Resonance Overlap is Responsible for Ejecting Planets in Binary Systems

Abstract

A planet orbiting around a star in a binary system can be ejected if it lies too far from its host star. We find that instability boundaries first obtained in numerical studies can be explained by overlap between sub-resonances within mean-motion resonances (mostly of the j:1 type). Strong secular forcing from the companion displaces the centroids of different sub-resonances, producing large regions of resonance overlap. Planets lying within these overlapping regions experience chaotic diffusion, which in most cases leads to their eventual ejection. The overlap region extends to shorter-period orbits as either the companion's mass or its eccentricity increase. Our analytical calculations reproduce the instability boundaries observed in numerical studies and yield the following two additional results. Firstly, the instability boundary as a function of eccentricity is jagged; thus, the widest stable orbit could be reduced from previously quoted values by as much as 20%. Secondly, very high order resonances (e.g., 50:3) do not significantly modify the instability boundary despite the fact that these weak resonances can produce slow chaotic diffusion which may be missed by finite-duration numerical integrations. We present some numerical evidence for the first result. More extensive experiments are called for to confirm these conclusions. For the special case of circular binaries, we find that the Hill criterion (based on the critical Jacobi integral) yields an instability boundary that is very similar to that obtained by resonance overlap arguments, making the former both a necessary and a sufficient condition for planet instability.