arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv subjects

Davide Bilò

Publications and source records attributed to Davide Bilò.

At least 37 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

Temporal Network Creation Games

Most networks are not static objects, but instead they change over time. This observation has sparked rigorous research on temporal graphs within the last years. In temporal graphs, we have a fixed set of nodes and the connections between them are only available at certain time steps. This gives rise to a plethora of algorithmic problems on such graphs, most prominently the problem of finding temporal spanners, i.e., the computation of subgraphs that guarantee all pairs reachability via temporal paths. To the best of our knowledge, only centralized approaches for the solution of this problem are known. However, many real-world networks are not shaped by a central designer but instead they emerge and evolve by the interaction of many strategic agents. This observation is the driving force of the recent intensive research on game-theoretic network formation models. In this work we bring together these two recent research directions: temporal graphs and game-theoretic network formation. As a first step into this new realm, we focus on a simplified setting where a complete temporal host graph is given and the agents, corresponding to its nodes, selfishly create incident edges to ensure that they can reach all other nodes via temporal paths in the created network. This yields temporal spanners as equilibria of our game. We prove results on the convergence to and the existence of equilibrium networks, on the complexity of finding best agent strategies, and on the quality of the equilibria. By taking these first important steps, we uncover challenging open problems that call for an in-depth exploration of the creation of temporal graphs by strategic agents.

cs.GT↗

Schelling Games with Continuous Types

In most major cities and urban areas, residents form homogeneous neighborhoods along ethnic or socioeconomic lines. This phenomenon is widely known as residential segregation and has been studied extensively. Fifty years ago, Schelling proposed a landmark model that explains residential segregation in an elegant agent-based way. A recent stream of papers analyzed Schelling's model using game-theoretic approaches. However, all these works considered models with a given number of discrete types modeling different ethnic groups. We focus on segregation caused by non-categorical attributes, such as household income or position in a political left-right spectrum. For this, we consider agent types that can be represented as real numbers. This opens up a great variety of reasonable models and, as a proof of concept, we focus on several natural candidates. In particular, we consider agents that evaluate their location by the average type-difference or the maximum type-difference to their neighbors, or by having a certain tolerance range for type-values of neighboring agents. We study the existence and computation of equilibria and provide bounds on the Price of Anarchy and Stability. Also, we present simulation results that compare our models and shed light on the obtained equilibria for our variants.

cs.GT↗

Compact Distance Oracles with Large Sensitivity and Low Stretch

An $f$-edge fault-tolerant distance sensitive oracle ($f$-DSO) with stretch $σ\geq 1$ is a data structure that preprocesses an input graph $G$. When queried with the triple $(s,t,F)$, where $s, t \in V$ and $F \subseteq E$ contains at most $f$ edges of $G$, the oracle returns an estimate $\widehat{d}_{G-F}(s,t)$ of the distance $d_{G-F}(s,t)$ between $s$ and $t$ in the graph $G-F$ such that $d_{G-F}(s,t) \leq \widehat{d}_{G-F}(s,t) \leq σd_{G-F}(s,t)$. For any positive integer $k \ge 2$ and any $0 < α< 1$, we present an $f$-DSO with sensitivity $f = o(\log n/\log\log n)$, stretch $2k-1$, space $O(n^{1+\frac{1}{k}+α+o(1)})$, and an $\widetilde{O}(n^{1+\frac{1}{k} - \fracα{k(f+1)}})$ query time. Prior to our work, there were only three known $f$-DSOs with subquadratic space. The first one by Chechik et al. [Algorithmica 2012] has a stretch of $(8k-2)(f+1)$, depending on $f$. Another approach is storing an $f$-edge fault-tolerant $(2k-1)$-spanner of $G$. The bottleneck is the large query time due to the size of any such spanner, which is $Ω(n^{1+1/k})$ under the Erdős girth conjecture. Bilò et al. [STOC 2023] gave a solution with stretch $3+\varepsilon$, query time $O(n^α)$ but space $O(n^{2-\fracα{f+1}})$, approaching the quadratic barrier for large sensitivity. In the realm of subquadratic space, our $f$-DSOs are the first ones that guarantee, at the same time, large sensitivity, low stretch, and non-trivial query time. To obtain our results, we use the approximate distance oracles of Thorup and Zwick [JACM 2005], and the derandomization of the $f$-DSO of Weimann and Yuster [TALG 2013], that was recently given by Karthik and Parter [SODA 2021].

