arXiv ScienceSearch

arXiv subjects

Drew Weisserman

Publications and source records attributed to Drew Weisserman.

15 recordsLinked to original sources

Night-sky emission correction techniques for high-resolution spectroscopy: Demonstration with NIRPS

Ground-based spectrographs operating in the near-infrared (NIR) regime are hampered by various absorption and emission features of Earth's atmosphere. While considerable attention has been paid to mitigating telluric absorption, correcting telluric emission features remains non-trivial and can significantly affect the observation of faint targets. We aim to develop and implement automated algorithms for sky background emission correction in the context of high-resolution spectroscopy. These empirical-based algorithms have been officially integrated into both NIRPS data reduction pipelines: NIRPS DRS and APERO DRS. Designed for flexibility, these techniques can be incorporated into the reduction workflow of any high-resolution spectrograph to improve the radial velocity (RV) performance. In our approach, a reference sky spectrum is first created by deep-stacking NIRPS sky calibration frames on a common wavelength grid and calculating the weighted median flux per pixel, separately for both the high-accuracy and high-efficiency instrument modes. This process is repeated for all spectral orders and for both the object and sky-calibration fibres: fibre A and fibre B, respectively. In this reference sky spectrum, the sky emission lines can be identified and used to construct a static library. During the data reduction process, the emission features in the library are individually scaled in terms of flux using two distinct techniques, each specific to the two DRS pipelines. Finally, they are locally subtracted from the science observations to minimise their noise contribution to the final spectrum. We find that the correction algorithms significantly improve the RV measurements obtained using both the cross-correlation function and line-by-line techniques, enabling NIRPS to achieve submetre-per-second precision in the NIR. The techniques have been successfully validated and demonstrated.

astro-ph.IM

Radial velocity detection of the TRAPPIST-1 planetary system with SPIRou and NIRPS

The TRAPPIST-1 system is well-known for its seven transiting Earth-sized exoplanets. It has been extensively studied and characterized, notably with transit timing variations (TTVs) to precisely measure the mass of the planets. Using near-infrared spectroscopic observations obtained as part of the SPIRou Legacy Survey and the NIRPS Guaranteed Time Observation programs, we aimed to verify those values through radial velocity (RV) measurements of the system. Our RV analysis reveals that the current data do not have the precision required to individually detect the TRAPPIST-1 planets. However, we confidently detect ($\Delta\ln\mathcal{Z}=7.53$, 1860:1 odds) the combined RV signature of the planets by informing their relative masses on the TTV analysis, with TRAPPIST-1 b as a proxy of the whole system. For the first time, the RV signal of the TRAPPIST-1 system is recovered: we find a RV semi-amplitude of $K_b=3.65^{+0.78}_{-0.83}$ m s$^{-1}$ corresponding to a planetary mass of $M_{p,\,b}=1.31\pm0.29$ M$_\oplus$, demonstrating that the RV measurements are consistent with the TTV model ($M_{p,\,b;\,\text{TTV}}=1.374\pm0.069$ M$_\oplus$). Additionally, the NIRPS RVs constrain the presence of giant planets beyond the snow line, excluding Saturn-mass planets out to 2.7-yr orbits and Neptune-mass objects out to 20 d. Through RV, we determined the stellar activity period to be of $3.22^{+0.22}_{-0.20}$ d. Its agreement with photometric measurements (K2 and TESS) confirms stellar rotation as the origin of the $\sim3.3$-d periodicity observed for TRAPPIST-1. We further investigated stellar activity with SPIRou polarimetric measurements, placing an upper limit on the longitudinal field ($|B_l|<40$ G, $3\sigma$). This limit is compatible with a weak multipolar large-scale magnetic geometry, as observed in some of the later-type rapidly rotating M dwarfs.

astro-ph.EP

New and Updated Rossiter-McLaughlin Measurements for Three Hot Jupiter-Hosting M Dwarfs

