Cooperation dynamics between persuasion-prone and persuasion-averse populations under random sequential guidance

Abstract

Social guidance, as a universal mechanism to promote collective cooperation, effectively maintains and enhances the level of population cooperation by correcting the behavior of defectors. However, existing guidance models have two key limitations: first, they assume that guidance actions are inevitably successful; second, they neglect information sharing among guides, leading to repeated guidance of the same successfully guided defector. Additionally, the psychological characteristics of individuals are often not fully considered in existing models. Here, we construct a stochastic sequence guidance model by introducing random ordering of guides and termination conditions for guidance actions to optimize the efficiency of guidance. Besides, we incorporate individual psychological traits such as persuasion-prone (where the success rate of persuasion increases with attempts) and persuasion-averse (where the success rate of persuasion decreases with attempts) into the modeling framework. We find that the introduction of random sequence guidance can not only effectively promote cooperation but also mitigate the second-order free-rider problem. Importantly, cooperation thrives with stronger persuasion, lower costs, and larger groups.