arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv · 2611.11443

Finite models for the order axioms of the Hilbert Plane: Redundancies and Finite Independence Models

Abstract

Results on the redundancy and on the independence of the order axioms of the Hilbert plane are scattered in the literature, from Veblen's 1904 remark that the independence of the axioms of order can be shown by finite models to the redundancies removed from Hilbert's axioms of order in later editions of the Grundlagen. The aim of this note is to collect them in an organic and self-contained form for the incidence and order axioms as presented by Greenberg. In doing so we single out three redundancies inside the order axioms: the symmetry of betweenness, the existence part of trichotomy, and the second clause of plane separation. Each of them dictates which part of the corresponding axiom an independence model must violate, and we give explicit finite models of three, three, nine and twenty-five points. A model of all the incidence and order axioms, on the contrary, is necessarily infinite, so the independence of any axiom added to them requires infinite models; for two of the order axioms the finite models also give independence from all the remaining axioms of the Hilbert plane.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Roberto Volpe. 2026-11-08. Finite models for the order axioms of the Hilbert Plane: Redundancies and Finite Independence Models. https://arxiv.science/abs/2611.11443

Citations retain the original authors and DOI and include this site’s record URL. If this discovery service contributed to your research, you can also cite arXiv Science by Indiciae: BibTeX · RIS.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Frege's logic in Grundgesetze is nonclassical

I show that the axioms and rules of inference about the horizontal in the subsystem of Grundgesetze without value-ranges fail to capture its intended interpretation. That is, I build a nonstandard model in which $-a$ is the true iff $a$ is not the false, thereby confirming a conjecture made by Landini that $a \to (-a) = a$ is not provable in this subsystem. This motivates our main result, namely, soundness and completeness proofs for the first-order fragment without value-ranges with respect to a new nonclassical semantics of boolean truncation. Simply put, the widespread assumption that Grundgesetze's first-order logic is classical first-order logic is mistaken.

math.HO↗

Sophie Germain, mathématicienne extraordinaire: A story stranger than fiction. Sophie Germain, mathématicienne extraordinaire: une histoire plus étrange qu'une fiction

English: Sophie Germain (1776-1831) is the first woman known for important original research in mathematics, specifically in elasticity theory and number theory. We outline Germain's recently unearthed number theory results on Fermat's Last Theorem, in the context of her life, work, and interactions with Lagrange, Legendre, and Gauss. For two centuries her accomplishment was thought to consist of a single theorem attributed to her by Legendre, the first general result towards proving Fermat's Last Theorem. But recent discoveries in her handwritten manuscripts and correspondence show that she accomplished much more, albeit forgotten. In particular, she had a plan for proving Fermat's Last Theorem in its entirety, and carried this plan far, using then new tools, e.g., congruence, modular primitive roots, and permutations. Français: Sophie Germain (1776-1831) est la première femme connu pour des recherches originales importantes en mathématiques, en particulier en théorie de l'élasticité et en théorie des nombres. Nous exposons les résultats récemment découverts de Germain en théorie des nombres sur le dernier théorème de Fermat, dans le contexte de sa vie, de son oeuvre et de ses interactions avec Lagrange, Legendre et Gauss. Pendant deux siècles, ses résultats ont été considérés comme formant un seul théorème, attribué à elle par Legendre, et qui était le premier résultat général pour démontrer le dernier théorème de Fermat. Mais des découvertes récentes dans ses manuscrits et sa correspondance montrent qu'elle a accompli bien plus, quoique ce fut oublié. En particulier, elle avait un plan pour démontrer dans son intégralité le dernier théorème de Fermat, et elle a mené loin ce plan, utilisant alors de nouveaux outils, par exemple, la congruence, les racines primitives modulaires et les permutations.

math.HO↗

From Objective Compromise to Structure-Enabled Intelligence: Reshaping the Scientific Paradigm of AI

Mainstream artificial intelligence systems, particularly Large Language Models (LLMs), are fundamentally constructed upon the Optimization-Driven (OD) paradigm. This paradigm can be characterized as an ill-posed optimization problem within a high-dimensional parameter space. When confronted with real-world scenarios characterized by noise and conflicting constraints, the logic of global error minimization inherently induces a strong smoothing effect. Consequently, this yields statistical compromise solutions that flatten local features, making it arduous to overcome the inherent bottleneck of Out-of-Distribution (OOD) generalization. Existing AI models generate outputs purely based on statistical probabilities. They lack the capacity to autonomously discern truth from falsehood or establish causal logic, thereby lacking genuine cognitive intelligence. To address the ontological limitations of the OD paradigm, this paper proposes a novel paradigm termed \textit{Structure-Enabled Intelligence}. This approach abandons the conventional path of relying solely on computing power scaling and data fitting to achieve emergent intelligence. Instead, it embeds mathematical structures and physical mechanisms as underlying priors into the algorithmic architecture, constraining the model's solving process with structured scientific rules. Through this paradigm shift from ``data-driven objective fitting'' to ``mechanism-structure dominance,'' the proposed approach fundamentally mitigates the issue of statistical compromise, enhances the model's extrapolation and generalization capabilities, and simultaneously reshapes human-AI synergy by upholding human subjectivity in scientific cognition.

math.HO↗