cs.DS↗

Sparse Temporal Spanners with Low Stretch

A temporal graph is an undirected graph $G=(V,E)$ along with a function that assigns a time-label to each edge in $E$. A path in $G$ with non-decreasing time-labels is called temporal path and the distance from $u$ to $v$ is the minimum length (i.e., the number of edges) of a temporal path from $u$ to $v$. A temporal $α$-spanner of $G$ is a (temporal) subgraph $H$ that preserves the distances between any pair of vertices in $V$, up to a multiplicative stretch factor of $α$. The size of $H$ is the number of its edges. In this work we study the size-stretch trade-offs of temporal spanners. We show that temporal cliques always admit a temporal $(2k-1)-$spanner with $\tilde{O}(kn^{1+\frac{1}{k}})$ edges, where $k>1$ is an integer parameter of choice. Choosing $k=\lfloor\log n\rfloor$, we obtain a temporal $O(\log n)$-spanner with $\tilde{O}(n)$ edges that has almost the same size (up to logarithmic factors) as the temporal spanner in [Casteigts et al., JCSS 2021] which only preserves temporal connectivity. We then consider general temporal graphs. Since $Ω(n^2)$ edges might be needed by any connectivity-preserving temporal subgraph [Axiotis et al., ICALP'16], we focus on approximating distances from a single source. We show that $\tilde{O}(n/\log(1+\varepsilon))$ edges suffice to obtain a stretch of $(1+\varepsilon)$, for any small $\varepsilon>0$. This result is essentially tight since there are temporal graphs for which any temporal subgraph preserving exact distances from a single-source must use $Ω(n^2)$ edges. We extend our analysis to prove an upper bound of $\tilde{O}(n^2/β)$ on the size of any temporal $β$-additive spanner, which is tight up to polylogarithmic factors. Finally, we investigate how the lifetime of $G$, i.e., the number of its distinct time-labels, affects the trade-off between the size and the stretch of a temporal spanner.

cs.DS↗

Tolerance is Necessary for Stability: Single-Peaked Swap Schelling Games

Residential segregation in metropolitan areas is a phenomenon that can be observed all over the world. Recently, this was investigated via game-theoretic models. There, selfish agents of two types are equipped with a monotone utility function that ensures higher utility if an agent has more same-type neighbors. The agents strategically choose their location on a given graph that serves as residential area to maximize their utility. However, sociological polls suggest that real-world agents are actually favoring mixed-type neighborhoods, and hence should be modeled via non-monotone utility functions. To address this, we study Swap Schelling Games with single-peaked utility functions. Our main finding is that tolerance, i.e., agents favoring fifty-fifty neighborhoods or being in the minority, is necessary for equilibrium existence on almost regular or bipartite graphs. Regarding the quality of equilibria, we derive (almost) tight bounds on the Price of Anarchy and the Price of Stability. In particular, we show that the latter is constant on bipartite and almost regular graphs.

cs.GT↗

Deterministic Sensitivity Oracles for Diameter, Eccentricities and All Pairs Distances

We construct data structures for extremal and pairwise distances in directed graphs in the presence of transient edge failures. Henzinger et al. [ITCS 2017] initiated the study of fault-tolerant (sensitivity) oracles for the diameter and vertex eccentricities. We extend this with a special focus on space efficiency. We present several new data structures, among them the first fault-tolerant eccentricity oracle for dual failures in subcubic space. We further prove lower bounds that show limits to approximation vs. space and diameter vs. space trade-offs for fault-tolerant oracles. They highlight key differences between data structures for undirected and directed graphs. Initially, our oracles are randomized leaning on a sampling technique frequently used in sensitivity analysis. Building on the work of Alon, Chechik, and Cohen [ICALP 2019] as well as Karthik and Parter [SODA 2021], we develop a hierarchical framework to derandomize fault-tolerant data structures. We first apply it to our own diameter and eccentricity oracles and then show its versatility by derandomizing algorithms from the literature: the distance sensitivity oracle of Ren [JCSS 2022] and the Single-Source Replacement Path algorithm of Chechik and Magen [ICALP 2020]. This way, we obtain the first deterministic distance sensitivity oracle with subcubic preprocessing time.

