arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv · 2611.13266

Challenging the hoop conjecture with spinning pancakes and baguettes

Abstract

Understanding when gravitational collapse produces a black hole remains a central challenge in general relativity. Black-hole uniqueness results characterize the stationary endpoint under suitable assumptions, while singularity theorems establish geodesic incompleteness in the presence of trapped surfaces and appropriate energy and global conditions. Neither, however, provides a general criterion for horizon formation. The hoop conjecture offers such a criterion by relating the enclosed mass to the compactness of a matter distribution in every direction. We construct axisymmetric families of initial data describing rotating dust and test a formulation of the conjecture adapted to this setting. We explore highly prolate and oblate configurations with both constant and differential rescaled angular-velocity profiles, including configurations near the threshold for apparent-horizon formation. We find that the conjecture holds for rotating configurations, with a coefficient within 14% of unity as in the nonrotating case, provided the quasilocal mass includes the rotational energy. If the irreducible mass of the apparent horizon is used instead, the deviations grow with spin, as they do for Kerr black holes. For horizonless configurations, the conjecture likewise holds when the mass is restricted to the energy enclosed by the matter surface, whereas using the ADM mass, which also includes rotational field energy outside the matter, leads to apparent violations of up to $\approx$25%. We also discuss the possible evolution of compact configurations without apparent horizons, their relation to weak cosmic censorship, and their implications for horizonless compact objects.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Robin Croft, Gerardo García-Moreno, Paolo Pani. 2026-11-16. Challenging the hoop conjecture with spinning pancakes and baguettes. https://arxiv.science/abs/2611.13266

Citations retain the original authors and DOI and include this site’s record URL. If this discovery service contributed to your research, you can also cite arXiv Science by Indiciae: BibTeX · RIS.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Quantum-information bounds on black-hole evaporation and de Sitter expansion

It is well-known that the unitary nature of black hole evaporation enforces its entropy evolution to follow the Page curve. In this Letter, we further explore the outcome of the quantum speed limit on how fast a quantum system can evolve unitarily. When combined with the maximal information transmission bound, we place upper limits on the evaporation rates of dynamical black-hole entropy and mass that are otherwise divergent at the very end of the Hawking evaporation, during which the Penrose inequality from the cosmic censorship conjecture is consistently obeyed. Further applying the maximal information transmission bound to an effective-field-theory description for all sub-horizon regions of a de Sitter space would sufficiently reproduce a weaker trans-Planckian censorship conjecture up to a numeric prefactor conditionally.

gr-qc↗

Quantum particle production and radiative properties of a new bumblebee black hole

In this work, we investigate the quantum and radiative properties of a recently proposed static bumblebee black hole arising from a general Lorentz-violating vacuum configuration. The analysis begins with the geometric structure of the solution and the thermodynamic temperature obtained from the surface-gravity prescription. The associated thermodynamic topological structure is also examined. Quantum particle production is then analyzed for bosonic and fermionic fields using the tunneling method. Analytic greybody bounds are derived for spin-0, spin-1, spin-2, and spin-1/2 fields. Furthermore, full greybody factors are computed with the sixth-order WKB method, together with the corresponding absorption cross sections and their characteristic spin-dependent peak patterns. These results support the evaluation of the evaporation lifetimes and the emission rates of energy and particle modes associated with each spin contribution, followed by a comparison of the high-frequency regime with other Lorentz-violating geometries, including the metric bumblebee, metric-affine bumblebee, Kalb-Ramond, and non-commutative Kalb-Ramond black holes. In addition, greybody factors are obtained using a quasinormal-mode-based prescription.

gr-qc↗

Inter-detector correlations in LIGO-Virgo strain: an exploratory study and possible astrophysical implications

We investigate inter-detector correlations in public LIGO-Virgo strain around nine O2 and O3 events, using a band-pass-only statistic without waveform-template fitting. The primary sample comprises 27 event-pair measurements, with three complementary measurements for GW191127. Event-window maxima over $|τ|\leq35$ ms are compared with 200 surrounding off-source maxima. With verified fractional catalog epochs, seven of the 27 primary event-pair measurements, all H1$\times$L1, reach the local finite-background floor $p=1/201$. No individual comparison passes a Holm correction at 5% for this family; the available background limits the attainable tail resolution. Complementary comparisons of simultaneous and time-displaced off-source data show processing-dependent structure, including a local excess near GW200219 that does not recur at comparable size in the additional segments examined. We discuss the possibility that part of the strain classified operationally as noise contains an astrophysical contribution, including an accumulated gravitational-radiation background associated with Bondi radiative processes.

gr-qc↗