arXiv subjects

David Manlove

Publications and source records attributed to David Manlove.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

arXiv2026

Optimal b-Colourings and Fall Colourings in $H$-Free Graphs

In a colouring of a graph, a vertex is b-chromatic if it is adjacent to a vertex of every other colour. We consider four well-studied colouring problems: b-Chromatic Number, Tight b-Chromatic Number, Fall Chromatic Number and Fall Achromatic Number, which fit into a framework based on whether every colour class has (i) at least one b-chromatic vertex, (ii) exactly one b-chromatic vertex, or (iii) all of its vertices being b-chromatic. By combining known and new results, we fully classify the computational complexity of b-Chromatic Number, Fall Chromatic Number and Fall Achromatic Number in $H$-free graphs. For Tight b-Chromatic Number in $H$-free graphs, we develop a general technique to determine new graphs $H$, for which the problem is polynomial-time solvable, and we also determine new graphs $H$, for which the problem is still NP-complete. We show, for the first time, the existence of a graph $H$ such that in $H$-free graphs, b-Chromatic Number is NP-hard, while Tight b-Chromatic Number is polynomial-time solvable.

math.CO↗

arXiv2026

Stable Matching with Deviators and Conformists

In the Stable Marriage and Stable Roommates problems, there are inherent trade-offs between the size and stability of solutions. While in the former problem, a stable matching always exists and can be found efficiently using the Gale-Shapley algorithm, the existence of a stable matching is not guaranteed in the latter problem, but can be determined efficiently using Irving's algorithm. However, the computation of matchings that minimise the instability, either due to the presence of constraints on the size of the matching or due to restrictive preference cycles, gives rise to a collection of infamously intractable almost-stable matching problems. In practice, however, not every agent is able or likely to initiate deviations caused by blocking pairs. Suppose we knew, for example, due to a set of requirements or estimates based on historical data, which agents are likely to initiate deviations - the deviators - and which are likely to comply with whatever matching they are presented with - the conformists. Can we decide efficiently whether a matching exists in which no deviator is blocking, i.e., in which no deviator has an incentive to initiate a deviation? Furthermore, can we find matchings in which only a few deviators are blocking? We characterise the computational complexity of this question in bipartite and non-bipartite settings. Surprisingly, these problems prove intractable in very strong ways. On the positive side, we identify polynomial-time and fixed-parameter tractable cases (with respect to the number of deviators and the preference list length), providing novel algorithmics for problems where stability cannot be fully guaranteed, and resolving some open cases from the literature along the way.

cs.GT↗

arXiv2026

A Minimax Perspective on Almost-Stable Matchings

Stability is crucial in matching markets, yet in many real-world settings - from hospital residency allocations to roommate assignments - full stability is either unachievable or comes at the cost of leaving agents unmatched. In these cases, algorithmicists and market designers face a critical question: how should instability be measured and distributed among participants? Existing approaches to "almost-stable" matchings focus on aggregate measures, minimising the number of blocking pairs or the count of agents involved in blocking pairs. However, these objectives can result in concentrated instability on a few agents, raising concerns about fairness and incentives to deviate. We introduce a fairness-oriented approach to approximate stability based on the minimax principle: we seek matchings that minimise the maximum number of blocking pairs any agent is in. Equivalently, we minimise the maximum number of agents that anyone has justified envy towards. This distributional objective protects the worst-off agents from bearing a disproportionate amount of instability. We characterise the computational complexity of this notion across fundamental matching settings. Surprisingly, even very modest guarantees with respect to the distribution of instability prove computationally intractable: we show that it is NP-complete to decide whether a matching exists in which no agent is in more than one blocking pair, even when preference lists are bounded. This result applies to both Stable Roommates and maximum cardinality Stable Marriage. On the positive side, we provide polynomial-time algorithms when agents rank at most two others, and present approximation algorithms and integer programs for general settings. Our results map the algorithmic landscape and reveal fundamental trade-offs between distributional guarantees on justified envy and computational feasibility in matching market design.

