Absence of universal backscattering immunity in reciprocal photonic waveguides

Abstract

Suppressing parasitic back-reflection caused by imperfections, such as random defects, material inhomogeneities, localized inclusions, and fabrication-induced geometric deviations, has long been a central objective in optical-waveguide engineering. In this Letter, we theoretically establish that universal immunity to backscattering from arbitrary disorder is fundamentally impossible in reciprocal optical waveguides, irrespective of whether the underlying structure is topologically trivial or nontrivial.We establish this result through two complementary constructions of physically admissible reciprocal perturbations. The first considers weak permittivity perturbations of finite spatial extent within the first Born approximation, whereas the second considers optically small dielectric perturbations of finite contrast. In each construction, an admissible realization exists that produces a nonzero leading-order backward-scattering amplitude. We trace the fundamental origin of this limitation to the absence in photons of the intrinsic spin-$\tfrac{1}{2}$ and fermionic time-reversal structure underlying Kramers protection in electronic systems. Consequently, any mechanism that enforces photonic backscattering suppression throughout a prescribed class of disorder must instead be engineered into the underlying electromagnetic structure and its constitutive response, which can itself be modified by generic reciprocal perturbations. Numerical examples in representative reciprocal topological waveguides further illustrate these limitations for random defects and sharp bends. We further identify several constructive strategies for suppressing back-reflection within certain prescribed classes of disorder.