Less is Moore

Abstract

A Moore graph simultaneously asks for two things that normally pull in opposite directions: every vertex should have many neighbors, while every pair of vertices should remain close. For diameter two and degree $k$, the Moore bound is $k^2+1$, and equality forces a remarkably rigid graph: it is strongly regular with parameters $(k^2+1,k,0,1)$. Hoffman and Singleton showed that such a graph can exist only for $k=2,3,7$, and possibly 57. The degree-57 case on 3,250 vertices remains open. This paper is not an attempt to settle that open problem. Instead, we ask a more algorithmic question: How efficiently can the defining Moore structure itself be searched exactly? We begin from a human-developed exhaustive search based on the radius-two Moore tree. Leaves fall into $k$ groups of size $k-1$, and the edges between every pair of such groups form a perfect matching - a permutation. For efficiency, a partial construction is abandoned immediately when it creates a triangle or quadrangle. We then describe a sequence of exact algorithm-engineering improvements developed through a human-guided AI process and accepted only after mathematical checking and controlled regression tests. The main steps are reversible short-cycle forbid counters, bit-parallel domains, minimum-remaining-value branching, singleton propagation, matching-based AllDifferent filtering, balanced replayable parallel frontiers, residual-symmetry orbit pruning, and canonical deduplication of frontier states. On the principal $k=9$ benchmark, stronger symmetry cuts wall time from 47.6 to 17.9 seconds on a six-core laptop setup. Further parallelization speedup is reported separately; on a 16-core/32-thread machine, median wall time is reduced to 5.28 seconds. Degrees 10 and 57 are used as stress tests, and a five-minute degree-57 run uses only 161 MiB peak resident memory, showing that state size is modest.