cs.GT↗

arXiv2025

Total b-chromatic Colouring of Graphs

A b-chromatic colouring of a graph $G$ is a proper $k$-colouring of the vertices of $G$, for some integer $k$, such that, for each colour $i$ ($1\leq i\leq k$), there exists a vertex $v$ of colour $i$ such that $v$ is adjacent to a vertex of colour $j$, for each $j$ ($1\leq j\leq k$, $j\neq i$). The b-chromatic number of $G$ is the maximum integer $k$ such that $G$ admits a b-chromatic colouring using $k$ colours. In this paper we introduce the concept of a total b-chromatic colouring, which extends the notion of b-chromatic colourings to both vertices and edges in a graph. We show that the problem of computing the total b-chromatic number is NP-hard in general graphs. On the other hand for a subclass of caterpillars we give a polynomial-time algorithm to compute the total b-chromatic number, and indeed a total b-chromatic colouring with the maximum number of colours.

math.CO↗

arXiv2025

Complexity and Manipulation of International Kidney Exchange Programmes with Country-Specific Parameters

Kidney Exchange Programmes (KEPs) facilitate the exchange of kidneys, and larger pools of recipient-donor pairs tend to yield proportionally more transplants, leading to the proposal of international KEPs (IKEPs). However, as studied by \citet{mincu2021ip}, practical limitations must be considered in IKEPs to ensure that countries remain willing to participate. Thus, we study IKEPs with country-specific parameters, represented by a tuple $\Gamma$, restricting the selected transplants to be feasible for the countries to conduct, e.g., imposing an upper limit on the number of consecutive exchanges within a country's borders. We provide a complete complexity dichotomy for the problem of finding a feasible (according to the constraints given by $\Gamma$) cycle packing with the maximum number of transplants, for every possible $\Gamma$. We also study the potential for countries to misreport their parameters to increase their allocation. As manipulation can harm the total number of transplants, we propose a novel individually rational and incentive compatible mechanism $\mathcal{M}_{\text{order}}$. We first give a theoretical approximation ratio for $\mathcal{M}_{\text{order}}$ in terms of the number of transplants, and show that the approximation ratio of $\mathcal{M}_{\text{order}}$ is asymptotically optimal. We then use simulations which suggest that, in practice, the performance of $\mathcal{M}_{\text{order}}$ is significantly better than this worst-case ratio.

cs.GT↗

arXiv2025

Course Allocation with Credits via Stable Matching

In the {\sc Course Allocation} problem, there are a set of students and a set of courses at a given university. University courses may have different numbers of credits, typically related to different numbers of learning hours, and there may be other constraints such as courses running concurrently. Our goal is to allocate the students to the courses such that the resulting matching is stable, which means that no student and course(s) have an incentive to break away from the matching and become assigned to one another. We study several definitions of stability and for each we give a mixture of polynomial-time algorithms and hardness results for problems involving verifying the stability of a matching, finding a stable matching or determining that none exists, and finding a maximum size stable matching. We also study variants of the problem with master lists of students, and lower quotas on the number of students allocated to a course, establishing additional complexity results in these settings.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2025

Unsolvability and Beyond in Many-To-Many Non-Bipartite Stable Matching

We study the Stable Fixtures problem, a many-to-many generalisation of the classical non-bipartite Stable Roommates matching problem. Building on the foundational work of Tan on stable partitions, we extend his results to this significantly more general setting and develop a rich framework for understanding stable structures. Our main contribution, the notion of a generalised stable partition (GSP), not only characterises the solution space but also serves as a versatile tool for ordinal preference systems with capacity constraints. We show that a GSP can be computed efficiently and can provide an elegant representation of key aspects of a preference system. Leveraging a connection to stable half-matchings, we also establish an analogous Rural Hospitals Theorem for stable half-matchings and GSPs, and connect our results to recent work on near-feasible matchings, providing a simpler algorithm and tighter analysis. Our work also addresses the computational challenges of finding optimal stable half-matchings and GSPs, presenting a flexible integer linear programming model for various objectives. Beyond theoretical insights, we conduct the first empirical analysis of random Stable Fixtures instances. Our work unifies and extends classical and recent perspectives on stability in non-bipartite stable matching and establishes new tools and techniques for stable matchings and their applications.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2025

