Emergence of Horndeski gravity from asymptotic safety?
There are strong motivations to modify gravity in the ultraviolet as well as the infrared. Such modifications are usually pursued independently from one another. Using the predictive power of asymptotically safe quantum gravity, we can constrain the effective-field-theory coefficients of scalar-tensor theories and thereby connect ultraviolet and infrared modifications of gravity. We focus on two non-minimal couplings, which are naturally generated in asymptotic safety and belong to the Horndeski Lagrangian only if the couplings satisfy a specific ratio. A priori, one would expect to find a negative answer to the question in our title. Surprisingly, we find that despite the constraints from asymptotic safety, this ratio can be achieved for a specific value of the cosmological constant. We interpret this as a non-trivial hint that asymptotically safe scalar-tensor theories could be free of extra propagating degrees of freedom in the infrared. We further find that the same result holds in an effective asymptotic safety scenario, where asymptotic safety is not a fundamental theory and quantum scale symmetry, the symmetry underlying asymptotic safety, only holds over an intermediate range of scales. Finally, we report novel non-trivial indications of approximate radiative stability in the aforementioned Horndeski sector for a range of coupling values, independently of any particular UV completion.