Hyades Oxygen Abundances from the Lambda 6300 [O I] Line: The Giant-Dwarf Discrepancy Revisited

Abstract

We present the results of our abundance analysis of Fe, Ni, and O in high S/N, high-resolution VLT/UVES and McDonald/2dcoude spectra of nine dwarfs and three giants in the Hyades open cluster. The difference in Fe abundances derived from Fe II and Fe I lines ([Fe II/H] - [Fe I/H]) and Ni I abundances derived from moderately high-excitation (Chi ~ 4.20 eV) lines are found to increase with decreasing T_eff for the dwarfs. Both of these findings are in concordance with previous results of over-excitation/ionization in cool young dwarfs. Oxygen abundances are derived from the Lambda 6300 [O I] line, with careful attention given to the Ni I blend. The dwarf O abundances are in star-to-star agreement within uncertainties, but the abundances of the three coolest dwarfs (4573 < T_eff < 4834 K) evince an increase with decreasing T_eff. Possible causes for the apparent trend are considered, including the effects of over-dissociation of O-containing molecules. O abundances are derived from the near-UV Lambda 3167 OH line in high-quality Keck/HIRES spectra, and no such effects are found- indeed, the OH-based abundances show an increase with decreasing T_eff, leaving the nature and reality of the cool dwarf [O I]-based O trend uncertain. The mean relative O abundance of the six warmest dwarfs (5075 < T_eff < 5978 K) is [O/H] = +0.14 +/- 0.02, and we find a mean abundance of [O/H] = +0.08 +/- 0.02 for the giants. Thus, our updated analysis of the Lambda 6300 [O I] line does not confirm the Hyades giant-dwarf oxygen discrepancy initially reported by King & Hiltgen (1996), suggesting the discrepancy was a consequence of analysis-related systematic errors....