cs.DS↗

Fixed-Parameter Sensitivity Oracles

We combine ideas from distance sensitivity oracles (DSOs) and fixed-parameter tractability (FPT) to design sensitivity oracles for FPT graph problems. An oracle with sensitivity $f$ for an FPT problem $Π$ on a graph $G$ with parameter $k$ preprocesses $G$ in time $O(g(f,k) \cdot \textsf{poly}(n))$. When queried with a set $F$ of at most $f$ edges of $G$, the oracle reports the answer to the $Π$-with the same parameter $k$-on the graph $G-F$, i.e., $G$ deprived of $F$. The oracle should answer queries in a time that is significantly faster than merely running the best-known FPT algorithm on $G-F$ from scratch. We mainly design sensitivity oracles for the $k$-Path and the $k$-Vertex Cover problem. Following our line of research connecting fault-tolerant FPT and shortest paths problems, we also introduce parameterization to the computation of distance preservers. We study the problem, given a directed unweighted graph with a fixed source $s$ and parameters $f$ and $k$, to construct a polynomial-sized oracle that efficiently reports, for any target vertex $v$ and set $F$ of at most $f$ edges, whether the distance from $s$ to $v$ increases at most by an additive term of $k$ in $G-F$.

cs.DS↗

Space-Efficient Fault-Tolerant Diameter Oracles

We design $f$-edge fault-tolerant diameter oracles ($f$-FDOs). We preprocess a given graph $G$ on $n$ vertices and $m$ edges, and a positive integer $f$, to construct a data structure that, when queried with a set $F$ of $|F| \leq f$ edges, returns the diameter of $G-F$. For a single failure ($f=1$) in an unweighted directed graph of diameter $D$, there exists an approximate FDO by Henzinger et al. [ITCS 2017] with stretch $(1+\varepsilon)$, constant query time, space $O(m)$, and a combinatorial preprocessing time of $\widetilde{O}(mn + n^{1.5} \sqrt{Dm/\varepsilon})$.We present an FDO for directed graphs with the same stretch, query time, and space. It has a preprocessing time of $\widetilde{O}(mn + n^2/\varepsilon)$. The preprocessing time nearly matches a conditional lower bound for combinatorial algorithms, also by Henzinger et al. With fast matrix multiplication, we achieve a preprocessing time of $\widetilde{O}(n^{2.5794} + n^2/\varepsilon)$. We further prove an information-theoretic lower bound showing that any FDO with stretch better than $3/2$ requires $Ω(m)$ bits of space. For multiple failures ($f>1$) in undirected graphs with non-negative edge weights, we give an $f$-FDO with stretch $(f+2)$, query time $O(f^2\log^2{n})$, $\widetilde{O}(fn)$ space, and preprocessing time $\widetilde{O}(fm)$. We complement this with a lower bound excluding any finite stretch in $o(fn)$ space. We show that for unweighted graphs with polylogarithmic diameter and up to $f = o(\log n/ \log\log n)$ failures, one can swap approximation for query time and space. We present an exact combinatorial $f$-FDO with preprocessing time $mn^{1+o(1)}$, query time $n^{o(1)}$, and space $n^{2+o(1)}$. When using fast matrix multiplication instead, the preprocessing time can be improved to $n^{ω+o(1)}$, where $ω< 2.373$ is the matrix multiplication exponent.

cs.DS↗

Near-Optimal Deterministic Single-Source Distance Sensitivity Oracles

Given a graph with a source vertex $s$, the Single Source Replacement Paths (SSRP) problem is to compute, for every vertex $t$ and edge $e$, the length $d(s,t,e)$ of a shortest path from $s$ to $t$ that avoids $e$. A Single-Source Distance Sensitivity Oracle (Single-Source DSO) is a data structure that answers queries of the form $(t,e)$ by returning the distance $d(s,t,e)$. We show how to deterministically compress the output of the SSRP problem on $n$-vertex, $m$-edge graphs with integer edge weights in the range $[1,M]$ into a Single-Source DSO of size $O(M^{1/2}n^{3/2})$ with query time $\widetilde{O}(1)$. The space requirement is optimal (up to the word size) and our techniques can also handle vertex failures. Chechik and Cohen [SODA 2019] presented a combinatorial, randomized $\widetilde{O}(m\sqrt{n}+n^2)$ time SSRP algorithm for undirected and unweighted graphs. Grandoni and Vassilevska Williams [FOCS 2012, TALG 2020] gave an algebraic, randomized $\widetilde{O}(Mn^ω)$ time SSRP algorithm for graphs with integer edge weights in the range $[1,M]$, where $ω<2.373$ is the matrix multiplication exponent. We derandomize both algorithms for undirected graphs in the same asymptotic running time and apply our compression to obtain deterministic Single-Source DSOs. The $\widetilde{O}(m\sqrt{n}+n^2)$ and $\widetilde{O}(Mn^ω)$ preprocessing times are polynomial improvements over previous $o(n^2)$-space oracles. On sparse graphs with $m=O(n^{5/4-\varepsilon}/M^{7/4})$ edges, for any constant $\varepsilon > 0$, we reduce the preprocessing to randomized $\widetilde{O}(M^{7/8}m^{1/2}n^{11/8})=O(n^{2-\varepsilon/2})$ time. This is the first truly subquadratic time algorithm for building Single-Source DSOs on sparse graphs.

