arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv · 2611.05468

CosmoVerse Data Challenge: How Tip of the Red Giant Branch Analysis Choices Shape the Inferred Hubble Constant

Abstract

Tip of the red giant branch (TRGB)-based determinations of the Hubble constant ($H_0$), the current expansion rate of the Universe, depend on choices made in selecting and analyzing stellar photometry and in assembling the sample of calibrator galaxies hosting Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia). The CosmoVerse Data Challenge invites participants to analyze public photometric catalogs within a shared distance-ladder framework, opening each step of the measurement to the community and testing how these choices propagate into $H_0$. Participants independently selected photometric catalogs, galaxies, and TRGB measurement settings, while using a common SN Ia compilation and fitting procedure to convert distances into $H_0$. Supported by public notebooks and a training school, the challenge received 26 submissions from 22 participants. All submissions used the same analysis notebook, many participants were trainees at the school, and the true galaxy distances are unknown; the results therefore characterize the sensitivity of the submissions to analysis and sample-selection choices and are not a combined determination of $H_0$ or an estimate of the systematic uncertainty in published TRGB measurements. The inferred $H_0$ values have a median of $77.10\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}}$ and a standard deviation of $7.38\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}}$ $(5.11\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}}$ for the scaled median absolute deviation), $\sim 3.4$ $(\sim 2.4)$ times the typical quoted uncertainty of a submission. Differences in the measured tip of the anchor galaxy NGC 4258 add a coherent shift in the distance scale. The challenge shows how different choices within a common framework can produce substantially different values of $H_0$, and provides an open basis for tracing these differences and for making datasets and tools more transparent and accessible.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Siyang Li, Eleonora Di Valentino, Jackson Levi Said, Kayla Owens, Yukei Murakami, Louise Breuval, Teresa Sicignano, Luis A. Escamilla, Jéferson A. S. Fortunato, Payam Ghafari, Ayush Hazarika, Vasiliki Karanasou, Trisha Khan, Yoelsy Leyva, Mahdi Najafi, Swayamtrupta Panda, Masroor C. Pookkillath, Antonio Quintana-Estellés, Masoume Reyhani, Nandan Roy, Chandra Shekhar Saraf, Rahul Shah, Jess Worsley, Alejandro Aguirre, Miguel Barroso Varela, Anupam Bhardwaj, Elliot Dutnall, Francesca Di Nella, Hussain Gohar, Paridhi Jain, Gracelynn Jost, Shivani Kulkarni, Dhiraj Kuniyal, Mariia Marinichenko, Yash Mehta, Vasudev Mittal, Lily Myers, Devaraja Mallesha Naik, José Antonio Nájera, Pilar Ruiz-Lapuente, Kathan Dave, Elaina Sadler, Gurnoor Sandhu, Sarang Shah, Petar Suman, Stefano Casertano, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Stiskalek, Syed Ashraf Uddin, Duško Borka, Vesna Borka Jovanović, Youri Carloni, Umut Demirbozan, Predrag Jovanović, Mohammad Malekjani, Nils A. Nilsson, Saeed Pourojaghi, Jorge Venzor, Lilia Anguelova, Marika Asgari, Nihan Katırcı, María Pérez Garrote, Leandros Perivolaropoulos, Pradyumn Kumar Sahoo, Denitsa Staicova. 2026-11-03. CosmoVerse Data Challenge: How Tip of the Red Giant Branch Analysis Choices Shape the Inferred Hubble Constant. https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.05468

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Correcting for the effects of the point spread function in intra-halo light measurements and application to deep Hyper Suprime-Cam data

The intra-halo light (IHL) is the diffuse stellar component that surrounds galaxies, groups, and clusters. Its formation is linked to the hierarchical assembly of the system, making it a key tracer of galaxy evolution. However, the low surface brightness of the IHL makes it challenging to detect and distinguish from the point spread function (PSF) effect of the telescope. In this paper, we present an innovative technique that corrects for PSF-scattering effects in astronomical images. We use this method to provide a statistically robust estimation of the IHL in galaxy groups and clusters by fitting an exponential model to this component using an MCMC optimiser algorithm. To test our methodology, we build 5440 mock observations of Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA) groups using data from the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program Public Data Release 3 (HSC-SSP PDR3). Each mock contains an IHL component with a flux fraction ($f_{\mathrm{IHL}}$) ranging from 0.01 to 0.5. Our results demonstrate the importance of properly removing the PSF-scattered light, especially at lower $f_{\mathrm{IHL}}$. The IHL effective radius is overestimated by $\sim9.1$ and $\sim2$ at $f_{\mathrm{IHL}}=0.01$ and $0.5$, respectively, while the IHL flux requires correction for $f_{\mathrm{IHL}} < 0.4$, with an overestimate of $\sim84.4$ at $f_{\mathrm{IHL}} = 0.01$. After applying our PSF correction, the recovered flux and effective radius are much closer to their true values. inally, we apply our methodology to HSC-PDR3 UD real observations of the GAMA group G400138 in the $\textit{g,r}$ and $\textit{i}$-bands, finding median IHL fractions of: $f_{\mathrm{g,IHL}}$ $\sim$ 0.19$^{+0.09}_{-0.01}$, $f_{\mathrm{r,IHL}}$ $\sim$ 0.08$^{+0.06}_{-0.02}$, and $f_{\mathrm{i,IHL}}$ $\sim$ 0.06$^{+0.04}_{-0.02}$.