Evidence suggests that Kozai-Lidov high-eccentricity migration (HEM) is the dominant migration channel for short-period Giant Exoplanets around M dwarf Stars (GEMS). However, it is unlikely that all short-period GEMS form via HEM, given that most systems lack known massive companions capable of driving HEM. Characterizing the stellar obliquities of GEMS via the Rossiter-McLaughlin (RM) effect can help shed light on the dynamical histories of GEMS. We present RM effect detections for the GEMS TOI-5205 b, TIC 46432937 b, and TOI-3714 b using the Gemini-North/MAROON-X spectrograph, bringing the total number of GEMS with RM detections to five. Our systems are well-aligned, with sky-projected obliquities of $\lambda = 0 \pm 6^\circ$, $3_{-3}^{+4}$$^\circ$, and $15_{-8}^{+12}$$^\circ$, respectively, and we measure a deprojected obliquity of $\psi = 24_{-8}^{+7}$ $^\circ$ for TOI-3714. We analyze archival radial velocities, astrometry, and speckle imaging data to search for additional companions around all five known GEMS with RM detections. We find tentative evidence for a new massive companion around one of these GEMS, TOI-5293 A, in Gaia DR2+DR3 data, though further follow-up is needed for confirmation. We rule out massive companions between $\sim 1-10\textrm{ AU}$ in the remaining systems, but cannot rule out all companions capable of driving HEM. Our findings present further evidence that short-period GEMS are preferentially aligned. While current results remain consistent with both primordial alignment and HEM plus tidal damping, we offer future directions for studies to further constrain the dominant migration channel for GEMS.

astro-ph.EP

The breaking of cold traps and onset of titanium in ultra-hot Jupiter atmospheres: WASP-189b in context

Condensates are ubiquitous to all Solar System planets with significant ($>$10mbar) atmospheres. The same is true for most exoplanets with characterised atmospheres, with even ultra-hot exoplanets being able to form clouds on their cooler nightsides. One high-interest condensate is titanium, a highly refractory element that as an oxide (TiO) is a potent optical absorber long believed to be a driver of thermal inversions in highly irradiated exoplanet atmospheres. Observations have shown that some ultra-hot Jupiters have strong thermal inversions despite being significantly Ti-depleted, likely due to cold trapping, raising doubts about whether TiO is the main cause of their inverted temperature structures. Our aim was to retrieve the titanium-to-iron ratio of the dayside atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-189b to determine whether the full titanium budget is accounted for in the gas phase. We analysed thermal emission observations of WASP-189b taken with the HARPS and NIRPS spectrographs using different atmospheric retrieval prescriptions to infer the planet's atmospheric thermal structure and composition. We observed Fe and Ti signals in cross-correlation and measured a sub-solar Ti/Fe ratio for WASP-189b using both free and chemical equilibrium retrieval approaches. We find the Ti/Fe of the planetary atmosphere to be between 28% and 81% (1-$\sigma$ bounds) that of the stellar value. The slight underabundance of Ti with respect to Fe on the dayside atmosphere of WASP-189b suggests that some titanium is missing from the gas phase, potentially due to a partial nightside cold trap. In the context of the ultra-hot Jupiter population, the onset of titanium in exoplanetary atmospheres appears to occur progressively, coinciding not with when thermal inversions begin but rather when the vapourisation threshold of titanium is reached on the nightside.

astro-ph.EP

Super-Earth masses and stellar abundances from NIRPS reveal tentative evidence for water-rich formation around M dwarfs

Tracing the compositional link between terrestrial super-Earths and their host stars provides clues to their dominant formation pathway. By constraining the stellar abundances of refractory elements, we can predict the core mass fractions (CMFs) of their super-Earths. The level of agreement between this prediction and the planetary CMF derived from their masses and radii can reveal past formation processes, like mantle stripping and water-rich formation plus sequestration in the planet's core. Here, we present the first results from the Near Infrared Planet Searcher (NIRPS) GTO CMF subprogram: an intensive radial velocity campaign to refine masses and compute host stellar abundances of three hot super- Earths around M dwarfs (GJ 1132 b, GJ 1252 b, and LTT 3780 b), calculating masses of $1.69 \pm 0.15M_\oplus$, $1.54 \pm 0.18M_\oplus$, and $2.34 \pm 0.10M_\oplus$ respectively. We measure the CMFs of these and six further hot super-Earths with precise masses already available in the literature to 10-15% precision. We compare these to CMF predictions made from measuring the Fe, Mg, and Si abundances of their host stars measured from the NIRPS spectra. We find that the CMFs of these planets are smaller than expected from their host stellar abundances, to a statistically significant degree. This discrepancy is suggestive of significant reservoirs of water, and while these planets are too hot to harbor surface water, they likely have interior water mass fractions of $\sim$1%.

