Andrei Kanavalau | arXiv Science

arXiv2026

Post-Grokking Collapse at the Representation-Readout Interface in Muon-Trained Transformers

Under the standard split, Muon gets hidden matrices and AdamW embeddings/output head. Muon groks modular addition faster, but its solutions do not hold. All nine configurations on $(a+b) \bmod 113$ grok and later lose generalization. Across five seeds the selected AdamW reference falls below threshold on four, reaching 27.59%. Instability persists across two moduli, two widths, two training fractions, subtraction, and depth. The failure arises at the representation-readout interface, identified only jointly up to an invertible map unselected by the loss. After solving the training set, the gradient falls to order $10^{-6}$ and the optimizers respond differently: step-size elasticity is -0.03 for Muon versus +1.5 for AdamW, and the Muon group moves 8.0 times faster per parameter. From bit-identical states, freezing either group prevents failure. Freezing embeddings/readout removes it in five runs over 451,400 post-grokking steps and five paired seeds: unfrozen arms record 137-321 sub-threshold evaluations, frozen arms none. Removing Muon's normalization and orthogonalization is no substitute: it collapses representation from 326 effective conjugate pairs to 4, shows no recurrent collapse, and fails terminally. Fourier filtering separates circuit failure from masking. Across 43 checkpoints over five seeds and three regimes, the task-aligned family reaches exactly 100% alone. In circuit failure it no longer solves the task; in masking it remains perfect while the full model reaches 45.85%, giving a positive margin on every example, including errors, but being outvoted by a near-equal adversarial remainder. Rescaling it restores 99.9%; grokking is the same condition resolving upward. The task selects the family, swapping $(k,k)$ for $(k,-k)$ under subtraction. Across an abrupt collapse, standard Fourier support is unchanged and the power-distribution cosine remains 0.9899.

cs.AI↗

arXiv2026

Gated Normalization Removal and Scale Anchoring in Pre-Norm Transformers

Normalization layers are standard in transformers, but it is not clear whether their sample-dependent computations are necessary throughout both training and inference. This work develops a gated normalization-removal approach for pre-norm transformers. The approach is implemented using TaperNorm, which starts from standard RMSNorm/LayerNorm and gradually tapers to learned sample-independent linear or affine maps. Once the gate reaches zero, per-token statistics are no longer computed in the tapered layers and the resulting maps can be folded into adjacent linear projections. The results indicate that internal normalization can be tapered in the tested pre-training and fine-tuning settings with small validation-loss increases. Our approach helps reveal a distinct role for final normalization, namely that it anchors the scale of the pre-logit representation. With this anchor present, radial changes in the last hidden state do not directly reduce the loss; when it is removed, reducing cross-entropy can be achieved by increasing logit magnitudes. A fixed-target scale loss provides an explicit alternative anchor and enables fully norm-free ablations in the tested regimes. Finally, in a KV-cached autoregressive decoding benchmark, tapering internal norms gives up to $1.14\times$ higher throughput with explicit scaling operations and up to $1.18\times$ after folding.

cs.LG↗