Can the Steep Mass Profile of A1689 Be Explained by a Triaxial Dark Halo?

Abstract

The steep mass profile of A1689 derived from recent detailed lensing observations is not readily reconciled with the low concentration halos predicted by the standard CDM model. However, halo triaxiality may act to bias the profile constraints derived assuming a spherically symmetric mass distribution, since lensing relates only to the projected mass distribution. A degree of halo triaxiality is inherent to the CDM structure formation, arising from the collision-less nature of the dark matter. Here we compare the CDM-based model predictions of triaxial halo with the precise lensing measurements of A1689 based on the ACS/HST and Subaru data, over a wide range of 10kpc<r<2Mpc. The model lensing profiles cover the intrinsic spread of halo mass and shape, and are projected over all inclinations when comparing with the data. We show that the model parameters are only weakly constrained and strongly degenerate mainly because of the lack of information along the line of sight. In particular, the limits on the concentration parameter become less restrictive with increasing triaxiality. Yet, by comparing the obtained constraints with expected probability distributions for the axis ratio and concentration parameters computed from numerical simulations, we find that ~6% of cluster-size halos in the CDM model can match the A1689 lensing observations at the 2-sigma level, corresponding to cases where the major-axis of the halo is aligned with the line of sight. Thus halo triaxiality could reduce the apparent discrepancy between theory and observation. This hypothesis needs to be further explored by a statistical lensing study for other clusters as well as by complementary three-dimensional information derived using X-ray, kinematics, and SZ effect observations.