astro-ph.EP

TOI-4552 b: A new ultra-short period rocky world revealed by NIRPS and TESS

A particularly intriguing subclass of rocky exoplanets are the ultra-short period (USP) worlds that orbit their host stars in less than a day. These planets are particularly rare around M dwarf stars, with so far only ten that have a constrained mass and radius. We present the validation and characterization of the ultra-short period (0.3-days), Earth-sized planet TOI-4552b orbiting a nearby (27.26-pc away) M4.5V dwarf. Complementing the TESS photometry, ground-based transit observations from LCO, ExTrA and SPECULOOS validated the planetary radius and cleared the field of any contaminants. Speckle imaging with Zorro (Gemini-S) rules out false positive scenarios caused by eclipsing binary sources. Spectroscopic observations with NIRPS and HARPS were used to obtain stellar abundances, constrain the planetary mass, and, in conjunction with the transit observations, estimate the orbital parameters. TOI-4552 is a quiet star exhibiting no short-term stellar variations seen in photometric or radial velocity data that can be associated to stellar rotation. TOI-4552b ($M_p=1.83\pm0.47\,M_e$, $R_p=1.11\pm0.04\,R_e$) lies between the Earth-like and iron-rich composition tracks on the Mass-Radius diagram. The EXOPIE interior structure model, without constraints from refractory abundance ratio, yields a core mass fraction (CMF) of 0.54 and a bulk density of 7.74g/cm$^3$. Since the CMF spans a wide range due to the large uncertainty on the mass, the definitive interior composition cannot be determined with the current dataset. TOI-4552b hints as being marginally more iron-rich compared to the Earth but confirmation of its status requires additional, precise radial velocity measurements. Combined with its high emission spectroscopic metric (ESM=19.5), negligible stellar activity and short orbital period, TOI-4552b emerges as a compelling target for atmospheric and surface composition studies with JWST.

astro-ph.EP

Confirmation of the hot super-Neptune TOI-672 b with NIRPS and HARPS and Insights into the Neptunian desert around M dwarfs

The Neptunian desert is a distinct lack of Neptune-sized planets at short orbital periods, purportedly carved by photoevaporation and tidal circularization following high-eccentricity migration. Constraining these processes and how they vary across different host-star spectral types requires the detailed characterization of planets in the desert and around its boundaries. In this study, we confirm the planetary nature of a massive super-Neptune identified by TESS around the M0 dwarf TOI-672. We analyse photometry from TESS and ExTrA and precise radial velocity measurements taken with the recently commissioned Near-InfraRed Planet Searcher (NIRPS) and HARPS spectrographs. We measure the planetary orbital period, radius, and mass of 3.634 days, 5.31 +0.24 -0.26 Rearth, and 50.9 +4.5 -4.4 Mearth, respectively. Our findings place TOI-672 b within the Neptunian ridge, a pile-up of planets from 3--5 days at the Neptunian desert boundary. We then use a novel approach to determine the desert boundaries in period-radius space and instellation-radius space, and, for the first time, compare the Neptunian desert boundaries for planets orbiting FGK versus M dwarf stars. We determine that the boundary ridge shifts slightly inward from 3.3 +- 1.4 days for FGK host stars to 2.2 +- 1.0 days for M dwarf host stars; these values do not statistically significantly differ from each other, and the shift to shorter periods for M dwarf planets is smaller than theoretical photoevaporation models predict. We also find that TOI-672 b is a single-planet system within the sensitivity limits of our RV and TTV datasets.

astro-ph.EP

NIRPS tightens the mass estimate of GJ 3090 b and detects a planet near the stellar rotation period

We present an updated characterization of the planetary system orbiting the nearby M2 dwarf GJ 3090 (TOI-177; $d = 22$ pc), based on new high-precision radial velocity (RV) observations from NIRPS and HARPS. With an orbital period of 2.85 d, the transiting sub-Neptune GJ 3090 b has a mass we refine to $4.52 \pm 0.47 M_{\oplus}$, which, combined with our derived radius of $2.18 \pm 0.06 R_{\oplus}$, yields a density of $2.40^{+0.33}_{-0.30}$ g cm$^{-3}$. The combined interior structure and atmospheric constraints indicate that GJ 3090 b is a compelling water-world candidate, with a volatile-rich envelope in which water likely represents a significant fraction. We also confirm the presence of a second planet, GJ 3090 c, a sub-Neptune with a 15.9 d orbit and a minimum mass of $10.0 \pm 1.3 M_{\oplus}$, which does not transit. Despite its proximity to the star's 18 d rotation period, our joint analysis using a multidimensional Gaussian process (GP) model that incorporates TESS photometry and differential stellar temperature measurements distinguishes this planetary signal from activity-induced variability. In addition, we place new constraints on a non-transiting planet candidate with a period of 12.7 d, suggested in earlier RV analyses. This candidate remains a compelling target for future monitoring. These results highlight the crucial role of multidimensional GP modelling in disentangling planetary signals from stellar activity, enabling the detection of a planet near the stellar rotation period that could have remained undetected with traditional approaches.

