arXiv · 2609.31973
Attributing Sensor Deviations to Degradation, Weather, or Attack in Oilfield Digital Twins: A Simulation Study of Probabilistic Attribution and Cost-Based Decisions
Abstract
When an oilfield digital twin disagrees with its instruments, the operator must decide whether the cause is hardware degradation, harsh-weather effects, or malicious data manipulation. Existing digital-twin work appears to treat these causes separately: sensor-validation architectures target faults, and attack-focused twins have been evaluated on water-sector testbeds. We study joint cause attribution on a simulated four-well wellpad with 15 coupled instruments, legitimate operating transients, and weather. A physics-informed twin, identified from normal data only, produces analytical-redundancy residuals; windowed features feed a gradient-boosted classifier whose posterior drives an alarm gate with a fixed false-alarm rate and a cost-based decision rule that may defer to an analyst. On three independently generated sites, the classifier reaches macro-F1 of 0.818 on windows where the injected deviation is observable (0.723 when latent post-onset windows are included at the primary site). The physics twin accounts for essentially all of this: removing the data-driven twin changes macro-F1 by less than 0.01, whereas removing all twins drops it to about 0.58. Attacks are detected quickly (median 1.7 h) but attributed correctly at alarm time only 42% of the time, rising to 73% six hours later. A cost-aware policy that defers ambiguous cases had the lowest expected cost among all policies in every one of 144 cost and prior settings tested, sometimes by a small margin; the result depends on illustrative costs and on analysts resolving deferred cases. A twin-aware attacker was detected in 45% of episodes yet almost never attributed to attack. These results are conditional on the simulator's generative assumptions and have not been validated on field data.
Explore related subjects
Keep this discovery
Explore connections, maps & timelines
Mustafa S. Aljumaily, Nawar S. Alseelawi, Hayder Kareem Abed. 2026-09-25. Attributing Sensor Deviations to Degradation, Weather, or Attack in Oilfield Digital Twins: A Simulation Study of Probabilistic Attribution and Cost-Based Decisions. https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.31973
Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.