Learning in Large Populations With Anticipatory Payoffs: Bregman Meets Willems and Lyapunov

Abstract

We study evolutionary Nash equilibrium learning in large populations whose payoffs are generated by dynamic mechanisms. Counterclockwise dissipativity (CCW) provides a passivity-like framework for establishing learning/convergence under a broad convex cone of so-called well-behaved learning rules satisfying a natural payoff-alignment condition according to which, away from equilibria, the population's state (strategic profile) moves in a direction positively correlated with the payoffs. The cone is closed under conic combinations and encompasses a broad range of noise-free rules, including discontinuous rules such as best response, imitative rules such as the replicator rule that is not $δ$-passive, and all noise-free $δ$-passive rules. Existing CCW results require no knowledge of the particular rule, but establish convergence without providing a Lyapunov function or Lyapunov stability. We develop a methodology that closes this gap by constructing rule-independent Lyapunov functions from CCW storage functions of the payoff mechanism. For a nonlinear class of anticipatory mechanisms, in which agents compare current payoffs with those associated with a smoothed population state, we show that a storage can be derived as a Bregman divergence. The resulting Lyapunov function combines a potential gap with this divergence and establishes global asymptotic stability. A congestion game with a nonlinear congestion-growth toll illustrates the results.