting its validity even at high redshifts.

astro-ph.CO

Is $\omega_0 \omega_a$CDM a good model for the clumpy Universe?

The DESI collaboration just obtained a set of precise BAO measurements, that combined with CMB and SNIa datasets show that the $\omega_0 \omega_a$CDM model is preferred over $\Lambda$CDM, at more than $4\,\sigma$, to describe the dynamics of the expanding Universe. This raises the question whether this model also suitably describes the clumpy Universe. Also lately, detailed analyses of diverse cosmic tracers resulted in a new dataset of measurements of an observable from the clumpy Universe: $\sigma_8(z)$, spanning a high-redshift data $z \in [0.013, 3.8]$. In this work we use this dataset of 15 $\sigma_8(z_i)$ measurements to study the viability of the $\omega_0 \omega_a$CDM cosmological model to explain the clustered Universe. Our analyses compare the $\omega_0 \omega_a$CDM model with the $\sigma_8(z)$ function reconstructed from the data points using Gaussian Process. Moreover, we perform a similar evaluation of the $\Lambda$CDM model considering Planck and~DESI best-fit parameters. In addition, we implemented robustness tests regarding Gaussian Process reconstruction to support our results.

astro-ph.CO

Revisiting the temperature evolution law of the CMB with gaussian processes

In this work, we perform a statistical inference of the classical background law governing the evolution of the temperature of the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB), given by $T_{\rm CMB}(z) = T_0(1 + z)$. To this end, we employ Gaussian Process (GP) regression techniques to reconstruct the temperature evolution based on two observational datasets: (i) CMB-Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) cluster measurements and (ii) CMB-interstellar medium (ISM) interaction data. Our analysis reveals interesting results that may suggest potential deviations from the standard temperature-redshift relation, particularly at low redshifts ($z < 0.5$), where discrepancies up to $\sim$2$\sigma$ are observed. Additionally, we identify a mild but noteworthy tension, also at the $\sim$2$\sigma$ level, between our GP inferred value of the present-day CMB temperature, $T_{\rm CMB}(z=0)$, and the precise direct measurement from the COBE/FIRAS experiment. We also explore possible phenomenological implications of our findings, including interpretations associated with possible variations in fundamental constants, such as the fine-structure constant $\alpha$, which could provide a physical explanation for the observed deviations at low redshift.

astro-ph.CO

Viability of general relativity and modified gravity cosmologies using high-redshift cosmic probes

Several models based on General Relativity and Modified Gravity aim to reproduce the observed universe with precision comparable to the flat-$\Lambda$CDM cosmological model. In this study, we investigate the consistency of some of these models with current high-redshift cosmic data, assessing their ability to simultaneously describe both the background expansion and matter clustering, using measurements of the Hubble parameter $H(z)$, the luminosity distance $D_L(z)$, and the growth rate of structures $[f\sigma_8](z)$ through parametric and non-parametric methods. Our results indicate that background observables alone offer limited capacity to distinguish between models, while the inclusion of growth of structures data proves useful in revealing deviations, even if small. An $F(Q)$ model, the non-flat $\Lambda$CDM and the $\omega$CDM emerge as alternatives well supported by data, closely matching the growth data and showing performance comparable to $\Lambda$CDM, as revealed by the Akaike Information Criterion. In contrast, $F(R)$ models are strongly disfavored compared to $\Lambda$CDM and $F(Q)$. However, according to the Bayesian Information Criterion, $\Lambda$CDM remains the preferred model among the models analysed. These analyses illustrate the usefulness of both parametric and non-parametric approaches to explore the observational viability of alternative cosmological models.

astro-ph.CO

Probing cosmic isotropy: Hubble constant and matter density large-angle variations with the Pantheon+SH0ES data

