Gravity, Entropy, and the Second Law: A Pedagogical Perspective

Jorge Pinochet; Giorgio Sonnino

Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2610.08832

Gravity, Entropy, and the Second Law: A Pedagogical Perspective

Jorge Pinochet·Giorgio Sonnino

View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

An interesting question for discussion in university physics courses is whether gravity can conflict with the second law of thermodynamics. In this work, we address this question by comparing the behavior of an ideal gas in two conceptually different regimes: one in which gravitational effects can be neglected and another in which self-gravity becomes important. In the first case, free expansion provides the familiar example in which an increase in the volume accessible to the gas leads to an increase in entropy. Self-gravitating systems behave differently: gravitational contraction can reduce the volume occupied by matter while releasing energy and increasing the entropy of the surroundings. This illustrates why the usual intuition that increasing entropy necessarily corresponds to increasing spatial dispersion cannot be applied directly to self-gravitating systems. Using elementary thermodynamic arguments and a minimal amount of mathematics, we discuss this apparent tension and show how entropy must be considered for the complete system, including emitted radiation. The discussion is finally extended to black holes and Hawking radiation, where the appropriate framework is the generalized second law of thermodynamics. The analysis is intended to provide a pedagogical bridge between elementary thermodynamics and some of the distinctive thermodynamic properties of gravitating systems.

Explore related subjects

physics.gen-ph

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Jorge Pinochet, Giorgio Sonnino. 2026-09-27. Gravity, Entropy, and the Second Law: A Pedagogical Perspective. https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.08832

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

On the Meaning of Localization in Non-Local Quantum Field Theory

In this paper we explore and derive an uncertainty principle for an ultraviolet complete nonlocal quantum field theory where under our hypothesises of an induced equal time detector response kernel, we then prove that the observed localization width obeys an exact variance addition law. Then when we combine this with the ordinary Heisenberg inequality and we obtain a nonlocal uncertainty relation. The bound reduces to the usual local relation in the infrared or local limit when $E_M \to \infty$, while in the ultraviolet it implies a minimal localization length of order $L_M$. We go on to explain what this means for locality, microcausality, the interpretation of spacetime points, and the ultraviolet structure of quantum field theory. In this formulation we note and prove that spacetime will remain a Lorentz covariant continuum at the level of the manifold description but pointlike localization ceases to be a physically realizable observable notion below the nonlocality scale.

physics.gen-ph↗

arXiv2026

Physics-integrated neural network modeling of heat and mass transfer in cryogenic liquid storage under static and dynamic conditions

Accurate system-level prediction of cryogenic liquid storage remains challenging because reduced-order models rely on regime-dependent closures for unresolved heat and mass transfer, particularly under sloshing. We present a physics-integrated neural-network framework that combines a conservation-based zero-dimensional nodal model with data-driven closures for wall and interfacial heat transfer, phase change, pressurant quality, and liquid thermal-boundary-layer evolution. Thermal stratification and mixing within the liquid are represented through a first-order dynamical model for the boundary-layer thickness, while four operating-regime-specific neural networks infer the closure parameters for self-pressurization and relaxation, active pressurization, venting, and lateral sloshing. The framework was identified and evaluated using a dedicated database of 48 multi-stage cryogenic-tank experiments conducted in an optically accessible facility operated with liquid nitrogen. The experiments combine controlled wall heating, vapor injection and evacuation, and forced lateral sloshing, thereby covering both slowly evolving thermal states and strongly transient operating conditions. Generalization was assessed through experiment-level K-fold cross-validation, while an entropy-production penalty was included in the loss function to discourage violations of the second law of thermodynamics. Across the investigated cross-validation configurations, the global normalized root-mean-square error remained under 3%, with sloshing representing the most demanding regime. A final model trained on the complete database reconstructed the experiments with a global error of 1.6%. These results demonstrate that the proposed framework can extract physically interpretable and computationally efficient closure laws from a limited but information-rich experimental database.

physics.gen-ph↗

arXiv2026

Metric Variation of the Energy-Momentum Tensor of a Perfect Fluid and Its Applications to Cosmology and Neutron Stars

We show that the expressions for the matter Lagrangian $L_m$ and the metric variation $δT_{μν}$ of a perfect fluid obtained in previous studies appear to be inconsistent with the standard energy-momentum tensor under general conditions. Consequently, a large number of studies in astrophysics and cosmology relying on these expressions may need to be re-examined. By performing a series of straightforward calculations directly on the standard energy-momentum tensor $T_{μν}$ together with the particle number conservation condition, we derive an expression for $δT_{μν}$ that is independent of the choice of $L_m$. Applying this result to $f(R,T)$ gravity, we obtain the exact form of the tensor $Θ_{μν} = g^{σρ} \frac{δT_{σρ}}{δg^{μν}}$, which remains an important yet long-standing controversial quantity. This expression is shown to hold also for radiation, regardless of whether particle number is conserved. A major result is that if the energy-momentum tensor $T_{μν}$ of the Universe consists solely of standard components (baryonic/cold dark matter, radiation, and the cosmological constant), then $f(R,T)$ gravity satisfies the conservation law $\nabla_μT^{μν} = 0$ for any function $f(R,T)$. This contrasts with previous studies, which found that the conservation law holds only for a restricted class of $f(R,T)$ functions. Applying the same formalism to stellar interiors, we derive a class of functions that preserve the conservation law. We construct a specific $f(R,T)$ model that is consistent at both cosmological scales and in high-density objects such as neutron stars. Remarkably, the same parameter set in this model simultaneously alleviates the Hubble tension and reproduces the observed mass-radius (M--R) relation of neutron stars.

physics.gen-ph↗