cs.DS↗

Finding single-source shortest $p$-disjoint paths: fast computation and sparse preservers

Let $G$ be a directed graph with $n$ vertices, $m$ edges, and non-negative edge costs. Given $G$, a fixed source vertex $s$, and a positive integer $p$, we consider the problem of computing, for each vertex $t\neq s$, $p$ edge-disjoint paths of minimum total cost from $s$ to $t$ in $G$. Suurballe and Tarjan~[Networks, 1984] solved the above problem for $p=2$ by designing a $O(m+n\log n)$ time algorithm which also computes a sparse \emph{single-source $2$-multipath preserver}, i.e., a subgraph containing $2$ edge-disjoint paths of minimum total cost from $s$ to every other vertex of $G$. The case $p \geq 3$ was left as an open problem. We study the general problem ($p\geq 2$) and prove that any graph admits a sparse single-source $p$-multipath preserver with $p(n-1)$ edges. This size is optimal since the in-degree of each non-root vertex $v$ must be at least $p$. Moreover, we design an algorithm that requires $O(pn^2 (p + \log n))$ time to compute both $p$ edge-disjoint paths of minimum total cost from the source to all other vertices and an optimal-size single-source $p$-multipath preserver. The running time of our algorithm outperforms that of a natural approach that solves $n-1$ single-pair instances using the well-known \emph{successive shortest paths} algorithm by a factor of $Θ(\frac{m}{np})$ and is asymptotically near optimal if $p=O(1)$ and $m=Θ(n^2)$. Our results extend naturally to the case of $p$ vertex-disjoint paths.

cs.DS↗

Selfish Creation of Social Networks

Understanding real-world networks has been a core research endeavor throughout the last two decades. Network Creation Games are a promising approach for this from a game-theoretic perspective. In these games, selfish agents corresponding to nodes in a network strategically decide which links to form to optimize their centrality. Many versions have been introduced and analyzed, but none of them fits to modeling the evolution of social networks. In real-world social networks, connections are often established by recommendations from common acquaintances or by a chain of such recommendations. Thus establishing and maintaining a contact with a friend of a friend is easier than connecting to complete strangers. This explains the high clustering, i.e., the abundance of triangles, in real-world social networks. We propose and analyze a network creation model inspired by real-world social networks. Edges are formed in our model via bilateral consent of both endpoints and the cost for establishing and maintaining an edge is proportional to the distance of the endpoints before establishing the connection. We provide results for generic cost functions, which essentially only must be convex functions in the distance of the endpoints without the respective edge. For this broad class of cost functions, we provide many structural properties of equilibrium networks and prove (almost) tight bounds on the diameter, the Price of Anarchy and the Price of Stability. Moreover, as a proof-of-concept we show via experiments that the created equilibrium networks of our model indeed closely mimics real-world social networks. We observe degree distributions that seem to follow a power-law, high clustering, and low diameters. This can be seen as a promising first step towards game-theoretic network creation models that predict networks featuring all core real-world properties.