Perspectives on Unsolvability in the Roommates Problem

In the well-studied Stable Roommates problem, we seek a stable matching of agents into pairs, where no two agents prefer each other over their assigned partners. However, some instances of this problem are unsolvable, lacking any stable matching. A long-standing open question posed by Gusfield and Irving (1989) asks about the behavior of the probability function Pn, which measures the likelihood that a random instance with n agents is solvable. This paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the landscape surrounding this question, combining structural, probabilistic, and experimental perspectives. We review existing approaches from the past four decades, highlight connections to related problems, and present novel structural and experimental findings. Specifically, we estimate Pn for instances with preferences sampled from diverse statistical distributions, examining problem sizes up to 5,001 agents, and look for specific sub-structures that cause unsolvability. Our results reveal that while Pn tends to be low for most distributions, the number and lengths of "unstable" structures remain limited, suggesting that random instances are "close" to being solvable. Additionally, we present the first empirical study of the number of stable matchings and the number of stable partitions that random instances admit, using recently developed algorithms. Our findings show that the solution sets are typically small. This implies that many NP-hard problems related to computing optimal stable matchings and optimal stable partitions become tractable in practice, and motivates efficient alternative solution concepts for unsolvable instances, such as stable half-matchings and maximum stable matchings.

cs.GT↗

arXiv2025

Operational research approaches and mathematical models for kidney exchange: A literature survey and empirical evaluation

Kidney exchange is a transplant modality that has provided new opportunities for living kidney donation in many countries around the world since 1991. It has been extensively studied from an Operational Research (OR) perspective since 2004. This article provides a comprehensive literature survey on OR approaches to fundamental computational problems associated with kidney exchange over the last two decades. We also summarise the key integer linear programming (ILP) models for kidney exchange, showing how to model optimisation problems involving only cycles and chains separately. This allows new combined ILP models, not previously presented, to be obtained by amalgamating cycle and chain models. We present a comprehensive empirical evaluation involving all combined models from this paper in addition to bespoke software packages from the literature involving advanced techniques. This focuses primarily on computation times for 49 methods applied to 4,320 problem instances of varying sizes that reflect the characteristics of real kidney exchange datasets, corresponding to over 200,000 algorithm executions. We have made our implementations of all cycle and chain models described in this paper, together with all instances used for the experiments, and a web application to visualise our experimental results, publicly available.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2025

Structural aspects of the Student Project Allocation problem

We study the Student Project Allocation problem with lecturer preferences over Students (SPA-S), which involves the assignment of students to projects based on student preferences over projects, lecturer preferences over students, and capacity constraints on both projects and lecturers. The goal is to find a stable matching that ensures no student and lecturer can mutually benefit by deviating from a given assignment to form an alternative arrangement involving some project. We explore the structural properties of SPA-S and characterise the set of stable matchings for an arbitrary SPA-S instance. We prove that, similar to the classical Stable Marriage problem (SM) and the Hospital Residents problem (HR), the set of all stable matchings in SPA-S forms a distributive lattice. In this lattice, the student-optimal and lecturer-optimal stable matchings represent the minimum and maximum elements, respectively. Finally, we introduce meta-rotations in the SPA-S setting using illustrations, demonstrating how they capture the relationships between stable matchings. These novel structural insights paves the way for efficient algorithms that address several open problems related to stable matchings in SPA-S.

cs.GT↗

arXiv2024

Couples can be tractable: New algorithms and hardness results for the Hospitals / Residents problem with Couples

