p-adic Rigidity and Supercongruences at Rank Two Attractors

Abstract

We study a $p$-adic rigidity phenomenon suggested by rank two attractors. Near an ordinary special fiber of a Calabi--Yau family, the excellent Frobenius of Beukers and Vlasenko acts on the parameter disk. Achinger--Zdanowicz construct a canonical $W_2$-lift of the Frobenius twist, while Brantner--Taelman construct a canonical formal lift. We conjecture that the Dwork and Achinger--Zdanowicz first-order obstruction maps agree and that the fixed points of the excellent Frobenius are precisely the parameters of the Brantner--Taelman canonical formal lifts. Our main theorem gives a cohomological criterion in arbitrary dimension. Under its hypotheses, a Frobenius-stable rank two factor of the $p$-adic cohomology containing the holomorphic class forces that class to span a Cartier-stable line and gives supercongruences modulo $p^{2s}$ for every $s\geq1$. Moreover, if the hypotheses of the Beukers--Vlasenko excellent lift theorem hold, then the excellent Frobenius fixes the corresponding parameter. We apply the criterion to the Hulek--Verrill $A_4$ family at $t_*=-1/7$, a parameter predicted to be a rank two attractor. Assuming Dummigan's Conjecture~1.1, we prove that the excellent Frobenius fixes $t_*$, the supercongruences hold, and the fiber with parameter $t_*\bmod p^2$ is the Achinger--Zdanowicz canonical lift at every prime where the required Dwork ordinarity conditions are satisfied. A CM fiber of the mirror quartic K3 pencil gives a second application. We also prove that the $q$-power map on a split formal torus has the unit section as its unique periodic point in the identity residue disk over every finite extension of $W(\mathbb{F}_q)[1/p]$, where $q$ is the cardinality of the residue field.