Confirming the gamma-ray burst spectral-energy correlations in the era of multiple time breaks

Abstract

We test the spectral-energy correlation including the new bursts detected (mostly) by Swift with firm measurements of their redshifts and peak energy. The problem of identifying the jet breaks is discussed in the complex and multibreak/flaring X-ray light curves observed by Swift. We use the optical data as the most reliable source for the identification of the jet break, since the X-ray flux may be produced by a mechanism different from the external shocks between the fireball and the circumburst medium, which are responsible for the optical afterglow. We show that the presence of an underlying SN event in XRF 050416A requires a break to occur in the afterglow optical light curve at around the expected jet break time. The possible presence of a jet break in the optical light curve of GRB 050401 is also discussed. We point out that, for measuring the jet break, it is mandatory that the optical light curve extends after the epoch where the jet break is expected. The interpretation of the early optical breaks in GRB 050922C and GRB 060206 as jet breaks is controversial because they might instead correspond to the flat-to-steep decay transition common in the early X-ray light curves. All the 16 bursts coming from Swift are consistent with the E_p-E_gamma and E_p-E_iso-t_jet correlation. No outlier is found to date. Moreover, the small dispersion of these correlations, confirmed also by the Swift bursts, strengthens the case of using GRBs as standard candles.