Thoughtful comments on 'Bessel beams and signal propagation'

Abstract

In this paper we present thoughtful comments on the paper `Bessel beams and signal propagation' showing that the main claims of that paper are wrong. Moreover, we take the opportunity to show the non trivial and indeed surprising result that a scalar pulse (i.e., a wave train of compact support in the time domain) that is solution of the homogeneous wave equation (vector ($\vec{E},\vec{B}$) pulse that is solution of Maxwell equations) is such that its {\em wave front} in some cases does travel with speed {\em greater} than $c$, the speed of light . In order for a pulse to posses a front that travels with speed $c$, an additional condition must be satisfied, namely the pulse must have finite energy. When this condition is fulfilled the pulse still can show peaks propagating with superluminal (or subluminal) velocities, but now its wave front travels at speed $c$. These results are important because they explain several experimental results obtained in recent experiments, where superluminal velocities have been observed, without implying in any breakdown of the Principle of Relativity.