Low-ionization structures in planetary nebulae: confronting models with observations

Abstract

Around 50 PNe are presently known to possess "small-scale" low-ionization structures (LISs). We consider here jets, jet-like, symmetrical and non-symmetrical LISs and present a detailed comparison of the existing model predictions with the observational morphological and kinematical properties. We find that nebulae with LISs appear indistinctly spread among all morphological classes of PNe, indicating that the processes leading to the formation of LISs are not necessarily related to those responsible for the asphericity of the large-scale morphological components of PNe. We show that both the observed velocities and locations of most non-symmetrical LISs can be reasonably well reproduced assuming either fossil condensations originated in the AGB wind or in-situ instabilities. The jet models proposed to date (HD and MHD interacting winds or accretion-disk collimated winds) appear unable to account simultaneously for the kinematical ages and the angle between the jet and the symmetry axes of the nebulae. The linear increase in velocity observed in several jets favors MHD confinement compared to pure HD interacting wind models. On the other hand, we find that the formation of jet-like systems characterized by relatively low expansion velocities cannot be explained by any of the existing models. Finally, the knots which appear in symmetrical and opposite pairs of low velocity could be understood as the survival of fossil (symmetrical) condensations formed during the AGB phase or as structures that have experienced substantial slowing down by the ambient medium.