astro-ph.EP

Reanalysis of the eclipses of LHS 1140 c: No evidence of an atmosphere and implications for the internal structure of the planet

We present the reanalysis of three 15 micron JWST/MIRI secondary eclipses of LHS 1140 c, a warm super-Earth (R$_{\rm{p}}$ = 1.272 R$_{\oplus}$) in a 3.78-day orbit around an M4.5 dwarf. We present a novel method for data reduction that leverages spatial derivatives of the point-spread function and compare it to widely used aperture photometry. Both methods yield eclipse depth consistent within 1 sigma of the values reported in the literature. We measure an eclipse depth of 271$^{+31}_{-30}$ ppm corresponding to a brightness temperature of $T_B=595^{+33}_{-34}$ K, consistent with a bare rock. The secondary eclipse occurs 4.1$\pm$0.8 minutes before the circular-orbit predicted time. We explore the implications of our results on the internal structure of LHS 1140 c, the orbital architecture of the system and the possibility of future observations with JWST. We find a core-mass fraction (CMF) informed by the stellar abundances of refractory elements of 0.34$\pm$0.11, inflated compared to the CMF from radius and mass measurements, suggesting the possible presence of bulk volatiles in the interior.

astro-ph.EP

Atmospheric composition and circulation of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-121b with joint NIRPS, HARPS and CRIRES+ transit spectroscopy

Ultra-hot Jupiters like WASP-121b provide unique laboratories for studying atmospheric chemistry and dynamics under extreme irradiation. Constraining their composition and circulation is key to tracing planet formation pathways. We present a comprehensive characterisation of WASP-121b using high-resolution transit spectroscopy from HARPS, NIRPS, and CRIRES+ across nine transits, complemented by five TESS sectors, two EulerCam light curves simultaneous with HARPS/NIRPS, and an extensive RV dataset refining orbital parameters. Cross-correlation detects Fe, CO, and V with SNRs of 5.8, 5.0, and 4.7, respectively. Retrieval analysis constrains H$_2$O to $-6.52^{+0.49}_{-0.68}$ dex, though its signal might be muted by the H$^-$ continuum. We measure volatile/refractory ratios, key to uncover planetary chemistry, evolution, and formation. Retrieved values align with solar composition in chemical equilibrium, suggesting minimal disequilibrium chemistry at the probed pressures (around $10^{-4}$-$10^{-3}$ bar). We update WASP-121b's orbital parameters analysing its largest RV dataset to date. Comparing orbital velocities from RVs and atmospheric retrieval reveals a non-zero circulation offset, $\mathrm{\Delta K}_{\mathrm{p}} = -15 \pm 3 \ \mathrm{km}\mathrm{s}^{-1}$ (assuming $\mathrm{M}_{\star} = 1.38 \pm 0.02 \ \mathrm{M}_{\odot}$), consistent with drag-free or weak-drag 3D GCM predictions, though sensitive to stellar mass. These results provide new constraints on WASP-121b's thermal structure, dynamics, and chemistry, underscoring the power of multi-instrument and multi-wavelength high-resolution spectroscopy to probe exoplanet atmospheres.

astro-ph.EP

Aligned Stellar Obliquities for Two Hot Jupiter-hosting M Dwarfs Revealed by MAROON-X: Implications for Hot Jupiter Formation