In this paper, we study the Hospitals / Residents problem with Couples (HRC), where a solution is a stable matching or a report that none exists. We present a novel polynomial-time algorithm that can find a near-feasible stable matching (adjusting the hospitals' capacities by at most 1) in an HRC instance where the couples' preferences are sub-responsive (i.e., if one member switches to a better hospital, then the couple also improves) and sub-complete (i.e., each pair of hospitals that are individually acceptable to both members are jointly acceptable for the couple) by reducing it to an instance of the Stable Fixtures problem. We also present a polynomial-time algorithm for HRC in a sub-responsive, sub-complete instance that is a Dual Market, or where all couples are one of several possible types. We show that our algorithm also implies the polynomial-time solvability of a stable b-matching problem, where the underlying graph is a multigraph with loops. We complement our algorithms with several hardness results. We show that HRC with sub-responsive and sub-complete couples is NP-hard, even with other strong restrictions. We also show that HRC with a Dual Market is NP-hard under several simultaneous restrictions. Finally, we show that the problem of finding a matching with the minimum number of blocking pairs in HRC is not approximable within $m^{1-\varepsilon}$, for any $\varepsilon>0$, where $m$ is the total length of the hospitals' preference lists, unless P=NP, even if each couple applies to only one pair of hospitals. Our polynomial-time solvability results greatly expand the class of known tractable instances of HRC and provide a useful tool for designing better and more efficient mechanisms in the future.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2024

MATWA: A Web Toolkit for Matching under Preferences

Matching markets, where agents are assigned to one another based on preferences and capacity constraints, are pervasive in various domains. This paper introduces MATWA (https://matwa.optimalmatching.com), a web application offering a rich collection of algorithms for fundamental problem models involving matching under preferences. MATWA provides results and visualizations of matching algorithm outputs based on different methods for providing problem instances. In this paper, we describe the features of the system, illustrating its usage for different problem models, and outlining the algorithm implementations that are supported. We also give evidence of usability testing and illustrate how the system was used to obtain new empirical results for a specific matching problem. MATWA is intended to be a resource for the community of researchers in the area of matching under preferences, supporting experimentation as well as aiding the understanding of matching algorithms.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2024

Envy-freeness in 3D Hedonic Games

We study the problem of partitioning a set of agents into coalitions based on the agents' additively separable preferences, which can also be viewed as a hedonic game. We apply three successively weaker solution concepts, namely envy-freeness, weakly justified envy-freeness, and justified envy-freeness. In a model in which coalitions may have any size, trivial solutions exist for these concepts, which provides a strong motivation for placing restrictions on coalition size. In this paper, we require feasible coalitions to have size three. We study the existence of partitions that are envy-free, weakly justified envy-free, and justified envy-free, and the computational complexity of finding such partitions, if they exist. We present a comprehensive complexity classification, in terms of the restrictions placed on the agents' preferences. From this, we identify a general trend that for the three successively weaker solution concepts, existence and polynomial-time solvability hold under successively weaker restrictions.

cs.GT↗

arXiv2024

Structural and Algorithmic Results for Stable Cycles and Partitions in the Roommates Problem

In the Stable Roommates problem, we seek a stable matching of the agents into pairs, in which no two agents have an incentive to deviate from their assignment. It is well known that a stable matching is unlikely to exist, but a stable partition always does and provides a succinct certificate for the unsolvability of an instance. Furthermore, apart from being a useful structural tool to study the problem, every stable partition corresponds to a stable half-matching, which has applications, for example, in sports scheduling and time-sharing. We establish new structural results for stable partitions and show how to enumerate all stable partitions and the cycles included in such structures efficiently. We also adapt optimality criteria from stable matchings to stable partitions and give complexity and approximability results for the problems of computing such "fair" and "optimal" stable partitions. Through this research, we contribute to a deeper understanding of stable partitions from a combinatorial point of view, as well as the computational complexity of computing "fair" or "optimal" stable half-matchings in practice, closing the gap between integral and fractional stable matchings and paving the way for further applications of stable partitions to unsolvable instances and computationally hard stable matching problems.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2024

