On the peak radio and X-ray emission from neutron star and black hole candidate X-ray transients

Abstract

We have compiled and analysed reports from the literature of (quasi-)simultaneous observations of X-ray transients at radio and X-ray wavelengths and compared them with each other and with more unusual radio-bright sources such as Cygnus X-3, GRS 1915+105 and Circinus X-1. There exists a significant (>97% likelihood) positive (rank) correlation between the peak X-ray flux P_X and radio flux density P_R for the black hole candidate (BHC) systems, and a marginally significant positive (rank) correlation for the neutron star (NS) systems. This is further evidence for a coupling between accretion and outflows in X-ray binary systems, in this case implying a relation between peak disc-accretion-rate and the number of synchroton-emitting electrons ejected. However, we also show that the distribution of `radio loudness', P_R/P_X, is significantly different for the two samples, in the sense that the BHCs generally have a higher ratio of P_R/P_X. The origin of this discrepancy is uncertain, but probably reflects differences in the energetics and/or radiative efficiency of flows around the neutron stars and black holes; we briefly discuss some of these possibilities. We conclude that these data point to the formation of a mildly relativistic jet whose luminosity is a function of the accretion rate, in the majority, if not all, of X-ray transient outbursts, but whose relation to the observed X-ray emission is dependent on the nature of the accreting compact object. (Abridged).