Hot Jupiters (HJs) are $2-3\times$ less common around early M dwarfs than around AFGK stars, suggesting that HJs may form and/or migrate via distinct pathways around different types of stars. One source of insight into HJ formation mechanisms is to trace their dynamical histories through measurements of host stellar obliquities via the Rossiter-McLaughlin (RM) effect. Here we present measurements of the RM effect for the HJs TOI-3714 b and TOI-5293 A b using the Gemini-North/MAROON-X spectrograph. Our measurements represent just the second and third hot Jupiters around M dwarfs (HJMD) with a detection of the RM effect. We find that both systems are well-aligned with sky-projected obliquities of $\lambda = 21^{+14}_{-11}$$\mathrm{^{\circ}}$ and $-12^{+19}_{-14}$$\mathrm{^{\circ}}$ and deprojected obliquities of $\psi = 26^{+11}_{-10}$$\mathrm{^{\circ}}$ and $24^{+11}_{-10}$$\mathrm{^{\circ}}$ for TOI-3714 and TOI-5293 A, respectively. Both stars are in wide binary systems. We refine the stellar parameters by decontaminating their unresolved $K_s$-band photometry and constrain the binary orbits using Gaia DR3 astrometry. We find that the minimum mutual inclination of the planet and binary companion in the TOI-5293 system is sufficiently large to drive Kozai-Lidov (KL) migration while the result for TOI-3714 is inconclusive. We present a population-level analysis of HJs around AFGK versus early M dwarfs and argue that KL migration is more efficient around the latter, which is expected to produce misaligned stellar obliquities in HJMD systems in the absence of efficient tidal damping. The emerging population of well-aligned HJMD hosts supports the expectation that M dwarfs, with their deep convective envelopes, do efficiently dampen misaligned obliquities.

astro-ph.EP

Hydride ion continuum hides absorption signatures in the NIRPS near-infrared transmission spectrum of the ultra-hot gas giant WASP-189b

Ultra-hot Jupiters showcase extreme atmospheric conditions, including molecular dissociation, ionisation, and significant day-to-night temperature contrasts. Their close proximity to host stars subjects them to intense stellar irradiation, driving high temperatures where hydride ions (H$^-$) significantly contribute to opacity, potentially obscuring metal features in near-infrared transmission spectra. We investigate the atmosphere of WASP-189b, targeting atomic, ionic, and molecular species (H, He, Fe, Ti, V, Mn, Na, Mg, Ca, Cr, Ni, Y, Ba, Sc, Fe$^+$, Ti$^+$, TiO, H$_2$O, CO, and OH), focusing on (i) the role of H$^-$ as a source of continuum opacity, and (ii) the relative hydride-to-Fe abundance using joint optical and near-infrared data. We present two transits of WASP-189b gathered simultaneously in the optical with HARPS and near-infrared with NIRPS, supported by photometric light curves from EulerCam and ExTrA. Transmission spectra were analysed via cross-correlation to detect absorption features and enhance the signal-to-noise ratio. Atmospheric retrievals quantified relative abundances by fitting overall metallicity and proxies for TiO, H$^-$, and e$^-$. Only atomic iron is detected in HARPS data (S/N ~5.5), but not in NIRPS, likely due to H$^-$ continuum dampening. Retrievals on HARPS-only and HARPS+NIRPS suggest the hydride-to-Fe ratio exceeds equilibrium predictions by about 0.5 dex, hinting at strong hydrogen ionisation. Including NIRPS data helps constrain H$^-$ abundance and set an upper limit on free electron density, unconstrained in HARPS-only data. These results emphasise H$^-$ as a significant continuum opacity source impeding detection of planetary absorption features in WASP-189b's near-infrared transmission spectrum.

astro-ph.EP

Detailed Architecture of the L 98-59 System and Confirmation of a Fifth Planet in the Habitable Zone

