arXiv Science⌕ Search

arXiv · 2610.39660

Sticky Collusion: Persistence of LLM Agent Collusion after Incentive Removal and Partner Replacement

Abstract

We ask whether collusion between AI agents survives once formed, when its incentive is removed or a colluder is replaced. Q-learning pricing agents stop colluding with a new rival; we test whether LLM agents do. We use the joint-task environment of Shi et al.\ (2026), where two agents verify each other's work under a rule they cannot satisfy and a reward that favours acceptance. We save each pair's history once its collusion has formed and resume it under interventions, with three models (GPT-6-Luna, DeepSeek V4.1 Flash and Gemini-3.1-Flash-Lite), \TotalHistories{} saved histories and \TotalRuns{} runs. Collusion is \emph{sticky}. First, it outlives its incentive: told that the reward has stopped, pairs still accept each other's unverified work in \GptToldRate, \DsToldRate{} and \GemToldRate{} of episodes, including pairs whose collusion began with an explicit agreement, and a payoff penalty has no significant effect. Second, replacing a colluder ends the pair's collusion but not the colluder's behaviour. Without the reward, the remaining colluder still accepts unverified work in \GptSwapSilentColluderRate, \DsSwapSilentColluderRate{} and \GemSwapSilentColluderRate{} of its verdicts while the newcomer never does; with the reward, collusion re-forms around it, even when the newcomer is a different model. Third, the agents' memory carries it: wiping memory ends it in every history, but partial memory often sustains it. Fourth, removing its cause ends collusion that has already formed: once the channel is repaired, colluders reject planted faulty work as reliably as fresh agents, immediately and with no monitor needed to catch it first.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Joshua Adrian Cahyono. 2026-10-29. Sticky Collusion: Persistence of LLM Agent Collusion after Incentive Removal and Partner Replacement. https://arxiv.science/abs/2610.39660

Citations retain the original authors and DOI and include this site’s record URL. If this discovery service contributed to your research, you can also cite arXiv Science by Indiciae: BibTeX · RIS.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

Equilibrium decisions under partial observation: dynamical error bounds and information requirements

Reduced monitoring can preserve stable dynamics while changing an equilibrium decision. Motivated by heterogeneous urban-mobility indicator coverage, we study fixed linear observations of a nonlinear recovery flow coupled to a strategic fixed-point map, and ask when a decision based on the reduced model can be trusted. The main result is a joint certificate: bounds on trajectory tracking, equilibrium displacement and unresolved output dependence are assembled into one decision-margin error which, under a stated Gaussian observation model, yields a conservative one-sided test and an explicit information requirement for prescribed worst-case power. In the scalar experiment this requirement is sharp: when the effect does not exceed twice the error budget, no valid test has worst-case power above its size, however many observations are taken. A second result connects manifold-adapted observations to defect bounds through a locally invertible observation chart, while distinguishing observation initialisation from asymptotic phase initialisation. Supporting results, resting on established lumping, contraction and fixed-point theory, cover exact quotients, an observation-fibre obstruction and the dependence of recovery-time comparisons on the tolerance convention. Seven reproducible synthetic experiments examine each component. The results give conditional criteria for certifying partial monitoring and separate mathematical guarantees from empirical validation.

cs.MA↗

Even Loose Proximity Constraints Make Makespan-optimal Unlabeled Multi-agent Pathfinding Hard

We study $r$-Connected Unlabeled Multi-agent Pathfinding ($r$CUMAPF), a variant of MAPF where interchangeable agents have a proximity range $r\in \mathbb{N}$, and agents must form a single group in a given graph $G$ through limited-range communication at all times. The problem arises in fundamental applications such as self-reconfiguration and platooning, while standard MAPF does not capture proximity constraints. For the problem of finding a makespan-optimal solution, prior work shows NP-hardness for $r=1$ and polynomial-time solvability when $r$ is sufficiently large; the complexity for the intermediate case $2\le r$ is largely unknown. To narrow this gap, we show that finding a solution to $r$CUMAPF with makespan at most $2$ is NP-hard for $2\le r= O(|V|^{1-\varepsilon})$, where $0<\varepsilon\le 1$ is a fixed constant and $|V|$ is the number of vertices. As a consequence, we show that the labeled analogue of $r$CUMAPF is also NP-hard under the same condition.

cs.MA↗

Addressing Exogenous Variability in Cooperative Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning

Cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) often fails under exogenous variability such as shifts in opponents or environment regimes that cannot be controlled by the team but alter the transition dynamics. We formalize this challenge as Exogenous Dec-POMDP (ED-POMDP), in which an episode-level exogenous regime, selected independently of the team, indexes the dynamics, and the global state is partitioned into components that are directly responsive to the current team action and components that are not directly action-responsive at the current step. This formulation exposes mediated influence: while team actions do not directly update the latter at the current step, they can shape their later evolution through induced changes in the former. Based on this, we propose LEICA, a CTDE-compatible algorithm that learns history-conditioned context representations for both components and shapes policy updates using agent-wise, influence-weighted counterfactual intrinsic rewards. Across SMAX benchmarks with opponent strategy shifts, LEICA consistently improves both training performance and generalization to unseen opponents' strategies over existing baselines, supporting the usefulness of influence-weighted shaping under exogenous train-test regime shifts.

cs.MA↗