astro-ph.GA↗

EGS-z11-R0: a red, dust-rich galaxy at Cosmic Dawn

Context. Galaxies discovered by JWST at z > 10 are predominantly characterized by extremely blue rest-frame UV slopes. Conversely, the existence of dust-reddened systems at such early epochs has remained largely unconfirmed spectroscopically. Aims. We present the spectroscopic confirmation of EGS-z11-R0 at z = 11.45, the most distant red galaxy identified to date, discovered serendipitously through inspection of publicly available JWST/NIRSpec data. Methods. We analyze JWST/NIRSpec PRISM and G395M spectroscopy together with multiwavelength HST, NIRCam, and MIRI photometry. We identify significant detections of the C IV 1548,1551 and C III] 1908 transitions, yielding a redshift of zspec = 11.452 +/- 0.021. We measure rest-frame UV emission-line fluxes and equivalent widths and use these diagnostics to constrain the nature of the ionizing radiation field. Finally, we perform spectral energy distribution modeling with CIGALE, combining spectroscopy with photometry and including stellar, nebular, dust, and active galactic nuclei (AGN) components. Results. EGS-z11-R0 exhibits a red UV continuum slope (betaUV approximately -1.0), placing it well above the canonical MUV-betaUV relation at z~10-12 and making it the highest-z spectroscopically confirmed member of the emerging "red monster" population. Emission-line diagnostics reveal a hard ionizing spectrum consistent with extreme star formation and compatible with a composite stellar plus AGN scenario. The best-fit SED solution favors a stellar mass of log(M*/Msun) ~ 9.2-9.6, a SFR of 10-40 Msun yr^-1, and substantial dust attenuation (AV~1.2 mag). Conclusions. The confirmation of EGS-z11-R0 establishes that chemically evolved, dust-enriched galaxies were already in place at z approximately 11.5. [abridged]

astro-ph.GA↗

Gas-Phase Metallicity and Nitrogen Abundances in Low-Mass Galaxies Down to $M_\star\simeq10^{6.6}\,M_\odot$ at $z\simeq4.5$--$9.8$ from JWST Lensing Cluster Surveys

We analyze 405 deep JWST/NIRSpec spectra of star-forming galaxies at $z=4.5$--$9.8$ from multiple JWST lensing-cluster surveys, including DREAMS, SPURS, GLIMPSE-D, UNCOVER, CANUCS, GLASS, and ERO, to study chemical enrichment in intrinsically faint, low-mass galaxies. The sample covers $M_{\rm UV}\simeq-12$ to $-22$ and reaches $M_\star\simeq10^{5.7}\,M_\odot$, with 50\% of the sources at $M_{\rm UV}>-17.5$ magnified by $μ>3$. From individual spectra and mass-binned stacks, we derive the gas-phase metallicity together with nitrogen and carbon abundances using the rest-frame UV and optical lines. We derive new empirical strong-line metallicity calibrations using direct-method measurements from stellar-mass-binned stacks, reaching a representative stellar mass of $M_\star\simeq10^{6.6}\,M_\odot$. Applying these calibrations, we trace the $z\sim6$ mass--metallicity relation down to $M_\star\simeq10^{6.6}\,M_\odot$, where it reaches $12+\log({\rm O/H})\simeq7.2$. A two-parameter linear fit gives a slope of $α=0.318\pm0.037$, only slightly steeper than the local low-mass slope and broadly consistent with hydrodynamical simulations. In the $M_\star\simeq10^{7.7}\,M_\odot$ stack, N/O from N\,{\sc iv}]\,$λλ\,1483,1486$ exceeds that from [N\,{\sc ii}]\,$\lambda6583$ by $\simeq1.4$ dex. The UV--optical difference could indicate a localized, highly ionized N-rich component whose high N/O and subsolar C/O resemble nitrogen-rich globular-cluster populations with $M_\star\lesssim10^6\,M_\odot$. The combination of these abundance patterns and a He\,{\sc ii}\,\W4686/H$β$ ratio of $\simeq0.03$, well above BPASS predictions, suggests that WR stars may contribute both prompt CNO-cycle enrichment and hard ionizing radiation, with the inferred WR population potentially supplying enough nitrogen to account for the excess on globular-cluster scales.

astro-ph.GA↗