No Massive Black-Hole in Cygnus X-3

Abstract

There has been a recent suggestion that Cyg X-3 contains a black hole (BH) of mass ~17 solar mass. This interpretation is closely linked to a previous claim that Cyg X-3 contains a Wolf-Rayet star of mass ~ 10 solar mass. The latter interpretation would imply that the X-ray source in this close binary (P = 4.8 hr) is enshrouded by a relatively cool superstrong wind > 10^{-5} solar mass/yr. It can be shown that such a wind would be completely opaque to the low energy X-rays observed from the source and hence the Wolf-Rayet hypothesis can not be a correct one. By pursuing the same argument it also follows that the compact object must be of modest mass ruling out the existence of a massive BH in Cyg X-3. Note, however, that at present we can not strictly rule out the probable existence of stellar mass BH in Cyg X-3 or any other X-ray binary which are believed to contain a neutron star as the compact object. Yet, a more probable scenario for Cyg X-3 would be one where the compact object is a canonical neutron star (NS) and the companion is an extremely low mass dwarf, ~0.001 solar mass, much like PSR 1957+20.