arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv · 2611.18541

No free lattice contains an infinite ascending chain of copies of FL(3)

Abstract

No free lattice contains an infinite strictly ascending chain of sublattices isomorphic to FL(3), the free lattice on three generators; this answers a question that R. A. Dean asked and the second author's 1997 notes on the problem left open. Every such chain would yield, inside FL(3), a coherent chain of proper self-embeddings $Θ_0, Θ_1, Θ_2, \dots$ with $Θ_k \circ Θ_j = Θ_j$ for $j < k$, so that each later embedding fixes the image of each earlier one pointwise. Every proper self-embedding of FL(3) whose fixed sublattice contains a free generating triple fixes one of the three generators, say $z$, because a power of it or of its dual lies above the identity, and a self-embedding that moves every generator and lies above the identity fixes at most eleven elements. Up to duality, a proper self-embedding fixing the image of such a $Θ_1$ pointwise fixes only elements above $z \wedge (x \vee y)$, where no free generating triple containing $z$ can lie. We also verify the one-step example of the 1997 notes, prove that no step toward such a chain is self-similar, and show that the configuration the argument rules out at length three does occur at length two. Without freeness the answer reverses: FL(3) contains an infinite strictly ascending chain of 3-generated sublattices, so the lattice analogue of Takahasi's chain condition for free groups fails. The theorem itself is checked by the Agda proof assistant under its safe flags, for free lattices over generators with decidable equality, and its formal proof uses no classical principle: finite searches and an induction on a finite set replace the infinite pigeonhole principle by which a chain yields a coherent chain.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

William DeMeo, Ralph Freese. 2026-11-13. No free lattice contains an infinite ascending chain of copies of FL(3). https://arxiv.science/abs/2611.18541

Citations retain the original authors and DOI and include this site’s record URL. If this discovery service contributed to your research, you can also cite arXiv Science by Indiciae: BibTeX · RIS.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Extremely proximal actions and primitivity of group rings

We present a purely dynamical criterion for the primitivity of group rings. To be precise, we show that if $G$ is a countable group that admits a topologically free, extremely proximal action, then the group ring $KG$ is primitive for any field $K$. Our criterion recovers several of the existing results on primitivity and applies to new examples, such as the commensurator groups of torsion-free non-elementary hyperbolic groups, some Kac-Moody groups, and other weakly hyperbolic groups.

math.RA↗

Self-injective dimensions and Iyama grade dualities over Noether algebras

Let $A$ be an algebra module-finite over a commutative Noetherian ring. We first establish a local criterion for the $n$-Gorenstein condition in terms of the grades and flat dimensions of injective envelopes of simple modules over central localizations. As a main application, we give an affirmative answer, in this module-finite setting, to a question of Huang on the symmetry of finite self-injective dimension under the Auslander condition. We also show that $A$ is Auslander--Gorenstein if and only if it is Iwanaga--Gorenstein and has the fiberwise Iyama grade duality. For Cohen--Macaulay algebras, central regular reductions to Artin algebras allow both the Auslander condition and the grade duality to be tested on simple modules over $A$ itself.

math.RA↗

Classification problems for diassociative and dendriform algebras: a survey

Diassociative algebras (associative dialgebras) and dendriform algebras are vector spaces with two binary operations, introduced by J.-L. Loday in the study of Leibniz algebras; their operads are Koszul dual to each other. We survey the classification problem for these two classes, including the Zinbiel algebras, the commutative dendriform algebras, which are Koszul dual to Leibniz algebras. We recall the definitions, the main examples and the Loday diagram with its extension by left-symmetric algebras and dialgebras, and describe the methods used to classify algebras of small dimension: direct computation from lists of associative algebras, annihilator (central) extensions and geometric classification by degenerations. We then collect, by dimension, the known algebraic classifications of diassociative algebras, dendriform algebras and their commutative case, the Zinbiel algebras, point out lists that later work corrected, and summarise the cohomological results that the methods rely on. We close with a list of open problems.

math.RA↗