The L 98-59 system, identified by TESS in 2019, features three transiting exoplanets in compact orbits of 2.253, 3.691, and 7.451 days around an M3V star, with an outer 12.83-day non-transiting planet confirmed in 2021 using ESPRESSO. The planets exhibit a diverse range of sizes (0.8-1.6 R$_{\oplus}$), masses (0.5-3 M$_{\oplus}$), and likely compositions (Earth-like to possibly water-rich), prompting atmospheric characterization studies with HST and JWST. Here, we analyze 16 new TESS sectors and improve radial velocity (RV) precision of archival ESPRESSO and HARPS data using a line-by-line framework, enabling stellar activity detrending via a novel differential temperature indicator. We refine the radii of L 98-59 b, c, and d to 0.837 $\pm$ 0.019 R$_{\oplus}$, 1.329 $\pm$ 0.029 R$_{\oplus}$, 1.627 $\pm$ 0.041 R$_{\oplus}$, respectively. Combining RVs with transit timing variations (TTV) of L 98-59 c and d from TESS and JWST provides unprecedented constraints on the masses and eccentricities of the planets. We report updated masses of 0.46 $\pm$ 0.11 M$_{\oplus}$ for b, 2.00 $\pm$ 0.13 M$_{\oplus}$ for c, and 1.64 $\pm$ 0.07 M$_{\oplus}$ for d, and a minimum mass of 2.82 $\pm$ 0.19 M$_{\oplus}$ for e. We additionally confirm L 98-59\,f, a non-transiting super-Earth with a minimal mass of 2.80 $\pm$ 0.30 M$_{\oplus}$ on a 23.06-day orbit inside the Habitable Zone. The TTVs of L 98-59 c and d (<3 min, $P_{\rm TTV} = 396$ days) constrain the eccentricities of all planets to near-circular orbits ($e \lesssim 0.04$). An internal structure analysis of the transiting planets reveals increasing water-mass fractions ($f_{\rm H_{2}O}$) with orbital distance, reaching $f_{\rm H_{2}O} \approx 0.16$ for L 98-59\ d. We predict eccentricity-induced tidal heating in L 98-59 b with heat fluxes comparable to those of Io, potentially driving volcanic activity.

astro-ph.EP

New Field OB and OBe Binaries of the SMC Wing: Observational Properties and Population Modeling

We present a radial velocity (RV) survey of the field OB and OBe stars of the SMC Wing. We use multi-epoch observations of 55 targets obtained with the Magellan IMACS and M2FS multi-object spectrographs to identify single- and double-lined spectroscopic binaries. We also use TESS light curves to identify new eclipsing binary candidates. We find that 10 each of our 34 OB (29\%) and 21 OBe (48\%) stars are confirmed binaries, and at least $\sim$ 6 more are candidates. Using our RV measurements, we set constraints on the companion masses, and in some cases, on periods, eccentricities and inclinations. The RV data suggest that OB binaries favor more circular orbits (mean eccentricity $\langle e\rangle = 0.08\pm 0.02$) while OBe binaries are eccentric ($\langle e\rangle = 0.45\pm 0.04$). We identify 2 candidate black hole binaries, [M2002] 77616, and 81941. We use BPASS to predict the frequencies of ejected OB and OBe stars and binaries, assuming OBe stars are binary mass gainers ejected by the companion supernova. We also predict the frequencies of black-hole, neutron-star, and stripped-star companions, and we model the distributions of primary and secondary masses, periods, eccentricities, and velocity distributions. The models are broadly consistent with the binary origin scenario for OBe stars, and predict an even larger number of post-supernova OB binaries. Comparison with the kinematics supports a significant contribution from dynamical ejections for both OB and OBe stars, although less so for binaries.

astro-ph.SR

Kepler-80 Revisited: Assessing the Participation of a Newly Discovered Planet in the Resonant Chain

In this paper, we consider the chain of resonances in the Kepler-80 system and evaluate the impact that the additional member of the resonant chain discovered by Shallue & Vanderburg (2018) has on the dynamics of the system and the physical parameters that can be recovered by a fit to the transit timing variations (TTVs). Ultimately, we calculate the mass of Kepler-80 g to be $0.8 \pm 0.3 M_\oplus$ when assuming all planets have zero eccentricity, and $1.0 \pm 0.3 \ M_{\oplus}$ when relaxing that assumption. We show that the outer five planets are in successive three-body mean-motion resonances (MMRs). We assess the current state of two-body MMRs in the system and find that the planets do not appear to be in two-body MMRs. We find that while the existence of the additional member of the resonant chain does not significantly alter the character of the Kepler-80 three-body MMRs, it can alter the physical parameters derived from the TTVs, suggesting caution should be applied when drawing conclusions from TTVs for potentially incomplete systems. We also compare our results to those of MacDonald et al. (2021), who perform a similar analysis on the same system with a different method. Although the results of this work and MacDonald et al. (2021) show that different fit methodologies and underlying assumptions can result in different measured orbital parameters, the most secure conclusion is that which holds true across all lines of analysis: Kepler-80 contains a chain of planets in three-body MMRs but not in two-body MMRs.

astro-ph.EP