Cosmological Constant or Intergalactic Dust? Constraints from the Cosmic Far Infrared Background

Abstract

Recent observations of Type Ia SNe at redshifts 0 < z <1 reveal a progressive dimming which has been interpreted as evidence for a cosmological constant of Omega_Lambda ~ 0.7. An alternative explanation of the SN results is an open universe with Omega_Lambda=0 and the presence of > 0.1 micron dust grains with a mass density of Omega_dust ~ (few) * 10^{-5} in the intergalactic (IG) medium. The same dust that dims the SNe absorbs the cosmic UV/optical background radiation around ~ 1 micron, and re-emits it at far infrared (FIR) wavelengths. Here we compare the FIR emission from IG dust with observations of the cosmic microwave (CMB) and cosmic far infrared backgrounds (FIRB) by the DIRBE/FIRAS instruments. We find that the emission would not lead to measurable distortion to the CMB, but would represent a substantial fraction (> 75%) of the measured value of the FIRB in the 300-1000 micron range. This contribution would be marginally consistent with the present unresolved fraction of the observed FIRB in an open universe. However, we find that IG dust probably could not reconcile the standard Omega=1 CDM model with the SN observations, even if the necessary quantity of dust existed. Future observations able to reliably resolve the FIRB to a flux limit of ~0.5 mJy, along with a more precise measure of the coarse-grained FIRB, will provide a definitive test of the IG dust hypothesis in all cosmologies.