In this study we investigate potential large-angle anisotropies in the angular distribution of the cosmological parameters $H_0$ (the Hubble constant) and $\Omega_m$ (the matter density) in the flat-$\Lambda$CDM framework, using the Pantheon+SH0ES supernovae catalog. For this we perform a directional analysis by dividing the celestial sphere into a set of directions, and estimate the best-fit cosmological parameters across the sky using a MCMC approach. Our results show a dominant dipolar pattern for both parameters in study, suggesting a preferred axis in the universe expansion and in the distribution of matter. However, we also found that for $z \gtrsim 0.015$, this dipolar behavior is not statistically significant, confirming the expectation -- in the $\Lambda$CDM scenario -- of an isotropic expansion and a uniform angular distribution of matter (both results at $1\,\sigma$ confidence level). Nevertheless, for nearby supernovae, at distances $\lesssim 60$ Mpc or $z \lesssim 0.015$, the peculiar velocities introduce a highly significant dipole in the angular distribution of $H_0$. Furthermore, we perform various robustness tests that support our findings, and consistency tests of our methodology.

astro-ph.CO

Probing large-scale structures with the two-point function and the power spectrum: insights into cosmic clustering evolution

Understanding the large-scale structure of the Universe requires analyses of cosmic clustering and its evolution over time. In this work, we investigate the clustering properties of SDSS blue galaxies, which are excellent tracers of dark matter, along two distinct epochs of the Universe, utilizing estimators like the two-point angular correlation function (2PACF), the angular power spectra, among others. Considering a model-independent approach, we perform analyses in two disjoint redshift shells, $0 \leq z < 0.06$ and $0.06 \leq z < 0.12$, to investigate the distribution of large cosmic structures. Using Bayesian inference methods, we constrain the parameter that quantifies the galaxy clustering in the 2PACF, enabling us to perform comparisons among different regions on the sky and between different epochs in the Universe regarding the gravitational action on matter structures. Our analyses complement previous efforts to map large-scale structures in the Local Universe. In addition, this study reveals differences regarding the clustering of large cosmic structures comparing two epochs of the Universe, analyses done with diverse estimators. Results reveal, clearly, distinct evolutionary signatures between the two redshift shells. Moreover, we had the opportunity to test the concordance cosmological model under extreme conditions in the highly non-linear Local Universe, computing the amplitude of the angular power spectrum at very small scales. Ultimately, all our analyses serve as a set of consistency tests of the concordance cosmological model, the $\Lambda$CDM.

astro-ph.CO

Dipolar fluence distribution of statistically isotropic FERMI gamma-ray bursts

We investigated the large-angle distribution of the gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) from the updated FERMI/GBM catalog to probe the statistical isotropy of these astrophysical transient events. We also studied the angular distribution of the GRB fluence as a way to explore whether this radiative feature shows some preferred direction on the sky that suggest their origin. Our model-independent approach performed a directional analysis of the updated FERMI/GBM catalog. The statistical significance of our results is obtained by comparison with a large set of statistically isotropic samples of cosmic objects, with the same features of the FERMI data. Our analyses confirm that the angular distribution of the FERMIGRB is statistically isotropic on the celestial sphere. Moreover, analyzing the directional distribution of the FERMIGRB fluence, that is, the median GRB fluence in a set of directions that scans the celestial sphere, we found that this astrophysical property exhibits a net dipolar structure with a directional preference for latitudes near the Galactic plane. However, additional studies show that this directional preference is not correlated with the Milky Way Galactic plane, which suggests that the GRB dataset, and its fluence dipolar structure, are extra-Galactic in origin. Interestingly, the analyses of the BATSE Channel 4 fluence data, that is, those GRBs from BATSE with energy $>$ 300 keV, reveal that its dipole direction is very well aligned with the cosmic microwave background dipole.