cs.GT↗

Fair Tree Connection Games with Topology-Dependent Edge Cost

How do rational agents self-organize when trying to connect to a common target? We study this question with a simple tree formation game which is related to the well-known fair single-source connection game by Anshelevich et al. (FOCS'04) and selfish spanning tree games by Gourvès and Monnot (WINE'08). In our game agents correspond to nodes in a network that activate a single outgoing edge to connect to the common target node (possibly via other nodes). Agents pay for their path to the common target, and edge costs are shared fairly among all agents using an edge. The main novelty of our model is dynamic edge costs that depend on the in-degree of the respective endpoint. This reflects that connecting to popular nodes that have increased internal coordination costs is more expensive since they can charge higher prices for their routing service. In contrast to related models, we show that equilibria are not guaranteed to exist, but we prove the existence for infinitely many numbers of agents. Moreover, we analyze the structure of equilibrium trees and employ these insights to prove a constant upper bound on the Price of Anarchy as well as non-trivial lower bounds on both the Price of Anarchy and the Price of Stability. We also show that in comparison with the social optimum tree the overall cost of an equilibrium tree is more fairly shared among the agents. Thus, we prove that self-organization of rational agents yields on average only slightly higher cost per agent compared to the centralized optimum, and at the same time, it induces a more fair cost distribution. Moreover, equilibrium trees achieve a beneficial trade-off between a low height and low maximum degree, and hence these trees might be of independent interest from a combinatorics point-of-view. We conclude with a discussion of promising extensions of our model.

cs.GT↗

Geometric Network Creation Games

Network Creation Games are a well-known approach for explaining and analyzing the structure, quality and dynamics of real-world networks like the Internet and other infrastructure networks which evolved via the interaction of selfish agents without a central authority. In these games selfish agents which correspond to nodes in a network strategically buy incident edges to improve their centrality. However, past research on these games has only considered the creation of networks with unit-weight edges. In practice, e.g. when constructing a fiber-optic network, the choice of which nodes to connect and also the induced price for a link crucially depends on the distance between the involved nodes and such settings can be modeled via edge-weighted graphs. We incorporate arbitrary edge weights by generalizing the well-known model by Fabrikant et al.[PODC'03] to edge-weighted host graphs and focus on the geometric setting where the weights are induced by the distances in some metric space. In stark contrast to the state-of-the-art for the unit-weight version, where the Price of Anarchy is conjectured to be constant and where resolving this is a major open problem, we prove a tight non-constant bound on the Price of Anarchy for the metric version and a slightly weaker upper bound for the non-metric case. Moreover, we analyze the existence of equilibria, the computational hardness and the game dynamics for several natural metrics. The model we propose can be seen as the game-theoretic analogue of a variant of the classical Network Design Problem. Thus, low-cost equilibria of our game correspond to decentralized and stable approximations of the optimum network design.

cs.GT↗

Topological Influence and Locality in Swap Schelling Games

Residential segregation is a wide-spread phenomenon that can be observed in almost every major city. In these urban areas residents with different racial or socioeconomic background tend to form homogeneous clusters. Schelling's famous agent-based model for residential segregation explains how such clusters can form even if all agents are tolerant, i.e., if they agree to live in mixed neighborhoods. For segregation to occur, all it needs is a slight bias towards agents preferring similar neighbors. Very recently, Schelling's model has been investigated from a game-theoretic point of view with selfish agents that strategically select their residential location. In these games, agents can improve on their current location by performing a location swap with another agent who is willing to swap. We significantly deepen these investigations by studying the influence of the underlying topology modeling the residential area on the existence of equilibria, the Price of Anarchy and on the dynamic properties of the resulting strategic multi-agent system. Moreover, as a new conceptual contribution, we also consider the influence of locality, i.e., if the location swaps are restricted to swaps of neighboring agents. We give improved almost tight bounds on the Price of Anarchy for arbitrary underlying graphs and we present (almost) tight bounds for regular graphs, paths and cycles. Moreover, we give almost tight bounds for grids, which are commonly used in empirical studies. For grids we also show that locality has a severe impact on the game dynamics.