Packing $K_r$s in bounded degree graphs

We study the problem of finding a maximum-cardinality set of $r$-cliques in an undirected graph of fixed maximum degree $Δ$, subject to the cliques in that set being either vertex-disjoint or edge-disjoint. It is known for $r=3$ that the vertex-disjoint (edge-disjoint) problem is solvable in linear time if $Δ=3$ ($Δ=4$) but APX-hard if $Δ\geq 4$ ($Δ\geq 5$). We generalise these results to an arbitrary but fixed $r \geq 3$, and provide a complete complexity classification for both the vertex- and edge-disjoint variants in graphs of maximum degree $Δ$. Specifically, we show that the vertex-disjoint problem is solvable in linear time if $Δ< 3r/2 - 1$, solvable in polynomial time if $Δ< 5r/3 - 1$, and APX-hard if $Δ\geq \lceil 5r/3 \rceil - 1$. We also show that if $r\geq 6$ then the above implications also hold for the edge-disjoint problem. If $r \leq 5$, then the edge-disjoint problem is solvable in linear time if $Δ< 3r/2 - 1$, solvable in polynomial time if $Δ\leq 2r - 2$, and APX-hard if $Δ> 2r - 2$.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2023

On weakly and strongly popular rankings

Van Zuylen et al. [35] introduced the notion of a popular ranking in a voting context, where each voter submits a strict ranking of all candidates. A popular ranking $π$ of the candidates is at least as good as any other ranking $σ$ in the following sense: if we compare $π$ to $σ$, at least half of all voters will always weakly prefer $π$. Whether a voter prefers one ranking to another is calculated based on the Kendall distance. A more traditional definition of popularity -- as applied to popular matchings, a well-established topic in computational social choice -- is stricter, because it requires at least half of the voters who are not indifferent between $π$ and $σ$ to prefer $π$. In this paper, we derive structural and algorithmic results in both settings, also improving upon the results in [35]. We also point out connections to the famous open problem of finding a Kemeny consensus with three voters.

cs.GT↗

arXiv2021

Profile-based optimal stable matchings in the Roommates problem

The stable roommates problem can admit multiple different stable matchings. We have different criteria for deciding which one is optimal, but computing those is often NP-hard. We show that the problem of finding generous or rank-maximal stable matchings in an instance of the roommates problem with incomplete lists is NP-hard even when the preference lists are at most length 3. We show that just maximising the number of first choices or minimising the number of last choices is NP-hard with the short preference lists. We show that the number of $R^{th}$ choices, where $R$ is the minimum-regret of a given instance of SRI, is 2-approximable among all the stable matchings. Additionally, we show that the problem of finding a stable matching that maximises the number of first choices does not admit a constant time approximation algorithm and is W[1]-hard with respect to the number of first choices. We implement integer programming and constraint programming formulations for the optimality criteria of SRI. We find that constraint programming outperforms integer programming and an earlier answer set programming approach by Erdam et. al. (2020) for most optimality criteria. Integer programming outperforms constraint programming and answer set programming on the almost stable roommates problem.

cs.DS↗

arXiv2021

The Three-Dimensional Stable Roommates Problem with Additively Separable Preferences

The Stable Roommates problem involves matching a set of agents into pairs based on the agents' strict ordinal preference lists. The matching must be stable, meaning that no two agents strictly prefer each other to their assigned partners. A number of three-dimensional variants exist, in which agents are instead matched into triples. Both the original problem and these variants can also be viewed as hedonic games. We formalise a three-dimensional variant using general additively separable preferences, in which each agent provides an integer valuation of every other agent. In this variant, we show that a stable matching may not exist and that the related decision problem is NP-complete, even when the valuations are binary. In contrast, we show that if the valuations are binary and symmetric then a stable matching must exist and can be found in polynomial time. We also consider the related problem of finding a stable matching with maximum utilitarian welfare when valuations are binary and symmetric. We show that this optimisation problem is NP-hard and present a novel 2-approximation algorithm.

cs.GT↗