astro-ph.HE

Measuring the matter fluctuations in the Local Universe with the ALFALFA catalog

The standard model of cosmology describes the matter fluctuations through the matter power spectrum, where $\sigma_{8} \equiv \sigma_{8,0} \equiv \sigma_{8}(z = 0)$, defined at the scale of $8 h^{-1}$ Mpc, acts as a normalisation parameter. Currently, the literature reports measurements of $\sigma_{8}$ analysing different cosmic tracers, where some of these results were obtained assuming a fiducial cosmology. In this study we measure, in a model-independent approach, the matter fluctuations in the Local Universe using HI extragalactic sources mapped by the ALFALFA survey. Our analyses allow us to test the standard cosmological model under extreme conditions in the highly non-linear Local Universe, quantifying the amplitude of the matter fluctuations there. Our work directly measures $\sigma_{8}$ using the 3-dimensional distances of the HI sources determined by the ALFALFA survey without assuming a fiducial cosmology, resulting in a robust model-independent measurement of $\sigma_{8}$. Our methodology involves the construction of suitable mock catalogues to simulate the large scale structure features observed in the data, applying the 2-point correlation function, and making use of Markov Chain Monte Carlo methods to estimate the parameters. Analysing these data we measure $\sigma_8 = 0.78 \pm 0.04$ for $h = 0.6727$, $\sigma_8 = 0.80 \pm 0.05$ for $h = 0.698$, and $\sigma_8 = 0.83 \pm 0.05$ for $h = 0.7304$. Considering the data pairs $(\sigma_8, H_0)$ from the Planck CMB and Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT) CMB-lensing analyses, our measurement agrees with them within $1\,\sigma$ confidence level. From a model-independent perspective, we find that the scale where the matter fluctuation is $1$ is $R = 7.2 \pm 1.5~\text{Mpc}$.

astro-ph.CO

Bulk Flow Motion Detection in the Local Universe with Pantheon$+$ Type Ia Supernovae

The {\em bulk flow} in the Local Universe is a collective phenomenon due to the peculiar motions of matter structures, which, instead of moving in random directions, appears to follow an approximate dipole velocity flow. We apply a directional analysis to investigate, through the Hubble-Lema\^{\i}tre diagram, the angular dependence of the Hubble constant $H_0$ of a sample of Type Ia Supernovae from the Pantheon+ catalog in the Local Universe ($0.015 \le z \le 0.06$). We perform a directional analysis that reveals a statistically significant dipole variation of $H_0$, at more than $99.9\%$ confidence level, showing that matter structures follow a dipole bulk flow motion towards $(l,b) = (326.^\circ1 \pm 11.^\circ2,27.^\circ8 \pm 11.^\circ2)$, close to the Shapley supercluster $(l_{\scalebox{0.6}{Shapley}},b_{\scalebox{0.6}{Shapley}}) = (311.^\circ5, 32.^\circ3)$, with velocity $132.14 \pm 109.3$ km s$^{-1}$ at the effective distance $102.83 \pm 10.2$~Mpc. Interestingly, the antipodal direction of this dipole points close to the Dipole Repeller structure. Our analyses confirm that the gravitational dipole system Shapley-Dipole Repeller explains well the observed bulk flow velocity field in the Local Universe. Furthermore, we performed robustness tests that support our results. Additionally, our approach provides a measurement of the Hubble constant $H_0 = 70.39 \pm 1.4$~\text{km s$^{-1}$ Mpc$^{-1}$}, at the effective distance $102.8$~Mpc, $z \simeq 0.025$. Note that this value was obtained using the first order approximation of the Hubble law because our methodology is model-independent. If one assumes, for instance, cosmography at second order with the $\Lambda$CDM value $q_0 = -0.55$, which is a model-dependent hypothesis, then $H_0 = 72.6 \pm 1.5$ km s$^{-1}$ Mpc$^{-1}$, but our results: bulk flow velocity, dipole direction and its statistical significance remain the same.