cs.GT↗

Cutting Bamboo Down to Size

This paper studies the problem of programming a robotic panda gardener to keep a bamboo garden from obstructing the view of the lake by your house. The garden consists of $n$ bamboo stalks with known daily growth rates and the gardener can cut at most one bamboo per day. As a computer scientist, you found out that this problem has already been formalized in [Gąsieniec et al., SOFSEM'17] as the Bamboo Garden Trimming (BGT) problem, where the goal is that of computing a perpetual schedule (i.e., the sequence of bamboos to cut) for the robotic gardener to follow in order to minimize the makespan, i.e., the maximum height ever reached by a bamboo. Two natural strategies are Reduce-Max and Reduce-Fastest(x). Reduce-Max trims the tallest bamboo of the day, while Reduce-Fastest(x) trims the fastest growing bamboo among the ones that are taller than $x$. It is known that Reduce-Max and Reduce-Fastest(x) achieve a makespan of $O(\log n)$ and $4$ for the best choice of $x=2$, respectively. We prove the first constant upper bound of $9$ for Reduce-Max and improve the one for Reduce-Fastest(x) to $\frac{3+\sqrt{5}}{2} < 2.62$ for $x=1+\frac{1}{\sqrt{5}}$. Another critical aspect stems from the fact that your robotic gardener has a limited amount of processing power and memory. It is then important for the algorithm to be able to quickly determine the next bamboo to cut while requiring at most linear space. We formalize this aspect as the problem of designing a Trimming Oracle data structure, and we provide three efficient Trimming Oracles implementing different perpetual schedules, including those produced by Reduce-Max and Reduce-Fastest(x).

cs.DS↗

A Novel Algorithm for the All-Best-Swap-Edge Problem on Tree Spanners

Given a 2-edge connected, unweighted, and undirected graph $G$ with $n$ vertices and $m$ edges, a $σ$-tree spanner is a spanning tree $T$ of $G$ in which the ratio between the distance in $T$ of any pair of vertices and the corresponding distance in $G$ is upper bounded by $σ$. The minimum value of $σ$ for which $T$ is a $σ$-tree spanner of $G$ is also called the {\em stretch factor} of $T$. We address the fault-tolerant scenario in which each edge $e$ of a given tree spanner may temporarily fail and has to be replaced by a {\em best swap edge}, i.e. an edge that reconnects $T-e$ at a minimum stretch factor. More precisely, we design an $O(n^2)$ time and space algorithm that computes a best swap edge of every tree edge. Previously, an $O(n^2 \log^4 n)$ time and $O(n^2+m\log^2n)$ space algorithm was known for edge-weighted graphs [Bilò et al., ISAAC 2017]. Even if our improvements on both the time and space complexities are of a polylogarithmic factor, we stress the fact that the design of a $o(n^2)$ time and space algorithm would be considered a breakthrough.

cs.DS↗

Almost optimal algorithms for diameter-optimally augmenting trees

We consider the problem of augmenting an $n$-vertex tree with one shortcut in order to minimize the diameter of the resulting graph. The tree is embedded in an unknown space and we have access to an oracle that, when queried on a pair of vertices $u$ and $v$, reports the weight of the shortcut $(u,v)$ in constant time. Previously, the problem was solved in $O(n^2 \log^3 n)$ time for general weights [Oh and Ahn, ISAAC 2016], in $O(n^2 \log n)$ time for trees embedded in a metric space [Große et al., {\tt arXiv:1607.05547}], and in $O(n \log n)$ time for paths embedded in a metric space [Wang, WADS 2017]. Furthermore, a $(1+\varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm running in $O(n+1/\varepsilon^{3})$ has been designed for paths embedded in $\mathbb{R}^d$, for constant values of $d$ [Große et al., ICALP 2015]. The contribution of this paper is twofold: we address the problem for trees (not only paths) and we also improve upon all known results. More precisely, we design a {\em time-optimal} $O(n^2)$ time algorithm for general weights. Moreover, for trees embedded in a metric space, we design (i) an exact $O(n \log n)$ time algorithm and (ii) a $(1+\varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm that runs in $O\big(n+ \varepsilon^{-1}\log \varepsilon^{-1}\big)$ time.

cs.DS↗

An Interesting Structural Property Related to the Problem of Computing All the Best Swap Edges of a Tree Spanner in Unweighted Graphs

In this draft we prove an interesting structural property related to the problem of computing {\em all the best swap edges} of a {\em tree spanner} in unweighted graphs. Previous papers show that the maximum stretch factor of the tree where a failing edge is temporarily swapped with any other available edge that reconnects the tree depends only on the {\em critical edge}. However, in principle, each of the $O(n^2)$ swap edges, where $n$ is the number of vertices of the tree, may have its own critical edge. In this draft we show that there are at most 6 critical edges, i.e., each tree edge $e$ has a {\em critical set} of size at most 6 such that, a critical edge of each swap edge of $e$ is contained in the critical set.

cs.DM↗