Hybrid worlds are the commonest outcome among the M-dwarf sub-Neptunes characterised with JWST

Abstract

The sub-Neptunes orbiting M dwarfs are usually assigned to one of two classes: rocky cores beneath primordial hydrogen, or volatile-rich bodies formed beyond the water-ice line. Bulk density cannot distinguish them, the two being degenerate in mass and radius once envelope evolution is modelled self-consistently (Rogers et al. 2023); the atmospheric mean molecular weight μ is the route past it. We compile the eight M-dwarf sub-Neptunes with published JWST spectra and a constrained μ, and combine it, graded by quality of evidence, with the restricted Jeans parameter and with energy-limited escape integrated over the system lifetime. The XUV history is taken from M-dwarf activity-age relations at each host's spectral type rather than parameterised, and converted to the 1-912 Angstrom band explicitly. Four of the eight satisfy neither class, carrying envelopes of 3.8 < μ <= 18 amu that are neither primordial hydrogen nor the signature of a 50 per cent ice interior. One is a strict-sense water world. Not one has a μ retrieved from detected molecular features that places it in the gas-dwarf class. We term these intermediate objects hybrid worlds; they are the commonest outcome in the sample, and the selection function works against that result, since targets chosen for transmission-spectroscopy favourability should over-represent extended, low-μ envelopes. The evidence is asymmetric in the same direction: the hybrid assignments rest on positive molecular detections, while both end-members are populated by provisional ones. The debate is not binary, and its two models do not describe the bulk of the population they were framed to explain.