astro-ph.CO

Baryon acoustic scale at $z_{\eff} = 0.166$ with the SDSS blue galaxies

The Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) phenomenon provides a unique opportunity to establish a standard ruler at any epoch in the history of the evolving universe. The key lies in identifying a suitable cosmological tracer to conduct the measurement. In this study, we focus on quantifying the sound horizon scale of BAO in the Local Universe. Our chosen cosmological tracer is a sample of blue galaxies from the SDSS survey, positioned at the effective redshift $z_{{\eff}} = 0.166$. Utilizing Planck-CMB input values for redshift-to-distance conversion, we derive the BAO scale $s_{\scalebox{0.65}{\rm BAO}} = 100.28 ^{+10.79} _{-22.96}$ Mpc$/h$ at the 1$\sigma$ confidence level. Subsequently, we extrapolate the BAO signal scale in redshift space: $\Delta z_{\scalebox{0.6}{\rm BAO}}(z_{\rm eff}=0.166)=0.0361^{+0.00262}_ {-0.0055}$. This measurement holds the potential to discriminate among dark energy models within the Local Universe. To validate the robustness of our methodology for BAO scale measurement, we conduct three additional BAO analyses using different cosmographic approaches for distance calculation from redshifts. These tests aim to identify possible biases or systematics in our measurements of $s_{\scalebox{0.65}{\rm BAO}}$. Encouragingly, our diverse cosmographic approaches yield results in statistical agreement with the primary measurement, indicating no significant deviations. Conclusively, our study contributes with a novel determination of the BAO scale in the Local Universe, at $z_{{\eff}} = 0.166$, achieved through the analysis of the SDSS blue galaxies cosmic tracer.

astro-ph.CO

Probing cosmic isotropy in the Local Universe

This is a model-independent analysis that investigates the statistical isotropy in the Local Universe using the ALFALFA survey data ($0 < z < 0.06$). We investigate the angular distribution of HI extra-galactic sources from the ALFALFA catalogue and study whether they are compatible with the statistical isotropy hypothesis using the two-point angular correlation function (2PACF). Aware that the Local Universe is plenty of clustered structures and large voids, we compute the 2PACF with the Landy-Szalay estimator performing directional analyses to inspect 10 sky regions. We investigate these 2PACF using power-law best-fit analyses, and determine the statistical significance of the best-fit parameters for the 10 ALFALFA regions by comparison with the ones obtained through the same procedure applied to a set of mock catalogues produced under the homogeneity and isotropy hypotheses. Our conclusion is that the Local Universe, as mapped by the HI sources of the ALFALFA survey, is in agreement with the hypothesis of statistical isotropy within $2\,\sigma$ confidence level, for small and large angle analyses, with the only exception of one region -- located near the Dipole Repeller -- which appears slightly outlier ($2.4\,\sigma$). Interestingly, regarding the large angular distribution of the HI sources, we found 3 regions where the presence of cosmic voids reported in the literature left their signature in our 2PACF, suggesting projected large underdensities there, with number-density contrast $\delta \simeq -0.7$. According to the current literature these regions correspond, partially, to the sky position of the void structures known as Local Cosmic Void and Dipole Repeller.

astro-ph.CO

Reconstructing the growth index $\gamma$ with Gaussian Processes

Alternative cosmological models have been proposed to alleviate the tensions reported in the concordance cosmological model, or to explain the current accelerated phase of the universe. One way to distinguish between General Relativity and modified gravity models is using current astronomical data to measure the growth index $\gamma$, a parameter related to the growth of matter perturbations, which behaves differently in different metric theories. We propose a model independent methodology for determining $\gamma$, where our analyses combine diverse cosmological data sets, namely $\{ f(z_i) \}$, $\{ [f\sigma_8](z_i) \}$, and $\{ H(z_i) \}$, and use Gaussian Processes, a non-parametric approach suitable to reconstruct functions. This methodology is a new consistency test for $\gamma$ constant. Our results show that, for the redshift interval $0 < z < 1$, $\gamma$ is consistent with the constant value $\gamma = 0.55$, expected in General Relativity theory, within $2 \sigma$ confidence level (CL). Moreover, we find $\gamma(z=0)$ = 0.311 $\pm 0.144 $ and $\gamma(z=0) = 0.609 \pm 0.200$ for the reconstructions using the $\{ f(z_i) \}$ and $\{ [f\sigma_8](z_i) \}$ data sets, respectively, values that also agree at a 2$\sigma$ CL with $\gamma = 0.55$. Our methodology and analyses can be considered as an alternative approach in light of the current discussion in the literature that suggests a possible evidence for the growth index evolution.

astro-ph.CO